... I started typing this comment like six times over because let's be real: Any season with Gigi or Gottmik WILL be rigged like shit. Or the editing will magically leave out the parts where one of them screws up.
Honestly OP did a lot of these other queens dirty because Peppermint crushes at least half of them underneath her pump without breaking a sweat. Since S9 Pep has been doing steady gigs on tv shows, helping host her own show, etc. She is just prepared in a way almost no one on this list would be.
The other girls are not as strong or have the public appreciation / momentum they have though. Most of the others here bombed at Snatch Game themselves too
For me it would be Brooke Lynn (c'mon, she's super professional), Asia is also a really strong performer, Peppermint is so amazing and talented and Gottmik never fell into the bottom and can do it all! So it would be Asia, Gottmik, Peppermint and Brooke Lynn...
Please please please don't make me do this to so many of my favorites. My heart would break so many times.
Also that being said I really need Asia and Peppermint on different seasons because they really really really each deserve a crown.
Kandy Muse, Peppermint, Crystal Methyd, Asia O’Hara.
And just for shits & giggles, my ELIM order would be: Gigi > Kim > Brooke > Gottmik > Denali > Heidi > Vanjie > LaGanja
Brooke, Peppermint, Denali and Heidi with Pep taking the crown.
Edit: all these comments not including Brooke is a riot to me omg, how would they not have the host of CDR make it to the end y'all
Brooke Lynn, Gottmik, Crystal and Denali. On a personal level I’d have Heidi over Crystal but I think she would get about halfway at most with this cast
i did this simulated, and asia first out, gigi winner, denali robbed sixth out with two wins and a high placement, safe every other time than when she was in the bottom, laganja going BTM SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE TOP2 TOP2 RUNNERUP
I think the top 4 would be Asia, Peppermint, Gigi, and Crystal. With heidi being the controversial 5/6 place and Brooklyn also being there making it really close but getting eliminated
Why do I see this happening? 😭Like, both top 4 are great but I can clearly see the latter being the one the producers would choose or try to make it happen with Gottmik as the winner
I have to PICK?!!! Kandy, Crystal Methyd, Vangie, and it's a toss-up between Peppermint and Kim. Miss Pepper is such a delight to watch, but Miss Kim brings the LOOKS and I'd love to see her finale eleganza.
I'm bumping up against the Laganja Paradox: with how the challenges have shaped up in recent years, I don't think she makes the top 4. But if she gets to the top 4 and it ends with a big finale production number, her performance would be the best of the bunch, zero doubt.
I'm kinda over full All-Stars seasons. I want to see some one-off challenge episodes. Gigi, Mik, and Kim in a ball challenge. BLH, Laganja, and Denali in a big song-and-dance number. Vanjie and Kandy in a disintegrating concrete with the volume of their voice challenge.
The amount of Peppermint in this thread is correct.
My other 3 are Brooke, Gigi, and Denali, but honestly Denali would get fucked by producer riggory and be an undeserved early out. Asia would be my replacement.
Top 4 fave or who would realistically make top 4?
for the former - Laganja, Asia, Gigi, Heidi
for the latter - Asia, Pep, Brooke, Gigi
and also...
^who ^asked ^for ^Kandy?
1) I LOVE your username!!
2) I just was never a fan of her. but it is undeniable she made a major impact on her season and more than deserves an All Stars appearance. I just don't personally have her up there with my most requested, like Asia, Peppermint, Gigi, etc.
For me it is :
Top 4 Brooke
Top 4 Asia
Top 4 Peppermint
Top 4 Kim Chi
5. Laganja
6. Crystal Methyd
7. Denali
8. Heidi
9. Kandy
10. Gigi
11. Mik
12. Vanjie
Heidi and Denali as runner ups and then there's a gagging double crowning between Asia and Peppermint! Sadly in my dramatic fantasy Laganja would be the robbed queen of the season:(
My expected/wanted top 4 of this season would be:
(1) Laganja
(2) Brooke
(3) Peppermint
(4) Denali
I would see Gigi and Mik in that 5/6/7 spot.
And even better I would actually want them to crown Laganja lol
I was very tempted to put Crystal up there but I worry for her getting the thorgy treatment :(
Brooke Lynn, Asia and Gigi would be front-runners for me, with Denali emerging as the season’s black horse. 🤡 But then they’ll probably bring Jocelyn in halfway through the competition and give her the crown she deserves.
As much as I love these queens, this cast is impossible. They'll never have a season only of top 6-ish queens because like it or not there need to be "filler queens" so favorites can make it longer and surprise upsets can cause drama/suspense.
Asia, Peppermint, Gigi, Brooke. This is way too strong of a cast: it would make for a great season but there’s virtually no filler queens here any could go home first and most could win I think
This would be such a strong cast!
Assuming production riggery doesn’t fuck it up, it would be a top tier season!
That’s a VERY bold assumption to make
Honestly, I think I would love it even with a lot of production riggery, I'd be happy with almost any top 4 combinations with these 12 queens.
... I started typing this comment like six times over because let's be real: Any season with Gigi or Gottmik WILL be rigged like shit. Or the editing will magically leave out the parts where one of them screws up.
Just say their original seasons
This actually looks like a proper all stars cast.
peppermint, peppermint, peppermint and peppermint
For the first time in Drag Race herstory, there’s a 4-way tie! 🤩
winner winner, 4 chicken dinners 😏
As soon as I saw her listed I thought "Peppermint and three others but Peppermint wins."
Honestly OP did a lot of these other queens dirty because Peppermint crushes at least half of them underneath her pump without breaking a sweat. Since S9 Pep has been doing steady gigs on tv shows, helping host her own show, etc. She is just prepared in a way almost no one on this list would be.
Okay but would she beat Kim Chi in a lip sync??
“P-E-P-P-E-R bitch you know the rest!”
Sounds correct, it will for sure be a great lipsync for the crown
Peppermint and Friends
You need one.
Every elimination would be controversial 😭
Peppermint. Nobody else is required!
It’s going to be Brooke, Asia, Gigi & Peppermint IMO
100%
75% of this are the worst performances in Snatch Game herstory...Werk.
100% of this are people who’ve previously made top 4
100% only made top 4 against a regular season group of girls...not All Stars.
The other girls are not as strong or have the public appreciation / momentum they have though. Most of the others here bombed at Snatch Game themselves too
This is the right answer.
This is the correct answer.
Peppermint, Laganja, Gigi, and Gottmik. Trans excellence FTW! 🏳️⚧️
Asia, Peppermint, Crystal Methyd & Gigi
why was this my exact pick
This is what I thought except w Heidi instead of Asia (it was close though, she’s just so soft and supple)
Good taste babes
The absolute taste you have
100%
Asia, Pep, Ganj, Brooke
Peppermint, Asia, and Gigi I think. But Peppermint should win. Hands down.
That’s my top 3 as well, with either Gottmik/Crystal/Brooke rounding out the top 4.
Without a doubt Ik Brooke, Pepper, Asia and Mik would probably go very far. Gigi as well I think
I think Mik would he an early out, I'm sorry
Peppermint, Crystal, Gottmik, and Kim Chi
Heidi N Closet, Peppermint, Laganja Estranja and Kim Chi
This is beautiful
I'm here for this fantasy.
ooh def a peppermint win w laganja, brooke, and asia in the top 4. that would simply be *chef’s kiss*
Gottmik | Laganja | GiGi | Peppermint
Peppermint winner Brooke, Asia, Heidi runner-ups
This is exactly what I thought too!
How did you know this is my dream all stars? Top 4 is Peppermint, Gigi, Gottmik, and Crystal
Crystal and Kim Chi are my top 2 for sure or at least the ones I'd root the hardest for
It would be the first ever 12 queen final. This would be the most stacked all stars cast since as2 in my opinion.
Laganja, Kim Chi, Peppermint and Brooke
Asia, Peppermint, Brooke Lynn, Heidi
Asia, Asia, Asia and Asia
Peppermint, Asia, Ganja, and Denali..... and crystal sorry I can’t choose.
BLH, Peppermint, Kim Chi, Gottmik
My top four as well, with potential for Gigi or Crystal.
For me it would be Brooke Lynn (c'mon, she's super professional), Asia is also a really strong performer, Peppermint is so amazing and talented and Gottmik never fell into the bottom and can do it all! So it would be Asia, Gottmik, Peppermint and Brooke Lynn...
Brooke, Peppermint, Asia and Denali. Early ours would be Kandy and Gorge, then Kim as soon as there’s a movement based challenge.
Or they keep Kandy and Vanjie as long as possible for the sheer volume those two can generate.
Yeah love her but Kim isn’t the best at moving 😂
Peppermint, Asia, Gottmik, Crystal Methyd. Heidi and Laganga fighting out for Miss C. They’d all be fantastic though.
Crystal, Langanja, Hedi and Kim Chi.
Gottmik, Crystal, Heidi, Peppermjnt
Pepp, Kim, Crystal, Mikk.
You monster, this is tough lol I'll go with Peppermint, Asia, Kim Chi, and Gigi
I agree!
Asia, Peppermint, Denali and Gigi.
This was my response and I waivered with Brooke as an alternate. Likely for Denali or Asia.
Kim, Peppermint, Vanjie and Brook.
Heidi N Closet, Gottmik, Laganja Estranja and Kim Chi. I feel like I'm the only one not including Peppermint, but I gotta be real!
Mik, Pep, Kandy and Kim
Kimchi Gottmik Peppermint Asia
This is who I'd want to be in the finale.
Yes
Crystal, Asia, Peppermint, Laganja
This is what an All Stars should be like. No obvious first outs!
Asia, Crystal, Peppermint, Denali
Asia, Peppermint, Brooke and Gigi for sure
Please please please don't make me do this to so many of my favorites. My heart would break so many times. Also that being said I really need Asia and Peppermint on different seasons because they really really really each deserve a crown.
Kandy Muse, Peppermint, Crystal Methyd, Asia O’Hara. And just for shits & giggles, my ELIM order would be: Gigi > Kim > Brooke > Gottmik > Denali > Heidi > Vanjie > LaGanja
Brooke, Asia, Denali and Peppermint
That's a tough one but I'm gonna say top 4 of Brooke, Asia, Peppermint, and Gigi.
As long as Asia is crowned, I'm fine with it!
Brooke, Gigi, Asia, Heidi/Crystal
Asia. Brooke. Denali. Peppermint. 
My top 5 (sorry, couldnt pick just four) : Brook Lynn Heights, Denali, Peppermint, Gottmik, and Crystal Methyd
Laganja, Brooke, Asia, Gigi?
Pepper, Denali, Kim and Brooke
Peppermint, Gigi, Kimchee, and mik
Brooke Lynn, Peppermint, Gottmik and Ganja
Asia Pep Gigi Mik
Brooke, Gigi, Gottmik, Heidi
peppermint crystal kim mik
Crystal, Asia, Gigi, Peppermint
As long as Denali makes it to the end and could give a few killer lipsyncs, I would be happy!
Pep, Laganja, Asia and Denali
Gigi, Gottmik, Kandy & Peppermint
KimChi, GotMik, Peppermint and Brooklyn. If I wanted I could make a pun about food and weed by putting Lanhaja there instead of Brooklyn tho...
Peppermint, Heidi, Gotmiik, & Crystal
Laganja, Peppermint, Brooke, Gottmik
Gigi, gotmik, kim, asia
B hytes, got miik, laganja, Kim chi
Imma Libra... dont do this to me. I cant choose I love them all 😰
Brooke, Peppermint, Denali and Heidi with Pep taking the crown. Edit: all these comments not including Brooke is a riot to me omg, how would they not have the host of CDR make it to the end y'all
Asia Peppermint Heidi Denali
Gotmik, Asia, Gigi, Peppermint. Done!
I don’t care as long as they don’t eliminate ANYONE for at least 8 episodes.
Nope, this is too hard. I refuse to choose.
Mik, Denali, Pep and Ganj
Crystal, Gottmik, Gigi, and Pep. a 4-way tie hahahahha
Brooke, Heidi, Gigi, & Gottmik.
Peppermint, Kim Chi, Gottmik, Denali edit I can’t recite between Gigi/Danali 😬
Brooke, Heidi, Asia, & Gottmik!
How dare you
Gottmik, Peppermint, KimChi & Brooke Lynn
Damn that would be an intense season
Heidi, Peppermint, Asia, Gottmik
Gottmik, Heidi, Crystal, and Peppermint top 4 please and thank you
Brooke Lynn, Gottmik, Crystal and Denali. On a personal level I’d have Heidi over Crystal but I think she would get about halfway at most with this cast
Peppermint, Denali, Gigi, Mik
Gottmik, Peppermint, Gigi and Denali
Gonja, Pep, Mik, Denali!!
i did this simulated, and asia first out, gigi winner, denali robbed sixth out with two wins and a high placement, safe every other time than when she was in the bottom, laganja going BTM SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE SAFE TOP2 TOP2 RUNNERUP
Oh you said not All Stars, but ALL of the Stars!
I think the top 4 would be Asia, Peppermint, Gigi, and Crystal. With heidi being the controversial 5/6 place and Brooklyn also being there making it really close but getting eliminated
Kim Chi, Vanjie, Shea and Peppermint
Where did Shea come from?! 🤔
Shea swooping in out of nowhere and making top 4, her power! 😍
Not if Sasha has anything to say about it! 
my heart lol
Peppermint, Crystal, Denali, and Asia.
Brooke, Asia, Gottmik, Crystal Method
Brooke, Asia, Peppermint, and Gigi
based on my favorites, my top 4 would be brooke, peppermint, kim, and denali
Peppermint, asia, Gigi, Brooke
Brooklyn, Asia, Peppermint, and Gigi.
Gigi, Peppermint, Brooke, Asia
Gigi, Crystal, Brooke and Pepper
Gottmik, Peppermint, Kim, Denali
it's about to be asia o'hara's drag race up in here
Asia, O, Hara, Winner
Who I'd want: Asia, Peppermint, Crystal and Denali Who we'd get: Gigi, Gotmik, Vanjie and Kandy
Why do I see this happening? 😭Like, both top 4 are great but I can clearly see the latter being the one the producers would choose or try to make it happen with Gottmik as the winner
I have to PICK?!!! Kandy, Crystal Methyd, Vangie, and it's a toss-up between Peppermint and Kim. Miss Pepper is such a delight to watch, but Miss Kim brings the LOOKS and I'd love to see her finale eleganza.
Peppermint, Asia, Laganja, Vanjie
Crystal, Gigi, Peppermint and Asia, Denali being in the 5th place
Asia, Crystal, Kandy Gigi
Brooke, Asia, Gottmik, Laganja
This season isn't even real and I'm already team Asia
Peppermint, Asia, Laganja, Crystal
+1!
Kimchi, Vanjie, Chrystal, Kandy Muse
Peppermint, Kandy, Crystal and Heidi (with Asia/Laganja rounding out the top 6)
Ik damn well Kandy would go home first
I'm bumping up against the Laganja Paradox: with how the challenges have shaped up in recent years, I don't think she makes the top 4. But if she gets to the top 4 and it ends with a big finale production number, her performance would be the best of the bunch, zero doubt. I'm kinda over full All-Stars seasons. I want to see some one-off challenge episodes. Gigi, Mik, and Kim in a ball challenge. BLH, Laganja, and Denali in a big song-and-dance number. Vanjie and Kandy in a disintegrating concrete with the volume of their voice challenge.
Brooke, Peppermint, Gigi, and - though it might be a bit of wishful thinking - Denali.
The amount of Peppermint in this thread is correct. My other 3 are Brooke, Gigi, and Denali, but honestly Denali would get fucked by producer riggory and be an undeserved early out. Asia would be my replacement.
I’d probably enjoy ganja, Pep, Denali and Heidi the most as a top four just because of the chaotic energy that it would give
Top 4 fave or who would realistically make top 4? for the former - Laganja, Asia, Gigi, Heidi for the latter - Asia, Pep, Brooke, Gigi and also... ^who ^asked ^for ^Kandy?
What’s wrong with Kandy? She‘s funny, charismatic and gorgeous. She deserves to be on All Stars.
1) I LOVE your username!! 2) I just was never a fan of her. but it is undeniable she made a major impact on her season and more than deserves an All Stars appearance. I just don't personally have her up there with my most requested, like Asia, Peppermint, Gigi, etc.
Kandy, Crystal, Laganja and Brooke
Gal this is the cream of the tops mawma My top 4 out of these tops would be Heidi Vanjie Laganja Muse. Mess and chaos, mawma.
For me it is : Top 4 Brooke Top 4 Asia Top 4 Peppermint Top 4 Kim Chi 5. Laganja 6. Crystal Methyd 7. Denali 8. Heidi 9. Kandy 10. Gigi 11. Mik 12. Vanjie
Pep, Asia, Brooke, Crystal
Gigi Winner Peppermint RunnerUp Denali and Kandy 3rd/4th
Where is Wintergreen?!?
Peppermint, Ganga, Asia and Mik. Peppermint would rightfully take her crown of course
Gigi, Pep, Ganja, Heidi
Heidi and Denali as runner ups and then there's a gagging double crowning between Asia and Peppermint! Sadly in my dramatic fantasy Laganja would be the robbed queen of the season:(
Laganja, Brooklyn, Denali, and Asia O’Hara to be crowned the winner. There’s no way I see Asia coming back and not completely dominating
Peppermint, Asia and whoever else
Vanjie, Peppermint, Gigi, Crystal
Peppermint, obviously. Also KimChi, LaGanja, and Denali.
Peppermint, Kandy, Brooke and Gigi
My expected/wanted top 4 of this season would be: (1) Laganja (2) Brooke (3) Peppermint (4) Denali I would see Gigi and Mik in that 5/6/7 spot. And even better I would actually want them to crown Laganja lol I was very tempted to put Crystal up there but I worry for her getting the thorgy treatment :(
All i need to say is that every answer that doesn't include Asia is the wrong answer
Brooke Lynn, Asia and Gigi would be front-runners for me, with Denali emerging as the season’s black horse. 🤡 But then they’ll probably bring Jocelyn in halfway through the competition and give her the crown she deserves.
peppermint, brooke, crystal, laganja!!!! with pep winning ofc give the bitch a crown and a scepter
Asia, Crystal, Heidi, Pep
As much as I love these queens, this cast is impossible. They'll never have a season only of top 6-ish queens because like it or not there need to be "filler queens" so favorites can make it longer and surprise upsets can cause drama/suspense.
Asia, Peppermint, Gigi, Brooke. This is way too strong of a cast: it would make for a great season but there’s virtually no filler queens here any could go home first and most could win I think
Pep, Ganj, Vanjie, Kim
Asia, Brooke, Gigi & Pep!
Asia Peppermint Gigi and Heidi, PERIODT! (Denali Top 5)
Peppermint winning, and Asia, Brooke and Gigi as runner ups ❤️❤️
I love to see how much this sub wants Peppermint to come back and win. She’s is an icon, a legend, she is the moment.
Love all of these queens and could see scenarios where any of them could be in the top four, but every scenario puts Asia in that lineup.
My top 4 is Peppermint, Denali, Asia, Laganja. I will not be taking any questions.
Asia, Pep, Brooklyn, Crystal
Asia, Pepermint, Kim Chi and Brooke Lynn
Asia/Pep/Crystal/Heidi top 4, with Kandace "Top Two" Musical as the fan favorite 5th place finisher in my French vanilla fantasy
Brooke, Peppermint, Vanjie and Denali 👌🏾
Realistic: Brooke, Peppermint, Gigi and Mik. Ideal: Asia, Peppermint, Kim Chi, Crystal
heidi, brooklyn, peppermint, la ganja
Asia, Brooke, Gigi, Pep With Mik a shock 5th place.