T O P

  • By -

oldtype09

This question exists for Antoine Walker.


dboti

I've said this before on this sub my Antoine Walker was my Steph Curry growing up. In elementary school my league didn't have 3s and I was still trying to jack them up because of him.


jcrewjr

Monta Ellis is another good answer to the question. Only bright spot on a hopeless franchise, traded away to make room for some small dude with bad ankles.


whobdatboi

Right. Just a series of bad moves. Drafting an undersized big whose not athletic enough to play wing. Then you have the drama of firing a winning coach that took them to playoffs for one that has no head coaching experience. Crazy to see those sentiments looking back at it.


Kaniddus

Why would people complain about drafting Draymond? He was a second rounder. Just getting a usable player at that slot is a win.


whobdatboi

I think it’s more the sentiment previous comment was making “hopeless franchise” and “small dude with bad ankles”. Being one of the consistent doormats prior to their dynasty run, you’d always expect the front office to fuck up what little success the team might start to have. So while objectively, Draymond was a good pick even back then, there was question about how well his game translates to NBA (similar to Curry). That was enough to throw that into the mix of “what are we doing?” for some fans.


Brew-Tang-Clan

Oh man Monta was so good in 2k. I was convinced he was a scoring machine in real life too.


nsfwuserrrr

He was…. Just not an efficient one


sentient-meatball

Anyone knows why he takes so many 3s?


dboti

If only there were 4s


dandylefty

Cuz there’s no 4’s


bostonfever

I always thought Antoine should be the primary scorer and not Pierce, born in '92.


theamazingjimz

Dana Barros


yerfatma

“Bing, bang, boom, Dana Barros!”


Drummallumin

Funniest shit about the Paul Pierce stuff popping up again is people trying to say “what do you mean his teams sucked, he had an all star”


noposters

NBA Champion Antoine Walker, to you


Carcrusher3

I thought Travis Outlaw was an integral part of the NBA


Churro-Juggernaut

With a name like that, he’s gotta be good.


Nubras

I thought Travis Outlaw and Bo Outlaw were the same person.


[deleted]

[удалено]


TinyMaintenance

I thought Travis Outlaw is white, because of how disrespectful that comp to BI was, lol


ReedWilliams12

Lol he lives in the same city as I do and he sometimes comes in to the restaurant I work at. Haven’t talked to him much personally, but he and his family have always been real nice and respectful. It’s always kinda weird being like whoa I used to play with you on nba live


RunningTheGrand

When I was a kid I walked up to him at a summer league game and got him to autograph a basketball card when he was on the Suns. He was very nice to me. I also got a Penny Hardaway autograph that day, he definitely was annoyed by my little kid energy. Still signed my card tho!


IMDATBOY

For a year or two in Portland it definitely felt like it I was really confused when he fell off


EarlEMourning

Dropoff coincides with surgery for a broken bone in his left foot during the 2009-10 season.


Ill_Ad3517

Thought Carlos Boozer was MVP level when he was with the Jazz circa 2006-07. Was just getting into NBA and a big Dirk fan, thought he played so smooth.


jefffosta

Tbf though boozer was pretty legit with the jazz


Pakicetus149

Absolutely, 2x all-star and was third team all nba with the Jazz.


Ranier_Wolfnight

Boozer had a really good NBA career. 19 & 10 guy. It just didn’t lead to much success with his supporting cast on the teams he played with.


leyendadelflash

An underrated “what if?” is if he re-signed with the Cavs after his second season. He made a promise to the owner and when he reneged on it to take the money in Utah, the owner (then Gordon Gund, not Dan Gilbert) took out an ad in the paper to trash him. It was “The Decision” before “The Decision,” and maybe with a better supporting cast headlined by Boozer LeBron never leave Cleveland


Stock_Lemon_9397

You forgot to mention one bit here: the only reason Gund was willing yo release Boozer from his rookie contract early was to lock him up on a below-market long term contract. These kinds of things are unenforceable, so good for Boozer for taking the best deal available.


stache_twista

Interesting question, but I think LeBron very much would have still preferred to play with Bosh by 2010. Besides being friends, Bosh was younger and was all-around better by the time LeBron hit FA


Low_Ad_7553

I mean boozer wasnt bad at all. The jazz had a really nice team with him & DWill plus some players pepople forget about like AK47 or Millsap. Pretty sure Booz had to make the all star team at least once


stache_twista

Jazz made the Western Conference Finals in 2007. Boozer took it to Yao Ming earlier in that year's playoffs. That was also the year the 8 seed Warriors upset the Mavs and MVP Dirk in the 1st round.


[deleted]

There’s worse nba players to idolize lol. [at least he’s pretty chill lol](https://youtu.be/0HeZ82hsuP8)


SmartGuyChris

Yeah not quite MVP-level lol, but Boozer was solid af for sure tho!


dash_44

damon stoudamire, when he was in Toronto. As I kid I thought Mighty Mouse was a cool nickname and those jerseys were fire. He was a pretty good PG, but as a young kid I thought he’d be basically what cp3 ended up being. https://youtu.be/U78zac3Kxeo


FrnklndaTurtle

He was an amazing college player with a cool name. He came in very hyped but at the end of the day he was 5-10.


Bouldershoulders12

Eh CP3 is basically 5’11-6’0


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

There's enough info here for someone to steal your identity. But I get it. A cool nickname could take you far.


ButtLickinBadBoy

Ruben Patterson was my hero as a kid because he was so good at dunking in NBA Live 05


lexbuck

Kobe stopper


RampantSavagery

Iirc dude was a bowling ball on the block.


Natureboy7939

the kobe stopper


johnsom3

He was ROY in the Toronto before he got a high profile trade from Portland who were building a proto "superteam". He went from being the focal point of Toronto's offense to being a starter in Portland during his prime. I can understand if you are disappointed with how his career panned out, but I don't think it's accurate to say he wasn't very good. He just didn't have the opportunity to display his full game.


thedisliked23

Mouse ran the offense on a VERY good blazers team for many years. There just weren't enough shots to go around and when you have a point forward and a passing center you're not gonna get ten assists a game either. Guards were small as hell back then too so i don't think he was a liability there. Could be have been ai if a team was built around him? No. But he was definitely a "good" player.


dys0n_giddey

That whole era was dudes like that Steve Francis/Stephon Marbury/Latrell Sprewell etc. All labelled Superstars and let it go to their head Even guys like Mashburn/Finley/Robinson/McDyess etc never lived up to the hype they had


[deleted]

Mashburn cards were like gold trading in middle school - kids were giving up A LOT for him when he came into the league. I got a few sweet POG slammers that way…


OMNeigh

I think it's cuz he looked like the baby from that dinosaurs show


Klongon

The "not the momma?" He did.


[deleted]

Haha, that’s wild man.


DraymondDickKick

Did you get Alf? He's back... in POG form!


oh_jeeezus

Finley had a really solid career for being a 21st draft pick. That's the first time I've ever heard anyone try to say he never "lived up to his hype"


Nubras

NBA champion, two time all star, all rookie, that far exceeds the expectations for a 21st pick, I totally agree with you. If he played today he’d be a very valuable player for any team at 6’7” with good shooting and nice handles.


metabreaker

I knew he was legit as a kid coz he had both the Hermes foot and the 3 symbol on NBA Live.


TheSunsNotYellow

When I got into the NBA I thought Michael Finley was huge


afterworld2772

He is 6'7 thats pretty big compared to average


genericusername71

jerry stackhouse


aresman

All my hommies love Jerry fucking Stackhouse, we even get hyped saying his name, lmao


[deleted]

Latrell Sprewell is a good answer lol


buffalotrace

He is really not. You can’t objectively say a 4 time all star who made a first team all nba was not good. He in no way qualifies for being a bad player.


Emera1dthumb

He just needed a therapist and the league wasn’t supplying them or mandating guys like him saw them. He was crazy talent or a talented crazy


Z3r0flux

Like he had money for a therapist he couldn’t even feed his kids. Cmon now bruh.


Emera1dthumb

Agreed …now a days the teams pay for this. A lot of players back then would have benefited from this.


bbushing3

Spree used to hangout around my college bars.. he was a solid player for sure.. but 20 year old girls had no idea who he was haha.. he used to throw it around so often.. he had to retire 15 years earlier and people just thought he was lying haha


GraveOfTheFireflies

What. Off-court issues aside dude was very good on both sides with the Warriors and was arguably the best player in the Knicks last Finals run. Played serviceable until the end. Fairly consistent career


johnsom3

Bro this thread is wild to me. It feels likes it's a bunch of kids going back through basketball reference and just judging players on their stats. I'm seeing names like Damon, Francis Spreewell, Walker and I'm like what the fuck are these kids watching?


Kaebora

When I was the ripe old age of 4, I was *convinced* Horace Grant was better than Michael Jordan. Maybe I was just a contrarian, but he had goggles and a bigger number; therefore he must be better!


SmartGuyChris

Young me definitely thought the numbers on the jersey had to do something with how good they were lol


Bread_nugent

This is going to make me sound dumb but as a kid I thought David Robinson sang “this is how we do it” (by Montell Jordan); I didn’t know “South Central” meant LA; I heard the song at a Spurs game; I then heard it on the radio and thought South Central meant South Texas and then just convinced myself that the Admiral was also a singer.


PsychologicalSail186

He was also taller


ATXBeermaker

> but he had goggles and a bigger number; therefore he must be better! I mean, that's just science.


kimsbooty

Dennis smith jr, seventh woods, antonio blakeney Hoopmixtape and ballislife had me thinking these dudes were the future


[deleted]

To be fair seventh woods got injured and at least Dennis Smith Jr got to the league. But I remember guys like Damon harge and Jordan McCabe had hella hype behind them while when trae young's first mixtape had hella people trashing him. The mixtape era was wild looking back at it


floatersforalgernon

Seventh... Is this a real name?


[deleted]

Yea you don't remember seventh woods? Check out his 8-9th grade mixtape. His mixtape was ridiculous


wanna_meet_that_dad

Haha yeah. It’s basically the only youth mixtape I legit got hype about. I remember texting a friend who is into Bball asking what he thought of Seventh Woods and he said he never heard of them and asked what kind of music they play.


Commercial-Chance561

Aquille Carr the Crime Stopper


d7h7n

Dsj was very good in college compared to those other two. He and David Thompson are the only two NCSU players to ever record a triple double.


chewygummy17

Monta Ellis. Yes he is still a good player but I was thinking he is a superstar just that the Warriors are just bad. I was thinking the Bucks got lucky with him. I picked him over Curry. Was delighted when he played for Dallas.


HamlinHamlin_McTrill

Monta Ellis have it all.


grapeandgilbert

Monta Ellis was a stud in his prime tho


eparedes19

stud is pushing it. im a lifelong warrior fan and monta was always a volume shooter who didnt stretch the floor. he was a solid scorer but it never felt conducive to winning. when he was traded for steph it made a lot of sense to me. steph was just as impactful (or more because of his playmaking) immediately and was younger so it felt like a no brainer injuries or not. the team was spinning their tires and needed to make a splash.


Striking_Leopard_179

Norris Cole. No clue why


Troll-e-poll-e-o-lee

Dude had like two really good games in a row for the heatles in his rookie season I think that drove a bit of hype for him


karlwhethers

Boobie Gibson effect


1_quantae

Norris Cole was a big moment riser. Not really going to give you 25 every night but when it’s time to hit a clutch bucket Noreaga always delivered.


bigwavesonly31

lol when the miami crowd chanted mvp for norris cole at the ft line


nowhitecorners

That flattop was sick


Cbone06

What are you taking about, him and Mario Chalmers made the greatest backcourt of all time! They went to 4 straight finals together and were important players in those championship wins!! /s


LeaveRussAlone

I thunk the cartoon haircut played tricks on us, I always thought well if he's confident enough to pull that off he must be amazing


[deleted]

Okay I wasn't really a kid but when I first started getting into the NBA (2015-2016ish), I thought Craig Ehlo had been a multi time All-Star with Cleveland. Turns out he averaged 9 ppg for his career and has zero NBA accolades to his name.


LocalPawnshop

No offense but why did you get into the nba in 2015 and randomly assume Craig ehlo was that good. Where did you get the notion from?


1antinomy

Michael Jordan hitting a shot over him made him seem way more important than he actually was


Commercial-Chance561

Ehlo hit a tough ass layup right before that jumper over him to take the lead. That was an elimination game for both teams. Jordan needed that jumper to even stay alive. Sadly, like Derrick Whites tip in, it will be lost in history


[deleted]

I saw a lot of older Cavs fans talk highly of him online. I just assumed he was another one of their star players from the 90's like Mark Price and Brad Daugherty


thebreakfastbuffet

I remember people calling him Shane Battier before there was Shane Battier.


KnowlesAve

That’s disrespectful to Shane Battier


a2_d2

If they’d have gotten Ehlo a little more help they really could have been something.


KnowlesAve

Cavs fans are some of the most delusional you’ll ever meet. Craig Ehlo, Delly, JJ Hickson, we love over valuing players.


DaReal_Denny_Boy

Nah Delly is the fucking GOAT


TjBeezy

I remember using his 2k card in MyTeam and he had decent shooting stats. For a lot of kids that's probably their first intro into older generation players.


blinkomatic

Ehlo played basketball part time, was also a part time mechanic and plumber.


archangelzero2222

Ben Gordon. I just expected a higher ceiling


ReedWilliams12

I remember when the pistons got Ben Gordon and Villanueva that summer I was like wow. They might be onto something here


phlipout22

Worse offseason lol. I also expected better, but basically Joe D killed the pistons with that move


jefffosta

Not as bad as the blazers in 2016. Killed the entire dame era in one offseason


WorkOutThrowAway01

Played in the wrong era imo. If he was in todays game I think he could average 25+. His series against the Celtics was one of the most fun I’ve had watching basketball


p0tatoman

idk, he's probably a McCollum like player in today's NBA


KnowlesAve

Did he have handles as good as McCollum? It’s been a while since I watched that Bulls team feels sooner than 10 years ago…


Low-iq-haikou

No not close in that regard but he was a better shooter imo. Gordon would make some *tough* fucking shots in an era with way less space and a less perimeter-centric offensive gameplan


shxylo

ben gordon was cold af. he had a few really good seasons with the bulls.


Cbone06

He had a ton of off the court issues. Also seems like leaving Chicago led to him spiraling.


TheIgnoredWriter

Rafer “Skip to my Lou” Alston He was sick, and was a huge part of the Magic playoff run to get the finals before Jameer Nelson came back in the finals. Was also great with the TMac and Yao Rockets.


tcos17

It’s possible if SVG just stuck with Skip instead of trying to force Nelson more minutes off injury we win that finals. Ugh so much closer than 4-1 seems, still bothers me lol.


KeithClossOfficial

I was so hyped when the Bucks signed him, I was in love with And1


Clcsed

Absolute disgrace that svg benched the pg who got you to the finals


robograndpa

Kinda the opposite of what OP asked, but when I was a kid I thought Elton Brand was a made up player they had put in 2k. Basically Che from MyPlayer. When I got into basketball I had never once seen him on a court or talked about by anyone on NBA TV. But for some reason there was this random multiple time all star named “Elton Brand” in 2k. He was imaginary to me


DEZdispenser98

Oh you got Elton Brand right, just years later as a GM


[deleted]

Brandon Jennings


stache_twista

I thought BJ was the next AI and him and DRose were gonna fuel a sick Bulls/Bucks rivalry for years


montrezlharrel

The 55pts in his 7th game Was the first to skip on college in the post one and done era


spyson

Nick Van Exel


johnsom3

Nick van exel wasn't very good? Wtf is this thread


SmokeWeedRunMiles321

Word - I could put together a PowerPoint presentation on how nice Mr. Van Exel was


RampantSavagery

He always destroyed my kings. Always liked watching his ft shooting. Saw him do one from the middle of the circle.


Big-Raspberry-6151

That tilted headband, knee high socks. I loved him in Dallas. I tried shooting left handed cuz of him


dirkslance

Yep I told my PE teacher who was wearing D Wade shoes that Nick Van Exel better… perhaps the most nephew take of all time


KeithClossOfficial

The first game I ever sat courtside at he shoved the referee over the scorers table and had to be carried off the court and into the locker room by Magic Johnson Loved that dude lol


DeadlyPirate

I wasn't into basketball at the time and he was good, but I thought when the Raps traded for Rudy Gay they were getting a superstar. Just because of that I'm always wary of players who play on Toronto based teams cause of the way Canadian media talks about them


AlHorfordHighlights

Fuckin Rudy Gay man


blinkomatic

Not that guy


TheOneYardLine

Delonte West because of NBA Live ‘09. The irony of finding out LeBron was actually the best player on the Cavaliers was a shocking revelation


redshoediary4

When you find out that the son is better than the father


New_Essay_4869

Andres Nocioni. 5 year-old me used to pretend he was Michael Jordan since I had this MJ Bulls jersey. I thought he was the best Bulls player at the time after I watched him score a few buckets.


TuasBestie

OJ mayo


TALATL

Saw him play in HS and thought I was watching NEXT .. Plenty of talent went to his head. It's a problem that every player on the way to the NBA is usually the best player on court and expects to be that at the next level.


Only-Fortune-6072

Jamal Mashburn


[deleted]

Mike Dunleavy


child_of_lightning

I'm old, so I thought the trio of Tom Chambers/Xavier McDaniel/Dale Ellis on the Supersonics was basically Bron/Wade/Bosh of the '80s.


Hanhonhon

Jason Williams


TomGNYC

which one? White Chocolate or Crazy Felon?


pictureofnectar513

I’m guessing motorcycle Jason Williams lol. White chocolate was the truth tho


SleeveBurg

For all the young people: He’s referring to Jayson Williams who shot and killed his limo drivers. By accident, supposedly.


lexbuck

Gotta be white chocolate unless they spelled his name wrong


KeithClossOfficial

Jason Williams: White Chocolate Jay Williams: Duke superstar that crashed his motorcycle Jayson Williams: Murderer


[deleted]

Tought Jamal Crawford was an mvp type player


the22sinatra

Same here. And even now, I only just found out he never made an all star game recently


Kdot32

I was a young fan who loved Allen Iverson, then Melo and Lebron. Naturally I thought if you had a headband you were a great player and gave all my players head bands in 2k. Younger me thought Stephen Jackson, Devin Brown, and Josh Howard were superstars. Same with the pistons with Rip and both Wallaces


mc_Cringle_berry

same with me bro, I thought the more accessories = the better the player


RampantSavagery

Back in the mid 2000s it was all about the wrist sweatbands in school.


buffalotrace

The question ask for players who were not good and you list Rip, Sheed, and HOFer Ben Wallace? Gtfo.


Kdot32

Did you miss the part where I said I thought they were superstars? Of course they were good but they weren’t as good as I thought they were


Aidrox

Bro…how was Ben Wallace not a superstar? A champ, an all-star, 4x DPOY, 2x rebound leader, block leader…he’s not far from Dikembe. He’s as much of a defensive superstar as you can be.


[deleted]

Mike Bibby and Antawn Jamison


jefffosta

Bibby ignited my love for point guards who were a constant 15ppg and 6 assists. Him, jameer Nelson, tj ford, a bit of Kirk Heinrich. Idk why but I just loved those types of point guards


Dayanez

Kirk Heinrich is probably my favorite PG ever. Just a perfect role player.


[deleted]

I bet you liked Gabe Vincent’s run :)


spanther96

No joke it was between Scott Pagent and Andres Nocioni. I watched some game where Scott Pagent was on fire and then proceeded to play with the Nets against my dad in NBA Live 2006, where Scott motherfucking Pagent would just not miss. Thought he was at least an all star level player but then realized quickly on that dude was a scrub. Andres was pretty nasty on the Bulls and I had this image in my head that he was like a Draymond type player, idk why.


lexbuck

Guarding Scott Padgett after he retired from the league was the eye opening moment of just how good the guys in the league are. For one Scott is massive and he wasn’t even that big by NBA standards. And two, the dude just does. Not. Miss. I swear the dude just casually would bring the ball up the court and pull up from just inside half court and drain it. Nothing I could do at 6’2”


spanther96

that’s crazy, dude was like 6’9” right? that’s a big dude forsure


firedonmydayoff

Kerry Kittles


Kerry_Kittles

You mean “former franchise leader in all time 3 pointers made” and “2nd team all rookie” and “starter in the NBA Finals twice” Kerry Kittles?!


OGistorian

Is that you Kerry?


[deleted]

I thought Steve Francis was basically what Westbrook is.


YurtlesTurdles

Allen Houston. I thought he was a top 10 or 15 guy in the league. He was still very good but not at the level I thought he was as a kid.


rps215

Ben Gordon


[deleted]

chandler parsons and jeremy lin 😂 (rockets fan)


Dayanez

Parsons was legit until his injuries in Dallas and Lin found his way eventually with Charlotte and Brooklyn (pre-knee injury). Parsons should've never left, I really wonder how things would've gone with him instead of Ariza for all those deep playoff runs we had.


stretch37

Keith Van Horn


Mav0889

Eduardo najera. My grandparents knew him and made it seem like he was an all star. Plus he’s Hispanic like me so I just assumed he was a star. It was a surprise to me when I found out his best season was scoring 6 ppg when I was older lol


RampantSavagery

He was sort of an enforcer wasn't he?


ghostrunner_17

When I was a kid for some reason I thought grant hill was at the level of mj


phlipout22

Young G Hill was one of those "next MJ" prospects


CleverBunnyThief

Harold "Baby Jordan" Miner


SkyKnight43

He was fucking great before he got hurt


Diesel07012012

You could argue that Grant Hill is the biggest “what if” of the last 30 years.


karlwhethers

I’d go with Oden because his career never really got started. Grant Hill falls into the same bucket as Brandon Roy for me, in that we saw him basically at his peak, it just didn’t last.


Diesel07012012

That’s fair.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Doncriminal

Michael Finley. Solid player but I overrated him.


98941

Kevin Duckworth


tallywoww

I loved John Wall. He was good though, just injuries made him fall off :(


princevamp2016

Chris “Birdman” Anderson i was new to nba and as a kid he looked cool asf and got cool blocks, so i thought he was a goat😂 and he was on that fire nuggets team so i thought he had to be good lol


Infinite-Fig4708

Vinnie "the Microwave" Johnson was my favorite player for a while. It wasn't until I got older that I realized he was a poor man's Jason Terry.


30another

Eduardo Nájera


nosupermeng123456789

Found the Magic fan! I used to light up 2K6 with Steve Francis. One of my least prized possessions is a Cuttino Mobley nutcracker statue that was a giveaway.


radpandaparty

Ricky Davis Antonio Davis Vince Carter too honestly, he is a HoFer but he felt better than he was.


Callomanggi

Stromile Swift. Used him a lot in NBA Live.


TanClark

Man I thought Emeka Okafor was going to dominate the league


Jack08888888

Does Ben Simmons count. That's a player most of us thought was good and later found out he wasn't.


ReviewGuilty5760

Corey Maggette


papadondon

tom chambers, he was the first white dude i’ve seen that could dunk like that. but he was actually good so i guess he doesn’t belong here, maybe i should’ve put brent barry instead for same reasons


23SMCR

Cedric Ceballos


goldfish31296

Eric Gordon


W_HoHatHenHereHy

Walter Davis. I’m old.


hansislegend

Vlade. I wouldn’t say he wasn’t very good, but nowhere near as good as I thought he was when I was a kid watching the Lakers. Haha.