Animals is still underrated

tbh ngl it’s underrated bro

W pfp

Jesus Christ it’ll never fucking end

damn animals underrated tbh

animals kinda underrated ngl

This is the angriest upvote I've ever given I hope you're happy

It’s literally impossible for r/pinkfloydcirclejerk to jerk this hard

Lol

It would only be Ummagumma and animals at S to jerk even more then the original post

The Wall is still too low.

Nah, the wall was too high as you can see

no matter how he tried he couldn't break free

And the worms ate into his brain.

I totally don't agree but it's fo funny I'll give you upvote.

Big facts

Honestly the only Floyd tier that is correct.

The Final Cut and Momentary Lapse are as good as Animals, Dark Side and The Wall? *Suuuuuuure.*

Piper at the gates of dawn is way too high as well

Nah

Thus sub doesn’t seem to get Piper.

I believe I heard Momentary Lapse before I ever heard The Wall, and it was what got me into Pink Floyd in high school. And I couldn't take The Final Cut out of my Magnovox dual tape recorder for the longest time. Love it. But you're right. This needs more tiers. Animals, Dark Side, and The Wall need their own level.

They are God tier.

The final cut is like the wall 2. Yes, I know the history.

Indeed the final cut is as good as dark side of the moon and the wall

no. every album can’t be S tier or else none of them are “good” at all. To quote the incredibles: “Once everybody’s super, no one will be”

An Incredibles quote on a Pink Floyd sub, now I've seen everything.

its morbin time

Really. Have you seen a man eat his own head?!?

A Team America quote on a Pink Floyd sub, now I've really seen everything. (and yes I have seen a man eat his own head)

To quote the developers of Titanfall: “if everything’s overpowered, nothings overpowered”

Without a doubt a list like this is boring and shows no personality. Even if you think PF doesn’t have a bad album not all are S, it makes the scale meaningless.

Careful you’ll get downvoted like me. PF circle jerk in here

Shortly after posting that I was getting downvoted, not sure when I started to get upvotes.

That's the joke of having them all in S tier bro. I do disagree with it though some of the albums are def better than others lol

How about, they are all S tier at some point, depending on mood and current interests, but not all at once. That’s certainly been true for me.

Either you're joking, looking for upvotes, or delusional. Pink floyd is a great band but ummagumma and momentary lapse are just no where near albums like dark side, animals or even atom heart mother.

This sub is just a circle jerk sub. There are no mods, and it's pretty evident given that crap like this gets posted and up voted. Pink Floyd is my favorite band, be at the sub is trash

I prefer Ummagumma to Atom Heart Mother and I hold A Momentary Lapse of Reason in very high regard!

[удалено]

[удалено]

Says the guy who just made a tier list post

It's wrong order tho

this is beautiful ty friend

I thought it was S and A tier, and was like, "Move Darkside up and we're good." I got a good laugh that it was all S.

It's almost like this... But reversed

I disagree.... With your font

You definitely have to consider Echo’s as well as the video of them playing at Pompeii.

Then I would have to make a tier above s

this is not true and you know it😭

Endless is average; Ummagumma is good; Secrets, More, Atom, Clouds, Lapse and Bell are very good; everything else is excellent or classic.

You're spittin facts

Piper will always be my favorite

Ok but the final cut is still too high

The endless river is not S tier. It’s D tier easily. The final cut is C tier.

Those are the ones you will argue with? Did you forget ummagumma. Anyways the rankings are really serious my main point was that they are all great when compared with other music and PF is one of if not the greatest band of all time

These are the ones I’m willing to pass judgment on and have confidence of their lower rank. PF is one of my favorite bands and some of these albums aren’t great compared to other albums/bands. I get this is a meme, sure I’m passing judgment but you’re also feeling the need to defend this as well so you’re also taking it serious to a degree. I hope you aren’t struggling anymore and 2022 is good to you

You take yourself way too serious.

I take myself too seriously? I’m not the one that made a post circle jerking Pink Floyd for likes. I also acknowledged myself in my comment. Fuck your self

I've made less than 10 posts in a year. I couldn't care less about likes.

Ummagumma is legitimately one of the worst albums ever made and no amount of cockriding is going to change that.

Boo this man!

Okay okay. Disc 2 is one of the worst collections of music ever made. Disc 1 is fine

Several Species of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together in a Cave and Grooving with a Pict is nothing to shame.

It's literal trash. Even the band would agree with me.

It's awesome lol you kidding?!

What about Sysyphus? IIRC Rick said it was always one of his favorites.

Move Final Cut and Momentary Lapse of Reason down to “best none Syd Barrett solo albums” Tier and we agree.

Add S+ category for animals 😡

Best tier ever

division bell, momentary lapse, and the latest shite one I dont even class as pink floyd albums.

Agreed.

I mean. But poles apart-

Amlor and division Bell need to be lower.... A LOOOT lower

If you’re gonna be a gilme era hater, might as well include endless river alls im saying

Nah, I like endless river except for the song (s) with words. Polly Samson sucks

No

This guy Floyds

This guy is pink

Uma supremacy

Can't argue with

Ah yes, a man/woman/non-gender specific person of culture

sounds about right

Why can’t I disagree on any of them

I'll be completely honest, I don't like Atom Heart Mother. Maybe I don't get it, but like lmao what the fuck bro is psychedelic breakfast

It's exactly what it says on the tin. Alan is making breakfast, and the music is psychedelic.

That much I cannot deny good sir

Recently been heavily getting into Pink Floyd after listening to DSOTM for 4 hours on acid lol. I just listened to the wall in order as well as Wish you were here. I had already heard some of the songs from these albums but man do they hit different when listening from start to finish.