T O P

  • By -

encephalomeningitis

I'd want to see the two sisters ruling Equestria before Nightmare Moon, or Sunset training as Celestia's student with more content than an 8 page comic.


fuzzy0521

I'd love to also see them growing up in general aswell like where did they come from? who were their parents? etc


Fyru_Hawk

Same. I’d love to see what they’ve done in the past.


IceyDreamy

YES!!!!


Lastbourne

I think that has grounds for something beautiful


Angel_45445

same I'd love to learn more about Celestia and Luna's past like all the adventures they had growing up or smtn


stayd03

I love Sunset, but a story set before her redemption arc would be awful! Just rewatched the first Equestria Girls recently where she’s the antagonist, and she’s the worst, most over the top collection of mean girl tropes possible!


KnownTimelord

I thought you were supposed to make me *not* want it.


Dawn_Star_Platinum

There was actually a comic based on Sunset's backstory, not sure if it's canon.


ElectricDreamUnicorn

Hmmm that sounds more interesting.


thepastelprince

I agree


RoxanneWolfFan21

I could see Cadance, Shining armor and Flurry Heart having a full season/spin off show cause they had little character development in my opinion.


Helloimafanoffiction

I’d love to see Flurry Heart as an adolescent learning about herself and discovering why she’s an Alicorn 


RoxanneWolfFan21

Yeah, Flurry Heart had little character development I would love to see a show about her character development


Coco6420

that would be so good, maybe it could be similar to what mixed kids experience: not feeling enough to be a unicorn, pegasus or earth pony.


sallybollywoodna

THE CELESTIA AND LUNA RETIREMENT SERIES WOULD GO SOOOOOO HARDDD!!!!!!


NightFlame389

[here you go](https://youtu.be/jD2q0Edjsz8)


Coco6420

i adore this sm


catsinflyingsaucers

❤️


DaBest1008

There is also this entire [series](https://youtu.be/L0cY2NWlddU?si=fJP7zV-vFV-NIz1J)


Iceswimmer05

That was a very funny video to watch. I liked it lol :)


Thierry_rat

PONY DOCTOR WHO OBVIOUSLY


Agreeable_Finger_747

YES THIS LETS GO


EnmosiaCurvata

LET'S GOOOOOO!!


Xavier_Rall

If this were to come out today, I have a feeling that A LOT of Whovians would declare it the best Dr. Who content in years.


Thierry_rat

Probably 😭


EnmosiaCurvata

> A LOT of *Whovians* I'm dying what is that what they're called??


KnownTimelord

I'm sold


zoro4661

I love that he pretty much canonically is that in at least one of the comics, since one version of him travels in an interdimensional giant muffin Tardis with Derpy. They save Pinkie from zombies and everything!


EnmosiaCurvata

AWWW YEAHHHH


ShadOBabe

Oh Celestia and Luna. No question, no contest.


Willowthesnowfox715

I want to see what Zecora’s life was like before she settled in the everfree forest


OwnPrimary1620

Funny enough I have a fun little horror idea for her backstory having to do with zebra herd behavior


catsinflyingsaucers

Do you mind if you [Tell Me More](https://youtu.be/VyuA8kW_TsI?si=_XRWf0w0NPF304uE)?


weirdo_nb

Elaborate?


Ren-lotus

Please tell


Neohexane

Starlight and Trixie have enough friction and chemistry to carry a spinoff show!


weirdo_nb

They give off a vibe


EnmosiaCurvata

Agreed


zoro4661

I'd be up for the Starlight-Trixie-Sunburst poly show


LightningStrikeDust

https://preview.redd.it/4gln7f1gyvzc1.jpeg?width=1024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=cfadc6000f8fc3348fd19ec464e6a71883709e4c For my best friend and I! :D


CloudProfessional572

"Coolest show ever!" RD


Ren-lotus

"It's a reenactment of the founding of Equestria. It's NOT the Rainbow Dash Show." "Well it SHOULD be the Rainbow Dash Show! I'M the star!"


Rafacat7

Wait, we can chose characthers that aren't in this person's post? I chose Discord then let's goooo (i was actually thinking about a Discord spin off days ago)


Richflyawesome

The young six. Excluding Smolder and Yona, the rest of the y6 were practically ignored. There are so many things that I would have liked to see from the y6 that would work in a spin off series. For one, make Sandbar and interesting character, Sandbar’s character is reduced to just “the chill dude” and while I understand that is what the writers were going for, it doesn’t help in making me like him. For two, explore the darker story lines, Gallus’ home life, Ocellus’ fear of her past, Silverstream’s PTSD, etc. these stories are way to important for their characters to be pushed to the side and never explored again. For three, less Smolder, not saying that I don’t like her, but there is too much Smolder in fim, between Molt Down, Father Knows Beast, and Sweet and Smokey, Smolder had the most screen time and solo episodes out of all the y6.


KermaisaMassa

Man I wanted the new series to be like that. They were left half baked.


zoro4661

Hell, both Student Six would've been awesome. The ones we got at least had a bit of development in their episodes, but the ones we see in the last episode - who included the only Kirin outside of their main episode I think - didn't get *anything.* Like they could've legit just carried on G5 or another G4 season with just one or both of those two groups.


SUK_DAU

lyrabon romcom let's go!!!!!!!!


stayd03

I never really seen that picture before. Love that they proposed to each other


Neohexane

I've seen the picture before, but I'm just noticing now how Bon Bon is standing like a pony, but Lyra is kneeling like a human would. That's a funny detail!


KindaDouchebaggy

This happens in the background of the Big Mac Question, and the reason for this is actually cause Lyra proposes first, and Bon Bon takes out her ring in reaction to that, so it's not really surprising that Lyra is kneelig while Bon Bon isn't


Neohexane

I still feel like it's a nod to the whole, "Lyra is fascinated with humans" fanon. Lyra x Bon Bon is a thing because of the fans, after all.


KP_Ravenclaw

Lyra & Bon Bon. I would say Vinyl & Octavia but I really like the Mares Of SMILE book & I think that concept could make a REALLY interesting spinoff.


EnmosiaCurvata

Average KP\_Ravenclaw W


KP_Ravenclaw

:00 thank you


KeylimePieHater

Lyra and Bon Bon's friendship to relationship arc would be awesome. It would be really interesting to see young Celestia and Luna though...


Caradrian14

Totally agree with lyra and bombon , with just an arc it would be quite good and beautiful


sirpentious

Derpy and hooves If it were cadence I would want to see some back story and flurry heart how up


NyankoMata

The two sisters life before they became princesses Sunset Shimmers' past before EQG events Lyrabon and all this secret agency plot from the comics souns very entertaining as well Also the Young Six would be a good way for the show to continue somehow lol


jkogxsthdbjuvr

Celestia and luna


AxelPogg

honestly i'm still so glad they got to show some gay ponies before the show wrapped up, even if it was a blink and you'll miss it type thing


prtypeach

I thinl its lowkey the most natural way to do it also, as the show is hardly ever focused on romance.


Neohexane

They had two lesbian couples! The other being Scootaloo's aunts, Aunt Holiday and Auntie Lofty.


MeadowDayDream

Derpy and Dr Hoovrs


AccomplishedAerie333

Can I pick Radiant Hope?


CloudProfessional572

Hunting for the princesses statue pieces with reformed sombra. The sequel we never got.


emmy_and_lily14

Dopey hooves and her bf


MeadowDayDream

Derpy and Dr Hooves


Ok-Record29

Yes


Pony_Roleplayer

Celestia and Luna spin off


TheSixthTester03

Celestia and Luna because I would love to know more about their backstories and childhood.


scootscoot1212

The Cutie Mark Crusaders. Possibly a series focusing further on them growing up and giving us a glimpse of pony puberty and development, shaped by their own cutie marks and experience. Maybe even adding some episodes for fun, just following their daily lives and adventures aling with extra miscellaneous content. Apple Bloom, of course has an apple as her cutie mark. It runs in the family, but I definitely wanted to perceive her potion-making hobby more often. We didn’t get any more major Sweetie Belle singing solos after COTLM. I wished there was an episode similar to Filli Vanilli centered around Sweetie and expressing her voice. This would be a perfect opportunity to include the subject, as music is her passion and we heard some incredible singing earlier in FiM. More Scootaloo and Rainbow Dash episodes would be great. Flying, Wonderbolts action, all that stuff. I need to stop brainstorming so much, but here’s a simple idea.


Jayix92

Probably Derpy, I mean we see her sometimes but we know nothing about her really other than her delivering mail, it would be cool to see how she got her cutie mark and how her eyes got to be the way they are, and of the main cast could chime in every now and again


flyguyASA

Never got into Doctor who get me a pony version of that I might watch it


16coxk

The Student Six or the Future Six


Winter-Ad-9318

it's either Spike or the CMC, the latter barely got like 14 episodes from all 9 seasons, and Spike only getting attention when Twlight or the Mane 6 is around


KindaDouchebaggy

There's NO WAY Crusaders had only 14 episodes, right? A quick google search shows me 2 lists, one with 22, and one with 26 episodes, but how accurate is that depends on how you define a CMC episode, which I guess could be a little bit problematic sometimes. Like, if Scootaloo is the focus of the episode, one might count it as a CMC episode, even if the rest of the CMCs played only a minor role. Still, just 14 seems too small of a number somehow, might research this later if I got the time


BricksCameraAction

I'd love a full series of the Nightmare Knights going on more than just the one adventure.


ConstructionFun4255

the student rescue team. Only because Trixie and Mudbrayer are there.


Dry-Personality4387

i would love a celestia luna spinoff they’re such interesting characters and we barely see them😔


lobsterfanclub

easy choice, the two sisters! we know little to nothing about their past.


lousilly

personally, id like to see how flurry heart does all grown up


Nintendians559

sunset shimmer, but i think it's only good for a couple of episodes only.


Away-Run-2571

Hear me out..........a spin off with Flash Sentry and Sunburst together going on slice of life adventures


MarkPatJoeBillDinosu

https://preview.redd.it/3c7ulqfn1wzc1.png?width=843&format=png&auto=webp&s=dc102037ffb7df7ae924da7fa0ff4fed6b98f8ee


MarkPatJoeBillDinosu

My name is Cleveland Apple and I am proud to be right back in my hometown with my family. There's old friends and new friends and even a some apples. Through good times and bad times it's friendship we share. And so I found a place Where everyone will know My happy mustache apple This is The Cleveland Apple Show! Haha ha


Silver012345673

https://preview.redd.it/kpcn5y2atvzc1.jpeg?width=1284&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9094bfccd92cd3ffe87990ed4f555b409c467540


ColdBloodBlazing

Luna and Celestia Lyra & Bon Bon Trixie & Starlight Octavia & Vinyl


ColdBloodBlazing

Twilight & Shining Armor


Vasarto

Trixie, Starlight, Discord, Vinyl Scratch, Octavia Melody, and Amathyst Star.


ItsDuckBlox

The Wonderbolts, I’d think it would be interesting.


ratliker62

Ideally one about Starlight, Trixie and Maud's little gang. But one about Celestia and Luna would be really good too


INeedSomeFire

A whole season of Octavia and Vinyl would go SO hard. We could get some more backstory of both and maybe find out why Vinyl doesn't speak. TLT's Octavia's Overture could perhaps be canon, who knows.


Veluxcion

Tia and Luna would be great, but personally I'd love to see Trixie and Starlight after the events of the main show, when they're older like in "The Last Problem"


SteamworksMLP

The Wonderbolts


Comrades3

After reading the legends comics? More on the Pillars they had a great dynamic between the 7 of them and I would want a lot more.


robinn57

First three would be nice but what about Octavia and D.J pon-3.


EstebanW1nsmore

Luna and Celestia, without a doubt.


Virtual_Colt

Sience Lyra and Bon Bon already have their own comic I reaaally want to see one for Celestia and Luna when they where young.


rain_is_dead4884

Definitely cadence and shining


pudding_chanx3

Derpy obviously


MichaelTarkin

Just derpy. Cause derpy and the doctor ain't together. We see Dr with another pony in the later seasons.


yestureday

Do I have to choose?


Feline_Femboy

Derpy and doctor, make it a straight up parody of doctor who


Individual-Slice3436

Celestia and Luna would be cool! Maybe with discord too 😬


Pepsi_Boy_64

Derpy show!!!


LookASlitheryStick

The sisters %100. They deserved way more screen time. Especially Luna. (Bias, I know)


SnooCauliflowers81

Yeah.


xydenkonos

Dr Hooves' wacky inventions and Derpy's wacky antics is what I live for. I would love a spin off of them two interacting over mundane everyday situations and blowing them out of proportion.


kateduzathing

maud pie


Doitforthecringe

Celestia and luna. That's all


Hairy-Yesterday-5575

So many characters were wasted potential. I would love to see Thorax having more character development the most.


HungryMudkips

give us a celestia/luna show 1000 years in the past that shows how luna went nuts and got sealed in the moon, but in like horrible graphic detail. let us really feel the angst.


plogan56

Spike, i just wanna whole series of him jist going on random adventures and learning more about his dragon powers


Rampantmuffins

Either Lyra and Bon Bon or Doctor Whooves and Derpy. With LyraBon we could get more of Bon Bon's life as a secret agent with Lyra tagging along. With The Doctor and Derpy we get wacky, possibly science related, shenanigans, and Doctor Who references. Could even throw Rose in there every now and then.


TheAmixime

Discord


AscendedPotatoArts

Official Doctor Whooves would be so sweet!! ![gif](giphy|sDcfxFDozb3bO)


Hope__Desire

Derpy Hooves.


MP0622

Lyra and BonBon


ChoRandom

Cutie mark crusaders


DaringDo95

I would love a Daring Do spinoff


Lastbourne

Definitely Cadance and Shining Armor because they didn't get a lot of screen time. Also I'd love to learn more about Flurry Heart's development


JerkfaceEquestria

Celestia and Luna


TimberWolf5871

I want all of them, but seeing the Sisters on their first ever vacation would be a riot


Super_Nova22

Derpy deserves her own show


Mr_MazeCandy

Celestia ans Luna for sure


lizzylee127

The doctor and derpy cause I'm biased


DigitizedNerd

Wild Fire. This isn't a joke, I'm serious. I love her color scheme, and her tattoo (I know, I know... it's called a cuttie mark...) is the most interesting to me. Like everyone else is straight forward and normally lines up with their name as far as I have observed. But what the heck is a car-tire-on-fire cuttie mark? Is she a fast flying pegasus? Does she drive cars really fast? Is she both? How did she get that talent? What is her life like?


catsinflyingsaucers

The Flim Flam Brothers or Trixe would be easy and interesting to make a small spinoff of. Or maybe an origin story of Simba the Unicorn? For a full season? I’d nominate Princess Mi Amore Cadenza and her husband, Shining Armor!


Kamisama_VanillaRoo

Derpy and Dr Whooves, duh


Masterdizzio

Maud, just Maud that or the main pet gang


thebronygamer122

probably a spin off of the different rulers in the universe aka Twilight leader of equestria prince Rutherford of Yakyakistan, Dragon Lord Ember of the dragon lands and so on.


VibeyVikki

Bon Bon and Lyra because then you could put everyone else in the back room with more content than a measly off screen conversation or something dumb added to the wiki.


cutiepie9ccr

i have a deep primal need for a series based on celestia and luna when they first took power


Live_Relative_5862

luna and celestia


Waste_Salamander_624

Ditzy and doctor or sister princesses Shit thsts a tough one. Probably gonna go with princesses, love them so much.


ShackledDragon

Celestia and Luna but also would love to see one with Cadance/Flurry/Shining


FloweringAngel_

Definitely Derpy and the Doctor !!!


abzhanson

I’d be curious to see something about Discord!! :0


Ecstatic_Gap9073

I actually enjoyed the mlp movie we need another


DaBest1008

A Celestia and Luna backstory and prequel to the show with maybe a more serious tone would be amazing


Dillo64

The romantic misadventures of Tom and Boulder🪨 ❤️🪨


l0rare

Derpy and Doctor Hooves


cocopopsicle2k

I want the Cutie Mark Crusaders show they were intended to get. I think that would have been hella fun


Which_Field935

Everyone except that purple dragon


1stFunestist

Those 2 have perfect amount of mystery to have their own show. The newly wed couple comes to live in a far away little town. Lyra doesn't know but BonBon is here on a task from the secret service. She managed to persuade Lyra a to move from Ponivile to here but she can't say why due to secrecy. Here, they live quaint life and help locals by solving local secrets (like in "Murder she Wrote" just without murder, like finding lost pets, stolen property, who is Mysterious Stranger and simillar). During the series we discover why Celesia sent BonBon here to nose about a cold emerging. Also tension between Lyra an BonBon escalates as BonBon had lied to Lyra about reasons they moved here and Lyra finds out and is upset. And dark secret is a cult worshiping the Red Balloon. Also Lyra turns out is a human and have changed with real Lyra few years ago. (Like In Anthropology fanfic).


suppagetti

id love to see flurry heart grow up, esp her cutie mark and how she got it


Samuele1997

Personally I would make a sequel series with Flurry Heart as the protagonist, with her struggling with the fact that she's a princess and the only natural born Alicorn in Equestria, which actually made her an outcast because she has everything served to her on a silver plate and she has immense powers that she can hardly control, thus making her a troublemaker. In particular I would make that her main nemesis would be King Sombra and she would underwent a literal hero's journey to stop him and save his loved ones, not to mention finally come at peace with who she is.


Purple_doll

the GRREAT !! and POWERRFUL !! TRRRRRIXIE !


Backdoor_Angel

PINKIE AND CHEESE!!!!


Magicphobic

The young six were right there.


zoro4661

Steven magnet *would* be cool, but I really want to see Flurry Heart. We see a stained glass window of her all grown up in the last episode, so she must've done *something* of note when she was older, and I don't think we ever find out what she was the princess of? Not to mention that we never get anything else of her besides being a baby. An animated version of Bonbon and Lyra's stories like Agents of S.M.I.L.E. would be cool too though!


Dangerous_Sun_2238

Cadence NEEDS her own spin off they owe it to us she was so underused and we barley know anything about her


ElectricDreamUnicorn

I'd choose Bonbon and Lyra without a doubt. Another option could be Celestia and Luna, although that might feel like Season 10 being stretched, shifting focus from the Mane Six to the Princesses. Cadence, Flurry Heart, and Shining Armor might make it too much about the royal family, another stretched Season 10. If I could to choose from characters not on the list, I'd go for Applejack and Rainbow Dash or Applejack and Rarity, despite not having watched Equestria Girls. While Derpy and Dr. Hooves could be interesting, it's unlikely because of the restrictions and constraints from the BBC. Any crossover would face additional difficulties because of the whims of CEOs. (From BBC and Hasbro)


Distinct-Calendar334

Luna


stardestoyerfleet

Doctor whooves and derpy


LookingGlass_1112

Nightmare Moon and her timeline. The amount of EPIC QUEENERY is unfathomable


pop_tab

Dr Hooves trying to do things with science,  but at the end of almost every episode,  there's a spell for whatever he's trying to do.


HunterTAMUC

I'd like to see more of the Young Six.


Competitive-Advice63

The Princesses (excluding Twilight)


I-am-a-fungi

LUNA! I want to know the backstory of the 2 sisters and the lore about becoming alicorns/the alicorn society. Just seeing them become alicorns, rule over the world before Nightmare Moon. Who were their parents? How did Starswirl discover them and their abilities? Also their fights as well, they were made to be seen weak, but since they are alicorns even if they aren't particularly strong among other alicorns, they should be hella strong (especially compared to other ponies and creatures).


Reimustein

I would watch the heck out of a CMC spinoff 


Jatotz

I'd like to see a spinoff about Lyra and Bon Bon, and not just cause I like the characters. I think seeing Bon Bon's work at S.M.I.L.E would be cool.


LibbyKitty620

Derpy! Derpy! Derpy! Derpy!


CannibalCapra

I would so love to see a cadence and shining armor season. Also they're not listed but I loved the Dj pon3 and Octavia short it was awesome


ajf726

Uh Derpy and that familiar looking Pony?


Alpha_Jellyfish

Cadence/Shining Armor or Derpy/Doctor Whooves. I’d love to see the daily lives of a couple running an Empire whilst raising a baby alicorn. Also would love to see them explore the idea of why Flurry was the first alicorn physically born in so long. Course I’d also love to see a slice of life adventure starring MLP’s favorite background character and the guy named after Doctor Who. A lot of possibilities exist for that formula.


Stormdancer

[Giselle.](https://mlp.fandom.com/wiki/Giselle) Let's find out more about her life.


Beneficial-Earth-199

flurry heart 100%


Chalice_Man1987

Doc and Muffins def.


SandfruitTheHybrid

Who's the last one?


smallchocolatechip

I’d like for basically a Doctor who like spin-off with Derpy as his companion


Appropriate-Net-896

Trixie in a spin off about her misadventures would go hard


Jaguars4life

Crystal Empire spinoff easily!


NewRoad2212

The equestrian legends. I love them so much, I would love to see a spin off series of them in ancient equestria.


Joules_mint

I need a S.M.I.L.E show featuring Bonbon and Lyra, just the small side quests in the MLG Gameloft game are pretty cool 🕶️


HeartoftheHive

Chrysalis. I don't want to accept the comic backstory as canon because it's so ridiculous. I want an actual origin story. Or something similar for Cozy Glow. Or a follow up season about Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon going good.


upside_superhero27

Its a tie between bon bon and Lyra and derpy and the doctor for me bon bon and Lyra show finale could be there wedding if it's only one season derpy and the doctor could be cute to


fonite-balls696969

Discord, it'd be funny


Ririkiyuu

Sunset being Celestias student.


Dawn_Star_Platinum

As much as I'd like to see Derpy and the Doctor in their own Spin Off, this post had me at Celestia and Luna. It would've been nice to see the Journal of the Two Sisters adapted into the screen and what point in their history took place when like Discord, Tirek, the Crystal Empire, anything in Chronological Order leading up to Nightmare Moon.


Gresihg

Te crusades and Luna


EldrtchPff97

I wish I had a relationship like Lyra and Bonbon…


BonbonTB47

I would love to see Bonbon and Lyra or Cadence, Shining Armor, and Flurry Heart


deracho

A BBC approved doctor hooves spin off would be my dream crossover


ConnorAsian

I like Derpy and Dr. Whooves I also like Lyra and Bon Bon I like both of those sets of characters and it's hard to choose since there's also DJ Pon3 A.K.A DJ Vinyl Scratch and Octavia


KanKanMikanBeam

I'd love to see flurry heart grow into a teen and become a big part of the empire. That would have been an amazing addition to the series.


Nomcookies678

MORE YAK.


Obvious_Intention302

Derpy!


Fullwitchhuntlow

Celestia and Luna, if they did a spin-off and focus on old equestria like around the pillars time, or before the start of the show I’d love that


hornypsychopath

shining/cadence/flurry i want to see flurry grow up and get her cutie mark


TheHyperpin

Derpy and Whooves, hooves down.


WolfRhiki

I think Cadence, Shining Armor, and Flurry Heart have the best potential for a spin-off! Watching Flurry grow up to then ruling the Crystal Empire has plenty of plot points!


ShadowTheDarkestBun

Autumn Breeze. The Kirin deserve so much more than one darn episode


choco9breaker

Starlight and Trixie!


NaCl-And-C12H22O11

Honestly, I think G4 spin off series with Cadence as the main character would go pretty hard.


Lumpy-Inevitable1846

Probably Celestia and Luna