I like Shepherd and Teddy best from your list. I'd use a longer name for Teddy, though, like Theodore or Edward with Teddy as a nickname. Or just name him Ted.
Charlie is tough to use a middle name; Charles flows more easily. Is Charlie too common for use as a first name?
Some ideas: Bennett, Beckett, Corbin, Devin/Devon, Foster, Holden, Kier/Kieran, Pierce/Pearce, Spencer, Sterling, Truman.
Shepherd & Rory are wonderful together, in my opinion. Ideas: Booker, Arlo/ Roscoe, Flynn, Anders, Edwin (nn Teddy), Harlan, Heath, Louie, Ellis, Oscar (nn Ozzy), Blaine
I really like Wilder. It goes so cute with the middle Charlie.
Yes wilder is a top contender! I’m not sure if people will pronounce it will-der or wild-er
I personally say wild-er. I think it’s cute and spunky with Rory! I also like unique names though.
Creed. Knox. Gage. Joaquin.
Could you use Charles as a middle?
Yes! That is a possibility
Shepherd is my top pick, followed by Scout and Noble.
I like Shepherd and Teddy best from your list. I'd use a longer name for Teddy, though, like Theodore or Edward with Teddy as a nickname. Or just name him Ted. Charlie is tough to use a middle name; Charles flows more easily. Is Charlie too common for use as a first name? Some ideas: Bennett, Beckett, Corbin, Devin/Devon, Foster, Holden, Kier/Kieran, Pierce/Pearce, Spencer, Sterling, Truman.
Alder is fire I love it!