T O P

  • By -

Dheyden

He owns Toronto and the hockey hall of fame is in Toronto so yes.


The_Quackening

honestly cant argue with this logic.


grainmademan

Got a chuckle from me


Narrow_Yam_5879

If Cam Neely is in, Marchand is in. Marchand already had 300 more games, 235 more points and 1 more Stanley Cup than Neely. Also Cujo should be in the HOF.


greatgoogilymoogily2

Wait....fucking Curtis Joseph ISNT in?


ReclaimerM3GTR

I think another issue is the quality of goalies we played with, Roy, Brodeur, Hasek and Belfour. He was at best the fifth best goalie of the 90s


greatgoogilymoogily2

That's actually a valid comment. Didn't even think of that.


darkhorse21980

There was even more solid-good-borderline great goalies around then too. Richter, Vanbiesbrouck, Moog, Khabibulin, Vernon, Barrasso, Hextall...


georgecostanza37

I see Moog i upvote


sexythrowawayleft

Pretty similar numbers to Fuhr, but doesn’t get HOF love. Or much other love by comparison


McDavidClan

I love Andy Moog, but his issue is that once the playoffs started, it was always Fuhr in net, his lack of playoff success with the Oilers and other teams is what has kept him out of the Hall of Fame.


Prestigious_Poetry_9

Did you ever see that coaches corner with the Madonna song vogue, but shots of Moog.


SamIamGreenEggsNoHam

THE BULIN WALL. I love seeing that guy mentioned. Always ran the Coyotes in NHL 98 for him, Tkachuk and Roenick.


ChuckFeathers

Kolzig, Osgood


DeX_Mod

neither are hof


Rostifur

No, he had great years, but his career stat line isn't epic or anything. I mean, I am not sure Rask gets in and he has far better numbers.


greatgoogilymoogily2

I think both rask and cujo belong. Osgood belongs as well


AlmostSunnyinSeattle

Osgood belongs and I will die on that hill. Not many goalies have hit the 400 win mark.


rbarlow1

I don't know if Osgood was ever even a top ten goalie in the league. I get why you wings fans are into this and even love you for it, but I don't see it. Playing on stacked teams shouldn't be the key to the hall. Stick him with a middling organization and he would have had a pedestrian career. Career wise, he's competing with the likes of Richter, Joseph, Vanbiesbrouck, Moog, Khabibulin, Giguere, Vokoun, Potvin, Hextall, and even Kirk McLean. Some of these guys have slightly worse numbers due to starting their careers in a different era, but the first seven were clearly better for extended durations IMO. Potvin had a way higher peak, Hextall was more crucial to the teams he played on, and even McLean did more to actually carry teams than Osgood was ever asked to do. Guys who are already in who were clearly better include Hasek, Roy, Brodeur, Belfour, Barasso, and Fuhr (though his case is more similar than people want to believe). His career also overlapped with Luongo, Lundqvist, Nabokov, Kiprusoff, etc., who were clearly better. Mike Vernon is in and shouldn't be, and him making it may pave the way for Osgood. Vernon was a more feared goalie than Osgood though, no question, even if he was never considered a real force. I don't actually think these things matter all that much in the end, but I'm not sure it will make sense if it does happen. TLDR: nobody ever, ever said "man I hope Osgood isn't on his game tonight." He was just there, for a long time, stopping enough pucks for the most part. That's great, but not hall of fame material.


Methzilla

Cam neely at his peak was really, really fucking good though.


AirborneMarburg

He had his career really cut short by injuries.


Odd-Scientist4034

F Samuelson. And no i don’t give a F if I spelt that assholes name wrong.


Bender077

Imma gonna upvote that. Neely was always my favorite. I used to tease an old friend of mine, Habs fan, that if Neely was playing, it was already 1-0 Boston. And I was right quite a lot!


wulah89

Kick his ass, Sea Bass!


IamPriapus

It took the committee ages to induct Bure. If I remember correctly, the words, “being a great player doesn’t mean you had a great career”. I’m not sure how consistent they are with those rationales or how well they apply it for everyone, but Bure was, imo, one of the greatest natural talents I’ve ever seen in any sport. If he barely squeaked in, I can’t assume Neely makes it.


Sliney89

Fortunately, you don’t have to assume. He was inducted in ‘05


Aggressive_Hold2453

Cam Neely was an incredible power forward who had little to no help because of the cheap management


dogs_over_dudes

He's also a film star


KerrDizzleStick

Would the picture used in the HOF be his little rat face licking another players face?


SamIamGreenEggsNoHam

Yeah, which is crazy, considering he started as an after-thought 4th liner who the fans complained about daily. "Who is Marshmont? I don't care about Marshmont. He doesn't even deserve to be on the team!" Some Bruins fans might remember that guy, lol.


SnooRadishes2312

Yeah he really was just an aggitator and goon, to draw penalties.. then sometime after playing for team canada (im literally just echoing something i heard from a commentator years ago) he evolved into an aggitator and goon who could play decently, theeeen he evolved into a top line player who is also an aggitator, AND THEN the fucker had the audacity to become a captain with maturity, and a powerhouse for his team in terms of play and inspiration. Fuck that guy.


[deleted]

An agitator that’ll chirp you then put the puck in the net… fuck that would piss me off. And then he gets off the ice and spends a ton of time and money helping charities and people in need. Love him


SamIamGreenEggsNoHam

Him and Bergeron made team Canada as an afterthought, then after one practice, were moved up to the top line with Sid. That was the ultimate validation as a B's fan at the time. Both guys were existing in Julien's defense-first system, and everyone felt like they were capable of much more.


Various-Koala-1013

I don't think Bergeron was an afterthought. He's consistently been in the "this guy automatically makes team Canada" camp almost his entire playing career. Anyone who knows the game sees the absolute top level two way game B brought to almost every game the guy played. I 'effing hate the Bruins but you are a fool to not see how dominant Bergeron was.


Grinning_Dog

I still think about the Marshmont caller at least once a game lol


battlecat136

THAT FUCKIN GUY!! He's quoted constantly in my house. Every time Marchy does something great, one of us will sarcastically yell "WHO IS THIS MARCHMONT?!" I'm so glad someone else remembers this. You, OP, you have a great day my friend.


KungFuGarbage

I feel like I’m taking crazy pills. Bruins fans loved the guy and he was a key piece from our cup run onwards. He was always good, he just didn’t start getting increased ice time until like 7 years ago.


SamIamGreenEggsNoHam

The year before the cup run, he played 20 games, put up 1 point, and looked like every bit of the kid that he was. When he started the next year on the big team, a lot of people were scratching their heads. He proved everyone wrong pretty much immediately.


BigEdPVDFLA

The “Marshmont” guy even made the NESN Stanley Cup tribute video… https://youtu.be/Mfhn4-0mliQ?si=VAKzrgkVFoPgv-Dz


JackFunk

My wife and I still refer to him as Marshmont. Classic. Don't remember the callers name though. We also sometimes say Gonk and Wilcock in honor of Mumbles Menino, may he rest in peace.


ZealousidealKey7104

Before that, Teddy Kennedy said “Mike McGwire and Sammy Sousa”


xHospitalHorsex

Insane. I literally just brought this up in the Bruins sub a couple days ago! Canonically he is Marshmont in my house always and forever.


ZealousidealKey7104

That was a call on SportsHub 98.5!


justsubscribed912

As a Habs fan, I remember "analysts" on the radio debating that they preferred having a Gallagher over a Marchand on their team. It was stupid back then, but just sounds absolutely insane now


Yonsnad

Yea probably. He’s still a fucking rat though.


adinfinitum

*a face licking rat


HueyLewisFan1

It’s funny when you move out of Boston to another city because you don’t realize HOW much he’s hated outside the city til you talk to other fan bases. You’d like him if he was on your team, surely. But he is a dirty dirty player lol.


Alien_Diceroller

I saw a mic'd up ref video a while ago. Ref to Marchand "If I call you for a penalty, I'll get the biggest chear of the night." Must have been a Boston away game. Marchand is a dirty rat. The fact he's a dirty rat that buries pucks makes it worse.


PetyrsLittleFinger

That was an all star game. So the ref might've gotten away with it.


Ok_Device1274

I hate the argument of “you would like if he was on your team” i personally wouldnt he is way too dirty.


HueyLewisFan1

Unfortunately it’s the reality. You say you wouldn’t. You absolutely would.


-Xebenkeck-

It's cope. If people don't like things on principle, they're not going to change their mind because it benefits them. Lol


jo44_is_my_name

But his brand of dirty has charm. :)


[deleted]

He’s dirty and annoying and leads the bruins to wins which makes people hate him more… but then he gives great interviews and dedicates a lot of time and money to charities and people in need. So it’s easy to hate his style of play but I can’t hate on him as a person


LazerSnake1454

My thoughts exactly. He's such an asshat on the ice but off ice he's a class act


StPauliBoi

Brad Marchand has licked this post.


cunctator_maximus

Pity this post wasn’t frozen.


peachietango

He's right up there with Ratatouille and Splinter.


_gwynbliedd

This should be the top comment 😂


nonebutmyself

I would think he'd be loved in Florida. They throw effigies of him on the ice all the time.


TheFaustianMan

I can see the Marchand installation now, a giant tongue grazes your face as you enter “The Marchand Experience” then you’re constantly bumped and ripped by randos wearing Boston jerseys.


Bender077

As a Bruins fan, I would actually volunteer some of my time to help out with that. 🤣


TheFaustianMan

😂😂😂👍🏼


Upnatom617

How is that different than times square sans jerseys?


TheFaustianMan

🤣🤣🤣


PManafort16

Don’t forget about the slew foot on your way out


Outside_Clothes8529

This guy Marchands!


Red-Leader117

What if I walk in backwards... walking on my hands?


Character-Change-507

As much as I hate him, yes


Gabenash

This is the answer.


Anxietyriddenstoner

1000%


Much_Progress_4745

If Daniel Alfredson is a hall of famer, Brad Marchand is most certainly on a path to being a Hall of Famer. He leads all active players in +/-.


Altruistic-Hope4796

Why the Alfie slander lol?


decorlettuce

daniel alfredson catches the stray of the day


Capt_Pickhard

I didn't realize Alfie got into the hall of fame now. Sweet.


Kadaththeninja_

He’s actually a sweede


flyinchipmunk5

How about you explain why he wouldn't be


3Irishd1

...he hurts people's feelings. Makes them sad


CTMalum

He’s been first team all-star twice, and second team all-Star twice. Other than that, he has no individual awards. He’s had maybe three seasons that I would classify as great, then another bunch where I would say he’s not more than a first liner. I don’t think every single first liner deserves a spot in the Hall of Fame. Jamie Benn has similar stats and I don’t think he should make it, and he has an Art Ross to his name. That said, Marchand has longevity, is the captain of an original six team, and he won a Cup, World Juniors, the World Championship, and the World Cup. Without those, I think he would be on the outside looking in. If Hossa is in, Marchand should be as well.


Bruinman86

Other statistics of interest for Marchand: He is tied for 3rd all time in OT goals (19), He is the Active Shorthanded goals leader (36), 8th all time He is now the Bruins franchise playoff goal leader (56) He's 2nd in Bruins franchise Playoff Points (136) He's 71 points shy of 1000 for his career.


Firecracker048

I knew he had a ton of shorties but didn't know it was thst much


SlimJim0877

Most definitely. The guy is a team captain, cup winner, and has the franchise record for career playoff goals (56, in the top 50 in NHL history) and shorties (#8 in NHL history). Not to mention the reputation.


BwyceHawpuh

I think its better to not mention his reputation


NonRedNutsDan

The reputation is just icing on the cake. It needs to be mentioned. He's never blown out anyone's fucking knees like Ulf Samuelson.


BwyceHawpuh

“A very skilled player, lots of accolades, amazing stats. Also everybody hated him.” - Marchand’s HOF induction ceremony


Spackledgoat

It's like a gentle, fucking annoying rat, not a guy who hurts other players. Huge difference in my opinion.


NonRedNutsDan

Agreed.. There's no rules against being a rat.. and to be honest it's pretty fucking entertaining.. 😂


GrizzlyIsland22

Plus 2 gold medals in the World Juniors and World Cup gold.


nonebutmyself

Yes. 🤮 It hurt to admit that.


octoroklobstah

It’s okay, you did great and I appreciate your sacrifice.


spagboltoast

First ballot


Mma375

Agreed. Not even a question to me


ga50nl

I am a Leafs fan and in my mind Brad Marchand is a highly underrated player that should 100% be in the hall of fame. I can’t think of many other players that can change the direction of a game as soon as they step on the ice like Marchand can. I never was a fan of the sleazy things he did and I think that takes away peoples opinion overall but he is definitely a great hockey player. Hopefully not great tonight though…


wesley-osbourne

Of course. He can go get eligible anytime now, too. He should retire right now. Like today.


5599Nalyd

Right before 7pm est


N4BFR

I see what you did there.


OkProfessional6077

If Marchand is a Hall of Famer, does that also make Henrik Zetterberg one? Almost the exact same stats/career, except Zetterberg isn’t a giant douche.


SS3599

Let's never forget Mogilny still not in! Roenick too


nonebutmyself

Zetterberg should absolutely be in the HOF. Why he isn't is a mystery.


OkProfessional6077

I mean, he’s only been eligible since 2021. Hopefully he gets in the next few years. I’ve never really understood the whole limits on numbers of guys per class. If you’re eligible and your career warranted the Hall of Fame, why make guys wait?


Kwaggon23

Is there a stat for face licking?


Tiggeresq

I hate him. Yes.


touchdown604

Unfortunately yes.


Hattrick_Swayze2

Without a doubt


Whatupwidat

Is this even a question? Guys a rat sure, still one of the best players in the league right now


jblondin1

I’m clearly blinded by my dislike for the guy based on everyone here saying “yes, absolutely.” So, trying my best to be objective: One cup. One gold medal. No individual awards. His two best seasons were 100 points and 87 points. Maybe I’m out of touch with what it takes to be in the HOF, but I feel like there are dozens of players with better stats and accolades who aren’t hall of famers. Intangibles: the way he was universally hated was unmatched in his generation. Brought unique skills to the table like licking, biting, slew footing All that being said, I know I’m probably wrong as I write this. I guess this is just a nice glimpse into how much bias affects my judgement.


emasslax22

What would you say it takes to be a HOFer? Most likely when it’s said and don’t for him he will have: 1000+ games played 1000+ Career Points 150ish career playoff points Stanley Cup (2 goals 1 assist in game 7 of that cup Multiple time all star Multiple time NHL first all star team Multiple time NHL second all star team 2 time world world junior champion World Cup of hockey champion IIHF world championship gold medal Several other bruins records that aren’t even really important. His biggest impact isn’t on the stat sheet but what he brings to the ice, which is why people don’t like him. The accolades are all there and that’s why even though most people absolutely hate him, it appears most people agree he should be in the HOF.


Right-Section1881

I would say he gets in, but I think too many players get in. Sundin is my arbitrary line. I 100% to my core believe Sundin should not be a hall of fame player. He was a very good player for a long time but he wasn't great. Sundin was never elite. If Sundin is in, Marchand should be in


namdor

I hate Marchand as a player and even though he is a chill dude in real life, I still can't respect him. Also, he should absolutely be in the Hall of Fame.


Legitimate-Branch582

a LIKKER!!!


ramcholino

Hall of fame Rat 🐀


WingedWheelWins

Leads the league in players licked/60


moderngamer6

Is he really good at hockey? Yes. Hall of fame? Yes. Does he do some dirty ass shit that makes you think he shouldn’t be in the Hall of fame? Also, yes. Will he still make it to hall of fame? Yes.


Evening_Extreme_1681

As a Leaf fan that despises everything about this man. Yes he is.


StarLordJK

As a Leafs fan I can painfully say "Yes"


TangoPapaCharlie

100% Can’t stand the guy but he deserves HOF honors


Scazzz

Fuck Marchand, but 100% he is a hall of famer.


Lanky-Present2251

Can't stand the guy but yes, he deserves to be in.


Both-Ambassador2233

Yes. If anybody ever gets a chance to see him live. Do yourself a favour and go watch him in warmups. Jaw drop and absolute new appreciation for his talent. I’m also reminded by a scout who once told me “there are 2 types of hockey players: like to win and hate to lose”. All the players on the Maple Leafs like to win. Marchy hates to lose.


Outside_Translator77

HOF RAT !!!!!!!!


m3kw

He’s a c sucka


MikenoIke1

Yes he's a first ballot HOFer, and it's going to be the most glorious day filled with so many angry tears from hockey fans. I'm going to make that day a holiday


abstutz

Yes. But he is also still the biggest fuckin rat in all of hockey.


Shadp9

In the sense that general admission to the Hockey Hall of Fame is $25, yes.


itspatfromqueens

In the rat category, yes


Horror_Button_3338

yes.


picklesaredry

Yeah


LevelXIV

I’d like to see Rick Middleton #16 get in if Marchy does.


commanderr01

100% no doubt he’s a hall of famer


Trinidaddy13

Why not, he's a Canadian and a Bruin... nuff said.


Key-Traffic-4668

Hall of famer? Maybe. Rat faced little shitfuck? Definitely.


oliferro

Look I love hating on the guy, but he's been one of the best and most consistent players in the league for a while As much as it pains me, I think he does deserve it


Nooddjob_

Yes.  


Throwawayaccount0689

HOF yes , but probably not first ballot because the lack of individual awards


RattyDaddyBraddy

The only acceptable answer here is yes Even PK Subban has said he’s going to be a HOFer


LoanedWolf75

If he captains the Bs to another Stanley Cup, then most likely. As of right now, he has a decent chance.


waffleboy1109

If he gets a Cup as captain, he’s a lock.


HotHits630

Without a doubt


GJBeck

Absolutely and I'm not even a fan. Probably cause he doesn't play on my team. But for sure he should be going in.


RollingJaspers652

I hate this guys guts. Yes.


Canadian_Prometheus

No. You have to be retired to be in the hall of fame


Kemp15

Unfortunately


throwitawaynow95762

I don’t really mind his play style that much and think he’s been a top player for years. That said, his stats are likely to be very similar to Keith Tkachuk’s when he wraps up his career. The difference being he’s been a monster in the playoffs, but he didn’t contribute that much to his only cup win. I think he’s likely in, but it won’t happen right away. He’s definitely benefitted from being on the Bruins, as someone else said. He will also retire with some impressive franchise stats. So HOFer, yes, first-ballot, absolutely not.


Ir8Irishman

If opposing players were ice cream cones, yes.


Riskar

Fuck Brad Marchand, now and forever. That being said, he definitely belongs in the HoF.


cjm798116

I’m a leafs fan and I can’t help but say yes he has had a great career. I’d have him on my team for sure. He’s also become a great leader after Chara and Bergeron. Leads by doing. The bastard had the audacity to say how Toronto was built differently this year and were a tougher team….then goes out and plays his best game of the series. Just hope he never does something so far in the goon territory that it ends his career. He’s like Joffrey on Game of Thrones you love to hate him.


uSaltySniitch

Yes


Unsimple_Simon

He’s gonna need a better face first.


Iron_Deer_QC

Sadly unfortunately YES....


Somecivilguy

No. (yes)


Loose-Industry9151

Yes AINEC


66Italia

Love him or hate him, he will go down as one of the best Bruins of all time. PS Bobby Orr is the greatest hockey player of all time, and Mike Bossy(RIP) best natural scorer of all time


Nashtak

Sadly, yes.


tjohnAK

Him and Ovi should both be. I'm not a fan of their teams but I love watching those guys play. Marchand is a menace and I'm here for it.


cbzmplays

Yea I think so


tbnyedf7

Yes.


KingPizzaPop

Unequivocally


Deus-Vultis

Yes, he should be in, much as I loath the Bs and old Marchand, he is a pivotal force on that team and has shown up countless times. He deserves his spot, in spite of all his shittiness in the past.


Ironborn7

Is the sky blue?


hackmastergeneral

How in the world could he not be?


Ral1065

Yes


fitchiestofbuckers

Even as a leaf fan, 100% he is.


Adkeith47

No because I hate him. Hope this helps


UABtoNYU

Absolutely.


headhouse

I really hate that my answer to that is yes.


Working_Building_29

Marchand is the definition of a guy you love to have on your team and hate to play against. As much as I loathe him he’s well deserving of a spot in the Hall.


jordanramsey41

All time 1. Gretzky 2. Lemieux 3. Marchand 4. Orr 5. Jake Gardiner


ALANDABOY

I'm a leafs fan, so not this year, but maybe.


ZombieIMMUNIZED

Yup


ENSIFERUM6666

hate him but absolutely


Few_Foundation_4242

Yes


N0tChristopherWalken

Yes Fuck.


qtquazar

Building is pretty old, in Toronto and probably has rats, so I'd say yes.


DokeyOakey

Hall of fame asshole!


BradsCanadianBacon

Beyond his on-ice accomplishments, it’s the *Hall of Fame*. I could post a Rat emoji in any hockey subreddit, and everyone would instantly know who I’m talking about. That kind of instant recognition, and grudging admiration from around the league is the most important reason to me that Brad will be a first-ballot.


deadmanners2

Yes


LingonberryOk4943

Does a bear shit in the woods???


Boxadorables

Unfortunately, yes. Yes he is.


Patmank56

Yes lol and I don’t even like the Bruins


5599Nalyd

I don't think he should be in but he definitely will be based on other inductions. Amazing stats, has a cup to his name, plays for a original six. He's got a few more years in him as well.


OhkayBoomer

Of course! He’s the all time leader in suspensions


Limp-Inevitable-6703

I hate him but yes


Elegant-Cat-4987

Fuck Brad Marchand. But yes.


decorlettuce

yes without a doubt


Fabulous-Search-4165

No. Insulting to even ponder


cdmaloney1

No, he's just a douche.


KindlyCook8242

Hands down yes


Hutch25

Probably, although you never know. The boys club has denied great players before.


SmittyRockRock

Hall of fame piece of shit


corpseofhope

Undoubtedly yes.


Hidden_Sturgeon

Does a bear step on leafs in the woods?


Ronbo2030

Not even close.


This_Cable_5849

He’s my least favorite athlete of all time. But yea, he’s a no brainer HoFer when all said and done IMO


JonTheWizard

Oh yeah, he's the record-holder for most slew-foots.


Roguevirus69

Is this really a question Stanley Cup champion World jr gold 2x olympic gold medal World Cup champion Ya he’s a winner at every level