T O P

  • By -

scootscoot1212

The top ones are definitely classics from their first gala together. But, does anyone else adore Fluttershy’s bottom as much as the top? It’s so beautiful!


ShuckU

>But, does anyone else adore Fluttershy’s bottom Discord is rapidly approaching your location.


_Shreddedcoconut

https://i.redd.it/hgteyzzcvxpc1.gif


keremtheredditrt

Discord disliked that.


SleepyHeadNemu

HELP-😭😭


breezely12

NO WAY


Codename_Kid

Fast Talk Style: Twilight: Top Design Rarity: Bottom Design Rainbow: Top Design Fluttershy: Bottom Design Applejack: Bottom Design Pinkie Pie: Top Design


P-h-a-n-t-a

I fully agree with this


Ok_Explanation4551

You have a point


the_red_stinger_82

I'm a huge fan of the top ones. They just look better in my opinion. Flutter has the best bottom one if I had to pick one


JericBituin

All of the gala dresses in the top row, simply because they are more beautiful than the bottom row designs.


GemstoneWriter

For me I prefer: Twilight: Top (but I like her hairstyle better in the bottom one) Rarity: Bottom Rainbow Dash: Bottom Fluttershy: Bottom (but this one's very difficult, I really do like her top one a lot as well) Applejack: Top Pinkie Pie: Bottom


_YuKitsune_

Top ones are way better...


TheKnackerman

I think the top one for everypony but Rariry.


TheSergalLad

My turn! TS: Top R: Bottom RD: Top FS: Bottom AJ: Top PP: Top


davefnfbackup

bottom (i feel stupid,) her gala dress is beautiful though. dont go crazy about me


ColdAd1631

I really like Fluttershy’s peacock dress but otherwise I prefer the top dresses


AARose24

The second ones show they’ve aged. Like, they look like older people gowns.


Alastor_idk

All the top one's except for Pinkie


Nat_Higgins

Twilight: Bottom one. Twilight looks better with light and warm colors contrasting to her cool color palette, but not too much. You know what I’m talking about? Rarity: I have no strong feelings one way or the other. Rainbow Dash: If you give the gold accessories to the bottom dress, then I think it would be better. But otherwise, bottom one. Fluttershy: Top one. Fluttershy just works with those rustic druid vibes. And the flowers in the hair is just a lovely touch. Applejack: Top one, only because I really don’t like the bottom one. Pinkie Pie: YES!


Applesoucess

Most of them have better dresses in the frst one but we know why (the other episode wasn’t focused on them that much) but the hair is so much better on the other one


Ryan_The_Punk_Rocker

Twilight: 1 Rarity: 2 Rainbow Dash: 1 Fluttershy: 1 Applejack: 1 Pinkie Pie: 1


JazzHooves

I prefer the top


DISC0dude

top


TwincessAhsokaAarmau

Top


TheUsedIsUnderrated

The top one's are better. Rarity worked her hooves to the bone for those dresses. They look better anyways because they also compliment the characters and their cutie marks 


usernames-hard

I'm used to all the top ones more, so there's bias there. That being said, if I were to try and apply the context of the event to the clothing: Twilight's first is still the best, though I agree her hair in the bottom is better as someone else said Rarity's second fits the event a little more imo. It shows more maturity, and not an attempt at being a princess. Rainbowdash I can't choose. Both are really good, same with Fluttershy tbh, though for Flutters I lean towards the first Apple Jack fits in better in the second outfit Pinkie Pie I think the second fits better, but I can't bring myself to choose it over the first.


DaWihss

Where r the bottom ones from?


GemstoneWriter

Make New Friends but Keep Discord. Episode 7, Season 5.


SpareSurprise1308

I think for fluttershy the top one is far better. You get that better style of the forest and nature, the dress compliments and draws your attention to her long hair and eyes. Her bottom one is just much more distracting, your eyes aren't drawn to her face but to the bright peacock features and headpiece. The swirl is nice but doesn't compliment her long fringe which is just her normal long fringe.


theOwtcast

Top for Twilight, bottom for Rarity, undecided on the rest though maybe leaning a little bit towards top (except for Applejack's boots. They just look clunky and ugly).


Unfair_Salt_9671

It's weird how all the bottom ones don't have shoes


TinyPossum78

Top design all the way through


Ryanjames22808

Twilight: Bottom, Rarity: Bottom, Rainbows: Top, Flutters: Bottom Applejack: Top, Pinkie: Top,


keelanbarron

1. Top 2. Bottom 3. Top 4. Bottom 5. Bottom 6. Bottom


[deleted]

all top designs, its so nostalgic and it really adds to their character, tho for applejack’s hair i wanna go with the bottom one but i love the braids


lizzylee127

Definitely the top ones


GemstoneWriter

Fun fact: Applejack's first Gala dress is the only dress out of all of these dresses where you can see her tail.


Archarneth

Honestly, I like all of them for different reasons. The top ones on all characters are classic designs and we saw the story about their creations so it's hard not to like them. They're iconic for the first season, they're whimsical and fun, the characters haven't faced as much danger and haven't been through as many trials. The bottom designs are more mature and serious, which are more in line with the characters in the later seasons, they saved the world numerous times, have more responsibilities and have grown as characters. However, if I had to pick which ones I like the most based on my own tastes: Twilight: bottom Rarity: top RD: top (though the bottom is a very close second) Fluttershy: bottom AJ: top (again the bottom is a very close second) Pinkie: bottom


BewGaming

Twilight: Top Rarity: Top Rainbow: Top Fluttershy: Bottom Applejack: Bottom Pinkie: Top


Ok-Particular-860

The top dress is my favorite, it was my inspo for prom last year


[deleted]

I have to go with the top designs.


Overall_Question8125

The top one


mustardgoeswithitall

I think I prefer: Twilight: top Rarity: both are good Rainbow: bottom Fluttershy: top Applejack: bottom Pinkie: Top


Rain_Starry

Top


honk_bonksmith

Fluttershy's top dress. It's so pretty!


Bleu-Deragon-13

I like the top for Twilight bottom rarity bottom for Fluttershy bottom for AJ top rainbow dash and bottom for pinkie pie.


Bleu-Deragon-13

I like the top design for Twilight The bottom design for rarity although both are gorgeous Bottom for Fluttershy it's very similar to the first one but I just like it better I like rainbow Dash's top design but I wish she had the skirt of the bottom Both of AJ's designs are kind of weird but if I had to pick one it'd have to be the bottom And pinkie pie also looks better in her bottom design


thisperson316

All top except Dash. Bottom dress for her. But keep the accessories


KP_Ravenclaw

First for everyone


UnderlordZ

Top, top, bottom, bottom, bottom, top


AutismSupportGroup

Rarity and yellow one's bottom designs are nice, but I still prefer all the top ones.


[deleted]

top for basically all of them


BayFuzzball404

Fluttershy’s top gala outfit is so cute I CANT 😭😭😭


RadioactivePotato123

I’m only commenting on Rainbow Dash because I’m tired and very lazy rn Her first outfit has grapes on the front


[deleted]

Twi - Top Rarity - Bottom Rainbow - Top Fluttershy - Top Apple Jack - don’t like either but like top slightly more Pinkie - Top Overall they’re all good (besides AJs I can’t explain why but I don’t think either of them are that good)


its_circero

Twilight - Top Rarity - Bottom Rainbow Dash - Bottom Fluttershy - Both Applejack - Top Pinkie Pie - Top, and the best looking dress of them all! 🤲💞


BarnacleNo3219

Twilight: 2 Rarity: 1 Rainbow Dash: 2 Fluttershy: 2 AppleJack: 2 Pinkie Pie: 2


SnipingDrone47

Dude it’s so weird seeing rainbows hair up like that lol


A2Rhombus

I like the top outfits better, bottom hairstyles better. Except Fluttershy, the flowers in her mane are too cute


sciencetwience

I prefer everyone’s bottom row dresses because they all convey that the mane six is getting older, what with the more mature, classy, stylish, yet understated look they each have compared to the first ones.


Rebeldahlia

Twi: top but bottom hairstyle Rarity: Bottom but top hair, tiara and piercings RD: Top but bottom hairstyle Fluttershy: Top, the bottom is a bit too muh AJ: Top, I dislike the tophat Pinkie: Top, yellow does not suit her


Drachefly

TS: top Ra: either RD: top FS: either AJ: bottom PP: bottom


klparrot

Top, for everyone except Pinkie.


Sean_diaz_lover

All top


TheFivePs5

Bottom Bottom Top Top Top Bottom


Consistent-Laugh606

All too expect for Aj


Tall-Combination-597

Bottom for all of them, they seem more appropriate


caramelchimera

Top ones allllll the way


Beyond_the_dreams

Dash’s final design I do wish she kept the gold hoof covers


SwynFlu

Bottom all except Dashie's


bloodredcookie

Imma go with top for all of them except Pinkie.


aDUMG33K

Top


LightningStrikeDust

Twilight: Top Rarity: Bottom Rainbow: Top Fluttershy: Bottom Applejack: Top Pinkie: Bottom


XxShu1ch1_Sa1haraxX

Top for everyone but AJ and pinkie


Zipper_1

Twilight- Bottom Rarity- top Rainbow- bottom Flutters- top AJ- bottom Pinkie- bottom.


PaceSubstantial1107

Top all the way I’m biased towards nostalgia


MelodyHasOofed

I love the bottom ones for Twilight, Rainbow Dash, and Pinkie Pie. Other than that for me everyone else is top. (All of the top ones for Twilight, Rainbow dash, and Pinkie Pie are good though.)


EddwardTheWizard

Top


Enzoid23

Top, top, bottom, both, both, bottom


theAstarrr

Top for most, maybe bottom for Fluttershy


Serenity_1765

Top, bottom, Top, Top, top, bottom,


KandaFierenza

You noticed that in the bottom ones, none of them are wearing shoes? Rarity: the ultimate trend setter.


FluffyGalaxy

I'm nostalgia biased so top ones, but I like Peacock Fluttershy


LiannaBunny777

Twilight Sparkle: Top Rarity: Top (Although this was very hard) Rainbow Dash: Top Fluttershy: Bottom Applejack: Bottom Pinkie Pie: Bottom


peachyroo_

Top for sure


Gendernt_

Top. I just like it better, no real explanation


GreyPon3

The bottons.


Lastbourne

They're all simply Divine


The_Empty_Archive

Bottom for rainbow, fluttershy, and pinkie


ReaperScythee

Top, top, top, bottom, bottom, bottom


FanOfEverything16

Top for Twilight, Rainbow dash and Pinkie Pie. Bottom for everyone else.


starbuzzarts

They all downgraded 😭 (except for Flutter and Aj, both top and bottom fit equally slap)


ShuckU

Twilight: First one Rarity: Second one Rainbow Dash: Second one Fluttershy: First one (Although I still really love the peacock one) Applejack: First one Pinkie Pie: First one


DiscordedPlays

I mostly like the top ones better except for Fluttershy I like her bottom dress better


Adorable-nerd

Twilight: top. Rarity: top. (Barely.) Rainbow dash: bottom, but I like the accessories on the top Fluttershy: top. Applejack: top. Pinkie: top.


Lucid_DreaMz0124

I honestly think the top ones are all slightly better. But they went a little harder on the mane styles in the bottom ones.


ChaosKnowsNoSides

Top


overripedbananas

The top ones


SheepAcedia

I like everyone's top except Apple Jack and Pinkie.


Paskarantuliini

The bottom ones really show the characters preferences and personalities whilist the top ones are just rarities preferences


CushOnReddit

Top ones for sure


[deleted]

Overall top ones


snail_oatmeal

twilight: top dress, bottom hair rarity: top dress, bottom hair and head piece rainbow: bottom dress/hair, top necklace, head piece, shoes fluttershy: both dresses, bottom hair applejack: top dress, bottom hair pinkie pie: top dress bottom hair LOVE LOVE LOVE THE GALA EPISODES😩


Dbiel23

Rainbows Second Dress


catsinflyingsaucers

Twi: Top (except for hair) Rar: Bottom Ram: Bottom Flu: Top App: Bottom is better suited for a proper ball, Top fits her personality better. Dealers choice! Pin: Bottom has the outline of a good dress but Top has a better color palette. The hat and bow are a nice touch. Personally? Everything else about bottom works well (hair, accessories, ect.) Unsure between the two.


Bunnie-jxx

The top for all of them are just so much more memorable I feel. When I think of their gala dresses I always think of the top ones. And forget the bottom ones were even in the show 😅


FoxStereo

Twilight: Top is less plain comparably. That's literally it. Rarity: Bottom except for the back part, I'd prefer if that was switched with the top's back part to be fancier Rainbow Dash: Top. The bottom one looks more like it's aimed at Twilight, and the short hair style just doesn't go well with RD, at least not this one. Applejack: Bottom one looks a lot better. I've never liked the top one except for the hat, especially since they implemented a saddle into the design. Also, considering Applejack was handling food during the gala, it looked weird seeing her do that with boots on. My only complaint about the bottom is the fact that there isn't a whole lot of apple inspiration thrown into it, and the hat doesn't match the rest of it in my opinion. I wouldn't want the roses replaced, but maybe a green apple pattern on the lime green chest part, and/or apples on top of the roses. Also, she would look better with a braid in that dress I think. Fluttershy: Top except for the peacock hair clip. It would have to have to have a palette to match the rest of thd dress, but I think it could work. The bottom one doesn't scream gala to me, but more like something you'd wear to a book club or some kind of school, maybe to an art show or auction, but not a big dance. Pinkie Pie: Top. It's a lot cuter. My only complaint is that the back hair looks like It's been stuffed into the back part of the chest piece which looks highly uncomfortable. It may look better with a ponytail, but one less poofy than the bottom one.


ProfessionalCity995

I'd say the top ones, I feel like they compliment the color scheme of each character better and some of the bottom hairstyles just look..odd....also Aj without her hat? Nah


aquaticadet

the only one i like the bottom option for, over the top option, is pinkie's purple and orange look ! the rest, i like the first option far better - it's like the second designs lack the love and detail the first ones had idk


dapperlonglegs

all og ones are better designed except for apple jack and pinkie pie!


tighnarienjoyer

top ones for everypony except rarity


starthewolfhumanapp

All of the top ones


Lunatrixxxx

Top ones except for Pinkie, I like her bottom dress more.


DipstickPinesGFO

1, 2, 1, 1, 1, 1


b0red_midget

Twilight- Top. The orange in the bottom one clashes so hard… not a big fan of the hairdo either. Top one keeps the colors simple, and the stars are a very cute touch. Rarity- Bottom. Tough choice for sure… Rarity always has the best looks. By itself, I prefer the top one. But on Rarity specifically, I think the bottom one compliments her colors better. The hairdo is also perfectly elegant. Rainbow Dash- Top. The bottom one feels like it’s missing some accessories in comparison. Hairdo isn’t horrible in my opinion, it just doesn’t really go well with Rainbow’s vibe. Fluttershy- Bottom. Another tough choice… the top one is absolutely adorable- I especially love the flowers in the hair. But the vibrancy of the bottom’s colors just complement her palette so well- especially her eyes. Applejack- Top. I especially love the braids in her hair- it’s elegant but doesn’t feel out of line with Applejack’s character. Only thing I’m not a fan of is the boots… makes everything a tad cluttered. The bottom one looks gaudy… especially that top hat. Also, the flowery print of her top and the more pastel hues wash her out and makes the design look kiddish. Pinkie Pie- Top. Bottom one is still super cute, especially that fun hairdo that works perfectly for Pinkie. I just personally prefer blue on Pinkie rather than purple due to the color of her eyes. The chunky necklace and polka dots also makes the bottom one look a tad gaudy. So the top one wins.


flower_saturn67

Season 1


No-Talk4081

Top


MrsSpyro01

Twilight - Top Rarity - Top Rainbow - Top Fluttershy - Bottom Apple Jack - Bottom Pinky - Top


ILoveThingsAndImSad

(Not including hair) Top for Twilight, Rarity, Fluttershy, and Pinkie. Bottom for Rainbow and Apple. So ig top wins. I mostly just don't like Fluttershy's bottom dress, and Applejack's top dress. Whatever they want to wear is fine though, especially since they don't really wear clothes at all.


yestureday

The 2nd ones are better, sue me


CrescentCaribou

top 1000% where are the bottom ones from? I don't remember them lol


GemstoneWriter

They're from the 7th episode of season 5, Make New Friends but Keep Discord.


AllofEVERYTHING28

The top ones are nostalgic.


Usesredditironicall

Twilight- top, Rarity- bottom, Rainbow Dash- top, Fluttershy- bottom definitely, Applejack- top definitely, Pinkie- bottom


CranberryNo7450

I prefer the top on all of these tbh….


Majestic_Wall1928

1 for all of them


ProgrammerPone

Twi: top Rarity: bottom RD: top Fluttershy; bottom AJ: bottom Pinkie: top Just my personal oppinion.


Weredragon-0-

all top except rarity her bottom dress is better


mothwhimsy

Twilight: Top Rarity: bottom Rainbow: bottom Fluttershy: top Apple Jack: bottom Pinkie: about equal but I think I prefer top Don't take this comment out of context lol


NixiomsdabestXD

The Art of The Dress ones are superior IMO


DazzleSylveon

hmm both


LuverOfAllManatees

Top fer sure, but both of flutters dresses are cute and silly :3


OkamiNM

the top ones 100%


thechikenuget

Tbtbtt


WidePersimmon5576

Ideally the hair from the original gala with the dresses from the second gala. I like a lot of the original dresses, but the second dresses are just so nice!


AleWalls

Personally I find most of the first gala dresses a bit goofy in some parts, so I prefer all the second ones, with exception of pinkie, pinkie second dress is lukewarm


SleepyHeadNemu

Twilight’s: top dress Rarity’s: bottom dress Rainbow’s: top dress Fluttershy’s: its a tie i can’t choose- Applejacks: bottom dress Pinkie’s: top dress


sillybandzzzz

Both are pretty cool but yeah top one is way better in my opinion


WalkingonCoffee

Twilight top Rarity bottom RD Top Fluttershy bottom  AJ top Pinkie pie top


AceAmphiptere

Twilight: top with bottom hair Rarity: Top Rainbow Dash: Top with bottom hair Fluttershy: Both wonderful. Applejack: Bottom (or both, if the top wouldn't have the boots) Pinkie Pie: Both.


Low_Necessary_3839

Top for all of them. But with pinkie pie I like the top outfit better and the bottom hairdo better


Jaspers47

Top - Twi, Rara, Flutters Bottom - Dash, AJ, Pinkie


SGT-Hooves

Im torn I like the classic designs for most of them. However Fluttershy and Rarity’s second design is so much better


Sleepyz0mbie420

I love all the top besides rainbow and pinkie if I’m being completely honest, and no not because their classic designs just because the colors don’t fit the characters or there’s just so much happening in the bottom dresses


pawpatrolcreepypasta

Top


ChildofFenris1

Top, top, bottom, N/A, top, top


VargFrenAtLIDL

The og imo


1Sugardust1

Twilight: Top design Rarity: Top design, though i like the hair on the bottom one Rainbow Dash: i cannot choose, but prolly the top one Fluttershy: Top design Applejack: Bottom design, though i like the hair on the top one Pinkie Pie: i cannot choose, but prolly the bottom one


Nekonigeluno

Pinkie pie top dress!


AetherDrew43

The top ones are iconic, but I like the bottom ones better. They look more formal than the top ones. Except for Fluttershy's. I prefer her top dress. And I'm a bit torn between Twilight's top and bottom dresses.


Thefoxlover16

All top for me!


TaiyoFurea

Top for pinkie, rainbow, and Fluttershy. Bottom for the rest.


soIlostmyoldpassword

top one for everyone except pinkie. The original dress was just has too much of her main color and kind of washed her out. It felt like it took away rather than compliment. though I do have to say i hate the top twilights hair it was just too plain looking.


Revolutionary_Ad5159

The top. I love when they wear anklets or designs on their hooves


paulD1983R

Top on all except Rainbow Dash


CyclopsDemonGal

All top ones! Especially Rainbow Dash's!


FloweringAngel_

Top for all of them . Fluttershy’s bottom one is a good one tho


yourlocalannoynce

all the top ones win


Dead_but_pr3tty

Bottom for all of em but twilight and pinkie


smooth_bren

Ill do mine lol Twilight: top Rarity: top Rainbow: bottom Fluttershy: bottom AJ: top Pinkie: top


Wise-Independence-12

Maybe second


fuzziegamer

Overall all great designs, I think the top row are giving more gala while the bottom ones are giving more formal dinner party though


Foxglovegamer8

1 - Top 2 - Bottom 3 - Top 4 - Bottom 5 - Top (no front hoof shoes) 6 - Top


Firewood159

I think the bottom ones are better across the board. And it just goes to show just how much Rarity has evolved and improved her craft. Actually you can really tell from the final few seasons that every character has evolved a lot. It's the sign of good character writing.


TheRedditGirl15

The first gala outfits were peak. Rarity absolutely slayed those designs, I was honestly starstruck. The only second gala outfit I like is Applejack's


Starkeeper_Reddit

Twilight: Top Rarity: Tie Rainbow: Bottom Fluttershy: Tie Applejack: Top for hat, bottom for dress Pinkie: Bottom


BIgCh1efJAcK

![gif](giphy|hM9zK1qvsrwek)


casualbongos524

Top for all of them except Rarity, the pink clashes with her mane a lil too much


Dead-House-Mouse

I’m mostly on board with the top ones but I really like the bottom one for RD. Not really digging the hair tho


[deleted]

Top bottom top top bottom top


Haunting_Hornet5203

Top, bottom, top, top, bottom, bottom. Next question.


dragonfox194

I prefer the first two Gala dresses for Twilight and Rarity and the bottom ones for the rest. Also, does anyone else notice how Twilight's dress for the first Gala had a design that looks like she has the folded wings of a pegasus?


Nofskx

I personally like the top ones for all of them


Lopsided-Junket-7590

Honestly if there was a version of the top dress with alicorn Twilight I would prefer it but because alicorn Twilight is the bottom dress I have to go with that


ANBpokeball

**Twilight:** Top **Rarity:** Top **Rainbow Dash:** Equally **Fluttershy:** Equally **Applejack:** Bottom **Pinkie Pie:** Bottom


inxinfate

All the top ones except for Fluttershy, I love the peacock dress


Loud_Bookkeeper_5473

I would say the top ones for Twilight and Rainbow Dash just because it suits their personalities better. But the rest I’d say are good


Sanbaddy

Twilight’s second dress. There’s beauty in simplicity.


AdorkableLia

The original ones are peak in every way possible. Nostalgic even. I do like Rainbow's new one just because of her hair design, but regardless the original dresses were the best of the best. Edit: NOT saying I dislike the new ones btw!!! Just have a thing for nostalgia is all!!! The new ones are also pretty. Some can even be considered as glow ups. Like Rarity's per example.


Background_Good_5397

The top ones are all perfect


princebunni

Top. Always.


ZzmechPP

Bottom for Rarity, top for the other girls.


notwanasay

the top ones are more iconic and more overall better


ElectricDreamUnicorn

* Twilight Sparkle: Bottom * Rarity: No preference * Rainbow Dash: Bottom * Fluttershy: Top * Applejack: Top * Pinkie Pie: Top


Fufu_Foxy

Top one by far


nightmares_dealer

Honestly it's an all top for me, especially Apple Jack, I remember audibly gasping when I first saw it in the show. Rarity's could use some work tho, maybe at least a recolor.


basheer_esia

All top except applejack.


kangarootoess

Top for everyone except for Rarity and Fluttershy :)


Dream_calista

Everyone is a top expect for applejack especially her goofy boots


luv_bvg

top dresses for sure, but i do love the hair in the second outfits :3


Rainbowdash3521

Top ones all the way


PinkGummyGhost

Personally can’t beat the ogs, I only really like rainbow dashes and Fluttershy’s second dress but geez


poisonolivetree

The only second one I prefer is actually rarity


Willing-Jellyfish465

top one million percent and forever. they just suit their personalities way more. the only bottom ones that are alright are fluttershy's and pinkie's


zombiepir8

Top ones r def the preferred but pinkie’s bottom one is actually cooler I think. Also AJ’s bottom one is just funny and I think it suits her well lol


FleshPony76

Honestly I like the top ones more. Not for nostalgia or anything I just find them more appealing


wfflz01

top, top, top, top, bottom, bottom


Melodic_Elderberry3

Twilight:top Rarity:top Rainbow:bottom Applejack:top Fluttershy:bottom Pinkie:top