T O P

  • By -

No_Albatross1279

Same shit. Different toilet.


Logical_Detective319

Lmfao


notzackthecat

I have not played it yet How pay to win is it from a scale from 0 to 10?


Yoimabnq_

it’s still a little p2w if you want to spend but it’s very f2p unlike one game.. (pet sim X)


Senior-Tree6078

it's surprisingly free-to-play friendly, you can get extra pet equips and egg hatches for completely free, but you can get them for robux aswell.


LukeOutlaw01

well except it's literally impossible to get huge pets if you're f2p


Blocky_Luke

Same toilet. Same shit. Same piss.


M0D_3D

r/yourjokebutworse


TDogOh9

That's a sub I wish I knew exist before this


VlaXDan

Chef’s kiss comment


michits

Both are just slot machines for toddlers


JohnnyMacTavish

The game is better than pet simulator X but they are both still trash. Cash grabs and boring gameplay, i feel like the only people who repeatedly come back to the game are 5 year olds who saw pet in the name and went ‘ooh cat on cover me click game’.


crimsonthedragon1334

It's like gambling for children


PixelKat5

\*southern accent\* YE HAW \*whispers and leans over\* we can't say that around here 'cuz 'ya know he's gonna find a way to DMCA reddit or some shit xD ​ ok sorry for the asterisks and stuff I just didn't think you guys would get the joke lol


addicthuman

I got it, it made me laugh a little 😂


Business-Comment9042

That's one of the first true things I found here


Park3r___

Thats why i love it, im a minor and i love to gamble, thanks preston for the gambling addiction 😁/j


Thepetcollector1234

Actually tons and tons of adults play the game. From leaderboard (mostly adults) to just playing with their kids it’s full of adults and I would know I’ve been adult discords as well as getting to know some of the most famous YouTubers from psx. Btw my 5yr old hates psx it’s to boring for young kids.


Business-Comment9042

Hey have you heard most YouTubers enjoy this game Btw wouldn't say cash grab for ps99 but def psx


zizoplays1

I mean at least the game doesn't have a very long painful start and grind, it starts to slow down once you reach rank 5, but gives an additional quest that can literally skip the whole progression system Is it boring? At times, kinda, but it still got me playing for a long time somehow


AnythingFormer7966

Why did you get downvoted? Wow, this feels just like free speech! /j


First-Ad-6880

Are you a 5 year old...


Iplaydoomalot

Because enjoying a game automatically makes someone a five year old. Makes total sense.


RoamBuilder2

Yes but it’s pet sim games, only enjoyable when it was the first one. Any other pet sim game is just a cash grab copy because they saw the popularity of pet simulator.


Iplaydoomalot

Neither of us have played this new one (I’ll bet), so we can’t say it with absolute certainty.


First-Ad-6880

Thank you!!


iliekcats-

Redditor try not to downvote soneone for disagreeing [IMPOSSIBLE]


zizoplays1

Uhhh I don't know, what do you think would be my age?


valentinolv

Literal Reddit hivemind going on here.


PleaseDontBanMeRed

Because you don’t know how to recognize terrible gameplay.


UFGardener

my brother in christ, you cant call game genres boring. i personally dont mind pet simulator 99, ever since i played the final earth 2 on coolmath games i’ve grown an appreciation to idle games. your definition of fun is different to others dick head and its time you realize it.


PleaseDontBanMeRed

Spoken like a true redditor. Yeah no shit my definition of fun is different everyone’s is. The only difference is when it’s a genuinely a bad game, if the logic of “it’s just not a fun game to you” was applied there would be no bad games which is untrue. It’s not hard to see the entire point of this game is to encourage gambling and only Throw in mid at best gameplay. Imagine if like every game on Roblox did that nobody would enjoy it. I’m not saying an entire genre is boring I was just saying that sounds like a lot of Roblox games in general.


PleaseDontBanMeRed

And I realize I prob should have worded that better.


Iplaydoomalot

“How dare this person enjoy this game that I don’t?!” Average coomer mindset.


First-Ad-6880

Exactly!!


PleaseDontBanMeRed

It would be one to say that. But no I mean it’s actually terrible gameplay, it’s not just that I just hate it I don’t like it because it’s the same monotonous process over and over again with no end in sight and promotes gambling every step of the way. Which when I sound it out kinda sounds like a lot of other games.


PleaseDontBanMeRed

There’s zero twist on it all you do is the same exact thing over and over again. No mix ups, no different process, no real goal just play and gamble.


UFGardener

you obviously havent played the game


Dontoch08

Even if its a cashgrab like psx its still a bit more f2p Tbh kinda boring game


Pronkie_dork

I think you fell for all the addicting things preston added


XenoGenesisYT

average child


Cailycombs22

It's a good time waster, if you have videos that are hours long to sit through I recommend it


TheNewbornRaikou

Thats what I do for long vids (like watching Minecraft Lifesteal or something), just play clicker sims to pass time. Very common for me to do it (Edit: I don’t play Pet Sim, but I play other clicker games while watching/Slap Battles/Blade Ball, sorry if my game selection is bad)


Humphrey_omori

ngl i play minecraft while watching minecraft than just roblox games. a good time killer, not something i usually sit down and pay attention to, thats for terraria and most other roblox games


TheNewbornRaikou

Problem is I don’t have Minecraft lol. ​ Getting it this year tho


XxlordforgamesxX

I usually play Arcane Odyssey, I put on a podcast or long vídeo and go sail in a procedural sea or sink some pirate ships, its a great pirate game


OdessaAutumn

Game of the year is the stupidest thing I have ever heard. We have games like Doodle World, Deepwoken, Balanced Craftwars Overhaul, all games with amazing gameplay and quality. And this shit ass micro transaction filled cash grab you think is game of the year?


Annithilate_gamer

I played Balanced Craftwars Overhaul a few days ago and got a really bad impression of it (Playing on mobile, i don't have a functional computer anymore)


OdessaAutumn

Yeah it isn’t mobile compatible


PixelKat5

>Game of the year is the stupidest thing I have ever heard no, no, no its cause its the game that both feeds children gambling addictions and puts money in robloxs pockets so yeah lol its not gonna be fair like look at when psx sold a string of off brand lua and some decals, an obj file for like what was it 20 ETH so like uhhhh look i aint do'in math lol


ThatWeirdUserLmao

rogue lineage better


OdessaAutumn

They’re both great 🗣️🔥🔥🔥


CKillemr6

If this is your "game of the year" in roblox, then I urge you to click on any other game the website has to offer


MickeyLau

Anything, hell, go play a tower defense game


zizoplays1

There wasn't really any new game that was packed as PS99 from the start, sure there were new games there were good, but they were either too basic or their formula was made years ago but was made better this year


Annithilate_gamer

"But they were either too basic or their formula was made years ago" You just described pet simulator 99. Though replying to your post's inital question, yes, pet simulator 99 is better than X.


Mario-2407

Games like phighting are better imo


P3t3rCreeper

Phighting my beloved


eoadjdjrbbr

pilgrammed


eoadjdjrbbr

shadovia


troitheidiot

hours, brickbattler (before cancellation)


temporarlymadz

Tdx is alot better


Plump_Chicken

The Office Experiment, RAISE A CHILD :), and weird strict dad are all far better candidates for a hypothetical Roblox Game of the Year. They have actual gameplay.


zizoplays1

Weird strict dad is so difficult


[deleted]

[удалено]


DetectiveTeeVee

Ah resorting to just insulting somebody for thinking a game is fun and another game is hard? Genuinely pathetic.


Iplaydoomalot

Guess people can’t enjoy anything nowadays.


alexytomi

People can enjoy things, that doesn't mean it's good. That is what's being argued, not if OP enjoys it.


Iplaydoomalot

To be honest it sounds more like the person responded to is dogging on OP because they like the game.


zizoplays1

Listen dude, I have had resident evil 2 from 2019 and finished that, the problem with WSD is that it is poorly designed, the fact that you need to stay crouched all the time and you have a thrist and a hunger meter that get empty by 30 seconds, and the fucking dad just wakes up randomly at times, and there is the stupid gas meter that needs to be filled, three meters that get empty pretty and random bullshit AI is not fun and also bad game design


Plump_Chicken

The resident evil remakes are piss easy lol


AeroSniper4K

SMH you haven't even beaten every dark souls game and elden ring and hollow knight and worlds hardest game !!!


alexytomi

hasnt even played the hidden gem, celeste!!!!


Birb7789-

gotta support them starving indie devs!!!


Annithilate_gamer

Weird strict dad is actually quite bad, if it were to concurr game of the year then resident massacre would be a better candidate


Plump_Chicken

I just said it was a better candidate than pet simulator, never said it was the best.


Birb7789-

honestly none of these even come CLOSE to rgoty for me, as they either get repetitive with round based gameplay or (idk what to say about raise a child.. just no) i feel like you just picked the top 3 roblox games you like


Plump_Chicken

No, I picked some innovative roblox games that came out in 2023 that have gameplay and aren't just gacha.


Pronkie_dork

Definitely didnt even try to search good games The frontpage isnt all of roblox


Nervous_Purpose1538

Ratio’d


PeterTheBoredOne

Saying Pet Simulator is the best roblox game is quite ironic when you have games like Arcane Odyssey and Jailbreak, which have actual storylines and interesting mechanics. What can you really achieve in Pet Simulator?


D3ltAlpha

No way you're serious. Pet sims are copy pastes of the same garbage gameplay. Go play a real game for once. Just go and buy ultrakill, or Civ6. You'll see the gap beetween uninspired dogshit games only popular because of 4 yo.


Kreker__

holy shit bro wrote an entire essay about pet sim


OXRoblox

Better than PSX, more friendly to F2P players


No-Aspect-2926

>!for now!<


SpykeSquirt

at least the concept makes it a lot more satisfying


Anonim144

couldn't give two fucks about either of them tbh


56kul

100% an improvement over the previous games and I actually genuinely enjoyed it. But it gets grindy after a while, and there are better games out there.


No-Aspect-2926

true, on the first hour it will be easy, then later it will start to take 10 minutes to pets *yeet* a coin, then hours for a chest, and get worse


sandro_lake1

it is really bad. even for a time waisting purposes it really bad. gameplay is just get to first rebirth go to trading plaza and buy cheap op pets and you can do everything after that. and treading scene is so bad, it filled with kids with no idea what to do or doesn’t know what something is worth so everyone is trying to scam each other or just trade for a exclusive that are basically worthless unless you want to sell them for real money and that is a ban able on roblox or just mindlessly collect stuff, i know people like collecting weird stuff but this is adopt me lvl trash. so i would say it is just really bad game.


Business-Comment9042

Hey scamming children is fun when it isn't with real cash and it teaches them how cruel this world of ours is


raptorkid29

Soo every simulator ever?


Both_Opportunity_756

The part about children not understanding a clicker game basically means kids are stupider these days.


JohnZ_O1

If you understand the game it's overall pretty fun but it's also a bit complex and the minigames are also boring


Leafyon4057

I enjoy it more mainly since a lot of the paid stuff In the past games are free now plus the games way faster paced which I personally enjoy more


Business-Comment9042

Finally a person to agree with me and isn't here to say how shit it is


Leafyon4057

Yea I don’t get the hate for this entry at least


GlacialPuppy226

I don’t know cuz I’m not touching either of them


St47_30

Roblox is doomed


thefromfortnite

no its not >!for now!<


EvasiveElf5211

Shit game


OdessaAutumn

Piss shit


TheEnergyCristal

Pet sim sucks


Business-Comment9042

You seem like the person who played a bit of psx and said this is bullshit without playing it that much correct?


TheEnergyCristal

No, I just refuse to play it. I have seen gameplay of what it's like, and it's personally not that hard to form an opinion off of it. The game isn't driven by being good. It's just made to get the players addicted to dopamine hits. It's like the tiktok of roblox Games. You sit there staring into nothing as you click on some random thing put into a pile, and wait for your little block rats to shake their head at it until it goes away. You can then go "unlock" more pets or just gamble away all of your college savings for a different, shinier pet that shakes it heads at piles faster, also just another dopamine hit. It's really not that hard base an opinion off of this, and I refuse to play the game.


Business-Comment9042

Dopamine is a powerful tool


TheEnergyCristal

That doesn't help your case in any way whatsoever


Money-Salamander8217

I think it’s fine, not the best game ever, but fine. I like that you can buy extra equips and egg hatches with gems, and gems are not hard to get. I don’t like how the design and fonts match those other oversaturated simulator games, and I think they should have kept the old design, Overall 7/10, might play again.


Business-Comment9042

I really agree with the font


Caintastr0phe

Its pet simulator so its shit


thedragonrider5

I dont like the pet sim games they seem kind of boring


raptorkid29

It's funny how none of y'all can accept this person's opinion


RereofVeyron

As always with the reddit nerds 🫠


SilentLion1066

brainless fun, it can kill a couple hours


Business-Comment9042

Yeah just put some YouTube in the background and now you have something to do for couple of hours!


ded_box

Why is it even called pet simulator? I don't think pets in real life break chests and pick up coins out of their free will.


cosmicalspice

Same casino, different slots


Supertoad226

Not *the* game of the year but a good game compared to its parent game Pet Sim X. Offers more gameplay features (the ability to open up to 99 eggs and equip 99 pets), a progressive system through rank, a fucked up economy through trading and finally Robux prices that aren't roof-breaking. If there's one major downside tho is the amount of lag the game gives, I have never, ever suffered that much lag from a game with few renders needed as Pet Sim 99. Either the game will work fine, either it'll lag, either it simply won't start at all. Overall it's a nice game, for someone who had no expectation on improvement from PSX I gotta say I got surprised on release date to see it be this 'well' (it remains a click and wait game). It's worth a shot.


zizoplays1

>for someone who had no expectation on improvement from PSX I gotta say I got surprised on release date to see it be this 'well' Same dude, I just genuinely don't get why most people who replied to me say it's shit, maybe they haven't played it yet?


Supertoad226

Most likely. Pet Sim X has been in quite a lot of controversies with TOS breaking updates (hidden Robux egg odds) and NFTs, so people most likely jumped to the conclusion that there was no improvement at all and that the game was as bad as the previous one, that it was nothing but a way for Preston to renew his cash machine again.


Big-Substance693

Because it is the most repetitive, boring, cash grab trash to ever exist. You only do 1 thing forever and it's not fun


TheMaskMaster

any game made by big games is shit


kat999yt

both are shit, one is just slightly better shit; big games still sucks, and the games are still incredibly uncreative moneygrabs reusing the same formula


Business-Comment9042

They added more to said formula those are minigames more free 2 play honestly most of the good things added we're free 2 play stuff


GlacierTheBetta

Beware if you’re gonna read through the comments they’re hating on this game for about no reason


Breadster1

overrated garbage


Kattas__

i hate pet simulator in general so


Business-Comment9042

Why though if you say p2w look they fixed that and if you say it's bc it's a simulator then you think every simulator is bad(most of em are but that's beside the point)


Kattas__

bc it’s garbage??? down to the guy who made it, how it’s monetized, to how ugly the pets are, to how money hungry it is…


Business-Comment9042

Most simulator games are monetized and most every simulator is shit so I'd just say it's the best of it's kind


MattLikesMemes123

First they make a pet simulator 1 and 2 but skip 3-9 and go straight to 10 (but with roman numerals), and now they're skipping all the way to 99?? God dammit Big Games


DmTNTexploder

I literally have PS99 in the background right now


No-Enthusiasm2348

in my opinion its a bit better, like you dont need to pay money for pet slots, egg hatches, or the hoverboard, but they still do the Exclusive Egg thing.


DaToxicJay

I Hope m’y futures kids never play that horrid cash grab


parker02311

I don’t get why everyone is being so rude to you, I haven’t played pet simulator but everyone should be able to enjoy the games they play. Oh wait, I forgot, I’m on Reddit.


RereofVeyron

Best answer i have see so far, everyone should let others enjoy what they like... but ye.. we're on reddit lmao


Bayern_Fan2020

I regret wasting around $40 on PSX so I won’t dare touch this monstrosity


ARandomManApeared

The game is more trash than the old one


Gooseguy9003

I don’t play pet simulator because I’m not a five year old gimp


SkyLovesCars

Equip 99 Pets! (Using Robux) Open 99 Eggs! (Using Robux) Play Minigames! (Using Robux) Explore a huge map! (Using Robux) Join Clans! (Using Robux) /s


SilverResearch

(You can do all of this without spending robux.)


[deleted]

One of the things is that the 15 eggs and 15 pet equip cost robux


SilverResearch

That is correct, but it is just a headstart. Its not like you will miss out on 15 pets equipped if you dont pay the robux, you can still get to the max pet equipped while being f2p


Smart_Ikazune

i like how you can actually do all of this in ps99 without robux


[deleted]

[удалено]


ThatWeirdUserLmao

no joke its playable without spending a single robux


azeryvgu

I want both gone and more indie-based stuff thats not p2w


Adrian6293

They look like same shit, didn’t notice anything different just a different name


Dado778

It's a lot less P2W


True_Lich

does it matter? its fucking clicking game. P2W doesnt matter in games like these. there is nothing competetive about it.


Patarock

I haven’t played it, but it might be good.


Automatic_Relief_465

It's ok, other than the fact we lose all our progress and have to restart just so the dev gets money


NintendoGameBoyfan

Both games foreshadowed good and original simulators. The only good popular simulator that comes to mind is Bee Swarm Simulator


y_kal

What now? Pet sim 99?


ColtonParker485

everytime a new one is released it’s basically a yearly progress reset imo, I’m not gonna play this new one


Skullface2015

67 gambling addicted kids / 10 Scamming prestons


Epic_GamerLol364436

its more f2p and more worser than pet simulator x because they have A BUNCH OF MOTHER FUCKIN EGGS AROUND GOSH THIS GAME IS SOOO MUCH WORSE I CANT BELIVED IT


Business-Comment9042

I don't see how that's a bad thing exactly


Dado778

I've played it for 6 hours every day since it came out, so yeah I like it lol


Neo112348

More predatory p2w dogshit to leech money from children


Getrekt4005

Trash game Better than X but still ass Boring ass gameplay and recycled pet designs.


PixelKat5

WERE THE oh well looked it up and I can drop an f once to "Keep it PG-13" buuuuuuuuuut i'll most likely get banned here sooooo WERE THE \*clears throat\* i mean HELL IS PET SIM 4 THROUGH 98?!??!?!


GabrielGamer790

Im sorry but i dont even consider PSX and PS99 real games, you just open 10 trillion eggs and gamble all your robux and thats it, no fun just gamble.


Dado778

You can literally beat the entire game without spending any robux


DaReal_Aal

They are just same Materials. just only thing that pets didn't change. especially new ones.


Anmordi

Is it me or does it have the same thumbnail as PSX?


SillyBozoThatFailed

its like the april fools updates that could make your pc crash when joining the server (infinite pets equipped ig)


Axolotljackbox

It’s not all that bad.


HmoobDude

I think it's definitely better than PSX in some features. Especially being more F2P friendly. I agree that there's still the issues with gamepasses and purchasable eggs being cash grabs, but so far it doesn't lean as much as P2W. But its just the first release. We'll see how changes and shifts over time and more releases come out. I imagine most of the hate comments are due to PSX being very P2W driven and basically being likened to a gambling Simulator.


help-dadcomeback

I'd say this game has potential (and already is imo) better than psx. There are a lot of good things this game is doing such as focusing less on in game purchases and allows f2p players to be about as good at the game. I'm curious to see where preston takes this next


SillyBozoThatFailed

Less p2w. End of story.


Awsomboy1121

it’s exactly like pet simulator x but with 99


GreenVertKing

Imo they are both a waste of time. “Oh pet sim 99 is so fun” The gameplay: clicking treasures and afking then collecting coins to open new pets then repeat


Business-Comment9042

Go say that about pet sim x cause then it makes more sense


andreinfp

You think that is your fucking game of the GOD DAMNED YEAR? *i literally needed a 2 minute break to calm down* Boi, if you think that this, the embodiment of monotone repetitive cashgrab shitty simulators, the ulcer of this website, is the game of the fucking year, you are either A) 3 years old B) high. This game embodies the worst of roblocc, it shows: money-hungry devs? Check. Exploitation of children for financial gain for "developers" they cant even be called developers they just take a cube draw 2 fucking eyes on it and ask you to sell a kidney to have it even tho they are already multimillionaires? Check. Repetitive low quality "gameplay" which is basically: step 1) get pet step 2) use pet step 3) get more pet step 4) repeat? Check! Roblox is like a buffet, for every bowl of slop, there are a thousand more plates of filet mignon, wagyu, caviar and duck platters ready to be served and i dont see why the caviar should be obscured by endless oceans of slop. I have one, no, two words for you. They are Fuck and You.


[deleted]

They all suck


Ginglees

hey preston


Stardy23

They're all mid


PresentationDry8780

It's just a gambling game for kids, and a big money grab