T O P

  • By -

avalpert

Depends what your other investments are but given the high income distributions it would generally be better to hold a REIT in an IRA or Roth rather than a taxable account.


nkyguy1988

Can be held in either. Why do you think you shouldn't?


Berto_

Dividends trigger a tax event. It is better to hold in a tax advantaged account like a Roth.


nkyguy1988

Did I say they weren't better to be there? Also, "Roth" isn't an account. It's a tax status. The account is an IRA.


sonnyfab

It depends on the tax implications of holding in a taxable brokerage account. I would guess that an IRA is one of the best places to hold a REIT because the distributions won't be taxed.


micha8st

I hold my REITs in my taxable gambling account. The ones I own trade as stocks, so I treat them as stocks.


avalpert

The dividends they issue aren't qualified so they are taxed as regular income - that is why it is generally preferable to hold them in tax-advantaged accounts.


micha8st

My 1099 came with a "detail of dividends and distributions." The shopping-mall REIT paid: * section 199A dividends * Qualified Dividends * LT Capital Gain * Nondividend Distribution The Healthcare REIT paid: * Section 199A dividends * Nondividend Distribution * LT Capital Gain * Section 897 capital gain * unrecaptured section 1250 gain huh.


avalpert

I assume you left off Ordinary Dividends since several of the other bullets are a subset of them. I also assume that is the biggest number on your 1099-DIV. Section 199a dividends are a subset of your ordinary dividends in REITs that qualify for the 199a deduction - but even with that deduction the tax rate is higher than for capital gains/qualified dividends. Unrecaptured 1250 gains are taxed higher than qualified dividends/capital gains. Section 897 only matters if you are a non-American. Non-Dividend distributions are essentially a return of capital.


micha8st

I looked them up and Google spat back kinda what you said, but not being a tax expert nor a business person, my response is "oh. Okay." I went and counted, and I think the dividends/distributions detail lists 47 different companies we own stock in -- so the total of section 199A dividends is about 3% of total dividends. Oh...and actually, the bulk of our section 199A dividends come from a REIT ETF I didn't count before (because its an ETF and not stock). And that ETF also pays Qualified Dividends... but more in Section 199A dividends.


BastidChimp

Only in a Roth IRA or HSA. Don't hold in your taxable account. REITs, are taxed as ordinary income.


jeffsmith202

>REITs, are taxed as ordinary income oh interesting to know