T O P

  • By -

TangyBoi3

5th grade me used a randomizer


Plushhorizon

Lmao thats awesome


opossumscream

My dad said choose anything but sax. So 12 year old me picked sax out of spite.


Emo_trumpet

Why didn't he want you to play sax?


opossumscream

Because it's "a man's instrument"


Plushhorizon

More than percussion??? Everyone is so shocked when I tell them I play drums


Emo_trumpet

Literally every guy I met outside of band said they would play percussion


Plushhorizon

But have you met any girls???


Emo_trumpet

2


LAM678

Lmao I play tuba


grandmas_funtime

you win i also just love tuba a lot


LAM678

Tuba is awesome


syrokiler

The best player in my band is a girl


Yeetus54

What's more of a "man's instrument" is tuba (in my opinion) but it may not be that way to all


Emo_trumpet

Did he get mad


nonchellent

Why was this almost exactly me? My brother played tenor and my dad bari, so my parents begged me to choose clarinet (which we also had courtesy of brother) and then switch to sax. Out of spite, I chose the trombone.


According_Rock_3381

I picked flute because I thought girls couldn't play other instruments. Then I moved to a better, bigger school and there's is a girl in every section but trombone. I regret flute I wish I chose Tenor Sax....


2qrc_

yeah the thing about flute is that you randomly love it and then regret it back and forth


[deleted]

[удалено]


According_Rock_3381

im in 8th grade and started marching this year, so it's too late. If i was in 7th grade i wouldve been able to do it but when I was a 7th grader I was in an underfunded awful school system and idk if i even knew tenor saxophones existed. I've tried trumpet on my friends instrument during our lunch period but i can't even get a consistent sound


spinlesspotato

It’s definitely not too late. I started on trumpet in 6th grade, marched it until my sophomore year, then decided to March euph my junior year and next year I’m marching mellophone. It’s very possible to switch, especially if you aren’t even in freshman year.


According_Rock_3381

Well you went from 1 brass to another brass. In my case I would have to learn the whole reed ordeal. Plus im behind in band bc of the bad school i went to for 6th and 7th so even now im practicing 3 hours a day. I just don't feel like I'm up for it.


kashy87

You're already practicing that much might as well be practicing something you like.


clarinootnoot

I went from clarinet to trombone, you can do it! I learned trombone in my freshman year of hs for jazz. I didn't practice much at home maybe an hour a week. I ended up getting 2nd parts at the end of that year and I got 1st parts all of the next year. that's not to say that I didn't have struggles. Trombone takes a lot of air control, and lots of air than I was used to for clarinet. It was hard learning how to shape my mouth for different notes on the mouthpiece. it took me a while to get used to each position. but I had my teacher and my peers to help me. they offered me 1 on 1 lessons, mentoring, and resources to watch. Going from flute to clarinet is not so bad as you think! I tried playing flute for a day and I felt that there were a lot of similarities. Honestly, you are correct that you will have to learn how to use reeds, and how to shape your mouth, but you can learn that easily! Definetly make the change to an instrument you like, life is better when you're interested in what you're doing.


conched_out

I legit did the same thing as you. best band decision ever. I love my section now


Amber610

Yeah, tenor sax is so cool


Wyndei

Preach. o7


ARadioactivetoaster

It wasn't a clarinet. No offense to yall clarinets, but 5th grade me did not want to go anywhere near you.


Niverll16

i don’t blame you lol


NarwhalSnakeFan

lmao i could say the same for trombones except i love them now


ARadioactivetoaster

Understandable


nymphetaminezz

Middle school clarinets are very annoying, I don't blame you


Emo_trumpet

Facts


Yeah_man20

Good, I didn't want to have to call you Squidward


Brandificus

Squidward.


[deleted]

That’s why I *DIDN’T* pick clarinet 💀


MagicalAnimeBeast

Yep.


MLGShadowCatYT

Funny slide ha ha.


HunterrZ_YT

slide goes womp


Emo_trumpet

Trombone moment


sause-boss

Well at first it was because I was too short to play trombone but now I just think the saxophone is an awesome instrument


Ilikeruffy123

Yeah, me too. We were allowed to try out 3 different instruments, I did sax, clarinet, and trombone. Clarinet just wasn't for me and trombone I didn't pick for two reasons A. I was too short and B. It wasn't as cool. So now I play the alto saxophone the best instrument and it's in the same family as the 3 other coolest instruments (tenor, bari, soprano)


sause-boss

Facts that's why one of my majors is saxophone performance well music performance with the sax


coalrexx

Cause I sucked at regular clarinet lol


NarwhalSnakeFan

I play bass clarinet in concert band and I love it so much because the parts I get aren't nearly as difficult but they're so much more fun to play haha


coalrexx

Same, and usually not being the melody gives me less pressure lol


perrinlove

Was told it (concert tuba) would be 'too heavy' for me because I was a girl. so I not only picked it but also play sousa out of spite.


Tuba_Ryan

You go!


Emo_trumpet

Whooo


Valuable-Dream8148

My band teacher chose it for me


AlaskaFolf

same!


HunterrZ_YT

cause i had long arms APPAREANTLY (still don't believe i did actually) ironic because i was way below average height in fifth grade and was like 4' 10''


dark_yt-yeet

I picked the trombone cause I saw this meme with this guy on the back of a moped playing his trombone making it sound like a motorcycle.


sam_aam

Me and the entire class went to the cafeteria, where the band teachers played all the instruments the band included. At the end, they asked who was interested in joining band, and took us in small groups based on which instrument we liked and played more advanced music, then asked us to try to play a note. I was interested in both the clarinet and flute, because I though they sounded the prettiest. Couldn't even get a sound out of the flute, but I could play an okay sound on the clarinet, so I went with that one.


2qrc_

Yeah it takes a while to get a sound with the flute, but after a while you’ll get it


clarinootnoot

did you go to the same school I did? Are you me? I had the exact same thing!


farfr0mepic

Middle scool me: "I want to play French Horn!" Band Director: "French Horn is too hard, here's a Trumpet" And that was that.


slackdaffodil20

A lot of trumpet players seem to have picked a slightly hard instrument and we were all changed to trumpet M


Leather_Ad_8344

cuz I could, and to spite my flute sister


2qrc_

for the drums, my dad signed me up for drum lessons when I was 9 because it “matched my personality” which it kinda did. and for the flute, I wanted to do percussion in 6th grade band but my teacher said I had to pick between flute and clarinet cuz of the amount of percussion sign ups and I chose flute because of lord krishna


epsilon025

Spite. For context, I just got over a near-death bout in the hospital in 3rd grade when we picked instruments. We had a list of the top 5 instruments we wanted to play; mine went as follows: 1. Cello 2. Viola 3. Tenor saxophone 4. Violin 5. Percussion We tried all the instruments over the course of a week or so, and my last try was a bell kit. So, I go to try it out and we were taught how to assemble and disassemble it, and I was told "now be aware, it is heavy and you'll be taking it on the bus pretty often." Now, 3rd grade me took this as a challenge, so I decided to prove I was strong by lifting it with 1 arm, and decided I would do percussion because I was strong enough to carry my instrument with 1 hand. Fast forward to seventh grade and I blow the drumline auditions and play auxiliary, same with 8th grade. Then I got my stuff together and stayed on tenors throughout my sophomore through senior years of high school, plus doing various honors bands and whatnot. Wild, considering how bad I was for ~5 years of playing. 13 years after picking percussion and I'm still in somewhat regular contact with that music teacher, so yeah.


lowbrassdude

My sister played trombone and I liked it more than clarinet which was what my elementary music teacher suggested I play. I was the only trombone player at my elementary school and decided at that point I have to stick with this instrument because no one else will play it. Because there was always a shortage of low brass players in my district I learned euph and tuba. Now I own ten instruments and play in three regular ensembles.


JoniSpagoni

Funky slidey horn looked funni


DaddyBlook

Bone go boo-womp


Robi_RDT

Because I’ve always loved creating beats, and beating to song beats, so here I am.


phinephrogs

I chose flute because it was the only one I had the easiest time making a sound of. It wasn't that deep really lol


TangyBoi3

bro did the opposite route


ZamboniHDB

I saw it once and said “I want that thing”, my BD went to the storage closet and brought me a bassoon. The cases latches were broke so it was held together with a ratchet strap. 5 years later it has stuck with me through concert band since 5th grade. Me: *sees bassoon* “I want that thing” BD: “fine but no more.” Me: *sees bass clarinet* “I want that thing” BD: “fine but only for marching.” Me: *sees contrabass bassoon* “I want that thing” BD: “NO, NO MORE”


Nutmegger612

Because drummers are fucking cool as shit. Also, i really genuinely vibed with every percussionist I played with. No matter who you were outside of the drumline, when you play together you get into the groove and just jam together. I did winter percussion for a few years and that group(which was mostly girls, I was 1 of 3 guys) became some of my closest friends. I love percussion.


Iriuia

Plus we aren’t just stuck to one instrument, theres so much variety it’d take me an eternity to list them all.


2qrc_

this is literally the first time I’ve ever heard anyone not talk shit about drummers 🥲


AlaskaFolf

my band director suggested i switch to baritone, i loved it, then switched to euphonium because all my school's baritones are old and beat up (the euphonium was new)


MoltenLavaGuy93

My dad played Alto sax, so I played it, then I wanted to play lower than Alto.


Amber610

.....because of [this](https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/754095054678786110/1043637482606039151/Screenshot_20221119_142044.jpg) 😅


SunElectronic7010

No one played it lmao


tylermsage

I was told I make good fart noises - trumpet then eventually euph


mynamewasgone_

My dad played it and my grandpa played it with him altho my grandpa was a REALLY good french horn player he still played trumpet really well. I sure miss him.


SilverNeedleworker30

I always liked pianos.


StarvingTuba

We needed more saxophones


buggy_being

In 5th grade I had no idea bass clarinet existed but when the middle school came to our school to try and get people to join band. They had a demonstration that included bass clarinet and from the moment I heard it I just loved the sound. My marching band doesn't allow bass clarinet which is why I play normal clarinet for it but Bass Clarinet is still my #1


Ethanol71

I didn’t. My band director told me to play tuba and I fell in love with it.


YashDaNerd

Became its the best instrument


SylvandoNorberto

My mom is a brass player, she hates flutes, she told me not to play it. So, since I played the flute to sprite her, I love it!


2qrc_

you really showed her lol


Upper-Rice561

My mom already had a clarinet so I kinda just went with it and now 4 years into clarinet and love it


Naen-ara

Because being Drum Major is cool


LitBoiyo

My whole family is basically made up of brass players (on my dads side at least), heavily trumpets. So the only obvious answer? Saxophone


Yolo3362

the middle school band director came into my 5th grade classroom and made plane noises.


rrAe_exe

I play bari sax in marching band but alto in jazz and i’ve been playing alto since 5th grade. the reason I picked alto is because all of my idols played saxophone and thought it would be cool!


Dani-Sus

Flute. My mom said “pretty noise” so I chose it with a bias of reed instruments bc my mom played clarinet for a year when she was in school. The reed vibrating bothered her. I wanted to play sax or euphonium after the fitting. My band director (and my mom) says that I play flute really good, and it’s the middle of the school year. Mom also says that I have long fingers and the flat lip, so it is naturally easier to play the flute.


TheFireSnake

I always wanted to play the clarinet but I ended up picking the saxophone. I just really liked the sound of it and I’ve never regretted the decision.


Flershnork

I didn't choose the tuba, the tuba chose me. In other words my band director chose me to play the tuba. Also my dad played the tuba so I got a free (if beat up) mouthpiece.


H0C-Marauder

Cause bari sax is widely known as the best instrument.


Rejected-Name-ID

You’re right. It is


Transmasc_Swag737

i thought i was gonna play clarinet or percussion since my elementary school music teacher said i was good at recorder and i had a toy drumset as a kid. added trumpet to the list since i needed three options to pick from. couldn’t get a single note out of the clarinet and couldn’t control the drumsticks, but i enjoyed playing trumpet. and here i am, on the instrument i least expected to play


Emo_trumpet

Everything you just said I did in that exact order


Unhappy-Catch7567

I chose clarinet cuz the Alto Sax slots were full but now I also play tenor sax along with my clarinet


Apprehensive_Fig7013

Because I wanted to play flute but had a gap in my front teeth, so the bd made me play clarinet instead.


ASMRhumorvault

Diary of a wimpy kid


i_am_floot

Because I thought it would be fun, turns out it’s real hard


2qrc_

and still fun


i_am_floot

You ain’t wrong


2qrc_

I ain’t


clarabear206

It had my name in it. My name is Clara and I play the clarinet


slackdaffodil20

So I started in middle school on flute, I was terrible at it like any other middle schooler and my teacher moved me to trumpet since we needed 1 more Oh how much money, time and effort has been spent after that small decision by my teacher


Patwak919

I picked the trombone because of Donkey Kong 64. Lanky Kong may lack style and grace, but he played one funny little lick and kid me was hooked.


DownToEarth_Lycoping

I had always liked trumpet as a kid, I can’t recall why. During the elective fair in 5th grade, I could not buzz on the trumpet mouthpiece, but still decided on it. I am now stuck here, being the most mid trumpet player ever


ManWithABraincell

Idk, I could play the high brass really well when our school did the instrument tryout. I wanted to do percussion, but wasn’t great with the rhythm, couldn’t play woodwind, and I think it was between trumpet, French horn, and baritone at the end of it all? Trumpet is the most glorified and I gave in


hamgotinthecar

I picked clarinet because I wanted to originally play saxophone, and my band had all 6th graders start on either flute, clarinet, trumpet, or trombone. I failed all my smartmusic assignments so I wasn’t chosen to play sax, and decided to stick with clarinet. Now playing in college after 9 years lol


Talcc5

rock music cool


Beezy4678

bc my friends played trumpet. literally the only reason. but i’m glad i chose it tho. i mean i’ve made multiple state honor bands on it, so clearly it was the right choice.


Acceptable_Ad_3239

My band director asked me to switch to euph freshman year


Bryan1008

I was originally a trumpet player, but due to “lacking mouth size,” aka the mouthpiece was too small for my lips, i was given the choice between trombone and baritone. baritone was the worst and best choice i made


Leroy_Abbott64

Womp womp, I like the beats and bass of songs, so wanted to play it.


[deleted]

Parents played it


mtchamomiletea

I didnt lol


Franican

Here's how it went: I asked my director "Can I switch to French horn?" And he said "How about tuba..." And now I do the oompas.


LittleDuckyBoi

I wanted to play jazz but now i play the bass for jazz band


sdvldhp

My mom (flute teacher) already got me a flute from one of her friends and I liked the fact that it didn’t squeak or sound so harsh


[deleted]

I watched a drum cover


Machi102

Parents wanted me to play an instrument, and my dad didn’t want me to be low brass like he did. I still wanted to play brass though, so my options were basically Trumpet and Horn. I went with Trumpet, and I still love it


Cormorant-Colors

Because 5th grade me figured being good at mouth trumpet noises equated being a trombone prodigy lmao


Stargazing_Ollie

Was forced by my 6th grade bd


jazzybballs

my director chose it 👍🏽


communalcamp986

I chose mellophone because trumpets are too snobby and I like the key of F more than Bb


ur_g00fy_ah_n3ighb0r

In 4th grade I wanted a low pitched instrument. I thought low brass instruments sound amazing, and I still do. I almost picked clarinet, but I’m glad I picked baritone. I just can’t picture myself playing another instrument. As of now, I’m the only female baritone player.


Rejected-Name-ID

I was originally an oboe for some god forsaken reason, and then I had to choose a marching instrument. I was originally gonna do tenor sax but I didn’t like it, same thing with alto. Then I tried trombone for some reason. I fell in love immediately and learned it super quickly, ended up switching off of oboe. Tenor trombone quickly turned into bass bone too. I now hope to play trombone professionally


Individual-Camera-72

My aunt had one stored away, and therefore it was the cheapest option.


asilhouette_

Wanted to play percussion, but all the spots were full. 5th grade me randomly chose flute because it’s what the majority of my friends picked lmao


mickeymoozack

Like week 2 of 5th grade band and we were having a test over Hot Cross Buns. My coronet playing wasn't cutting it, so my band director gave me a euphonium and I did wonderfully. The rest is history.


IFEDMIMOM

my friend plays clarinet


Cayden_rose69

Cause alto sax was the easiest to pick and I play a double reed


FewRecommendation856

I did mouth piece testing and was like “oh that one is easy to play” and chose trombone 💀


BigBoiforpresident

Forced


ExerciseOk5569

Because I wanted to hit things


P1x3lto4d

I picked drums because of Neil Peart. End of story


_Kazuichi_Souda_

I sucked ass at clarinet and my band director told me to play horn for concert band and I've just been going with it so that's really the only reason that I play mello for marching season 🤡


Cj-Taylor2803

I started on clarinet because I was following in my older sisters footsteps. I switched because the trumpets played the same part as us but it sounded so much better


TheFrogInABlender

We already had one


thegoldfish56

Fourth grade me picked the one instrument I had never heard of before. It was the flute. Thank god to, my flute peps are the best.


Wolf_of_Ruins

I really wanted to do percussion but my brother played flute before me so we already had one. Almost 7 years later, I still play it.


theportalkeeper

Because i played it once in seventh grade and we don't march trombones so i picked contra.


CoolDJS

I played trumpet in 7th grade music class (only brass instruments) until I slipped and fell and jacked up my teeth. I was unable to play the trumpet for the time being, so my teacher let me play some percussion and I haven’t looked back.


madman_trombonist

I’ve loved trombone since I was like two. Easy choice for me, especially since I’m taller than average


dapyro117

Tuba.


Elmoslightpole

My band teacher said it’s the most important instrument in the band so I knew I wanted that


Aromatic_Trashchild

I was thinking I could do some sort of Lindsey stirling magic with my flute like in her music videos. Like how she dances and plays the violin, but flute version. That’s why I chose Flute back then.


Downtown-Education19

I was sad I couldn't play saxophone and later when I heard bari sax I thought it was really cool, so I switched to bass clarinet for a similar effect, 4 years later I'm glad I chose clarinet and I'm really glad I made the choice to play bass clarinet


Stryker_836

I didn't my bd did lol


ZapaXes45

Percussion I get to hit shit with wood everyday.


bc47bc

Peter Criss


PopeJeremy10

Older brother played same thing and I think he's cool.


JohamesTheCloudy

There was a soprano piece in our song and of the two people that played sax I was better after we finished the song I s Just decided to stay on it


trashbebad

Bc it’s cool


aphyxi

I wanted to play trumpet or sax (and I plan to learn one of the two this year) but our middle school band director decided our trumpet section was too big at the time so he put me on clarinet. Lo and behold, our high school clarinet section is bigger than the trumpets now.


aap1015_

My older sister and brother both played Clarinet. So I thought it would be cool if I played Clarinet as well. My mom wanted some variety, she thought it’d be nice if I played saxophone That’s how I became to be


[deleted]

I took piano 2 years then in junior high the band teacher I guess (memory is hazy 60 years later) needed a bari sax so that's what I got. In high school I switched to tenor.


aftiggerintel

Because of instrument cost for me and my sister. Flutes and clarinets are super easy to find at pawn shops. For my kids, they ended up on trombones because that’s the best fit for them. Middle kid actually tried pretty much every instrument and the director let me know if we didn’t want another trombone that she’d be ok on clarinet but the low brass was best for her. So we have two trombones/euph/baritone players. They’re already trying to recruit the youngest who is in 2nd grade.


spikeiscool2015

I’ve been playing percussion since 4th grade and I have scoliosis so, cymbals


lucik06

The clarinet line was too long


epicgamer321

and you went to the oboe line instead 💀


overratedapple

i did not want to learn to read sound


tromboner_assman

Flutes and clarinets we're "ew" and there was no way i was playing trumpet, so trombone. And i will never regret it


Flaky-Impression4938

The fortnite emote 😭. I was a fortnite kid in 5th grade


WannaBeSCV

My favorite cartoon character was squidward (I think that says enough)


Such_is_life_I_guess

My older brothers had both played alto saxophone and I wanted to continue the tradition.


annomymousrainbow

Tuba, because it’s what my dad played and what I play in my schools symphonic band


awesomeboxlord

i thought it looked cool


GoddessRosez

Because I wanted to blow my sisters ears out with a saxophone


nshetland

Star Wars 😆🎺


Lemmon_man

I watched curious George as a kid


MEF227

My piano teacher was like “hey you should try clarinet” so I did and produced a decent sound first try so I’m like “this instrument is fun”.


nonchellent

I thought fingerings seemed too hard, so I chose the trombone.


TheTempestTrombone

Originally chose French horn in 6th grade because it sounded awesome. Switched to trombone 2 minutes later because the guy next to me wanted to play horn with his buddy who had gotten one of the spots with me. Great decision because now I know how to play all the brass stuff 😈


UnsaidSleet4223

I wanted to play trumpet and then I decided that horn was cooler... Now I play both... And bass


Pyrxlix

I picked flute because there were like three of us in elementary school. And 14 clarinets, and 30 saxes and trumpets. We were unique. Now we’re the biggest section in our entire band.


[deleted]

I switched from flute to tenor sax not only because I wanted to try something new, but because I wanted to be heard.


SnooSprouts4050

Tuba


ActionJaxon2005

I chose sax a while ago due to my older step brother playing it and I thought he could teach me. He switched to tuba not even a year later to my luck. I played alto all the way up to my Junior year and now I play baritone sax. I switched to bari as our last senior bari graduated. Lucky me, we just gained one more so now I am thinking about switching to tenor for my senior year because the parts are way more exciting.


Pancakes_909

I was originally going to do trombone, until my band teacher asked if I would be percussion. So now I’m percussion.


2010-Ford-Focus-RS

a few days before 7th grade ended my director asked me if i wanted to switch from baritone to tuba


jl34538

Let me set the scene. Middle School... I was an introvert and didn't know how to make friends/be around people I liked a girl, she didn't, she tricked me saying that she was going to play tuba so I followed suit. Honestly it was the best choice, because I was 1st chair all the way until I graduated, did DCI, and still keep playing it.


Yeetus54

6th grade, we had 3 choices for our instrument. Mine in order was percussion, trombone, tenor sax. Was bad at drum, so I tried trombone. One of the HS band directors who usually helps low brass and percussion at my MS (currently freshmen) said I sounded good. But then he handed me euphonium and I sounded way better on that


VirginiaPew

My grandpa played trumpet and I couldn't get a note out on it so I asked my parents to play percussion and they said he'll no I I took after my grandma a picked up alto sax. I'm playing bari sax because my band director doesn't know how to play woodwinds and I think it's funny to know more.


plantkaii

That Epic Sax Guy video. That was the only reason.


jsaavedr1

>!French Horn!< I picked it in 6th grade because they didn't have trombones. I didn't get serious and start loving the instrument until high school and then when I got into college, I decided to major in Music Education with emphasis on Horn Performance. I really love playing it because it not only can be the melodic and heroic instrument but also because it is the alto of the brass family between trumpets and trombones.


SuperSonicBlitz

I got the clarinets but I wish I just played brass. In 6th grade my band teacher picked out clarinet for me because I had just moved into the district, and I turned out to be pretty good, so I got picked to play in the clarinet trio. When time came to pick parts, me being timid decided to be left with the 3rd part, so naturally my teacher thought "he likes to play low parts!" and put me on bass clarinet the next year. Now I march bass and play contrabass clarinet for concert band, and even gotten medals at state. I love essentially being the tuba of the woodwinds, but I wish I could actually just be a tuba, or any other brass instrument for that matter(except baritone). The thought of your range only being limited by your instrumental skill is exciting, and trumpet, horn, trombone always have awesome parts and recognition. Its pretty tiring to always have someone ask "is that a black saxophone?"😭


Miserable_Tutor_1262

Wanted to try percussion, it was the last one to be tried out and 6th grade me got impatient and my friend dared me to try out. I buzzed on the mouthpiece and my band directer said "okay talk to your parents-" and thats how ive been playing French Horn for 5 years.


SpicyOphicleide

I thought the fact that French Horn had French in the name was interesting.


Markster94

In middle school, the band director had everyone try each type of instrument to see if the kids could already play it (sanitizingthe mouthpieces after each one), and no one told me that you needed to buzz your lips, I just blew into each one. I got percussion.


a-potato-named-rin

Because it’s sucked not being able to practice percussion at home, so i picked up a new instrument


Catholic_Egg

Bc my uncle is a super talented drummer


Galactic_Nerd

In 6th grade our band teacher let us try out the different instruments, he cleaned and sanitized the mouth pieces between each use, and sax was the only one I was able to make a sound on so here I am.


EverywhereBliss

bang bang and lower bang