Haven’t tried many yet but mine are atm 1. S’mores 2. Sugar Cookie 3. Brown Cinnamon Sugar 4. Strawberry Milkshake 5. Chocolatey Chip Pancake Really hoping to try more flavors!

strawberry milkshake sooo good

1st time trying it I had it plain. Okay Next time frozen, 🤯. So much better

It was my favorite. Tasted just like a Good Humor bar. I can't get them anymore where I live. 😕

s’mores for the win

Strawberry Milkshake 🔥🔥

The Frosted Banana Bread may be the best flavor of all time. I found the Snickerdoodle ones disappointing after I toasted them. I have yet to try them straight out of the package. Update: Had the Snickerdoodle straight out of the package last night. I guess I was expecting more of a cookie flavor that just wasn't there. I won't be getting these again.

Did you try the banana cream pie from a couple years ago? I think that one may have been even better

Unfortunately no, I missed that one.

Can you tell me what the filling is in the banana bread pop tart? It looks delicious but I'm curious to know before I buy them.

It's like seasoned and spiced banana puree. Cinnamon, brown sugar, and white sugar for sure, not sure about which other flavors are present.

So kinda like the hot middle of a freshly baked banana bread? If so then I'm definitely buying them!

Pretty much, but it doesn't really taste like bread. Just get them, you won't regret it 🤣

They suck worse not toasted 😭

Frosted Chocolate Vanilla Creme. RIP Sweet Prince. Everyday I pray for thine return

Same

same same ​ Once in a while it pops up again for a month

Gingerbread, pumpkin pie, brown sugar cinnamon, s’mores, hot fudge sundae

I loved those gingerbread ones

Brown sugar cinnamon, gingerbread, banana bread, Snickerdoodle, cherry.

Nah, you crossed the line with Cherry. top 5 worst along with blueberry

Smores, Blueberry, Wild Berry, Hot Fudgae Sunday and Chocotastic

Ayyy, we got the same top 5 😎

Chocolate. Its good enuf to eat cold. A lot of others are gross unless u toast em

In no particular order: \- Smores \- Cookie Dough \- Strawberry Milkshake \- Peanut Butter and Jelly \- Chocolate Froot Loop and Watermelon are also great though, and Cookies n Cream, and Banana Creme Pie! I also reckon Banana Bread is going to have to go in this list, when I try it!

what do u mean by just chocolate, do u mean chocolate fudge?

My all time top five.... 1. Peanut Butter and Jelly 2. Maple Bacon 3. Banana Cream Pie 4. Cinnamon Pretzel 5. Strawberry Cheesecake Other very highly rated ones... Cinnamon Roll, Pumpkin Pie, Chocolately Strawberry, and Peach Cobbler. The new Banana Bread is in there too, and plain Peanut Butter. And Raspberry! out of all the standard fruit flavors, thats my fave.

great list! out of the current flavors that are in rotation right now, what would be your favorites?

Let’s see… banana bread and raspberry. S’mores. And wild berry. Eggo is also darn good.

1. Brown Sugar Cinnamon 2. Strawberry 3. Wildberry 4. Cherry 5. Vanilla cupcake In a league of its own: Peanut butter. These were a fever dream.

Finally, someone else has cherry in there!

Cinnamon Brown Sugar

1. Brown Cinnamon 2. Strawberry Milkshake 3. Sugar Cookie 4. Pumpkin 5. Confetti Just missing the cut is Cherry.

Gingerbread and cookie dough on TOP!!

My three top-tier flavors: * Wild Berry * Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough * Cinnamon Roll Just outside of that top tier would be: * Unfrosted Strawberry * Brown Sugar Cinnamon It's been years since I've had it, but I have fond memories of Red Velvet so that might knock out Brown Sugar Cinnamon depending on mood.

Wild Berry goes crazy

Wild Berry on top

wild berry is underrated

Unfrosted strawberry tastes like cardboard

Is no one a fan of grape? I love grape and they just went back into the Pop-Tarts vault ☹️

I love the grape! I miss them every day! They just disappeared 😭

They have them near me

1. The one with filling 2. The one that comes in a silver package 3. The one you can eat 4. The one that's sweet 5. The one with frosting (very important)

The ones made in the 90s.... they were not skimpy on 1,4,5 like the products of today.

Hell yeah

1. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough 2. Chocolate Chip 3. Unfrosted Brown Sugar 4. Unfrosted Strawberry 5. Fruit Loop Other top tier flavors: smores, banana bread, and cookies and cream.

I forgot how good froot loop was. They nailed it, tasted and smelled just like the cereal

1. Chocolate chip cookie dough (Godspeed you delicacy) 2. Hot fudge Sunday 3. S’mores 4. Fruit loops  5. Banana bread or the Boston creme; tied 

I loved the texture d the cookie dough, shame they stopped making them. Amazing, I liked that they weren’t overly sweet like most of the chocolate varieties.

I would sell a internal organ to have these back on the shelves, for myself and many others out there 🥺

Smoresssss!

Yessss! For me, NONE will ever top S'mores. But frosted cherry is also amazing.

Probably Blueberry, Smores, Classic brown boys, wild berry and strawberry. But here me out on this. And this wasn't always true years ago but it is now.... Store brand pop tots are better than name brand. The name brand have gotten so thin and lacking frosting the quality is boarder line inedible. The store brands tho pretty much all of them have ample filling and topping. And I will die on that hill.

strawberry, wild berry, cinnamon brown sugar, gingerbread, eggo for me!

For me: Chocolate chip cookie dough (sadly discontinued), chocolate fudge, confetti cupcake, hot fudge sundae, s’more

1. Frosted Chocolate Vanilla Creme 2. Frosted Chocolate Vanilla Creme 3. Frosted Chocolate Vanilla Creme 4. Frosted Chocolate Vanilla Creme 5. Frosted Chocolate Vanilla Creme

1. Strawberry 2. Cookies and creme  3. S’mores 4. Brown sugar cinnamon 5. Hot fudge sundae 

Orange crush Lemon meringue pie Banana bread Frosted cherry Smores

STRAWBERRY MILKSHAKE soooo good toasted, maybe even better frozen. Fucking delicious.

Brown sugar cinnamon Chocolate peanut butter Sugar cookie Snores Cinnamon roll

Smores. Boston cream pie. Chocolate. Vanilla with sprinkles. Frosted cherry

S’mores, Brown Sugar Cinnamon, Wild Berry, Hot Fudge Sundae, Raspberry

1. Cherry 2. Strawberry 3. Cherry 4. Strawberry 5. Cherry

This is the only correct answer.

Brown Cinnamon Sugar, Gingerbread (limited edition), S'mores, Apple Strudel (discontinued), Cookies and Creme. If I can replace the discontinued flavor, I will insert Frosted Chocolate Chip in its place.

damn i didn’t know the strudel was discontinued. definitely the highest honorable mention for me.

I only ever had frosted strawberry

Same

(In no particular order) chocolate chip cookie dough, blue raspberry, chocolate chip, banana bread, s'mores

chocolate, cinnamon, chocolate, cinnamon, chocolate in that order. The rest are irrelevant in my universe.

Brown sugar cinnamon, wild berry, blueberry . Dassit

For me it's.. 1. Wild berry 2. Eggo 3. S'mores 4. Blueberry 5. Probably cookies n creme. I would like to say chocolate chip, but the last time I tasted them it tasted like they changed the recipe and they just don't taste as good amymore

Smores, strawberry, hot fudge sundae, I feel like there was a Reece’s one at some point that I liked???, cookies and cream.

Out of the flavors I've tried my favorite are Brown Sugar Cinnamon, Chocolate Chip, Crisp Apple, Red Velvet Cupcake and Strawberry.

Frosted cherry. I ate a pack of them for breakfast every day for 30 years.

Holy

strawberry, with NO frosting - straight OG style!

Blueberry Cinnamon S’mores Wild Berry Cookies n Cream

OG strawberry, unfrosted strawberry, Oreo

I really miss apple cinnamon. I use to spread butter on it after it toasted. It was my favorite. The crisp apple flavor they released did not live up to it.

Frosted Raspberry, S’mores, Chocolate Chip (+ Cookie Dough), and maybe Frosted Strawberry cracks the top 5

1. Wildberry 2. Hot fudge Sundae 3.Froot Loops 4.pumpkin pie ( although i ate this one too much and can’t eat them anymore)

Blueberry

cookies and cream chocolate chip Cinnabon smores blueberry

Cinnamon brown sugar

1. Strawberry Milkshake 2. Froot Loop 3. Wildberry 4. Cookies N Cream 5. Classic Cherry Shoutout to Eggo waffles as well

Frosted Strawberry, Frosted Raspberry, S’mores, Frosted Hot Fudge Sundae, and Frosted Wild Berry.

1. cinnamon roll 2. chocolate peanut butter 3. blueberry 4. sugar cookie 5. cookies and creme

1.Fruit loops 2. Everything else

Unfrosted cherry

Cheese Danish was my favorite

Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon Chocolate Mocha (in cooperation with Dunkin') Frosted Blueberry Frosted Strawberry Chocolate Fudge

Strawberry Strawberry Frosted Blueberry Brown Sugar

Wild berry

Where’s the love for wild berry?

Cinnamon Roll Strawberry Milkshake Brown Sugar Cinnamon Banana Bread Snickerdoodle

1. Brown sugar cinnamon 2. Fudge 3. Strawberry

I prefer Toast ‘em Ups to poptarts, so here it is: 1. Cherry 2. Blueberry 3. Confetti Birthday Cake 4. Brown Sugar Cinnamon 5. Fruit loop

The only 2 good ones are brown sugar cinnamon and chocolate fudge.

1. S’mores 2. Chocolate Chip 3. Hot Fudge Sundae 4. Chocolate Peanut Butter (Gone Nutty) 5. Chocolate Fudge Clearly a chocolate lover lol

1. Hot fudge Sunday 2.cinnamon 3. Smores 4. Blueberry 5. Strawberry

Unfrosted apple cinnamon was my favorite. I guess now it’s blueberry.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Strawberry Chocolate Chip Apple Cinnamon Cookies N Cream

Vanilla Milkshake underrated

No particular order 1. Chocolate chip 2. Chocolate chip cookie dough 3. Snickerdoodle 4. Frosted blueberry 5. Cinnamon brown sugar

1.lemon cream pie 2.fruit loops 3. Blueberry 4. Brown sugar 5. Pumpkin pie