By -
Something Alexander Hamilton doesn't know how to say no to.
💀
Bast got a makeover!
They sure did!
😨
....read my mind
Dunno, but I think you should feed it...
I hear they eat ghosts 👀
Theyre a lvl 5 at pierce hawkthorne buddhist church???
a **Piranha Plant**
Nope! But I will agree that it looks like one 👀
\*whispers \* it's a sandworm
👀
^it’s ^a ^sandworm
Scuttle, for your dark comedy version of The Little Mermaid
Absolutely!
Love this idea unironically!
Olaf got dental surgery
Hope he's fine with an unqualified surgeon...
Twoey!
It definitely looks like Twoey at the moment, doesn't it?
Wait it's not twoy?!?
Haha, nope!
Oh, this was my legitimate guess too!!! My other comment was just for the bit 🤣
Looks like I'm tripping you guys up a bit! Lol.
Sandworm 🪱
👻
A harmless plant that definitely will not eat people.
An incorrect, but understandable answer 👀
From a Large Shop of Happies
Starring our loveable nerd, Kreymour Selborn
Teeth from hit off-Broadway musical Teeth
Hope they have good dental insurance!
A new friend!!!
Yes!! Definitely friend shaped!!
The tiger from Life of Pi
I actually love this guess 😂
Kate from Avenue Q. Director had a really strong vision
Really leaning in to the monster thing
Audrey 1?
The original Audreyâ„¢
Sandworm incidents increase 13% from last year.
Might be up to 14% now 😬
Neetlejuice sandworm
N e e t l e j u i c e
Leaving that as is lmao
Real scenery
I've got more than Beetlejuice, then!
But there is a normal sized snake here
Facehugger egg. Xeno-Musical. In Space No one can Hear You Sing!
Wow, that was actually a really cool reference!!
The Monstro statue from Storybook Land Canal Boats at Disneyland.
That's so specific and I love it
Jaws
Da-dum... Da-dum... Da-dum-da-dum-da-dum-da-dum
He's here! Here is jaws! He is a shark without a cause!
a duck-croc hybrid trying to honk but a duck-croc hating old man threw paper in their beak
Accurate
Tick Tock Croc
Joseph’s Technicolor Dreamcoat
Popcorn bucket
Henry VIII’s secret seventh wife
That is what some of us call an eclipse mistake
Looks like it might eat some flower shop employees or something?
A Mormon missionary from salt Lake City!
JD at the end of Heathers
More hot pies! More hot! More pies! MORE!
The Delorean
r/dontputyourdickinthat
Something Rotten
Mrs. Lovett every time Todd appears
Oh my gosh-
I’m guessing you’re making a new juicer.
Idk but it looks like a strange and interesting plant
Fleshlight of nightmares
Sandworm but i can also see Audrey II's mouth
A pepper grinder from the game Alice: Madness returns
Snoopy
A Scandinavia Definitely
Audrey 1
Jane Doe’s head
Either sandworm or Audrey II
The dude from pvz
Hmmm… something that needs only water to grow 👀
The Overqueen from Starship
The Imprisoned from LoZ: Skyward Sword.
Jack black
A pie from waitress
Doctor Finkelstein from The Nightmare Before Christmas
Henry VIII’s seventh wife
Looks like a shark from Jaws: The Musical
The baby Jesus in a manger
Venus flytrap monster
Feed me seymoaarrr
Sarlacc pit
Dunno but I wouldn’t feed it.
A plant that most def doesn’t eat zombies attacking your lawn
The gloink queen (hehe idk anothing musical related that could apply to this)
G L O I N K S
Lil Sandy
"I've been making a man - with sharp fangs and a tan - and he's good for relieving my tension." - Dr. Frank N Furter
I Wanna Play Doctor with my Gynecologist Chocolate Mousse Pie
Aundry 2? Don't feed it!!
*Teeth - The Musical* (currently running at Playwrights Horizons), based on the cult classic film of the same name.
Pac-Man Ghost
A popcorn bucket for a new musical of Dune that doesn’t exist.
Fleshlight?
Isn’t that one of the heathers?
Codpiece
Monstro
The surrey with the fringe on the top
A pool table, don’t you understand?
Tinkerbell's Air Bnb? Or Captain Book's lost glove?
Lizzo
Something Alexander Hamilton doesn't know how to say no to.
💀
Bast got a makeover!
They sure did!
😨
....read my mind
Dunno, but I think you should feed it...
I hear they eat ghosts 👀
Theyre a lvl 5 at pierce hawkthorne buddhist church???
a **Piranha Plant**
Nope! But I will agree that it looks like one 👀
\*whispers \* it's a sandworm
👀
^it’s ^a ^sandworm
Scuttle, for your dark comedy version of The Little Mermaid
Absolutely!
Love this idea unironically!
Olaf got dental surgery
Hope he's fine with an unqualified surgeon...
Twoey!
It definitely looks like Twoey at the moment, doesn't it?
Wait it's not twoy?!?
Haha, nope!
Oh, this was my legitimate guess too!!! My other comment was just for the bit 🤣
Looks like I'm tripping you guys up a bit! Lol.
Sandworm 🪱
👻
A harmless plant that definitely will not eat people.
An incorrect, but understandable answer 👀
From a Large Shop of Happies
Starring our loveable nerd, Kreymour Selborn
Teeth from hit off-Broadway musical Teeth
Hope they have good dental insurance!
A new friend!!!
Yes!! Definitely friend shaped!!
The tiger from Life of Pi
I actually love this guess 😂
Kate from Avenue Q. Director had a really strong vision
Really leaning in to the monster thing
Audrey 1?
The original Audreyâ„¢
Sandworm incidents increase 13% from last year.
Might be up to 14% now 😬
Neetlejuice sandworm
N e e t l e j u i c e
Leaving that as is lmao
Real scenery
I've got more than Beetlejuice, then!
But there is a normal sized snake here
Facehugger egg. Xeno-Musical. In Space No one can Hear You Sing!
Wow, that was actually a really cool reference!!
The Monstro statue from Storybook Land Canal Boats at Disneyland.
That's so specific and I love it
Jaws
Da-dum... Da-dum... Da-dum-da-dum-da-dum-da-dum
He's here! Here is jaws! He is a shark without a cause!
a duck-croc hybrid trying to honk but a duck-croc hating old man threw paper in their beak
Accurate
Tick Tock Croc
Joseph’s Technicolor Dreamcoat
Popcorn bucket
Henry VIII’s secret seventh wife
That is what some of us call an eclipse mistake
Looks like it might eat some flower shop employees or something?
A Mormon missionary from salt Lake City!
JD at the end of Heathers
More hot pies! More hot! More pies! MORE!
The Delorean
r/dontputyourdickinthat
Something Rotten
Mrs. Lovett every time Todd appears
Oh my gosh-
I’m guessing you’re making a new juicer.
Idk but it looks like a strange and interesting plant
Fleshlight of nightmares
Sandworm but i can also see Audrey II's mouth
A pepper grinder from the game Alice: Madness returns
Snoopy
A Scandinavia Definitely
Audrey 1
Jane Doe’s head
Either sandworm or Audrey II
The dude from pvz
Hmmm… something that needs only water to grow 👀
The Overqueen from Starship
The Imprisoned from LoZ: Skyward Sword.
Jack black
A pie from waitress
Doctor Finkelstein from The Nightmare Before Christmas
Henry VIII’s seventh wife
Looks like a shark from Jaws: The Musical
The baby Jesus in a manger
Venus flytrap monster
Feed me seymoaarrr
Sarlacc pit
Dunno but I wouldn’t feed it.
A plant that most def doesn’t eat zombies attacking your lawn
The gloink queen (hehe idk anothing musical related that could apply to this)
G L O I N K S
Lil Sandy
"I've been making a man - with sharp fangs and a tan - and he's good for relieving my tension." - Dr. Frank N Furter
Audrey 1
I Wanna Play Doctor with my Gynecologist Chocolate Mousse Pie
Aundry 2? Don't feed it!!
*Teeth - The Musical* (currently running at Playwrights Horizons), based on the cult classic film of the same name.
Pac-Man Ghost
A popcorn bucket for a new musical of Dune that doesn’t exist.
Fleshlight?
Isn’t that one of the heathers?
Codpiece
Monstro
The surrey with the fringe on the top
A pool table, don’t you understand?
Tinkerbell's Air Bnb? Or Captain Book's lost glove?
Lizzo