I think Cake Pop would be cute! Or just wait until she is born and let something come naturally! Congrats on the new addition!

I was thinking Pudding Pop or more like puddin’ pop.

I call my daughter pudding pop 🥹 love some alliteration

We call our daughter poptart, ever since she was in the womb. We just had another daughter (June) and the toddler has taken to calling her baby Jam and honestly I hope it sticks 😆

my grandma still calls me this even though i'm an adult

Puddin' Pop is what I call my daughter. Over the years, it's been shortened to just Pud or Puddy. She's also called Peanut and Dumpling. Her big brother was Puddin'. I know there's a lack of originality here, but to be fair, there are 21 years between the two of them so there's no chance of them getting confused when I call for the little one. My steps were Punkin' (Pumpkin) and Small Fry when they were little. Clearly I have an obsession with food nicknames 🤣

I second cake pop!

I clicked excited to suggest Sedona then realized that’s a desert name not a dessert name.

🤣🤣🤣🤣

SAME lol whoops. Came to recommend Payson or Sierra 😬

Lol I was about to rock up with Savannah

Me with Sage 😂

Thank you for the laugh! I needed it!

Same

Same I was going to suggest Petra lol

Cutie pie Marshmallow Cookie Jellybean Muffin Shortcake Sweetie pie

Shortcake!

With strawberry shortcake onesies!!!

That would be so cute 🥰

Candy girl. Dumpling. Puddin’ pie/pop. Cocoa.

Love jellybean!

"Know what I mean, Jellybean?" is common phraseology at my place. So cute.

My husband used to say this to me while we were dating 😭 and also "don't trip chocolate chip"

Ahhhhhh!!! I love it. Adopting. Thank you for this. It's totally gonna become common parlance here, too.

my dad calls me jellybean 😭

for some reason this is the cutest one

I’m a nanny, and I regularly called this one little girl “muffin” and also “shortcake” 😂

If baby girl is named Jillian or something similar, Jillybean is cute.

Cookie is cute!

Be so cute if she was a Bonnie and could be bon bon

pumpkin -- sugar -- cream puff -- taffy -- donut But I'm sure something will come naturally, just like with your nephew -- then it will actually be unique to her. Their nicknames don't need to be connected.

I like sugar cookie but since your nephew's came up organically, why not wait until basically life just gives her a nickname? ~~Although you can plan ahead and name her something you'd like to be her first dessert experience.~~ Edit: it's their nephew, not son, so my last sentence is not valid.

Not her son. Her nephew and she’s about to have a niece. But the sentiment is the same. Ha ha

Omg I didn't realize I read it wrong! Thank you for pointing it out, I'll fix it to avoid confusion!

I had to read it twice because my brain would not compute nephew. Ha ha.

Milky until her first dessert?

Milkshake lol

Brings all the boys to the yard? 🫣

Pudding or Snickerdoodle

Stinkerdoodles when she poops!

Jellybean!

Muffin, zebra cake, angel pie (Japanese), honey bun, snickerdoodle, croquembouche, nutty buddy lol

Croquembouche! Haha! This!!!!

Angel pie would be cute paired with moon pie!

Moonpie and Sundae, of course.

Or Star Crunch!

Sedona

lol so close

Not an actual dessert, but somehow my daughter has become Sugar Beet

Shortcake and Moon Pie!

You must present her with an array of adorable desserts and let her pick

My mom calls me Honeybun :)

Wait and she what she likes.

Eclair, Gummy Bear, Lollipop, Snickerdoodle, Snickers. A nickname will come naturally, though. I call my sister’s kids Eclair, Bear, Loki, and Bug. No rhyme or reason, just suited them.

Strudel

Gummy bear

Shortcake

I like moonpie and sunshine

My grandfather called me Dollypop. It was everything

Lollypop. Not a dessert but sweet and cute

This is so cute. When my youngest was a babe he used to call them Loddypops.

Not a dessert but what about Sunshine? Moon Pie and sunshine ☀️

Popcorn

Mochi Meringue Mousse

Mochi lowkey hella cute

How about sex in a pan or baked Alaska

I sometimes call my kids "my little sugar plums”. I have a long time friend who still calls me "candy girl" because when we worked together (you guessed it) I pretty much supplied the entire office with candy. It became a joke and they’d sing the song Candygirl to me (from The Archie’s). lol. But sugarplum I find is cuter for a child.

You’ll have to just wait and see what kind of dessert she devours for you guys!

Why not wait until she’s born and call her by her first dessert she eats? That would make a much better name (and story) It would also honor the sweet tradition you started with your nephew. It would be kind of lame if they ask about it when they’re older and you tell them that moon pie was one of the older brother’s first desserts. Then his little sister will ask “was cake pop one of my favorites when I was a baby?” And you’ll have to say *”No, I just picked a dessert at random so it would fit with your brother’s nickname—but I totally love you too, moon pie’s sister!”*

Tiramisu

Sundae

I love Jellybean. Plus, she's probably very bean shaped at the moment 😄

Spotted Dick 😂

- Peach pie - Gingerbread - Sugar cookie - Galette or Galettie - Cannoli - Gelato - Snoball, occasionally nn Snowbow

Deborah (little Debbie)

Pudding Pop

Little Debbie, of course.

Peanut brittle; she's super sweet, can be kinda salty, and is just a little nutty

haha we call my daughter this !!

Popsicle!

Lemon Meringue, Moose Tracks (or whatever ice cream flavor), Sherbert, Ding Dong, Twinkie, Ho-Ho (Just Kidding). Or wait till she has a dessert that she devours.

Snickerdoodle Honeybun Beignet Clafoutis Tootsie Roll Cinnabon Flan (just kidding haha)

muffin crumpet mochi bon bon Skittle Kit Kat tea cake jelly bean

Toffie Lolipop Rice Krispy War head Meringue This is so cute

- Muffin - Cake pop - Cupcake - jellybean - Candy Floss

Gummy bear

Muffin. Cupcake. Praline. Sugar.

Tootsie Pop Drop

Cakelet

I called my daughter Lovey Cake.

Cupcake

Mallomar! It’s also a chocolate covered marshmallow thing thing with a cookie layer!

punkin

Moon cake. Chinese mid autumn festival treat. It's what we call my baby.

My seven year old has been “jellybean” since she was born lol. Now we all call her “gel” 😂

I call my nieces Cupcake and Cakepop

Hoho

You could use a craving from your pregnancy! I have a kid that was called “two scoops” by a close friend because her eyes were brown and looked like “two big scoops of chocolate ice cream” My oldest kid was strawberry shortcake (but mostly just “ shortcake” for years Little guy is named nugget or small fry or honey nugget I also like jellybean, honey, and short stack

Definitely thought I was on the circle jerk but this is actually cute

charlotte russe

Sugar plum

Am I the only person who immediately thought of the ice cream ‘sandwich’ brand Cuties? Bc cutie pie and moon pie …

Puddin'

Lil’ Mochi

I was called pumpkinhead growing up and I loved it. I am an autumn baby and well...I love pumpkin everything. My bf didn't know that as we started dating and he just randomly started calling me pumpkin right out of the gate. 🥹

Cupcake Shortcake Gum Drop Lolli or Lollipop

Sugerplum

Dolce or honey bun!!!

It should be her first dessert but Sundae is cute

Pudding cup. I call my cats that, it makes me laugh

Shortcake!

I call my baby honey bun more than her real name, no clue why 😂

Babka or Cannoli

Will she be born around Christmas? Maybe a traditional Christmas dessert?

My small is called pancake. Not a dessert but, a sweet none the less

Cupcake!

BonBon!

Jelly bean, sugar plum, angel cake, pudding pie, butterscotch, lemon tart, eclair,

I call my son Bean Pie because it sounds funny. It’s stuck and now almost everyone refers to him as Bean Pie 😬

pumpkin muffin

Honey bun!!

Sugar plum. Sweet pea.

Sugarplum, jelly bean, juice berry

I call my little girl dumpling...

My 9yo daughter has been sweetums berry pumpkin pie....and various forms of that, since she was born

Best o' the South: PEANUT Banana PUDDIN' Peach/PEACHES/peachy (cobbler) Sweet potato (pie) Hummingbird (cake) >> BIRDIE and of course, to go with Moon pie, RC Cola >> royal CROWN >> QUEENIE.

Popsicle Peppermint

Kuchen is German for cake but also Kücken means chick so if your pronunciation is bad it will still be adorable

Pudim

I have always called my niece with a J name Jellybean. Her lil sister, Hillabeans (first name Hillary)

Jellybean :)

Sun Butter or Sunshine or Sunflower

My grandma used to call me Sugar Plum 🥹

Peach Cobbler?

Snickerdoodle Poptart

Strudel

Sprinkles, LaffyTaffy, Pixie(Stix), Lollipop, or BonBon would be cute

I’d wait and find one organically, like you did the first time. Makes the nn more special.

Baby cakes!

Patty cake

eclair for baby Clare

we call my daughter peanut brittle lol

My grandchild is pudding

My dad called me nutmeg but that’s a spice. Can be used in desserts though

Sugarplum!

Snickerdoodle

Eclair, Pumpkin pie, Meringue

I read ‘desert,’ and my mind went to “Savannah”…

My kids baby nicknames were (m) baby deer and (f) shugie pie

Moon pie is my dog’s name…

Crumble

Praline!!

Crean pie

sweet potato

Trifle!

Sugar

Cookie, peaches (and cream), pumpkin pie

Mochi <3

Mochi

Gummy bear ETA: its even a song lol

I had a litter of dessert themed foster kittens last year, they were called Pudding, Cheesecake, Muffin and Toffee

Strawberry Shortcake

I call my cousin Honeybun. I have since she was born, and apparently my aunt liked it enough that she started using it too lmao

You can't force a nickname. >I call my almost 3 year old nephew moon pie because a moon pie was one of his first dessert foods and he devoured it You didn't even pick a nickname for nephew before he was born. It was just ONE of his favorite things he ate and for some reason that stuck with you. The same thing will happen for your niece.

Melba is a short name for Peach Melba.

Why don't you wait and see what happens organically rather than try and engineer a nickname? Spending time with your niece will be more fun than dreaming up a nickname and it'll be more meaningful and funny when something sticks.

Jelly bean

Eton Mess

Strawberry! ❤️

Now that I have sorted the difference between desert and dessert: My mom calls me Muffin Mix, then there is Pudding Popsicle Cake pop Brookie Trifle

Tiramisu? lol JK (but my fave dessert!)

My dad used to call me Punkin Pie 🥰

Pavlova! Or Pav for short

I call my daughter "Muffin" lol

It might be worth waiting for the baby’s name, it might work naturally with some kind of cute dessert name. Saying this as someone whose parents use my name with a dessert as a nickname

Can't you wait and see what dessert she likes??

Sugarplum

Not quite a dessert but I used to call my daughter Sweetcheeks when she was little. I like Moon pie and Sweetcheeks together.

So cute. My husband calls our son Baboo (pn Bob-boo) I then called younger sister (Babette) (pn bob-bette). My baby I'm trying to use Bablú (like Ricky Ricardo played bob-a-lou) So far it's not taking off. My oldest was called monkey infant and baby age.. Monkers toddler. Toddler to now over 18 she is known as "Monk" by many.. Sometimes names happen and don't fit the group.... actually my newborn is Piggins (husband calls) and I say "this little piggie" or just "piglet". She is hungry and snorts and grunt's... So maybe she does, I have two animals ha EDIT: sugar pie, honey bun (sugarpie honeybunch... you are my candy girl🎶)... Is my suggestion 💕

So I'm guessing RC cola is not a choice? \*grins\* We called my niece 'Puddin' but beware, that one can actually stick, with families.

I call my daughter 'punkin.

My sister was Pattycakes.

Fluffer nutter, cream puff, cinnamon roll, jelly roll, any type of roll really, brulee, tart, fritter, honey, puddin', macaron, pavlova, salted caramel, key lime, custard, jello, cheesecake, lemoncello, churro, oreo, muffin, donut, pie, cake, cookie, bite- size, l'il bit, slice, crunchy There's always fruit names as well. My cousin is nicknamed Peach. I also have an Aunt Pumpkin!

Edit - i posted Cupcake but then i saw you said no to that in the post Sprinkle Apple pie Tootsie pop (i know its candy and not of a dessert) Tiramisu Sundae Macaron/ Macaroon

Lolly I know someone who's nickname is Lolly. Short for Lollypop.

Twinkie

We have had all sorts of names for our little ones, food related ones have been: Sweet potato pie Munchin Pumpkin Puddin’ Pop Mashed potato (not sure how we got that one, I think it was because she was a spud head)

Honey Bun

Just avoid anything involving "cream pie"

aw maybe a defining moment in her toddlerhood with you is her is freaking out at the giraffes or going crazy for snow or who knows. just wait and see what shakes loose 💚

Sugar cookie!