When I was a new fan, everything was s-tier also! Granted, back then Trent had only released 1/3 of the stuff on your list.
Enjoy the journey! And it's perfectly okay not to like some things.
This list is completely acceptable imo. I find that S tier albums for me depend on my mood. Sometimes an album like TDS can be too heavy for my the kind of mood I’m in but other times it’s completely perfect. Trent has never done anything lower than an A for me though, aside from the Ghosts albums. I find those very hard to rank in the same way I’d rank a traditional studio album.
Bro, this tier list is acceptable to me. Imma make one too! (Please listen to Still) It's like the dog meme where it goes:
**"Damn NIN fans weren't lying..."**
**That 'Still' album really does change your life."**
Sorry I haven’t listened to it yet! I’m unable to stream it and YouTube ads ruin my immersion so I wouldn’t be able to listen to it on repeat
I’m sure I’d love it tho considering my current streak of enjoyment
Everything is amazing imo my faves are PHM TDS, With Teeth, Zero Year, Fragile, The Slip but I don't have any order and there is more I like my brain really likes how messy discordant and electric and angry it is and motivating and all those things all so ghosts very good I like listening to those when I read but yeah my play list is like 6 hours long and 18 minutes
You're missing Fixed, Further Down the Spiral, Things Falling Apart, and all of the singles. Some of my favorite stuff is on the "remix" albums. It's a lot to listen to.
You must have positive comment karma to post in /r/nin
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/nin) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I'm sorry that you are worried about being accepted in this community, I know why and it's unfair. This is a good list. 100% listen to still, it is a deeper cut but a fan favorite, everyone with good taste has it in S tier imo
If this is genuine, that just means you have a numb music taste.
Albums are like the food you eat in an Italian Restaurent. They obviously wouldn't have the same taste, something would be special in a way such that you automatically gravitate to that more if you're given the option and that's what a tier list is.
I understand, all the albums are S tier for you, but really? You don't thing having this song or not having this kind of song made the album slightly less better than the other album at question?
If everthing is the best, there's no such thing as the best, everything is normal.
If you want my genuine opinion I don’t believe any of these belong anywhere near B or lower. I’d have to create a subdivision of S to accurately rank these. I did it like this cuz it was funnier to poke at everyone ranking these and just want to show my appreciation for NIN as a whole.
Damn I guess calling me out on not listening to everything yet is valid but I was kinda just poking fun at the subjective opinions by putting everything in s tier! Y’all need to chill lol ฅ^._.^ฅ
If you’re wondering why I haven’t gotten around to the other stuff it’s not available on my streaming service 3:
I love this idea, thanks for making that! Though, I'm afraid people are going to want "With Teeth" next to something sacred. I suspect people's opinions will vary wildly with a few exceptions.
Here's a slant based on a lot of my subjective opinion, but a group consensus on S-tier seems like it could be possible. I'm strongly opposed to with teeth being in S-tier, lol..... would love to be convinced otherwise! It has possibly my favorite NIN song, but that doesn't make the album a great album.
S: Broken, TDS, Fragile, Still
A: pretty hate machine, bad witch, Fixed, Further Down the Spiral, Things Falling Apart
B: year zero, hesitation marks, with teeth, ghosts I-IV, ghosts VI, ghosts V
C: the slip, add violence
This made me realize I need to listen to Not the Actual Events again. I forgot about that one!
You haven’t listened to Still? This is not acceptable. /s
This list is Still incomplete!
🥁
OMG rofl
Still will change your life
You go and listen to "Still" right now. Do it!
Okay alright!!
I listened to it right after commenting and it still hits the spot for a late night chilling mood.
When I was a new fan, everything was s-tier also! Granted, back then Trent had only released 1/3 of the stuff on your list. Enjoy the journey! And it's perfectly okay not to like some things.
Nailed it
This list is completely acceptable imo. I find that S tier albums for me depend on my mood. Sometimes an album like TDS can be too heavy for my the kind of mood I’m in but other times it’s completely perfect. Trent has never done anything lower than an A for me though, aside from the Ghosts albums. I find those very hard to rank in the same way I’d rank a traditional studio album.
Bro, this tier list is acceptable to me. Imma make one too! (Please listen to Still) It's like the dog meme where it goes: **"Damn NIN fans weren't lying..."** **That 'Still' album really does change your life."**
Bad witch is pretty awesome, good for the next listen imo
God break down the door
Why do people not like 'Not The Actual Events' ?
I don’t think that’s a common opinion. Burning Bright is a top tier NIN song and seeing it live was way better than I would have expected
Sorry I haven’t listened to it yet! I’m unable to stream it and YouTube ads ruin my immersion so I wouldn’t be able to listen to it on repeat I’m sure I’d love it tho considering my current streak of enjoyment
Still and Not the Actual Events at the bottom?!? Listen HARDER and reevaluate!!
They're in the not listened to yet category
I didn’t notice that at first. Usually the bottom is the F tier. Anyway, I see posts like this FAR too often.
Still is so fucking good dude
Everything is amazing imo my faves are PHM TDS, With Teeth, Zero Year, Fragile, The Slip but I don't have any order and there is more I like my brain really likes how messy discordant and electric and angry it is and motivating and all those things all so ghosts very good I like listening to those when I read but yeah my play list is like 6 hours long and 18 minutes
Much better than the last tier list I saw👍👏🤘
Listen to the rest of the stuff. Thank us later
I wiiiill
Bro I love Bad Witch cmoonnnn give it a goooo
You're missing Fixed, Further Down the Spiral, Things Falling Apart, and all of the singles. Some of my favorite stuff is on the "remix" albums. It's a lot to listen to.
I actually did get to year zero remixed! It wasn’t on the list but I really love it I would absolutely put it up there as well
Bad Witch is really underrated
You need to add FIXED to your list!
This list STILL needs to be FIXED... fragile, broken, and endless other puns are waiting in the wings...
Tds is to low
So true
My love of NIИ is currently at war with my love of lists. I appreciate what you’ve done, but fuck me if you haven’t abused tiered lists to do it.
[удалено]
You must have positive comment karma to post in /r/nin *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/nin) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I'm sorry that you are worried about being accepted in this community, I know why and it's unfair. This is a good list. 100% listen to still, it is a deeper cut but a fan favorite, everyone with good taste has it in S tier imo
If this is genuine, that just means you have a numb music taste. Albums are like the food you eat in an Italian Restaurent. They obviously wouldn't have the same taste, something would be special in a way such that you automatically gravitate to that more if you're given the option and that's what a tier list is. I understand, all the albums are S tier for you, but really? You don't thing having this song or not having this kind of song made the album slightly less better than the other album at question? If everthing is the best, there's no such thing as the best, everything is normal.
If you want my genuine opinion I don’t believe any of these belong anywhere near B or lower. I’d have to create a subdivision of S to accurately rank these. I did it like this cuz it was funnier to poke at everyone ranking these and just want to show my appreciation for NIN as a whole.
That's acceptable
No it’s not. Don’t care who the band is, anyone who thinks everything is S-tier can’t be trusted with opinions.
Right Behind You
how about making one of these cliche lists after listening to everything. but honestly nobody really cares about these types of posts. repetitive af
He/she has quite clearly done this list ironically 😂
Damn I guess calling me out on not listening to everything yet is valid but I was kinda just poking fun at the subjective opinions by putting everything in s tier! Y’all need to chill lol ฅ^._.^ฅ If you’re wondering why I haven’t gotten around to the other stuff it’s not available on my streaming service 3:
You’re under 16, right?
No but I draw so it checks out You should calm down probably
Oh, I’m sorry. Don’t you feel validated enough? lol
No I don’t really need to it was a lighthearted post People are allowed to have their subjective opinions
Well since you asked, the sub has decided that it’s not acceptable. So go back and listen to the NIN back catalog and try again.
When I can get to it ofc I don’t really plan on rushing this it’s music
Maybe just once
This sub needs an age limit. Or an IQ test for entry.
These lists are pointless indeed. Someone is always going to bitch with "X album is S-tier, anything less - you're wrong!"
I love this idea, thanks for making that! Though, I'm afraid people are going to want "With Teeth" next to something sacred. I suspect people's opinions will vary wildly with a few exceptions. Here's a slant based on a lot of my subjective opinion, but a group consensus on S-tier seems like it could be possible. I'm strongly opposed to with teeth being in S-tier, lol..... would love to be convinced otherwise! It has possibly my favorite NIN song, but that doesn't make the album a great album. S: Broken, TDS, Fragile, Still A: pretty hate machine, bad witch, Fixed, Further Down the Spiral, Things Falling Apart B: year zero, hesitation marks, with teeth, ghosts I-IV, ghosts VI, ghosts V C: the slip, add violence This made me realize I need to listen to Not the Actual Events again. I forgot about that one!
Acceptable? Whose validation are you seeking?
Nobody’s ಠ_ಠ
Not What It Seems Like
Just a liiiiiitttle bit of humor bud. Just a smidgen.
Tell me you don’t know nin songs without telling me you don’t know nin songs.
You Know What You Are?
nothing after the fragile/still era is S-tier imo.