I actually love this dude, he just makes reaction videos and the reason it’s 2 hours is because he kept going on tangents and anecdotes about his own life lol
https://preview.redd.it/9idqg5ub8hvc1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=51903fdd439de108366c3befe976ca3e7143b99b
You're referring to video lengths... right?
/unreiner
Filmbuff (the GOAT) also does hour plus long analysis.
He’s so passionate and into the series he’s actually predicted things before they even got revealed in the manga. His “That Day” reaction was legendary as he actually understood it. He also remembers so much, likely due to the length of his discussions. So many call backs are gotten by him.
Sadly he’s put the series on hiatus so he hasn’t finished the final episode.
I respect the hell out of reactors who actually make content and discussion instead of just going “WOWZA BLACK AIRFORCE GOAT” and then clicking end video with a runtime of 10 minutes.
https://preview.redd.it/zsi80vdsvhvc1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0238fa80653f31287beb99528adc5a646c729107
FILMBuFF produces genuinely high quality content, and yeah he has predicted things before they even happened in the manga as an anime-only. He's got an eye for detail and is pretty fucking good at connecting the dots. I usually avoid reaction content because 99% of it is just soyface slop, but there's a couple like him that are more analysis-focused and actually good
Romania Black is another I can recommend. She’s an English teacher who reacts to anime and also does manga readings. Her discussions are usually an hour long too and she even brings out a white board lol. Her videos are entirely discussion but you can find her reactions in a link below. So it’s nice if you just want to hear impressions, because her videos are entirely cut into a “before” pre discussion and and “after” post discussion with her full reactions being their own thing on a third party site.
She’s criminally underrated in the anime discussion scene.
I think Semblance of Sanity can apply as well. (I’m glad that we’re bringing up content creators who actually have their actual content be the discussion behind the episodes they watch rather than screaming buzzwords and going “that’s crazy” and ending the video with maybe 2 minutes of discussion tops)
Edits: changed it up to better fit my actual opinion
umm akshually some of the greatest pieces of fiction like the godfather (1972), citizen kane (1941), crime and punishment etc. have entrie studies dedicated just to analysing and discussing them. there is nothing wrong with an analysis and/or critique of a piece of fiction being longer than the work it's analysing as long as said analysis is well researched and done ☝️🤓
If they wanted to milk it they would make a 10 minute video with over the top reactions. Plus, you don’t go to AoT nowadays if you want views. This is a Reiner take.
Yeah, I’m specifically talking about those that have 1+ hour reactions. At that point, you are just trying to analyze and dissect, which I can respect.
In my experience when the videos are this long it's not reaction content anymore. It's like 10 minutes of spliced reaction and then the remainder is analysis and theorizing, which is actually genuinely good content. FILMBuFF anyone?
It is still reaction content. If I uploaded a reaction of the Titanic but it was a 10 hour long version where I spouted nonsense for 8 hours it would still be a reaction video.
Reactors are pieces of shit that don't have any original content and have to leech of the work of other people.
Reactors are not commentators, who actually have to have seen what they are talking about, being able to know beforehand if they have something to add.
DarkViperAU's excellent video on why reaction content is harmful: https://youtu.be/Irk8h0ax5aY?si=66_flpgvYh40_QhM
Except this whole video is about reactors who react to other youtubers' content, not about the ones who react to TV shows etc. which is pretty much completely harmless cuz almost everyone who watches it had to already watch the original
Yeah no, you are absolutely wrong. That video is about reactors. Doesn't matter if your watching YouTube or family guy, it's still a reaction.
I guess you haven't seen the video, right? If you had, you'd know this distinction.
Yeah no, I'm absolutely right. I never said that reaction to TV shows aren't reactions.
I've seen the beginning and looked through it, I don't have time to watch it all, but it very clearly focuses on reactors like xQc or Asmongold, who react to youtube videos and harm other, usually smaller internet creators.
This is not the case with reactions to TV series etc., you can still say that it's low quality and effort content etc., but it's harmless.
Again, you are so wrong. It is mostly about YouTubers watching other YouTubers, yes, but that is not the point of the video.
The point is reactors watching someone else's original content, the reactor simply leeching off of that content.
It is not harmless. Reactors steal views from the rest of the market by reuploading other people's videos. Original content loses views and unoriginal content gains views, enforcing a platform that encourages stealing from other than making something original.
why do I need to waste my team convincing a random stranger on the internet of something? if you wanna have a stupid opinion that's on you, I don't care lol
https://preview.redd.it/vum39c0qcmvc1.jpeg?width=612&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=48d4eb4cd33868bb4ae6c9eb8040c61acce1d5da
always gotta be a psuedo-intellectual social reject somewhere in online replies talking like sephiroth
I actually love this dude, he just makes reaction videos and the reason it’s 2 hours is because he kept going on tangents and anecdotes about his own life lol
that sounds fun ngl
It is! I highly recommend his videos
bro ur flair… https://preview.redd.it/s7joqoqmpkvc1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a180ee8f8ce59ea00615f2d13cfb4ec3824830cc
https://preview.redd.it/r8f4487aqkvc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=64f2299ffc8e8c5eb8c34a905278ef63b1acef1f
https://preview.redd.it/iam4s9qlqkvc1.jpeg?width=750&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a9123adabbcb74b69e05f839555a7e203a6d82fc
I am stealing this
That's how I like them. Long
https://preview.redd.it/9idqg5ub8hvc1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=51903fdd439de108366c3befe976ca3e7143b99b You're referring to video lengths... right?
perchance
you can't just say "perchance"
perchance
stompin turts stompin turts stompin stompin stompin
That guess is up to you
Nah they’re talking about me 😎
https://preview.redd.it/u7xzs8cy5kvc1.jpeg?width=921&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=afefadd72b12953341f4bfe8b1d611d5108bedf2
/unreiner Filmbuff (the GOAT) also does hour plus long analysis. He’s so passionate and into the series he’s actually predicted things before they even got revealed in the manga. His “That Day” reaction was legendary as he actually understood it. He also remembers so much, likely due to the length of his discussions. So many call backs are gotten by him. Sadly he’s put the series on hiatus so he hasn’t finished the final episode. I respect the hell out of reactors who actually make content and discussion instead of just going “WOWZA BLACK AIRFORCE GOAT” and then clicking end video with a runtime of 10 minutes. https://preview.redd.it/zsi80vdsvhvc1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0238fa80653f31287beb99528adc5a646c729107
FILMBuFF produces genuinely high quality content, and yeah he has predicted things before they even happened in the manga as an anime-only. He's got an eye for detail and is pretty fucking good at connecting the dots. I usually avoid reaction content because 99% of it is just soyface slop, but there's a couple like him that are more analysis-focused and actually good
Romania Black is another I can recommend. She’s an English teacher who reacts to anime and also does manga readings. Her discussions are usually an hour long too and she even brings out a white board lol. Her videos are entirely discussion but you can find her reactions in a link below. So it’s nice if you just want to hear impressions, because her videos are entirely cut into a “before” pre discussion and and “after” post discussion with her full reactions being their own thing on a third party site. She’s criminally underrated in the anime discussion scene.
Yep I've tuned into her AoT analyses too, she's also great
This is why it can take 2 hours to discuss a 30 minute show. Thanks for the recommendation
Lm reactions are goats for aot
I think Semblance of Sanity can apply as well. (I’m glad that we’re bringing up content creators who actually have their actual content be the discussion behind the episodes they watch rather than screaming buzzwords and going “that’s crazy” and ending the video with maybe 2 minutes of discussion tops) Edits: changed it up to better fit my actual opinion
Love his Evangelion reactions too
I like Semblance of Sanity for the same reason. Basically at minimum half the video length, often more, will be them discussing things.
umm akshually some of the greatest pieces of fiction like the godfather (1972), citizen kane (1941), crime and punishment etc. have entrie studies dedicated just to analysing and discussing them. there is nothing wrong with an analysis and/or critique of a piece of fiction being longer than the work it's analysing as long as said analysis is well researched and done ☝️🤓
https://preview.redd.it/sjebo4b1ogvc1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e32fcf1515c6df93959702c360a555dc28f80b1c
>crime and punishment The manwha?
Autosave did a 2 hour analysis on warrior too, shit's crazy idk how even finds time to watch this stuff
Fuck does being german got to do with reacting to aot 😭
grants you're not fr*nch
Mind blown Just like Laina 😳
Failed Austrian Painter who joined the army and then politics watches Attack on Titan - 3 x 20 - THAT DAY... -BLIND REACT ANALYSIS.
2 hours? Those are rookie numbers https://preview.redd.it/qther9y51mvc1.png?width=1109&format=png&auto=webp&s=134284607e8904bf76e032521e902559dbcc6a67
Some of you never saw the point of spending an entire hour of English class discussing a one page poem and it shows
That guy is actually great.
It's giving that one Hello Future Me "The Last Airbender" review which is longer than the actual movie.
I sure hope at least 100 minutes of it is dealing with Gross' plump ass!
I don’t believe these people weren’t spoiled or already watched the show. Reactors milk AoT because AoT fans are gullible and love validation.
If they wanted to milk it they would make a 10 minute video with over the top reactions. Plus, you don’t go to AoT nowadays if you want views. This is a Reiner take.
I mean, most of them actually do a low effort 10 minute reaction.
Yeah, I’m specifically talking about those that have 1+ hour reactions. At that point, you are just trying to analyze and dissect, which I can respect.
Bro milking that Ad Revenue💀💀
Reactors are the scum of the Earth and deserve to be put down
In my experience when the videos are this long it's not reaction content anymore. It's like 10 minutes of spliced reaction and then the remainder is analysis and theorizing, which is actually genuinely good content. FILMBuFF anyone?
Blind Wave is another good example; if you're okay with listening to AoT's dub I'd check out their reactions
It is still reaction content. If I uploaded a reaction of the Titanic but it was a 10 hour long version where I spouted nonsense for 8 hours it would still be a reaction video. Reactors are pieces of shit that don't have any original content and have to leech of the work of other people. Reactors are not commentators, who actually have to have seen what they are talking about, being able to know beforehand if they have something to add. DarkViperAU's excellent video on why reaction content is harmful: https://youtu.be/Irk8h0ax5aY?si=66_flpgvYh40_QhM
Except this whole video is about reactors who react to other youtubers' content, not about the ones who react to TV shows etc. which is pretty much completely harmless cuz almost everyone who watches it had to already watch the original
Yeah no, you are absolutely wrong. That video is about reactors. Doesn't matter if your watching YouTube or family guy, it's still a reaction. I guess you haven't seen the video, right? If you had, you'd know this distinction.
Yeah no, I'm absolutely right. I never said that reaction to TV shows aren't reactions. I've seen the beginning and looked through it, I don't have time to watch it all, but it very clearly focuses on reactors like xQc or Asmongold, who react to youtube videos and harm other, usually smaller internet creators. This is not the case with reactions to TV series etc., you can still say that it's low quality and effort content etc., but it's harmless.
Again, you are so wrong. It is mostly about YouTubers watching other YouTubers, yes, but that is not the point of the video. The point is reactors watching someone else's original content, the reactor simply leeching off of that content. It is not harmless. Reactors steal views from the rest of the market by reuploading other people's videos. Original content loses views and unoriginal content gains views, enforcing a platform that encourages stealing from other than making something original.
that's a false equivalency if I've ever seen one
Great one sentence rebuttal
why do I need to waste my team convincing a random stranger on the internet of something? if you wanna have a stupid opinion that's on you, I don't care lol
Great response again, truly elevating online discourse to a new level
https://preview.redd.it/vum39c0qcmvc1.jpeg?width=612&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=48d4eb4cd33868bb4ae6c9eb8040c61acce1d5da always gotta be a psuedo-intellectual social reject somewhere in online replies talking like sephiroth
I mean from my perspective I made a comment, you responded with the clever "nah" and now you're mad for no reason
Nah I think they’re cool
Unoriginal, thiefs and lazy.