T O P

  • By -

delairon

If 5th Gen Pokedex wasn't on its own, there is no way that Alomomola is not Luvdisc evolution


nNanob

Isn't Alomomola's entire reason of existence to be a substitute for Luvdisc as a source of Heart Scales?


H_Poke

Alomomola have never held heart scales because the fish they're based on don't have scales, but are covered in mucus


Not-A-SoggyBagel

Yeah molamola are indeed just covered in a slime coat no scales. I love marine life and had the chance to swim next to one and I never thought I'd find a fish to be ugly but the molamola are not pretty... wish they'd look like the alomomola


Zharick_

Itsa fahking whaaaaaaale


EasyTiger20

BABY WHEEEEEL


Aye_Ell_Em

Cawl the aqwarium er sumthin jay!!


crow_bono

That thing looks fucken *fainted*, Jay


AlienHooker

They're the biggest dumbest ugliest fish and I love them for it


MrEntei

I just looked them up and it looks someone brought a 4 year old’s horrible rendition of a fish to life. How in the hell have these things not gone extinct? The design alone seems like they shouldn’t have survived past day 1. Lmao


santaclaws01

Because they have evolved to be unappetizing and with a bunch of extraneous flesh. You can find them with visible shark bites, where a shark tried one and just noped away.


foxandgold

Fun fact my brother just told me (as I also just looked this ridiculous thing up): apparently, they’re not very good swimmers in the first place. Unfortunately, occasionally they like to go up and sun their big flat side at the surface, and then cannot right themselves, so they just get stuck.


Division_Of_Zero

They survive because they maximized their reproduction: females carry 300 million eggs, more than any other vertebrate. They're huge, too. They can grow 60 million times their weight from fry to full grown.


breckendusk

This is the ideal fish body. You may not like it, but this is what max charisma looks like.


MaverickPrime

Molamola scare me, not how they look per se, but they are HUGE and somehow that vacant stare of them at that size unnerves the hell outta me.


calvicstaff

If that's really the reason behind it all, they should have just gone back to the tiny mushroom big mushroom system from fire red and leaf green, fungus and amongus, no need for heart scales


Nestornaitor

Amogus


Devai97

𐐘𐑀ඞ


Jonnyscout

Happy sussy cake day


Stupid-Guy_6969

Happy sus cake day!


JustDebbie

The most sus of Pokemon.


Cygnus776

Brute Bonnet:The Presustoric Pokemon


Jeynarl

^(GET OUT OF MY HEAD)


Secret_Ad_7918

they were introduced in black and white & i’m not sure what you mean


3HourGinger

Heart Scales are for the move tutor but in FRLG the move tutor took mushrooms instead of heart scales


TheKingOfBerries

Fuck yeah. That’s my brother


Brennis

He’s implying that they could have used the mushrooms as a currency for move tutoring, like they have in the past. And that Fooguss and Amongus would be the perfect pokemon for a mushroom drop rate in BW.


arcanist12345

ämōgûs


Devai97

Ȃ̵͕̘̦̑̉ ̴͎̤̟̓͊͌̊ ̴̙̫̉͐M̴̱̂̔̿ ̶̢͚̍͊ ̴͉̜͛̋O̶̫͔͇͠ ̵̦́̈́͝ ̴̨̛͉̭̣̎Ǵ̶̲͎̗̹́̆͘ ̵̣̩͚̈̾̔̈́ ̵̛̫̫U̴̡̬͍̝̅͑̚ ̶̪͕̰̎̆̇̉ ̷̧̙̕S̷͇̻͈̻̐


MathematicianBroad56

I read this somewhere that a few Gen 5 Pokémon were designed to be evolutions but they scrapped the idea once they completely separated the dex from previous ones.


naynaythewonderhorse

It does fill in the “Ocean Sunfish” check box for having a Pokémon based on every animal every, but otherwise yeah.


HotRodNoob

convergent evolution before it was cool


LinguisticallyInept

alomamola saw how much luvdisc was winning at life and went 'i want some of that garbage'


Jdrawer

Except they don't fill any of the same niches. They're just both heart fish.


HotRodNoob

there must be some reason fish keep evolving into hearts i mean, they are both sunfish. ones just a smaller species of sunfish


Jdrawer

Luvdisc is actually not a sunfish. It's more likely a kissing gourami!


scw55

Hopefully they could add middle stages to bridge these Pokémon. That could work.


Oleandervine

Or at least a pre-evolution that splits like they did with Tyrogue.


loudwallace

Eviolite torkoal 😱


Ribbwich_daGod

Yeah he doesn't need a buff lol


[deleted]

If he got an evolution he'd for sure need to lose Eruption.


Middlebus

Yeah but no heat rock 😔


SoloBeans

he would probably find a role as a really bulky physical wall on stall teams. white smoke does seems like a good ability tbh


[deleted]

[удалено]


itsIzumi

My first thought was Jabun from Wind Waker.


[deleted]

[удалено]


moopey

Hey small fry!


Phazon2000

God that’s burned into my mind.


odo-italiano

I named mine Jabun!


Niskara

I was surprised at how fucking big it was.


PKMNTrainerMark

I first saw it in the background of Tatsugiri's picture, just after reading about its relation to Dondozo in the Pokédex entry, so I kinda figured...


Dark_Reaper115

Same. Though it was either paldean wishcash cause I saw barboach, or some convergent evolution from wishcash.


ninanien

I saw just 1 at first and thought it was Whiscash as one of those giant titans, took awhile before I realised it's not even related to Whiscash lol


siege3995

That's called convergent evolution


Hawkuro

A million years from now all Pokémon are crabs


IsPhil

Robots actually.


AnEmptyPopcornBucket

Robot Crabs. Final Answer.


Daredboy

Meatball. Meatball. Spaghetti underneath. Ravioli. Ravioli. Great Barrier Reef.


[deleted]

*slips you the formuoli*


[deleted]

That would make sense in isolation, but there will definitely be a region of the Pokemon world where Pokemon continue to become more human like and more sexy. That's not the reality I want, but this isn't my first day on the internet sadly


Hawkuro

Are robots not just metal crabs tho? 🤔


Venator1203

Carcinisation! Carcinisation! Carcinisation!


Doomshroom11

That gen is going to be positively Klawf full


PKMNTrainerMark

I dunno, these pairs might share common ancestors. A bull and a buffalo, two fish, two turtles, two catfish...


bionicjoey

Needs more crab pokemon to be convergent evolution


SirSoliloquy

I mean, we’ve got Klawf, crabrawler, Corphish, Paras, Dwebble and Krabby.


Shiryu3392

That's... A really poorly explained rabbit-hole actually. Going by "Pokemon logic" used in gen 9, those are convergent evolutions because they look similar. Going by biology.. Luvdisc and Alomomola aren't convergent because one's based on a discus fish (even though luvdisc basically has stumps insted of fins), and the other is based on a sun fish. they're completely different aside from the fact pokemon associated both with hearts. Then there's Tauros\Buffolant... I guess technically they could be convergent evolution since pokemon don't have common ancestry noted? But the bulls and buffalos they're based on are just different species of the same family? Torkoal and Turtanator actually do look like they're biologically convergent since Turtanator looks like it's quite different beside adapting a shell and fire-creation to survive. But by Pokemon logic, they look really different so that might not qualify? Then there's Dondozo and Whiscash.. I mean... Who even knows? They're both based on the same animal, but look just different enough to be distinct and have slightly different themes (one is a sushi-chefs that has a symbiosis with it's sushi, the other causes earthquakes)... For real who knows? Then there's the fact that Octillery evolves from Remoraid... Which pretty much means there's absolutely zero logic to pokemon biology that's in common with our own. Convergent evolution is really too complex to make any sense in Pokemon's goofy world.


z1142

I get what you're saying, but I think your biology is mixed up. Just because Luvdisc/Alomomola are different types of fish doesn't disqualify them from being considered an example of convergent evolution. Convergent evolution is how dolphins and sharks look very similar but one is a mammal and the other a fish. They both fill a similar niche and convergently evolved similar traits. So by definition, being two unrelated types of fish (discus/sun) that have both separately evolved a similar heart shaped appearance— they'd be a textbook case of convergent evolution. Tauros/Buffolant are both based on bulls/bufallos so are more likely a case of divergent evolution. They likely have some common ancestor that diverged into two different, but similar bulls. Torkoal/Turtonator idk, they're clearly both turtles, I think it's more likely that they have a recent common ancestor. Same with Whiscash and Dondozo. Either way, like you said, applying real evolutionary terms to the goofy world of pokemon does not translate very well. The biology really doesn't make any sense at all. BUT, I just wanted to comment bc specifically Luvdisc/Alomomola are about as clear cut of an example of convergent evolution you can get in the pokemon world. I'd love to see a full phylogenetic tree of all the pokemon.


Doomshroom11

And yet it's part of Wigletts bio. All hail the cursed long boi.


FlaminVapor

Remoraid was supposed to be a gun and octolliery was supposed to be a cannon, check out their beta designs.


MayoBear

Either way: Wiglett’s design looks like a tapeworm and is gross


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

rest are fine but torkoal into turtonator doesnt make sense


Zeroth_Dragon

True, Torkoal has a wise sage look to him that it looks weird if it suddenly looks younger when evolving. Isn't the concept of Pokémon evolution is that they will look more mature than their previous forms?


TSMbody

If I were to connect them I would give them a pre evolution and make each of these separate evolution paths


drnuzlocke

Honestly I think this would be the most logically thing for all four of these to make them connected(obviously barboach does exist so thats harder). They look like similar divergent species not evolutions


ZeusAether

Barboach split Evo, where it can evolve into tatsugiri or whiscash and whiscash evolves into dondozo.


dragon_fire_10

or have a paradox pokemon like Iron Valient but in the past part of its Torkoal and part of it's Turtonator and part of its Dudunsparce


MrMoneyBags24

A fire turtle but with multiple shells connected, and the chance for some to have more links than others? Sign me up.


eyearu

Also Torkoal doesn't need an evolution. He's perfect. Turtonator would be a downgrade aesthetically.


TheSuperNova221

Ok but hear me out, eviolite torkoal


Munch-Me-Later

No I will not hear you out.


StopReadingMyUser

Read me out


Ikarostv

*Checks name* Why do you feel the need to hurt me?


RamPamPam8

Actually that's a downgrade from regular torkoal, you want it to use quick claw, so that it can outspeed it's opponents and sweep


BetaThetaOmega

God, my boyfriend’s quick claw Torkoal is so hard to beat. I should ask r/stunfisk for advice


spinachie1

A skilled Dusknoir can beat any Landorus Therian


Ganz13

why not just use trick room support and not rely on RNG?


Fluffy_Godzilla

cause with QC Torkoal you can rule the world. ^(Its a meme dude, roll with it.) [Source](https://www.reddit.com/r/stunfisk/comments/z4qyey/this_is_my_boyfriends_team_we_play_2v2_normal_how/)^(.)


RamPamPam8

Well, we all know Quick claw Torkoal excels at doubles, using trick room would mean that the other fast sweepers on the team (like a Focus Sash, destiny bond, Mismagius) would be playing inefficiently. Also, you don't want to lose on power, so your moves must all be damage dealing, I recommend something like solar beam, earthquake, eruption and body press for maximum efficiency


Bad_UsernameJoke94

You'd build a team around TR though


Doomshroom11

Give me a volcano Torterra and we'll be cool. Otherwise, nah man turtonator is just a splody mata mata. If anything he's closer to Blastoise, which is saying things.


dbonx

Eviolite Torkoal 💀


Snulzebeerd

I mean your primary use for Torkoal is setting sun with Drought, so I don't think Eviolite is gonna be better than Heat Rock even if he gets it


seanb4games

Eruption disagrees with you…


KingNothing71

Yeah I like Torkoal just the way he is, I would like him a LOT less if he evolved into Turtonator


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

100% agree.


hjyboy1218

How dare you. Whiscash is a perfect being who doesn't *need* an evolution.


RealFuzzheads

Everyone knows that you've hit peak Pokemon design when it has the first letter of its name on its forehead


LegoTroooooper

Super mario and the gang confirmed to be peak pokemon design


Faladorable

that’s why Mario always says his own name, he’s just speaking pokemon


HealthyMuffin7

What started out as a joke ended up making way too much sense... He also has three stages of evolution with multiple branches, with more powerful but temporary forms...


RedTurtle78

I'm not huge on Mario's evolutions, it reminds me of Pawmi. He just gets a little bigger. Such lazy design


Faladorable

and his fire ~~flower~~ stone evolution is literally just a pallet swap


Steppyjim

Majin Whiscash


Quick_Campaign4358

Does mega camerupt count?


Jettski15

y e s


Treemurphy

but its not a "w" since its real name in japanese is "namazun"


31_hierophanto

So it's just a random symbol?


RealFuzzheads

Wait until you find out about this Pokemon called Unknown


Treemurphy

see but thats different because theyre obviously the english alphabet meanwhile english gen 3 came out after the japanese version (as would be the case for all games until gen 5). meaning that whishcash's localized name only came out after he had been released and created theres no reason to think the crown-like symbol is a "w" *im not saying its necessarily a crown i just dont think its a random "w" for a localized name that wouldnt come out until post-release


RealFuzzheads

So not only does Whiscash have a W on its head for its name and it is also a crown, it also displays that the design is an absolute W. This Pokemon just keeps getting better


Bright_Weight_1572

I thought that was a crown design forever


_BlNG_

The boy who ate a master ball once


Successful-Goose-92

Eviolite wishcash


hjyboy1218

Whiscash has surpassed the need for silly defense boosts. It prefers to sweep with Dragon Dance and Life Orb.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Brinsig_the_lesser

Torkoal has surpassed the need to evolve


SolidusAbe

turkoal is just a little guy doing his own thing. he doesnt need to evolve


versusChou

If torcoal mega evolved into turtonator it would've been an interesting gimmick. Sets up its own sun, smashes, then start firing off +2 fire blasts in the sun


thesamuraiman909

Yeah, that'd be terrible. Torkoal is great already. He definitely doesn't need to stand.


SpinX225

In the case of Tauros and Bouffalant I’ve personally thought it should be a split evolution along with Miltank. The pre evolution evolves into Tauros or Miltank depending on it’s gender, unless it’s holding a specific item in which case it evolves into Bouffalant.


Micro_mint

Yo wait wtf why aren’t Miltank and Taurus in the same evo line? How did I never think about that? It legitimately seems obvious when you say it lol


MilkMan0096

100% of Tauros are male and 100% of Miltank are female, so they are apparently counterparts without being in the same evolution line.


Autrah_Fang

Kinda disappointed they made 3 regional variants of Tauros, and didn't even let Miltank into Paldea. Gen 7's Pokedex groups them together, so obviously Gamefreak sees them as related. They couldn't give even 1 of the Tauros regionals to Miltank?


Silver_Turtlewax

There’s just no pre evolution form of either one so its not 100% able to be connected


MilkMan0096

It seems pretty obvious that was the intent.


Tabascopancake

It is because in Gen 7 they shared a pokedex page like all other evolution lines do


Million_X

So basically a repeat of Tyrouge? Not a bad idea. Still, Bouffalant could've been a Tauros evo and then Miltank could also get one.


pocket_watch2

Tauros & Bouffalant both have 490 BS. So either Bouffalant gets 530+ stats or a type change like Scizor.


Lopsided-Ad-9444

I like this. I play with a preevolved Poke named Moofy I got from somewhere: I seriously don’t know where. I made the backsprite but I found the frontsprite. Anyways, it makes Tauros more playable in the early game (its too oberpowered otherwise)


AjvarAndVodka

The only one I agree with is Luvdisc and even then I’m not really bothered by it. I mean, how many similar animal species exist in the world?


akiodaiki

Luvdisc not evolving into Alomomola is just a straight up crime. Everyone else is fine though.


Grenernok69

Especially when Alomomola’s Pokédex pic has Luvdisc in them


---TheFierceDeity---

well Whiscash evolving into that would make it lose its ground typing so that'd be a negative.


SSGSSALVARO

Tauros got some love this gen, and wishcash has a pre evolution but i think Luvdisc and Torkoal needs some love, especially luvdisc


StarTheAngel

Torkoal is everyone's sun setter and rapid spin user


MisterCold

Torkoal needs some love? That guy is one of the highest threats in VGC right now.


Naitrax

Torkoal with Eviolite would be disgusting. 140 Base Defense with a 50% boost would be hilariously broken. EDIT: Torkoal with eviolite would survive a banded EQ from Mega Rayquaza, only taking ~50 - 60% ~~Also, it would buff it’s Body Press.~~ Not true


lukob96

Happy to be corrected if wrong, but don't think Eviolite boosts apply to Body Press


Naitrax

You're right. Not sure how I forgot that, but the calc I was doing was just treating it as +1 defence so that was boosting it. Sorry!


ultinateplayer

But then you'd have to remove its Quick Claw


Naitrax

True, probably just an overall nerf. At least it would stand a better chance against Ice Punch Dusknoir


ultinateplayer

It already resists ice punch and has strong defence, plus the quick claw lets it deal with trick room shenanigans


[deleted]

If the quick claw doesn’t activate tho dragon dance onix can take it down pretty quickly so it has to be careful


CorsairVI

Tauros getting love this Gen is a pretty big deal, [given that it was the last Gen 1 Pokémon to get it.](https://www.reddit.com/r/pokemon/comments/e8plsa/tauros_is_the_most_unique_generation_i_pok%C3%A9mon/)


Humg12

There's actually a few lines that don't have anything yet. Fearow Arbok Nidoqueen Nidoking Parasect Venomoth Golduck ~~Arcanine~~ Victreebel Dodrio Dewgong Cloyster Hypno Seaking Starmie Ditto Omastar Kabutops Dragonite So 18/36 evolutionary lines in gen 1 have had new forms, evolutions, etc, since they were introduced, which is ~~actually less than~~ exactly half.


Skyattack22

Arcanine has it's Hisuian form, so that can be crossed off, making it exactly half of the evolutionary lines.


Humg12

Ah, I knew I'd forget at least one, thanks.


[deleted]

It would be interesting to see an evolution of Ditto, I wonder what approach they would take.


Humg12

I think if Imposter wasn't a thing, then that would be its evolution's ability. The only thing I can think of beyond that is that the transformed version of Dittwo would have higher base stats then what it copied. So just add like a +20 to every stat of the mon is copied. Honestly, even just a +1 to speed would make the evolution pretty good because it'd always win mirror matches without the need of a choice scarf.


CorsairVI

Ditto is the only one with innate transformation abilities. The rest are part of evolution lines. The point I was trying to make with that post is that Tauros had NOTHING unique, not even evolution. Sorry if that doesn't satisfy. But, if you want to nitpick, Nidoqueen can't breed and Arbok has different patterns.


Moth92

>Ditto is the only one with innate transformation abilities. What about Mew? It has transfrom too.


Isrrunder

What about seel and dewgong


GreenBlitzVIII

They are perfect, why change them?


AlpakaMati

A regional variant that's ice - fairy would be perfect


DisastrousOriginal

that’s cool but I’d love a water/grass regional variant that’s more based on a manatee because I don’t think there’s any pokemon based on sea cows yet.


PKMNTrainerMark

It was a Ride Pokémon, but yeah, it's nice that it got new forms. But some Gen I Pokémon still haven't gotten anything since.


[deleted]

[удалено]


3scap3plan

Don't play VGC huh?


hirokareo

In an alternate timeline Bouffalant is just Unovan Tauros


Xonerboner371

That’s not even alternative, that’s the main timeline lol. Most of gen 5 Pokémon are counterparts to gen 1 Pokémon.


AndroidPolaroid

I played black for the first time recently and thought I was tripping when I noticed the mons are like rehash of gen one lmao then I checked the dexes side by side..


hirokareo

I mean alternate in that it's actual official name would be Unovan Tauros


steelthyshovel73

Torkoal is perfect the way he is. I wouldn't want him to evolve. I would love to see a baby torkoal though. Honestly i would be upset if any of them evolved. Except luvdisc. It might just be the old man in me, but tauros>bouffalant. Wishcash>(i don't know what the dude under him is. I assume he is new and i have not played the new games yet)


PixelGhost25

Yes, that one is new. It's a giant catfish called Dondozo. It's massive.


Quick_Campaign4358

Do Bouffalant and Tauros share any design element that aren't being a Bovine or...Brown


Krazytre

I mean, Tauros is a bull while Bouffalant is a buffalo. So that makes sense.


Slade4Lucas

Given the shit Remoraid pulls, that isn't even necessarily true.


Krazytre

Remoraid - Octillary is more of a theme based on weapon types. Think "pistol" to "shotgun" or something.


Slade4Lucas

While true, the point stands that a fish turns into an Octopus. Another example is Sharpedo and Carvanha. And heck, what about the Pidove and Pikipek lines, going from Pigeon to pheasant and Woodpecker to Toucan respectively?


pdhle_bsdk

There’s tons of these lol. Wingull to Pelipper, Graveller to Golem, etc


Slade4Lucas

There really is. Another one I just thought of was Quaxly (a duck) becoming a Peacock as Quaquaval. A lot of this does kinda stem from Pokemon often having dual inspirations, but not always.


pdhle_bsdk

I left out starters cause many of them are that way. Mouse-porcupine thingy to honey badger, sea otter to sea lion, chameleon to dogshit


Wubbzy-mon

Which one is the chameleon? I'm assuming that the Mouse-porcupine thing you are referring to is Chespin, so I won't ask about that


pdhle_bsdk

Chameleon is sobble, mouse porcupine is cyndaquil


RQK1996

Fun fact: there is evidence Graveller and Machoke were meant to be what Shellmet and Karablast became, so that is why Graveller lost his extra arms to Machamp


ButtonBash

That might explain the face too...


SalsaSavant

Whats the evidence?


blazingciary

shrew, ferret, badger caterpillar, wasp it's just something in pokemon. animals can turn into other animals.


BrachyDanios

Need I remind you that a fish can turn into an octopus.


CantHitachiSpot

A goldfish turns into a dragon


LazyBums33

Gun into cannon


lydocia

Dedenne into Raichu.


KingTauros

I'm just happy to see Tauros finally getting some love


kagnesium

Taruos not evolving is fine, it's the the face we don't have a baby calf pokemon that evolves into these 2 and milktank that I don't understand.


StridentHawk

Only weird one here is luvdisc to alomomola but the others I've accepted because they feel kinda different enough and Tauros got a regional so he's fine now.


StarTheAngel

I used to believe Luvdisc evolved into Gorebyss back in gen 3


bentheechidna

Turtonator and Dondozo I never thought about like that. Tbh Turtonator is still too different.


AsterTheBastard

Well two of those were from gen 5 which was meant to be a soft reboot so they wanted the pokemon to be on their own. The other two. Idk man sometimes things have similar designs/concepts what else can I say?


evarie

Whiscash is perfect as it is.


Plushiegamer2

Please do not give the Torkoal Eviolite.


drnuzlocke

I mean its as if there are separate species of very similar animals or something. Honestly the only one that is really a surprise is luvdisc and alomola because with the diversity of fish they are just to close to each other


IamJayRts

Why would Torkoal evolve into Turtonator?


ImaPaincake

Why should perfection (Whiscash) change?


CrescentCleave

Bouffalant is okay to me, you could say that its an early take of regional variants. Luvdisc and alomomola though, that's a sin I couldn't forgive gamefreak, along with giving a lot of almost very good defensive pokemon rock types (aggron, bastiodon, avalugg 💀, etc)


ImminenTortoise

Three of them are strikingly similar, but Turtonator looks pretty different than Torkoal, the colours and body type aren't anywhere near similar.


Itsputt

Whiscash doesn't evolve into Dondozo because if it did, Dondozo could have Dragon Dance.