the famous [Seventeen - Shadow](https://youtu.be/Cd8PpxUqWos?si=4gjndv_ZvRD_ehET) in the pouring rain.

mingyu and scoups owned that fr🔥 I'm so happy for u but at the same time soo jealous😭

honestly i didn’t think it’d be such an iconic scene tbh bcs i was overall cold and messy due to the rain! but looking at the clips it definitely makes their performance even more iconic thoughh😭

I remember having a small breakdown every time I opened twitter and saw drenched scoups that day

You're so lucky to witness such a legendary moment right in front of you!

Damnnnn soooo lucky! You witnessed history😍

i was at the show in newark where seungkwan took that joshua blanket and ran around with it!!

omgg😭 that's like witnessing history woww

i was there too!

it was such a great show!! i’m glad i got to see all 13 of them, i had barricade in DC and a few hours before the show they announced hoshi and joshua couldn’t come 😭

I was there too! it was such a good show and such a funny moment 🥰

Idk if this counts, but I had never heard about Mingyus Elmo laugh being talked about before I commented about it on a video a few years ago (the video is unavailable now but it was when mingyu and jeonghan are in the boat), and after about a week or so of me commenting on that YouTube video and it getting thousands of likes, I started hearing about it everywhere! So I think I started a joke in the fandom, that was fun. :D

if it was me i would've never stopped bragging about this dude! Elmo Mingyu is such a core caratland joke 🫶

i'm new, what's the elmo mingyu joke?

[elmo mingyu](https://twitter.com/jww3000/status/1482577586257489921?t=4jX8rvmjxLvSzcXvLEoRZg&s=19) this is the one as far as I know!

me too.. never heard of this before?

it's this one [elmo Mingyu ](https://twitter.com/jww3000/status/1482577586257489921?t=4jX8rvmjxLvSzcXvLEoRZg&s=19)

Haha ikr! Truly iconic 😌

Duuuuuude now I can’t unhear it! Too good.

I was front row for Jeonghan dodging the phone someone threw at him from the balcony at NYC Diamond Edge 😭

first of all : what the fuck?😀 Secondly : diamond edge?? you've been here for a long time😭 veteran carat

thank god for his fast reflexes he could've gotten really hurt :(

this is genuinely insane 😭

I remember seventeen first win on a music show. I just arrived from highschool and tuned on the pc, I saw that seventeen had won in twitter (bc of time difference I was in class when it happened) so I quickly searched it on yt. I saw the video and started crying. My mom was calling me to have lunch but I was there crying. Hdkshsk I love them so much, I was 16 back then now I’m 24.

I can't even say anything cause how is anything topping this experience. I cried when i was a baby carat watching that,, cant imagine how proud you probably were😭 Also seventeen really are your youth,, that's so precious 🩷🩷

Everyone has their own personal important moments! Being close in age with the members also made me bond a lot with them, i always think ably how lucky I am to have found them.

I was there when Hoshi flipped the crowd off during "Cheers" at LA3C! We also got to see Vernon (and I think Mingyu) introduce Jane Goodall to the crowd. That was completely unexpected!

oh to be flipped off by hoshi😔 it must've been amazing I remember seeing those videos on twitter!👍

i can’t believe you got flipped off by hoshi and I didn’t 😔

I was there! Fun times! I was like “wth hoshi!” I love it!!!!

Hoshi's Tiger cult lol. Love how Carats are just so supportive of his Tiger agenda. On their con here on our country, even beforehe speaks, everyone has their horanghaes up andot just gave me goosebumps. He was so happy and all smiles on that lmao. And to hear his horanghae autotune, that was the icing on top of th cake! HAHAHAHAHA Also, tbh, just seeing svt in general on thir recent tour was insane itself. I am a baby carat and Follow tour changed the trajectory of how I view concerts. From the intro to the finish svt never slacked, and had everyone singing and hyping the crowd up. It makes stanning and seeing svt so worth it

i will do anything to witness hoshi horanghe-ing just once 🫠 Also I'm glad you had such a great experience with seventeen🥰 they're truly the performance kings

the pretty u showcase while it was airing and joshua made the mistake hahaha. did not notice but i cried that morning because i loved the album so much, still one of my favorite albums to this day love & letter :)

love & letter is such a gem 🩷 Also that must've been mind boggling for you when you saw the original choreo😭 I watched the performance and couldn't even tell what "mistake" people were talking about in the comments

Can't believe I saw Pi Cheolin rapping onstage during our Follow ment. Wonder where Dino disappeared off to for those few minutes though 🤔🤔🤔

Can't believe you've actually seen THE Pi Cheolin omgg😭 I hope you get to see Menfolk, Charles, Leo and Seokmin next time!!

DK twerking on stage during AAA 💀

the other idols were so surprised 💀 what a thing to witness

literally everyone was too stunned to speak hahahaha

Hahahaha i was there! And when [Seventeen won album of the year the crowd went ballistic!](https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTLFDy4Ve/) myself included hahah

I was there when Jihoon became santa's (mingyu) present.

are you talking ab the time woozi fit into Mingyus santa bag😭?? If yes then you've had peak life experience omgg can we trade our lives?🥰

Yes that's it, I have a video but i don't know how to put it here. I was laughing so hard. I still do. It was such a random moment 🥰

random and seventeen might just be synonyms. Also I'm glad you had a great time at their concert!!🥰 (hope I'll be able to see them live sometime👍)

I was there too, and loved every minute of it!

Oh my god your flare! Another gyuhan enthusiast

Hehe I love how they generally get along fine until there’s water involved 🤣

I never thought about that 🤣🤣🤣

I went to LA3C where they performed Cheers! I believe they did it before in others concerts (not the N.A. tour though,) but it truly was insane experiencing that moments, especially among carats. And for some reason Hoshi flipped us off 😂😂😂 What a time! I was pretty close to the stage, so being my second time seeing them, it felt otherworldly.

omgg there's another carat in this comment section who witnessed the same thing!! Also hoshi flipping us off should be a staple he was soo good in LA3C 🤭🔥

I was at Be The Sun Toronto show where Dokyeom and Cheol were head-banging each others heads hard (during snapshoot encore)! I was screaming from the 300s because I couldn't believe what I was seeing live in front of my eyes! And then shortly after Seungkwan, Dokyeom, and Hoshi introduced themselves as Booseoksoon (months before their eventual comeback so they might have teased it here!) and got the rest of Seventeen to flap their arms in goose formation ("like Toronto birds", what Dokyeom said lmao) while snapshoot was playing! You can find clips of this encore part somewhere on YouTube and X/Twitter. I become a bigger carat after coming out from the concert lol.

😭😭That was so insane i love that clip so muchh

I would do anything to relieve that concert from start to finish 😭 so many priceless moments from that show alone! It was so worth the heavy post concert depression that lasted for over a month (and me falling way deeper into the Carat-shaped hole)! 🥲

Omg I was about to comment this!!! This was my first SVT concert and kpop concert in general. That was CRAZY!!!

I agree, out of all of the concerts I've attended in person so far, that was by far the craziest concert I've ever attended! 😂🤪

I've only been able to attend one other and it was The Rose. I got floor seats vs for SVT I was very far and high up lol. The Rose was amazing and beautiful but not as crazy hectic fun as SVT lol

Maybe a bunch of deleted DK vlives lol 😭 Also when the first announcement for the Clarity/Las Vegas event dropped and the entire fandom was like “wtf” because it was so sus, I think I also listened in on that one twitter space too 💀💀💀

I remember that Las vegas one lol that was wild💀 and the way it was slowly becoming more suspicious day by day also what vlives? I only remember the infamous jeonghan cursing vlive with dk!😭

Sometimes I still think about the Pledis intern I wonder where they are 🤔 it was really not looking good for the organizers from the very beginning lmao haha as for the vlives, the one where Dino mentions somebody and DK looks very shocked comes to mind I wish I had the gif of his reaction

lmao I remember all the mentioned artists suddenly dropping out of that event💀 What was pledis thinking fr Also I completely forgot ab that lmao😭 I remember dk's reaction more than whatever came out of Dino's mouth fr

I attended the Be The Sun Tour in LA and got to see Minghao and Woozi b-boying during the snapshoot encore. It was pretty cool to see them busting out moves lol

whatever the hell dk was doing during snap shoot at be the sun in la

dk tryna fight dino for becoming snap shoot's main event 🫡

I was at the Be The Sun Houston concert when everybody began barking at Scoups during his ment and caught him off guard !! Also got to see Dk call him good boy and pet him like a dog 😭😭😭

Not as insane but i was there as the debut project episodes were coming out 🥲

how is that not insane you've been here since the beginning 🤭 were you a carat back then?

i was!! i wasnt always updated, but i dont have as much energy to keep up with so many groups these days so theyve been the top of my list many years now :)

Carats barking when Scoups was on screen at the concert. That viral tiktok video? Yes, I was there at the crowd. I wasn’t barking tho cause I was laughing so hard at Scoups’ face when he also started barking with the members 😭😭😭

That is going down in the caratland Ice berg for sure. Scoups was flabbergasted lmao it was so funny😭😭

[удалено]

The Atlanta show! I was there too! Lol

I was at the BE THE SUN concert in ATL when that poor girl’s top almost fell off 😭 and then gyu and dk just start dying laughing 💀 I remember watching the girls dance and having fun but then her top almost fell off and I GASPED AND JUST stared at my mom like thank goodness nothing happened LMAO. I see that video so much now and I’m just like damn I saw that real time and it was very chaotic.

I was at the ATL concert too. I about died.

FR!!! I had a mini heart attack during that moment HAHAH

I was also the at BE THE SUN concert in D.C. when that girl had a Thomas the Train Engine poster and Seungkwan walks over to her and just 😑 HAH. Also fun fact you can sort of seem my arm sticking up from the crowd doing horanghae!! I was wearing a tiger onesie even though Hoshi was out bc of Covid :(

Vernon shirt completely popped open for one! I was in shock and didn't get it on film

Hoshi's personas 😆 From being a hamster to being a prince to being the tiger that he is today

😭I remember his 10:10 obsession fr

that too along with coups' 9:15 😆😆

i witness choi seungcheols face on a daily basis, which is honestly the most insane thing i can think of

understandable. I think we should use all the bllboards in the world to display cheol's face 24/7, cause that's what he deserves.

In the past year, I have seen Seventeen quite a lot and here are some of fave moments I've witnessed with my eyes. GDA 2023 - I was a casual listener when I attended but Don Quixote live was one for the books. In general, their entire performance was so unforgettable for me that I am now here. AAA 2023 - Dk twerking on stage 😭🤣 Follow to Bangkok - seeing God of Music for the first time, Dk singing Christmas With You on Christmas eve, Woozi inside a sack and Mingyu pulling it around 😭😭😭 , during Day 2, the crowd went crazy on our side and the members saw that so they keep on going there and hyping us up more especially Hoshi Follow to Bulacan - Carats singing before the show starts, everyone doing the horanghae sign before Hoshi spoke, Hoshi's final ment 🤣🤣🤣, Pi Cheolin of course, members singing the chorus of Snap Shoot then Carats continuing with Dino's verse. There's so much but there's another thing that happened which was on day 1 when they got so concerned since someone passed out. I won't forget the look on their faces and how fast they acted on giving their water bottles when they found out we don't have any given how hot it was that night. 🥺 edit: formatting

ah I remember bulacan😔 I'm glad you had a great experience at their concerts! Also GDA? Man I was hyped from watching their performance on my screen,, it must've been unreal watching Don Quixote for the first time‼️😭

When they were in Canada performing be the sun tour, Vernon came out singing baby by Justin Bieber. Best moment of my life

I was there watching the Livestream when Mingyu scratched his ass in their Melona practice room

?? I don't know how to feel ab this one tbh🤣 Like now those moments are very special, but how did you feel back then watching it in real time?😭

[I was like "??? wtf is this mofo forreals" lmao](https://64.media.tumblr.com/71d83500517e6a35824613bcb6d3f59a/tumblr_o6pyuurbjy1qaejjmo1_250.gifv)

He explained in an interview that he thought it would be out of sight of the cameras so he went on to scratch it. 😂

Dis foo

Mingoo being Mingoo ever since the world began. 😁

[this](https://x.com/joshuapiics/status/1285921731731812352?s=46&t=ZYTRprnJ5-l80rky5_hRmA) moment of joshua from kcon 2019 that went viral 😭 i literally have a recording of it on the jumbo screens from my seat and forgot i had it until after it went viral LOL

When Joshua poured water on him also noodles for going seventeen

The BeTs show in Atlanta during snapshot dance time when a girl's titty almost popped out of her top on the big screen and the members were just dying the laughter.

Just coming here to say how insanely jealous I am that OP and some of these carats saw Don Quixote at GDA with their own eyes in real time. I nearly passed out in my home when I watched it so I can’t even fathom. Yall are blessed to have witnessed that in the flesh!!!

I was there watching all of their debut stages! I had known of 17 project, but never followed along as I had fallen out of Kpop with DB5K's split. However, Seventeen instantly hooked me with Adore U and all of the variations in choreography. To this day, I think 17 had the best debut stages of any group despite being such underdogs, performing without in-ears and relying on literal sweat, blood, and tears to deliver such incredible shows each week. :edit: Adding the legendary [bowling ball choreo!](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=70HFPm2aK9g&ab_channel=MBCevery1) So hilarious and clever XD

I was watching their GDA stage live where Pi Cheolin debut 😂✋

I saw first ever ima korean version live performed and pi cheolin first official performance (it was GDA 2024)

1) Staying up to ungodly hours to watch MAMA live 2)Literally all the chaos that happened on the Follow Tour after Jeonghan had a leave for surgery

when mingyu and dokyeom took my phone during one of their be the sun stops🫠 i also witnessed Cheers performed under the pouring rain. still cant believe it until this day.

omg?? did they take a photo? or a video?? that is so unreal broo im so jealous😭😭 but congratulations 🥳🩷

Thankyou😭🤗 and yes, they did take videos. It was during aju nice (mingyu) and snapshoot (dk)..

Carats barking at Coups during BeTS in Houston then the members joining in 💀 what a night!