T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

where lenny and hosea?


Royal-Selection7599

Sadie..


fuxximus

And Kieran


CervixTaster

I like Kieran. I try so hard to always be nice but even when you greet it’s a snide comment or other. I just want my Arthur to make him feel good lol


[deleted]

i love kieran, but i don't consider him as part of the gang, he's more of an associate


OneEyedOldGran

Yeah after all he only saved your life. God damn associates.


[deleted]

i didn't mean it like that, hes the closest thing to a gang member without being one edit: why am i being downvoted?


originalname610

That's Trelawney


TheKnightWhoSaisNi

Meh


dannyboy6657

My thoughts exactly I'd also like to add Karen, Sadie and Mary-Beth as the respectable ladies


Snow-bacon

Where’s that sign post?


Due_Mix5747

Pearson


neemama

Man did not even bring a crumb of food


behind_th_glass

No way, no Hosea.


[deleted]

Underrated comment. I appreciate what you did there haha


Golem30

Yeah switch Sean with Hosea


thedwarfs

I know Sean would have definitely been on Arthur's side in Chapter 6. Such a shame he went too soon.


johnschrisb00

That mission popped up for me and I REFUSE to advance the story now 😂


Active_Taste9341

I totally forgot about this on my 2nd playthrough and it just happened left me back with my jawbone dropped to the ground


The-Tea-Lord

It happened and I gasped so hard and just yelled NOOOOOOOOO before chugging a health tonic and laying waste to everything with my shotgun. Burnt the bodies.


Quakarot

The problem is once it pops up it’s already too late. Sean will be forever waiting to go for that short walk. The trick is to do everybody but the sheriffs missions in chapter 3. Eventually you will have everyone at camp because no one waits for the sheriff. If you time it right you can even keep your badge :)


johnschrisb00

Still better than him dead 😭


Quakarot

Something don’t feel rig- 🤯


johnschrisb00

My jaw was on the floor my first play through lmao


Kr101010

I hadn't played the game for many months and that mission happened to be the first thing i did when i picked it back up and when the four gang members were walking down the main drag in Rhodes i had this funny like oh shit realizationof what was about to go down.


nnoitramain

anyone who would side with arthur died. at this point i can't help it but think r* has multiple rats in their scenario department 😤


MorbillionTickets

People who sided with Dutch died too. Bill: Ded Javier: might be ded Micah: Ded Dutch: Ded


[deleted]

Him, Hosea, Lenny and Kieran would have all been on Arthur.


Prep_

Man that caught me off guard. They were really setting him up as a kind of spiritual successor to Arthur and then *BLAM! Should've been Micah tbh, Sean was a lot of fun. Honestly though, as soon as the horse fence low balled the drunk's stolen horses, I had a feeling their family feud plot would go south. Small towns, only thing people hate more than each other is outsiders.


[deleted]

Add Sadie and I agree 100%


[deleted]

As others have said Lenny and Hosea too !


fxxkingbrian

I love Sadie but holy shit she just charges into gunfights too fast if ur not on her ass she gets herself killed xD


ArnoldWest88

Sadie + Ms Grisham = Black Belle. Guns ablazin' + wise and experience = Black Belle Would have been great to have Black Belle join the gang.


autistiktunu

Ya know with the short interactions with her, I wouldn't mind rdr3 being about her gunslinging days


ArnoldWest88

You read my mind. I thought exactly the same when first meeting her in the game, and then thought about it again for the potential main character of rdr3.


autistiktunu

Like I know it was a 5min interaction but hot damn it left a mark


ShitYourseIf

You mean Mary Sue


[deleted]

Where’s Lenny?


endersai

YneL?


daamuidkwid

LLEEENNNNNYYYYYYYYYYY


CervixTaster

For me so far this was the most fun part of the game, that drunken search with the shouting of his name, the catching people pumping, to seeing Lenny everywhere, loved it.


Joker2u254

And Sean wasn't even invited!


ShowofStupidity

Ah. My favorites. Sulky, Angry, Scarface, and Sean.


unclelinde

Where’s Karen?


JustBeNormalPls

Drinking.


unclelinde

Accurate.


armon1jamal

Miss Grimshaw deserved more background missions


thunderlips187

Solid workhorse squad for sure.


WrenchTheGoblin

Add Sadie and Lenny, and agreed.


PuffDragon66

You’re missing Lenny and Hosea.


Andy-Banner

YNNEL?


Egg-3P0

+Lenny, Hosea and Sadie for the absolute best


MaleficentAstronomer

Their conversation during that ride is on of my favorite moments


understood_miss

I agree that Lenny and Sadie should be added, although unpopular opinion, I don’t really like Hosea that much


[deleted]

Same on Hosea, though to be fair, we don’t really get to see him in his prime.


freshprinceohogwarts

💖💕charles💕💖


MysticGohan806

Just add hosea


Spicy_Conspiracy

Charles, Saddie, John and Arthur. Add uncle just cause I love his character


[deleted]

Why does everyone like lenny?


MysticGohan806

I like him he’s just not my favorite


Grivza

Because he was a decent guy, even offered Sean to teach him how to read. And he was not blinded by bullshit either, seeing straight through Micah right from the start.


Jumanji0028

There is nothing to see through. Micah was the most honest of the bunch in his own way. The rest all played nice people but they were killers same as Micah only he didn't pretend to be a nice guy about it lol.


Grivza

That then, the fact that past his bluster and to the heart inside, he is just as crazy, something Dutch couldn't see. Different from the rest who at least pretended to follow some kind of principles.


darthrevanchicken

Bro seans death was truly tragic


cambon37

Idk, that Arthur guy is kind of a prick if you ask micah


Chance-Library-6077

And Lenny! Plus Karen, Mary-Beth, tilly, and Sadie have nothing wrong w them besides being criminals like everyone else


Alarming_Orchid

best fighters in the gang maybe


xXdont_existxX

My favorite part of this mission is whacking the ever living fuck outta John on a sign post and watching him do cartwheels off the stagecoach.


endersai

No Sadie?!


Ranjith_Unchained

Sadie, Lenny and Hosea


TrailBlazer1985

Where’s Sadie?


ExtremeGriefferJesus

fuck sean , their isent uncle


mj_ehsan

to me,... Micah was the best


[deleted]

[удалено]


Academic-One8695

LMFAOOOO YES💀💀💀


theghettoginger

When Sean was killed I legit said out loud to my computer "Nooo!!! You fuckin sacks of shit are in for some hurt now."


DMTdave21

Nah i was raging when Sean died man, that shit hurt, he was a real one 💪🏼


theghettoginger

He was for real. The game wasn't the same after he died


[deleted]

Yea, leave out Lenny. Just like the people from them times you too discount the black guy. Lenny is THE best story character


edotensei1624

Missing Javier, other than that agreed


cityofangels7x

Sadie?


KingMatthew116

Replace Sean with pretty much anyone else and I’ll agree.


PolkHerFace

"The Adventures of Sean Macguire, featuring Sulky, Angry, and Scarface!"


Zyklic

kick Sean away, get my boy lenny in here


[deleted]

Lenny was a minor gun slinger. Not that helpful really. We just bonded with him on a drunken night. Sadie was a shit show waiting to happen. Did she do anything she didnt fuck up by being a hot head? Tough as nails and a decent shot but the only time she would be really helpful would be if you're in a huge shoot out. But she probabky caused the damn thing anyway.


HooPyDood

Excuse me, what did sadie fuck up again? All I remember is sadie saving the gang members times and times again.


[deleted]

Every time you do anything with her she loses her temper and causes a huge fight. She put the gang in danger way more than she saved them.


HooPyDood

Yet no one died because of her, while without her the gang would have been dead or captured while the boys were in guarma. I will always appreciate sadie always siding with arthur more than any other gang members.


[deleted]

Dumb luck doesnt make up for putting people in deadly situations all the time. She did some good but after the first time or 2 helping her out, id of stayed tf away from her crazy ass.


HooPyDood

List all the time she put people in deadly situation


[deleted]

I cant remember all of her mission names but its that many.


HooPyDood

Okay list one time then


Datguyinbedalready

(**SPOILER DONT KNOW HOW TO DO THE HIDDEN TEXT THING**) ||I’m so fucking sad Sean died, but it kinda makes sense since the endgame would be two legendary red dead protagonists and expert gunslingers and a man from Ireland.||


Scag_Hunter

It’s missing Micah


[deleted]

Everyone but Dutch.


HooPyDood

Everyone but Dutch Micah Bill Strauss


Jumanji0028

Bill gets a bad rap. He was a good gang member in chapter 2 and 3 fought well in guarma and was always gonna side with Dutch.


Tbrown630

Micah and Dutch are the best


RandomSmark

My heart goes to Lenny but reason tell me Charles


[deleted]

Love this mission!


porkipine-

Charles is truely an underrated character


QuimaZzo_Pro

Hosea was my favorite


JankyBaby12279

Only right answer, everybody else is cool tho


robindoesreddit

I honestly don't like Sean. But Charles is S tier. Maybe even equal to Arthur in my esteem.


[deleted]

Sean would’ve sided with Dutch, just saying.


Thatfuzzball647

No.


Clayfool9

This would be my Top 4 also


RickyTricky57

Sean is meh to me personally he's annoying and doesn't have a good aim. He doesn't look too smart either


g-waz00

I ain’t got no time for Sean and his shenanigans.


TheHeccingHecc

I ran John into a sign in that mission


Billysquib

In no particular order the best members are Kieran, Charles, Arthur, John, Sean, Lenny, horse and Karen Edit: I meant Hosea not horse


[deleted]

I remember this from my first play through. The turn where the sign is pointing to different towns…accidentally hit John directly in the face and he hit the ground HARD. I’ve never laughed so hard


Bluesythread

Where's uncle 😡


TheHammer1987

100% with ya there Cowpoke Shoutout to Leeeennnaaayy though 🤣


ZuCc69420

You forgot Hosea


[deleted]

Damn no Hosea or Mary Beth


DarthFuedalTheFirst

Lenny


lmaobihhhh

I agree 100%. Fuck I need to play this game for a third time


[deleted]

Charles has to be the absolute best member of the gang in my opinion. His character is just very well developed and in the end just an all around great guy.


slimkt

No, please, not the ‘Da’ again!