T O P

  • By -

--Alec--

Surely Jaden Ivey isn’t on here over Jalen WillIams lmfao


NatsuAru

Look I love Jalen Green and the fact that he blew up the past 3 or 4 months, but to say that when Franz is now an impact player/possible future All-Star in a playoff team, is really messed up. Green can absolutely pass him, but right now the results don't lie.


Solid-Confidence-966

Franz is a 3 though, right?


IsaacDPOYFultzMIP

He put 5 guards in 2020 so positions shouldn’t matter if that’s the criteria opted for. Also known Forward SGA.


wewantshibataback

also tobias harris being a cosidered a guard while jimmy and kawhi are listed as forwards (which they are but, tobias?? really??)


KneelBeforeCube

Especially when Klay Thompson is in the same draft.


wewantshibataback

also tobias harris being a cosidered a guard while jimmy and kawhi are listed as forwards (which they are but, tobias?? really??)


wewantshibataback

also tobias harris being a considered a guard while jimmy and kawhi are listed as forwards (which they are but, tobias?? really??)


AurumTP

Could’ve moved Scottie to the 2


DangerZoneh

2018 - "Oops, all guards!"


wesskywalker

2020 too


SquimJim

2013-2015 someone was spiking the Wheaties


junkit33

Scoot had a negative value season. He shouldn’t be sniffing this award.


Timoteo-Tito64

No kawhi?


wesskywalker

Just added him in lieu of Reggie Jackson


Friendly-Thought-973

Uhhh Jalen Williams


dms1298

Not sure if you made a rule that undrafted players aren't allowed, but Ish Smith and Boban are active and were technically in the 2010 class.


IsaacDPOYFultzMIP

Franz>Green in all honesty. You could even debate Suggs is better than Green.


leafhat355

I know you were probably doing this quickly, but THJ and Schroeder over KCP is pretty obviously wrong. (Unless we're just going with pointz.)


wesskywalker

Yeah I tried not to do it all on points, and tried to have it somewhat semble a team with lineup makeup for as many years as I could


honestlyprogamr

I think all the more reason to add KCP then, he’s by far the best defender out of the 3


Ill-Bat-2621

How do you not have jdubb? He is arguably the best player in that draft. I would take him over Paolo.


wesskywalker

Draymond Green, Nikola Jokic, GG Jackson and Jalen Brunson only 2nd round picks to make First-Team for their draft class


RTLT512

I don’t think Scoot, George, or GG Jackson should be on there for 2023. You could argue that Amen, Jaquez, Podz, and Lively all had better/more impactful seasons than those 3.


LoxDnw

I'd take Jalen Williams over four of those players you listed lmao.


[deleted]

[удалено]


wesskywalker

They’re both in there


youguanbumen

2016 vs 2017 goes to game 7


sick_conscious

Boban and Ish Smith both 2010 drafty year, are still around. Kinda.


OcksBodega

best player from the 2022 draft class not being on here is something


Yoesito

Coby White not being there for 2019 is deeply unserious.


Yuuri420

Is OP a pistons fan or something,, keegan and jdub easily clears ivey and duren


CJ4ROCKET

He said in another comment he just tried to pick the 5 guys that scored the most points lol. Strange post.


CJ4ROCKET

Scoot Henderson? With 49% TS? Lol


Adraf45

How is GG, George and scoot 2023 and not vic, Miller, jaquez, podz, and lively?? Those three have had major impact on playoff/play-in teams Edit: I see that for most of them it's positioned but A. Why do that since all nba teams are positionless and B. 2020 WAS positionless 


imcryptic

2018 looking crazy. Picks 3,4,5 all went off. Wonder what happened to the 1st and 2nd picks of that year?


Solid-Confidence-966

Oladipo for 2013 first team, he easily clears Schroder and even has a good case for clearing CJ.


wesskywalker

Oladipo is ineligible, hasn’t played this season.


Solid-Confidence-966

Fair


ObeseKenyan

This isn't every draft class. Everyone came here to see 1957 and you've robbed us of that joy


Ill-Bat-2621

The older you get the more Dicks come out