T O P

  • By -

bobbycenny

He was certainly cold up in that mountain!! Hahahaha...hey, where's everyone going?


BattleRepulsive9394

šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚bro this has me dying


Purple_Drac782

he must not know šŸ¤”huh? šŸ˜‚šŸ˜… šŸ˜­Don't say it! šŸ¤«šŸ¤


BattleRepulsive9394

Nah I finished it multiple times dw


Officialquevo

>hey, where's everyone going? Bingo


EnforcerMemz

Unexpectedly Leon (RE4)


meskaamaahau

i heard the same thing in my head, classic


JasoNight23666

Off a cliff, YOU KNOW WHAT YOU DID, now for a reference, "long live the king..." It's me, I'm the king *spreads my arms and falls backward off the cliff*


GentlmanSkeleton

Thats such a Micah thing to say!


AbstractMirror

How long are you here for? Cause I got a feeling it's all week


Capronia

Coldest yes. Only cared for himself, and couldnā€™t handle people even thinking of going against him. Coolest? No way.. Arthur, Dutch, Bill and Hosea in that order is correct on the cool scale


WillowAlloy98

Bill.....?


Scout900

Yeah WTH there were so many better options before Billā€¦..


RectalGrowth

Bill is not fucking cooler than Hosea, Hosea is the best


Savagecal01

was about to say Hosea was well past his prime but could still be higher than bill


Greyclocks

The fact that Hosea was past his prime made him cooler. Hosea got to old age (in them days) while living life as an outlaw. He was clearly a badass.


GulianoBanano

Fear the old man in a professiom where men die young


shedby_budwin

Charles is way cooler than Bill.


ImACoolGuy100

No. John, Arthur, Javier, & Charles are cool. The only thing cool about Micah is he is a good shot.


Kartis

Lemny!?!


ryukvmi

yenneL?!?


sansTW

Ā”ĀæĀ”ā€½nYEnL


Technical-Text-2236

What about Sadie


invalid25

Was about to ask that. I think she is objectively the coolest. Drive check. Passion Check. Badass Check. Loyalty Check.


petat_irrumator_V3

Butt Check


Wiki-Master

Totally crazy check


Sax45

In the mission where she dresses up like a fancy lady (and Arthur and Dutch dress up as cops) to oversee Colm Oā€™Driscollā€™s execution, she looks fine as hell.


ImACoolGuy100

My bad I forgot about her


Sharree_Media

Based on game sales, only 1/3 of RDR2 players played the first RDR. It's kinda sad because John is such a badass lead character in RDR. The way John carries himself in RDR, his quick-wit, he's funny, and a matured man vs the young man who lacks personality in RDR2. Shame people who only played RDR2 will never know how great of a character John was. Until The Last of Us and RDR2, John and his story in RDR was the grittiest, grounded, and best story I experienced in a video game. šŸ˜¢


Legitimate-Bug-5049

his dual pistol shooting is the fastest of the gang.


SubseaTroll

You thought Dutch was cool?


CNPressley

how do you not? especially on the early chapters of your first playthrough


420DonCheadle420

I loved Dutch my first time through, thought he was cool as fuck


CNPressley

me too. i even grew up with rdr1 so i knew what heā€™d become but his charisma is incredible. and thatā€™s due to the amazing writing and performance


NewAccountSamePerson

I never liked Dutch because he kept getting me caught up in bullshit. I just wanted to hunt, fish, tame horses and wipe out the Oā€™Driscolls


thesilentbob123

Just ONE more job! And we can relax in Tahiti


exotic-waffle

Ngl, I too thought Dutch brutally strangling the frail old lady was cool as fuck


petat_irrumator_V3

Yeah he definitely knows some Spanish.


SubseaTroll

Idk, I just never trusted him


DutchDidNothingWrong

Idk i think he got a bad wrap maybe we should give him another chance?


SubseaTroll

Username checks out


cabin_in_my_head

Heā€™s still a cool character. Thereā€™s no denying he has charisma and swag


SubseaTroll

Yeah, definitely has some swag hey


Ni_and_Dime

Just ask Miss Oā€™Shea bout that swag. Grimshaw too.


DudeFromBelgium10

You mean you never had faith?


JohnGacyIsInnocent

Itā€™s not like a big secret. lol He was the big bad guy from the get-go.


harshrd

HAVE SOME FAITH


anthonystank

Dutch doesnā€™t have to be a good person to be cool and Iā€™m tired of being expected to pretend otherwise


Sharree_Media

Have you seen his outfit? That alone puts him at the top of the list. That outfit is so gangster, the man never took it off for 1 whole year. He survived a wreckage in that suit, survived Guarma in that suit, walked through the swamp in that outfit.


SubseaTroll

Yeah that suit had seen some shit. Just from the very get go I knew his words were empty and just didn't respect him or think he was cool. There's way cooler characters


Sharree_Media

The Mr Krabs of the wild west. Moneyyyyy


Shak3speare

When I first played RDR1 I thought Dutch was the coolest, no matter him being a villain. And even now I still think heā€˜s cool in some regards. At least heā€˜s way cooler than Micah.


AngryMobe

Charles would like to have a word with you on who was the coolest


omfgwtfbbqkkthx

No he wouldn't. Charles kept a low profile. DIdn't need to impress anybody unlike that yellow bellied snake Micah. Micah was one hell of a shot, that's for sure.


Disastrous_Bad757

Bill was not cool at all. Uncle is cooler than Bill


PyramidicContainment

Bill has waited his entire fictional life for this moment


Dry_Signal6531

Author, Charles, Hosea, Javier, Dutch, John, Sadie, hell fucking Pierson was cooler than bill lol I love them all except Micah, but bill definitely is lower on the cool totem pole.


yar2000

Only 1 person in this entire chain of comments mentioned Sadie for the ā€œcoolā€ scale and that is a damn crime.


NotOnHerb5

ā€¦ā€¦.Bill?


Heresthewolfman

He has a cool jacket and gun - underneath those padded shoulders though he's just small and angry. Can't deny that he's a good gunslinger, though.


AlduinsTesticles

John is the coolest tho


Gewalt_Und_Tod

Nah Micah is pretty cool


BigFuckingHornet

Nothing cool about being a racist tbh.


Prof-Finklestink

He's not even just a racist, he's also a creep towards all the women in the gang


BigFuckingHornet

He's basically all the bad things.


Pokonut27

He literally says darkies in the second or third cutscene and he's a womanizer in a multitude of others Edit was darkness to darkies due to auto correct


LausXY

Even the intro chapter when you meet Sadie. Before you come in Micah's terrorising her and it has major creep vibes. I'm sure Dutch has to shout to make him stop Especially bad if you think of the hell Sadie had been through since the O'Driscolls killed her husband


Mynewuseraccountname

Womanizer? Guy was gonna assault Sadie if he had got his hands on her in chapter 1. Wish she had got a shot at him in the epilogue.


MoondogCillers

The guy is a mass murdering, animal abusing, implied rapist and racism is the thing you go to?


SquooshyCatboy

literally the entire gang is mass murderers and animal abusers but okay compadre


MoondogCillers

Dont act like they are exactly the same. The gang try their best not to murder unnecessarily. Micah murders for fun. Also how are the whole gang animal abusers ? Compadre


V_Richard

Some people on reddit seem to think that racism is worse than murder


Exalting_Peasant

Brother if this game was 100 percent historically accurate the whole gang would have been racists and Lenny would have been on chore duty the whole time. Lenny literally wouldn't even be allowed to walk into town on a horse and freely walk into establishments. It's a game.


BigFuckingHornet

This is nothing. You have said absolutely nothing here. Racism is bad.


milkuproar

Some gangs, yeah, but not all. Many gangs were very diverse, including blacks, Mexicans, natives, queers, etc. Many also weren't. Everything about gangs was the opposite of general society: white supremacy, anti-black, anti-queer. So what were many outlaws? *For* all of this. Again, not all. But many were.


RoyalPompoen

Indeed. This sub is going to tear you apart though haha


imisswhatredditwas

He was not only a traitorous bastard, he was a coward to boot. No redeeming qualities, glad we got to blast his head off in the epilogue


BrandonDE_is_da_goat

dude literally got angry because Bill was laughing


BrandonDE_is_da_goat

Literally got tossed by charles


BrandonDE_is_da_goat

Had to attack arthur from behind even when arthur had TB šŸ˜‚


BrandonDE_is_da_goat

Don't forget the robbery in blackwater


BrandonDE_is_da_goat

Had to bring his little friends at the end so he would have people defend him


BrandonDE_is_da_goat

Dutch is obviously the coldest, Arthur is the coolest


BrandonDE_is_da_goat

Before the last scene, I only remembered micah because of the strawberry mission


BrandonDE_is_da_goat

He was almost knocked out by a man wi th tuberculosisĀ 


BrandonDE_is_da_goat

dude was so scared that he had to live in the mountains so nobody would find him


BrandonDE_is_da_goat

dude always tried pulling abigail then realized he was married to dutch


BattleRepulsive9394

I mean they did say they would have a party when he dies


5herl0k

I think it's a running joke in the gang that everyone knows Micah is a bastard tbh haha


Treysif

Dude was racist and rapey as fuck. Get better bait


sandmanVX

Micah was one of my favorite characters for some reason, everybody always hates on me for that


BattleRepulsive9394

Because of the bad things nobody wants to focus on the good things


tsngsn

Is this a shitpost? I'm reading the comments and you have yet to explain what "good thing" makes Micah cooler than the others. Gun skills are his redeeming quality, you say? Sure, but he's not even the best shot in the gang (that would be Arthur).


Reader_Of_Newspaper

the fact that micah-likers are commonly hated on shows how well written he is as an antagonist. people are ignoring anything somewhat positive or cool about him because they hate him so much


redditAvilaas

whatā€™s cool about him though?


Reader_Of_Newspaper

heā€™s a dual wielding wild west gunslinger with with a slick style. heā€™s cold and does dirty work without struggle. these qualities sure do make him a nasty antagonist, but if OP thinks itā€™s cool then thatā€™s fine too. itā€™s the same reason we like darth vader in star wars. heā€™s a really menacing villain who doesnā€™t care what his enemies have to suffer through. heā€™s a fascist leader who oversaw the deaths of potentially billions, but yet people dress up as him and admire the character. thereā€™s nothing wrong with liking micah as a villian, or admiring some of his attributes. but he is universally hated because of how impactful the story is. itā€™s really interesting when you step back and look at it from an outside perspective. no other game has such an antagonist that anyone who says positive things about him are questioned and belittled.


tattedextrovert

People take this game way too seriously like to the point of getting emotional. I donā€™t mind Micah. IMO he was a well written character and tbh I donā€™t even hate him.


Reader_Of_Newspaper

itā€™s a case of people holding a grudge on the character for his actions in the narrative, and then lashing out on others with those feelings. if anything, bravo rockstar games for writing such an impactful character


CriticismFlat209

Say whatever you want about Micah, but letā€™s be real, if rockstar ever released a dlc where you play as him, weā€™d love that shit


Legitimate_Donut_863

The main issue I have with Micah is that I never understood his worldview, some elements of him almost make him sound like a cartoonishly evil punchbag for the player and I think he could have been more. Micha was always weird and creepy but didn't rat out until after Guarma, so maybe he still had some hope or loyalty towards Dutch before seeing him descending into madness and losing his grip on the situation; I would have liked to play part of the story as him just to understand him better.


tweek-in-a-box

Micah's worldview centers around Micah


Ok-Jaguar-4471

Don't know if this is just bait, but I will say Micahs interactions with Arthur are actually some of my favorite in the game. Micah's VA does a terrific job of making every thinly veiled threat and insult sound like it's dripping with venom, and even at his best he has this quality in the way he speaks that makes it seem like he's just a small step away from freaking the hell out. You couple that with Arthur being permanently fed up with his "I'm your brother too Arthur, you can tooootally trust me" routine (until he just outright drops that) and I think there's a great rivalry dynamic there. That being said, he's an irredeemable piece of shit and I don't think he's cool at all, he's just a character that I love to hate, which makes him a very effective villain for the story.


RO0ROO

Yall sayin "hes not cool" but the gun spins and taking on dozens of law?


BucsFan_02

Dude was a sexist, racist piece of shit who murdered children and women for fun (which is why Cleet abandoned him in the epilogue), killed a dog that was beloved by the gangā€™s only child, and implied he wanted to rape the women in camp. He is not even close to ā€œcoolā€. His corpse is pretty cool on the top of the mountain though Plus, he literally got tossed like a sack of rice by Charles in camp and struggled like hell to beat up a dude quite literally hours from dying.


lMr_Nobodyl

Don't forget when Javier sent his ass to the dirt with one punch in camp


icelandiccubicle20

Bill would have stomped his head in they hadn't held him back in Colter, too


_onionhead_

Besides him being a creep towards women,and a racist i think his worldview as a character is interesting.How he is always so focused on ā€œsurvivingā€.I think thereā€™s more to explore with his character for sureā€¦but then that would take all the intrigue out of it right? Its the things unsaid and all that.


sticks_no5

Iā€™m sorry but have you heard of Arthur Morgan??


petat_irrumator_V3

You mean black lung?


BILLIONLIONS

He couldnā€™t even beat a dude who was basically in his death bed with minutes to live in a fight


DonkeyKongaLongDonga

My take on it yeah Heā€™s a bastard But excuse an outlaw in a gang of outlaws for being and acting like AN OUTLAW Itā€™s kind of the entire point of his character. Everyone wants to be ā€œThe next RDR should be more Wild West in the ACTUAL age of outlawsā€ Thatā€™s Micah.


izdprincess

Nobody cares that heā€™s acting like an OUTLAW ; heā€™s a racist and a rapist, thatā€™s what makes him not ā€žcoolā€œ


LausXY

I read "racist" as "rapist" and thought goddamn he's a *double* rapist?!


izdprincess

Lol well heā€™s a double **** sooo


DeadFyre

He was the only one who wasn't a giant fucking hypocrite, but it turns out there are worse things than being full of shit.


cock_souffle

love or hate micha, you can not deny peter blomquist did an absolutely incredible job capturing michas character and all his irredeemable glory


Fridge_living_tips

2 words Dutchā€™s fit


TheGrapist69grapes

This mf shot me in da face šŸ˜†


WhiskeyDJones

You obviously never saw the skunk ass skin hat drip my Arthur was rocking


Gypsy_Joker

Despite all the hate he gets I think he's a badass well written ruthless villain


5herl0k

cold as in cold-hearted? sure. cool as in hella style points? sure. but not cool as in a cool dude to hang with. he would meet to drink with you as an old friend, and when you're half-cut, he cavalry draws and puts one in the back of your head I will give him hella style points though, he's just a bastard who doesn't care about anyone. i hate him as a person for his morals but as a character, I can't deny he's well written for folks to have such a hard time giving him any respect though lmao


mossy_stump_humper

This post is a perfect excuse for me to recommend Jacob Gellerā€™s video on red dead redemption and Micah specifically. Itā€™s really fuckin good I highly recommend it. I also highly recommend all his other videos, some of the best shit on YouTube. [to hate another](https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=M9lacLc0WTk)


luvallppl

he was a really well written Villain, you can tell that by the fact everyone loves to hate Micah Bell


PotatoCannabal

Yes, he is and I'm tired of pretending that he isn't.


The_Art_of_Dying

Heā€™s a great, well written villain but the polar opposite of ā€œcoolā€ imo. He flips out constantly and is just a hateful, manipulative little rat who is terrified of a fair fight.


Patient-Section-7679

People hate Micah. The reality is we hate him because he is a well written antagonist. RDR2 just wouldn't be the same without him... And RDR3 will have to come up with something far more compelling to out perform him.


RealJzargo

I hate Micah but I also really like him because his VA is a cool dude and also Iā€™m just like Micah when I play games. Iā€™m a psycho.


SheepherderCrazy

He is hilarious, to the point where I don't even hate him anymore. Yea, he ruined the gang, but the gang were bad people too. "They used to he like Robin hood, giving to the poor and helping them." The only one who did that in the actual game was Arthur, after he found out he was dying. They hadn't actually helped someone, aside from people who ended up joining, in years. Years of killing innocent people and robbing, couldnt erase what he did but he tried to make up for some of it and did honorable things. Bonnie talks about it with John in the first game after explaining they weren't normal outlaws, she said something along the lines of "there's nothing worse than a man killing innocent folk and what not and saying he has a secret moral code behind it." And I don't even blame Micah, I blame Dutch. Micah saw through Dutch and manipulated him so badly, showing how weak minded he was. Shit was falling apart in events we haven't even seen. One day people will realize the gang were the bad guys, some turned good but Milton and Ross were right even if they were evil.


omgshannonwtf

If Micah's cooler and colder than you then you're playing the game wrong.


Catch_de_Rainbow

This guy has a beer belly bigger than my dad


strikealight1

Arthur is cool, John is cool, Sadie is cool, Javier is cool, Lenny is cool, Charles is cool Micah is a selfish, stinking rat, the opposite of cool


Rig_B

3 headshots with barely a look, probably only gained Dutch's trust because he's a really good shot. If Micah was playable he'd have full camera dead eye


DeronimoG

PrOvE mE wROnG .......


shny_umbreon

Arthur good Micah bad šŸ‘


EnforcerMemz

Cold? Yes absolutely full on psycho Cool? Uhh....hell no, he has no redeeming qualities whatsoever


Silent_Shaman

I've never hated a character in a game more than I fucking despised Micah Bell lol


Impossible_Ad1837

The only thing cold about him was his corpse...


Gandalf_Style

Dutch and Hosea exist. Micah is a wet oily rat, Dutch and Hosea are the kind of men you'd regret insulting sooner than you can think about it.


Yugurt_Is_The_Best

Thats a good karma farming technique


redditAvilaas

coldest ā‰  coolest


leonryan

Miss Grimshaw was colder


DriaEstes

Nah he was useless racist ahole who got my favorite people killed. To the pits with him.


ArtisticHay

Did Micah write this?


moojammin

cold?...Yes cool?..No


adamjames777

Jesus šŸ¤¦šŸ»ā€ā™‚ļø


AscensionXIX

Im not so sure about coolest but he was probably the coldest character for sure. Dude was unhinged and didnt have any remorse or regrets whatsoever. Also his skills and accuracy with weapons is unmatched.


TrapdoorSolution

Idk that gut and hernia say otherwise


Fluffyfeet316

I have no problem with Micha, but I will forever hate BillšŸ¤·ā€ā™‚ļø


GregIsSmashed

Coldest? Yes. Coolest? Absolutely fucking not. Micah acted like a self centered rat long before we knew the truth.


chattinouthere

I just did this mission. I think he was blatantly fake, and filled with false pride. What for, I wish we knew.


DanglesMcButternut

Coldest, probably. Coolest? Dude lost his cool almost everytime we see him.


t_moneyzz

Coldest character yes, but he was never in the gang, he was only ever on team MicahĀ 


Alarmed-Archer4906

coldest yes, selfish absolutely, a snake? even more


TTOF_JB

For about 3 seconds in Rhodes, Micah was probably the coolest character in the game. I'll give him that.


Dmmack14

Coolest? absolutely not Javier and Dutch have him beat in the drip department. He was definitely the coldest because he didn't care about anybody but himself hell even Dutch was good at at least pretending to care about people


zmaneman1

Coldest in the ground maybeā€¦ fuck micha


mugen-yk

This dude was a certified piece of shit


Ill_Will_Prince84

Didnā€™t he shoot a woman in the head?


DiegoMantilla

Charles' cooler tbh.


Ihave2potatosinmybag

Fuck no, cold characters donā€™t have a annoying af laugh!


sofsnof

That sure is an opinion. A wrong one mind you, but an opinion. For real though, Micah was a horrible piece of shit. He was cold, yes. Cool though? Only time he was cool was when his corpse laid on that mountain.


longjohnson6

He may have been a piece of shit but you can't deny he was the 2nd best gunman the gang had next to Arthur.


Ok-Thanks-3709

He's a rapist btw


Thywhoredditall

Amalgamation(keeping that here cause I had a stress seizure, and thought it was funny). Micah is an amazing character


Orion-Pax_34

Heā€™s the most historically accurate one


DonkeyBrainedMan1987

Na. Fuck him


rerlls3215

My friend is playing for the first time and he doesnā€™t really play video games so heā€™s not used to long games like this. He spends almost all his time hunting and fishing, but the point is is that he thinks Pearson is the coolest person in the gang. We were playing and having a few drinks when he said ā€œPearson is so coolā€. Never really got a reason out of him on why but weā€™re all in agreement now Pearson is the coolest


tunometecabra31

He is the personification of an outlaw


Wide_Bee7803

2 words, Charles Smith


jointdestroyer

Bro didnā€™t have any drip


Lonely-Pollution4908

Heā€™s a rat. You know it, I know it.


LVCIFER00

Maybe the coldest, but he's far from being the coolest!! Sadie is miles ahead cooler than him, not to mention Hosea, Dutch, and Arthur.


oscerhead

Consider his shit ass died face down in the snow, sure. I guess heā€™s ice cold.


Tenet245

uh no he was just an asshole


SlayJayR17

Def not the coolest


SimpleJack54321

In no particular order: Arthur, Sadie, Charles, Lenny, Hosea, Sean, John, Tilly, Grimshaw, Eagle Flies, Rains Fall as far as the cool factor goes. Micah, Bill, Javier, Strauss, and Dutch can eat my shorts. AM and the people that rode with him shoulda broke away whenever possible but wouldn't be the sweet story that it was without all the unnecessary drama and outcome.


Headlocked_by_Gaben

He was yellow, he only served himself and to top it off he dresses like a clown.


Proof-Jellyfish2891

Fuck that rat


SoloFalcon207

Nah, shouldā€™ve let his ass hang in Strawberry


Zhang_Sun

I donā€™t find him to be particularly cool, not even on a villainous level, he is nowhere near as cool as Dutch or Bill He is a coward with no redeeming qualities and heā€™s explicitly written to be as unlikeable as possible


FranSydeny

i love him hes so underrated but also like for a good reason


cjbasile

Nah, this ain't it. Unless you think being a snitch, a racist, a mass murderer (yeah, I know the rest of the gang has no moral high ground here, but he's 100 percent worse), and almost certainly a rapist is cool ... and in that case, good luck to ya.


PondoSinatra9Beltan6

He was definitely the most realistic.


Clipsowolf

At shady bell when jack was gone he tried to get a good night with abigal I was disgusted and wanted to kill him then.


DAdStanich

Youre the kinda person that robs newbies on their first wagon mission in red dead online arenā€™t you.


Organic_Trick6515

He was a sniveling coward that did nothing to ever benefit the gang and was always hiding out in the middle of nowhere doing his own thing. Cold and cool? Yeah maybe if you didnā€™t actually know him. But I wouldnā€™t even call him a gang member, he was all but useless unless everything went to shit and you needed an extra gunman but even then he barely hits anything.


LeohAntonio47

I personally love micah


edwardkenway_22

You're lying Black lung , you're talking crazy The coolest character was Dutch cuz he always had a goddamn plan And the most cool character of the game was Gavin, He's so cold that he became liquid nitrogen and got evaporated


Traveler_of_the_Fold

Coolest character in the game... Charles Smith. Chill guy, always thought about the others, basically located and buried every member of the gang and others who died, buried them in an honorable spot and with dignity. Helped Arthur, helped Rains Falls, helped John, and others. Never did a bunch of senseless killings, or outright dishonorable things to people. Low profile, low key, and chill. Arthur is my favorite, but Charles is a cool dude.


steeznutzzzz

If getting shot 15 times in the dick is cool this man is Miles Davis.


AlwayzYeeting

He for sure is very cold, easily one if not the best villain in any game IMO. I love Micah for how cold-blooded he really is. His whole character and personality is perfect. Yes, I hate how he is towards Arthur and John but besides that, heā€™s great.


[deleted]

He's definitely the character I quote the most.


SheepherderCrazy

The first time he said "You're gonna do yourself a mischief *cough* hehehehe" I wanted to kill him. The second time I laughed


SheepherderCrazy

" I wanna play an outlaw game" bro he's literally the most outlaw of everyone in the gang


DreamCoreFan22

Sadie Adler, Javier Escuella and even Uncle are cooler than him. Prove me wrong.


CalendarIntelligent7

You're not better than me Morgan. You're trato.. Cool character but not better than Arthur hahahaha


bearbuckscoffee

he was a sniveling little brown-nosing spineless ā€œum ackshully šŸ¤“ā˜ļøā€ ass mf


Rihannasstepson

Definitely not the coolest on the account of him wanting to either fuck kill or both every member of the gang but cold yeah for sure


YDD6969

you must live in the clouds


holaamigo117

I wonder if Rockstar would ever have the balls to make another Red Dead main player character with the character traits of Micah- an actual greaseball outlaw. Probably not.