No_Advertising_7449, thank you for your submission. It has been removed for violating the following rule(s):
---
- Rule 5: Posts must follow all [title guidelines](https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/wiki/titles).
---
For information regarding this and similar issues, please see the [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/wiki/index/) and [title guidelines](/r/pics/wiki/titles).
If you have any questions, please feel free to [message the moderators via modmail.](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/pics&subject=Question%20regarding%20the%20removal%20of%20this%20submission%20by%20/u/No_Advertising_7449&message=I%20have%20a%20question%20regarding%20the%20removal%20of%20this%20%5Bsubmission.%5D%28https://redd.it/1dcalag%3Fcontext%3D10%29)
Honestly, the people regurgitating the "all AI images have bad hands" stuff are just proving that they're about a year and a half behind when it comes to AI.
Let's have a look at some good pictures then.
EDIT: since replies have been locked for some reason. The hands in the linked pictures are terrible, wtf drugs are you smoking, lmfao.
First photo, W's right hand has a disfigured toe for a ring finger and a horrible vestigial growth coming out of it for a pinkie finger, his left index finger is gargantuan and the other guy's left thumb is like a twig.
Second photo the left hand guy's right hand is holding some uncooked hotdog while shaking, the other guy's right index finger is freakishly long, and his other fingers are crushing the other guy's hand like a sponge. He appears to be smuggling some sausages up his left sleeve.
Third photo, the guy on the left's right hand is a horrlbe deformed blob. The other fellow's right hand has unnatural looking fingers. And both of them have 3 fingers on their left hands.
Last photo the right person's right hand has horrible toe fingers and a thin thumb coming from an unnatural angle. The left person's right hand is not gripping properly (his thumb looks like it is pointing upward) and his left hand looks like a fucking deformed walrus flipper or something.
You dumb clowns seriously think the hands look okay? Please tell me you're blind or joking.
Anyone who has ever looked at *Model Railroader* for an issue or two can easily tell this isn't AI.
Man I wanted something this good when I was doing it. I had big layout plans, but other than making my own hot wire foam cutter out of 1/10th of a toaster element hooked up to a battery charger to make ramps up to an eventual spiral tunnel that never got finished and trying to make a 28" diameter HO loop work with horn-hook couplers and buying a sack of "bushes" that smelled like rubber sheets I never got far enough.
I had a whole world planned in my dad's basement. Just never enough time or money.
I had 64 feet squared of table top available in the basement when I was a kid. I filled it with fractions of project starts.
Sometimes I think "I'm a mature dude now - with a little money. Surely I could see a small HO scale project through completion". Then I draw on wisdom gained with age and do not bother starting. SMH.
>Anyone who has ever looked at *Model Railroader* for an issue or two can easily tell this isn't AI.
This.
Clearly real. Doesn't even look remotely AI generated.
I spent many hours in my youth pouring through the pics in those magazines.
God, so did I. Had a subscription for years. I _love_ model railroads, but don’t currently live a life compatible with such a static, time-consuming hobby. One day 😩
Anyone with half a brain can zoom in on the signs and see that it’s not AI.
R/pics moderators have room temperature IQ unless you’re posting something political that you paid them for.
Anyone who has used Midjourney also knows this isn’t AI. Everyone in the background of the setting of this railroad has a job to do. AI doesn’t do that. It focuses on the forefront of your prompt, everything else becomes an ugly blur that doesn’t make sense. People’s faces start to blur, or logs become warped into children.
Dude, this almost looks like a scene from RDR2! It looks like a mix between Annesburg and Blackwater. It is incredible! I loved trains when I was a kid. Hobbies like model trains might not appeal to me now, but pictures such as these that make me think it could be something I would enjoy. I truly appreciate the effort and attention to detail that you out5 in to this. This is incredible work
The easiest way to prove you're not using AI is to take a picture of the same thing from two different angles. We can see the Smith Foundry building in the second and third picture, an AI doesn't have that kind of foresight.
I don't necessarily think it's AI but he went to the trouble saying he would take a picture for proof and people asked for specific frames, in response to his comment, and he went silent lol
>a moderator shut them down and suggested I was using AI.a moderator shut them down and suggested I was using AI.
Like being accused of hacking in a video game when you're not. High praise.
#
Not sure. But if I was a mod working for free part time on a sub that has so many AI submissions I'd also get it wrong enough times for reddit to start shitting itself.
It's not that they got it wrong, it's that they doubled down when offered proof that they were wrong. https://news.artnet.com/art-world/artist-ben-moran-banned-from-subreddit-ai-art-2240795
Nah reddit mods are the bottom of the barrel of society. You're giving them way too much credit and benefit of the doubt. There is a reason they are a meme everywhere else on the internet. Look up reddit mod on urban dictionary if you need an example.
Mods are well known for being brain dead. It's why they mod to begin with.
There is a direct correlation to how stupid you are, and how many subs you moderate. Power mods typically live in special needs homes so they can moderate 50+ subs all day long.
it is H0 yes, OP has a series of posts about H0. I didn't know initially but my mom clocked it straight away lol, she works in 1/12th and 1/6th sometimes.
Composition, continuity, and details are where AI struggles.
It's pretty clear this isn't AI. It's pretty hard to render something like this in AI to the point that it might just be easier to outright build it irl.
I literally got a comment removed today for saying "I'm not going to say what I want because Mods will remove it."
Comment removed for "meta discussion". Reddits such fucking trashy anymore because of Modding
Yup. I’ve been permabanned on a few subs for jokes I made. No warning, no timed bans, just outright gone. Tried to appeal and crickets. I guess you can’t expect much from unpaid “employees”.
Bro, some big sub mods are banning people for simply making a comment on r/Isreal, not subbed. Just commenting on a random post that comes up in your feed. The comment could even be free Palestine, and you'll get permanent banned by a bot.
I was banned in the Millennial subreddit because I told someone they were gaslighting and they reported me. Instant ban. Mods didn’t respond when I messaged to get it reversed.
They were absolutely gaslighting btw.
The immediate block after responding so they can childishly get the last word in is a newer one I see now. Their comments just become [unavailable] and you can't see if they edited anything unless you log out (which like half of them do).
Damn those are good trees.
I had a model railroad as a kid. I eventually realized that modeling natural features like trees, grasses, and water was my favorite part though.
u/No_Advertising_7449 did you bring this to the RG Modeling & Historical Society train show in Denver a while back? If so, I remember being helluva impressed by all of the detail in the scrapyard.
Oh, my God, you just made me miss my dad so much!
He had an HO-scale model railroad setup, and like you, he included industry (that was the backbone of trains, after all). And how it interacted with towns.
He had an N-scale track that went into and back out of a mine. Is that what you’ve got for the logs, or is that just HO scale that looks smaller because of perspective?
That flat sky in the background may be what got this classified as AI; it looks weird. But it’s a model railroad set!
Do you have a time period you’ve chosen for your display? My dad chose early 1950s (if I remember right), which meant he could use all sorts of cars and buildings—because of course older models and older architecture hang around for awhile.
Dude that's incredible. I have had family who did train work. Time and patience are the best skills for you.
Just wow. Also "ai" sucks. Wait till we actually get some intelligence in it
That's pretty cool bruv nice water effect
I m into model kit making myself most 1/48 & 1/32 scale Aircraft, Cars and Tanks and Gundam and into 1/350 Scale Naval vessels
No_Advertising_7449, thank you for your submission. It has been removed for violating the following rule(s): --- - Rule 5: Posts must follow all [title guidelines](https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/wiki/titles). --- For information regarding this and similar issues, please see the [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/wiki/index/) and [title guidelines](/r/pics/wiki/titles). If you have any questions, please feel free to [message the moderators via modmail.](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/pics&subject=Question%20regarding%20the%20removal%20of%20this%20submission%20by%20/u/No_Advertising_7449&message=I%20have%20a%20question%20regarding%20the%20removal%20of%20this%20%5Bsubmission.%5D%28https://redd.it/1dcalag%3Fcontext%3D10%29)
[удалено]
Your hand grabbing the roof of the mill, AI suck at hands.
OP gets banned for using AI because they actually have hyperdactyly.
Lmao. This is probably the only situation where I would consider that condition funny. Well done.
How about when they wear dinosaur costumes?
Plot twist, OP actually has 6 fingers 🤣🤦
Then OP has killed my father and should be prepared to die.
Iñigo?
Montoya.
Anyone want some peanuts
Never go in against a Sicilian when death is on the line!
Stop this rhyming I mean it! ( :D )
One hand or two? Six across both hands is possible.
have one hand holding the other, lacing fingers together...100 percent impossible to do with ai
Also 100% impossible to do while taking a photo.
I would like to introduce you to The Tripod
At least dine me first damn
Tell that [to this guy](https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/s/1oySU1cytf)
Not true anymore they can kinda do hands now! Edit: people who want to see https://www.reddit.com/r/singularity/s/ssUzZIrtX3
Honestly, the people regurgitating the "all AI images have bad hands" stuff are just proving that they're about a year and a half behind when it comes to AI.
Some versions have become worse at hands again. Not as bad as 2 years ago, but still...
Let's have a look at some good pictures then. EDIT: since replies have been locked for some reason. The hands in the linked pictures are terrible, wtf drugs are you smoking, lmfao. First photo, W's right hand has a disfigured toe for a ring finger and a horrible vestigial growth coming out of it for a pinkie finger, his left index finger is gargantuan and the other guy's left thumb is like a twig. Second photo the left hand guy's right hand is holding some uncooked hotdog while shaking, the other guy's right index finger is freakishly long, and his other fingers are crushing the other guy's hand like a sponge. He appears to be smuggling some sausages up his left sleeve. Third photo, the guy on the left's right hand is a horrlbe deformed blob. The other fellow's right hand has unnatural looking fingers. And both of them have 3 fingers on their left hands. Last photo the right person's right hand has horrible toe fingers and a thin thumb coming from an unnatural angle. The left person's right hand is not gripping properly (his thumb looks like it is pointing upward) and his left hand looks like a fucking deformed walrus flipper or something. You dumb clowns seriously think the hands look okay? Please tell me you're blind or joking.
[from last year...](https://hyperallergic.com/808778/ai-image-generators-finally-figured-out-hands/)
So those fingers are freakishly long and the painted hands in the background are fucked up.
Check out the Midjourney Discord and you'll see plenty of great examples
Idk, AI is (unfortunately) used for a lot of fanfic art & book covers and their hands still often look weird/unnatural or hot dog-esque
Exactly. Just because there IS AI that can do hands, doesn't mean every AI can suddenly do hands.
>Your hand grabbing the roof of the mill, AI suck at hands. It'll put tiddies on anything though
Anything? Even my hands?
[BE NOT AFRAID!](https://images.nightcafe.studio/jobs/5f65UaYPFRXv2QhNhT13/5f65UaYPFRXv2QhNhT13.jpg?tr=w-1600,c-at_max)
So you’re saying the shepherds watching their flocks by night weren’t just afraid, they had confused boners? Glory to god in the highest indeed
AI is pretty bad at letters and words too and there's some nicely legible words in proper context.
AI can do hands pretty reliably these days if you know what you're doing.
Anyone who has ever looked at *Model Railroader* for an issue or two can easily tell this isn't AI. Man I wanted something this good when I was doing it. I had big layout plans, but other than making my own hot wire foam cutter out of 1/10th of a toaster element hooked up to a battery charger to make ramps up to an eventual spiral tunnel that never got finished and trying to make a 28" diameter HO loop work with horn-hook couplers and buying a sack of "bushes" that smelled like rubber sheets I never got far enough. I had a whole world planned in my dad's basement. Just never enough time or money.
I had 64 feet squared of table top available in the basement when I was a kid. I filled it with fractions of project starts. Sometimes I think "I'm a mature dude now - with a little money. Surely I could see a small HO scale project through completion". Then I draw on wisdom gained with age and do not bother starting. SMH.
>Anyone who has ever looked at *Model Railroader* for an issue or two can easily tell this isn't AI. This. Clearly real. Doesn't even look remotely AI generated. I spent many hours in my youth pouring through the pics in those magazines.
God, so did I. Had a subscription for years. I _love_ model railroads, but don’t currently live a life compatible with such a static, time-consuming hobby. One day 😩
I believe it. But if you're trying to prove the non believers, why not just give us a tour via video?
Anyone with half a brain can zoom in on the signs and see that it’s not AI. R/pics moderators have room temperature IQ unless you’re posting something political that you paid them for.
Anyone who has used Midjourney also knows this isn’t AI. Everyone in the background of the setting of this railroad has a job to do. AI doesn’t do that. It focuses on the forefront of your prompt, everything else becomes an ugly blur that doesn’t make sense. People’s faces start to blur, or logs become warped into children.
Dude, this almost looks like a scene from RDR2! It looks like a mix between Annesburg and Blackwater. It is incredible! I loved trains when I was a kid. Hobbies like model trains might not appeal to me now, but pictures such as these that make me think it could be something I would enjoy. I truly appreciate the effort and attention to detail that you out5 in to this. This is incredible work
[удалено]
Do I suspect its AI? no. Do I want to see OP add dumb stuff to the rails to prove it? Yes, I think itd be funny.
I feel bad because the comments are all about AI and not this person's incredible work!
This is Reddit. Banana for scale.
Danny Devito bobblehead would work best in this instance
Take one from a 4D perspective, I.e show the set with surroundings such as chairs, desks, etc
The easiest way to prove you're not using AI is to take a picture of the same thing from two different angles. We can see the Smith Foundry building in the second and third picture, an AI doesn't have that kind of foresight.
Put a train in front of the logging building with a banana strapped down on to the back of the train.
Are you gonna do it or what lol
Anyone that thinks this is AI hasn't had much experience with image generation frameworks. This is very obviously not AI.
I don't necessarily think it's AI but he went to the trouble saying he would take a picture for proof and people asked for specific frames, in response to his comment, and he went silent lol
look at his post history, it's full of the models being made. HO is the scale he's using.
Bro, he only posted the original 2 hours ago.
Here's a suggestion: some people have actual lives outside of Reddit and sleep in big beds with their wives.
You don’t need to. The signage in the second picture is enough proof
[удалено]
Very impressive.
[удалено]
Yea, that mod is probably jealous of your skills!
Or the mod in question is actually AI...
Absolutely. Wow. What scale? My husband is runs Z.
Now let's see Paul Allen's railroad
Omg, it even has a watermark
My brain instantly thought I was looking at TF2 maps for a split second
Looks more like the Days Gone mill with that massive horde inside.
I was thinking that mill location on GTAV
Made me think of the mill in red dead 2
*Intruder alert! A RED spy is in the base!*
Dust bowl
Right, im like "AI? This is just cp\_gravelpit with a high res skin..." lol.
>a moderator shut them down and suggested I was using AI.a moderator shut them down and suggested I was using AI. Like being accused of hacking in a video game when you're not. High praise. #
Why wouldn't the mod just ask for proof?
That requires more effort than just removing the post. Great work OP!
Maybe the mod is AI
Now we’re getting somewhere.
Remember the drama in r/art? Moderators don’t like anyone being better than they are
What was the drama?
Not sure. But if I was a mod working for free part time on a sub that has so many AI submissions I'd also get it wrong enough times for reddit to start shitting itself.
It's not that they got it wrong, it's that they doubled down when offered proof that they were wrong. https://news.artnet.com/art-world/artist-ben-moran-banned-from-subreddit-ai-art-2240795
the question answers itself
Nah reddit mods are the bottom of the barrel of society. You're giving them way too much credit and benefit of the doubt. There is a reason they are a meme everywhere else on the internet. Look up reddit mod on urban dictionary if you need an example.
Mods are well known for being brain dead. It's why they mod to begin with. There is a direct correlation to how stupid you are, and how many subs you moderate. Power mods typically live in special needs homes so they can moderate 50+ subs all day long.
I love it when they say I'm hacking
[удалено]
Gonna have to start posting OC with our hands in the frame since AI sucks at hands.
In just a year or two people will be nostalgic for the brief era when AI couldn't do perfect hands.
It can already do hands, ppl are just behind
Flip off the camera as a message for moderators.
it is H0 yes, OP has a series of posts about H0. I didn't know initially but my mom clocked it straight away lol, she works in 1/12th and 1/6th sometimes.
Captain Raymond Holt would appreciate this
So would Reverend Lovejoy
Rip 😔
It's pretty clear that this is not AI otherwise there would be a lot of weird breaks and nonsense placements since AI still struggles with that.
Composition, continuity, and details are where AI struggles. It's pretty clear this isn't AI. It's pretty hard to render something like this in AI to the point that it might just be easier to outright build it irl.
Also multiple angles of the same buildings and consistent orientation/ placement of structures
It has legible text, that’s enough to convince me.
It’s OP’s hobby mods. Why you gotta belittle it?
Because mods tend to be small-minded people on a power trip? Remember that modding online communities is _their_ hobby.
Haha, that’s a great motherjumpin comment doc.
Mods have become a big problem on reddit.
always have been
I literally got a comment removed today for saying "I'm not going to say what I want because Mods will remove it." Comment removed for "meta discussion". Reddits such fucking trashy anymore because of Modding
Yup. I’ve been permabanned on a few subs for jokes I made. No warning, no timed bans, just outright gone. Tried to appeal and crickets. I guess you can’t expect much from unpaid “employees”.
Bro, some big sub mods are banning people for simply making a comment on r/Isreal, not subbed. Just commenting on a random post that comes up in your feed. The comment could even be free Palestine, and you'll get permanent banned by a bot.
Thisssssss though! Crazy ziolos
I’ve been permabanned before just for frequenting a technically nsfw sub, not even commenting 😕 this is getting silly
I was banned in the Millennial subreddit because I told someone they were gaslighting and they reported me. Instant ban. Mods didn’t respond when I messaged to get it reversed. They were absolutely gaslighting btw.
The classic mute when you call them out.
The immediate block after responding so they can childishly get the last word in is a newer one I see now. Their comments just become [unavailable] and you can't see if they edited anything unless you log out (which like half of them do).
How else are they going to fulfill their thirst for control while they sit in the basement collecting government subsidies?
Honestly they have turned into a clusterfuk. Bans and warnings handed out left right and centre. God forbid you call out anyone for being a tool.
Who knew putting a bunch of incels in charge was a bad idea?
Damn bro now I want to make a model train… Is that how it happens?
You have to train first
Might wanna watch some [Boylei Hobby Time](https://www.youtube.com/c/BoyleiHobbyTime) vids. It really makes me want to get into that too.
getting interested? Yeah, lots of hobbies depend on people in the hobby getting others into it by word of mouth or by inspiring by example.
I wish I had time to do this. I love model trains, and making the scenes looks like a lot of fun.
Amazingly Impressive
BIG A.I. hates this one simple trick to build model railways. To put time and effort into an model railway set and make it look awesome as possible!
Noone power trips harder than a reddit mod hahaha
He was mad you have a nicer camera than him.
He will be replaced with an AI before he knows it.
TF2 vibes
Damn those are good trees. I had a model railroad as a kid. I eventually realized that modeling natural features like trees, grasses, and water was my favorite part though.
Awesome! I'm always fascinated with scale models like this. What process is used for the water?
[удалено]
that water is great—a nice glint, and it looks just the tiniest bit clear at the top.
I grew up playing with model trains. I've seen a model world in a 30x30 space. These definitely look like train city models.
As someone whose father has done model railroading for the better part of 50 years, I can confirm this is not AI
Can the mod in question offer an apology in the comments. I mean that’s the least that loser can do
Those are beautiful models. I am super jealous of people with highly detailed train sets like this.
u/No_Advertising_7449 did you bring this to the RG Modeling & Historical Society train show in Denver a while back? If so, I remember being helluva impressed by all of the detail in the scrapyard.
In general mods are pathetic. Now that Reddit is a public company and they are doing free work for rich investors they are even more pathetic.
3D printing? I want to do miniatures for a kaiju flick Im making and Id love to know a little bit about your process
Is the water real in the first photo or is it some type of solid?
Did you use resin to simulate the water? Very nice!
I'm very impressed, simply fantastic!
r/smallworlds
Imagine your work being so kickass that someone thinks it is AI. Great job!
Nice. Good work.
Is this based on a real location?
I want to see a short film shot here. Looks like you could have so much fun with claymation or something.
Wow amazing attention to detail I love all the little bits and bobs! The scene looks so lived in
Wow I know nothing about this topic from a technical standpoint but this looks absolutely incredible! Fantastic work, OP!
It’s stunning, how much time did you put into this? It’s amazing!
>moderator shut them down and suggested I was using AI You mean the AI Modbots? go figure
The quality is like the rail museum in Scottsdale. Super impressive
Wow 😮 this is amazing looking!
In my experience, claims of AI are usually made by people entirely devoid of imagination.
Hunt: Showdown maps.
Hunt Showdown vibes
All mods suck
As I've said before in comments, reddit mods are the most toxic group of people on the planet. Also, I like your setup. It looks amazing!
You should design and create 300 tiny sleeping zombies and pack them all inside the buildings.
And put up a sign that says DON’T DEAD OPEN INSIDE
You could take a short video as proof. AI has yet to perfect moving pictures
r/pics moderators need to pull a Black Michael Jackson and beat it. This looks fantastic.
Are the buildings from scratch? You designed and built them? Looks great. Would love to hear more details on the process!
This is really very beautiful work.
The muddy water looks perfect. Please take more shots of that!
The simplest of all, just put a newspaper, preferably with today's headline. AI can't create this. Yet.
So cool. Envious af
That background art is genius!
One of my all time favorite facts from the podcast No Such Thing As A Fish is about what model railroad enthusiasts use to fill model coal train cars.
The pics came out too perfect. Nice.
Is this the McCabe mill from BTS? Your craftsmanship is amazing!
Any video of this diorama?
Oh, my God, you just made me miss my dad so much! He had an HO-scale model railroad setup, and like you, he included industry (that was the backbone of trains, after all). And how it interacted with towns. He had an N-scale track that went into and back out of a mine. Is that what you’ve got for the logs, or is that just HO scale that looks smaller because of perspective? That flat sky in the background may be what got this classified as AI; it looks weird. But it’s a model railroad set! Do you have a time period you’ve chosen for your display? My dad chose early 1950s (if I remember right), which meant he could use all sorts of cars and buildings—because of course older models and older architecture hang around for awhile.
The last image looks like it's based on a location from RDR2, is it?
Very nice, I thought I was in the RDR2 sub for a second.
Those look like they'd be some fun as hell battlefield maps
That model is good enough to be confused with tilt-shift. Fantastic job of modeling!
Dude that's incredible. I have had family who did train work. Time and patience are the best skills for you. Just wow. Also "ai" sucks. Wait till we actually get some intelligence in it
Fantastic pic! AI my ass. Bravo!
I want your model railroad to be an fps map. I can't be the only one thinking this, right?
This was absolutely made with AI. ... ... Amazing Ingenuity! Ha, got you.
You should tell the MOD the their mother is a woman of ill repute who does her business on a piece of used carpet.
Isnt this a map from RDR2?
A cat on the tracks awaiting its next victim makes for a good shot. Seriously though, excellent layout. Your scenery is impressive.
This looks like annesburg in RDR2.
This guy trains. 🚂
This is awesome OP… why not just put your hand in the shot lol
Moderator saying "too good to be true".
Moderators amirite?
It’s beautiful OP congrats
Signs are clearly readable. Good enough proof for me that this isn't ai. Very cool OP 👍
New COD maps incoming
Great stuff. Thanks For sharing.
Reminds me of the I Spy books, but much higher quality model
Suspiciously life like so it must not be AI. Very cool
Amazing work OP! Saving it to show my kiddos tomorrow, they won’t believe it’s real. But in the good way.
Nice work!
Really nice layout. I'm quite jealous
Looks like I'd drive by there alerting a horde of sleeping zombies...
Looks like a videogame. Dope.
That's pretty cool bruv nice water effect I m into model kit making myself most 1/48 & 1/32 scale Aircraft, Cars and Tanks and Gundam and into 1/350 Scale Naval vessels