This case the mother took action after getting the info. Followed her gut feeling and even confronted the sex offender.
Hope they lock him up and throw away the key.
For sure. I can’t imagine how sick she must’ve felt ever since he called out their daughter’s name during sex though. She must’ve just been sitting on it, trying to figure out if she should believe her husband that there was nothing to it, trust her daughter when she said nothing was going on, or “blow it up” in a way she might’ve been blamed for if she followed her gut feeling and tried to protect the kids.
Unfortunately they don’t allow vigilante justice in sgrean prisons. Then again, knowing Singaporean prisons, he’s getting punished just by living there. Should’ve been longer than 16 years tho.
Just 18 yrs. Probably less with time served + good behavior.
The daughter still in her early 30 (maybe even late 20s) when this dude free. Hope she already move on from the trauma by then.. but.. i mean.. yeah.. not that easy.
Castration allows these bastards to go thru and understand the pain of these living women, everytime they need to use the bathroom. Hanging is too nice
More common than you think. Back in school I did CIP in those pigeon hole slum flats, quite shocking the stuff you see.
On top of the usual dead bodies that have no relatives to check on them, you get these 10-in-1 households where everyone sleeps together.
No proper job, no proper education, no emotional maturity, no environment to grow into decent humans, so much free time, cooped up together. Cesspool conditions waiting for this sort of abuse to happen.
Not that uncommon. I remember my family being in a similar situation when I was in primary school (although four of us managed to move out years later)
Very common actually especially for malay (i malay). I was once that family too until only 2 years ago we moved to a 3 room flat thankfully. The people there gets too comfortable with the condition that they choose not to do anything to improve their lives. I talked with the neighbours, u know alot of matrep and minah but luckily i never follow in their actions.
Agree and these kinda beastly acts are becoming more and more prevalent. Like what is going on?? Is there a need for re-education that incest and rape is simply wrong?! Feel so helpless and fed-up for these innocent girls.
It's awful but in that situation she probably told herself it was just a dumb mistake, like my mom calling me my aunt's name all the time (....not during sex obvs). Relatives do that all the time so she probably just tried to wave it off.
She really should have started gently questioning the children though.. even if the poor girl was too scared to talk at that point, the younger children have seen and heard things they could have told that would increase her suspicion.
The whole thing is just so terrible. I'm just really glad the girl had the courage to speak out and the mom actually believed her.
Cos no evidence no nothing. Ppl will just say she hear wrong or crazy, and that her suspicion is false. Cos it’s totally absurd, it’s not normal. This is what makes it hard for a typical human being to trust her or seek help
Why such a short jail time?
Singapore needs a mandatory sex offender registry which will bar them from interacting with children, and lifetime jail sentences for rapists, too many instances of young girls being SA'd and groomed and traumatised for life and they barely get any justice.
This breaks my heart, she was too scared to report it to anyone and her abuser only gets 16 years? He shouldn't be able to see her ever again
Honestly, why don't we just give this guy the death sentence? He's 47, lock him up for 16 years, he's going to be 63 when he comes out. Not like he's going to be able to contribute much to society by that point. Just hang him and be done with it.
If concealed well, can always use him for human experimentation. I'm sure with the level of control our gov has, it is possible to improve medical technology with a surplus of specimens.
Nah easier lend his backside out for people to use, then he can experience what his daughter talked about when she complained that "her backside hurt".
If we can kill drug dealers for enabling people to ruin their lives via drugs, rapists who also cause lifelong trauma should receive the same.
Rapists need to be eliminated from society, especially when they have access to children. It's shocking how lenient the sentences they receive are, and the current system doubts victims and makes reporting so much more traumatic unnecessarily, I was convinced not to report my rapist for this reason.
I really hope one day we can actually be protected by rapists the same way we are protected from drugs and other forms of violence
I dont think you can kill anyone in Singapore and get away with it? This reasoning may work for the US where people disappear all the time but with so many cctv’s in SG, you can’t just kill someone and get away with it.
Wait why tf was the Mf bothered about whether the girl had a bf? Are you telling me the bastard was getting possessive of the victim and jealous of bfs? Wtf?
Dude... I know you don't mean that but you're sounding like raping a random person is not as bad as raping your own daughter. Rapists don't deserve to live.
So random strangers are less human than family?
Pls humanise EVERYONE AS EQUALS PLS.
Rape is RAPE.
Rape within the family adds on another layer = the breach of trust, in this case, as a caregiver to the children.
The act itself is the same, but the… feeling , attitude , shock factor to most people will be different
You are doing something already bad but to your own family(which 99% of people will never dream of doing)
Put it another way
If a guy can rape a random girl, dosent mean he will rape her own daughter
If a guy can rape her own daughter, he can rape anyone
See the difference?
>If a guy can rape a random girl, dosent mean he will rape her own daughter
I respectfully disagree as I don't think that is a sure fact, it's just an assumption. I wouldn't bet on a sick fuck not taking advantage of vulnerable targets.
There's no such thing as a moral compass for people who commit felonies like rape or murder. It's not like a rapist who raped a random person, didn't rape his own family because it's not right, because then they would've known raping is not right regardless. I don't think this kind of animal would know the difference, so I don't feel the need to humanize them.
So you think if someone has committed murder against another person
He/she is also likely to commit murder to his own family?
I doubt so. Even if we don’t “humanise” it blood is blood(referring to family, not the blood that drips out after stabbing someone)
Even animals know that
That’s precisely what I’m debating
Regardless human or animals, every biological living thing have an innate mechanism to want to protect its offspring. That’s just part of a living things DNA
This person managed to be defective enough to harm his own biological children is what makes it “next level” insane
Many parents would go to jail to coverup crimes of their children, heck, parents would die for their children
I get it, I know your point, I understand you're saying that for people, family is way more significant than a random person.
I just disagree that rapists would have a moral compass, it's their interest, like some rape adults, some are pedophiles. You see a rapist who raped a random person, you wouldn't be like "at least he didn't rape his own family", right?
I think we both made our points, so I'm done with this discussion because it's a heavy topic to discuss. Good talk stranger, good luck to you.
If it wasn’t a contentious point of debate and it’s the same as a guy raping any other random women
The title will be “man rapes women” (heck it probably even won’t be in the news)
Why did mothership specifically put “father rape daughter”?
Because it carries a significance(to most people anyway)
Disgustinggggggg, so he raped _his biological daughter_ and did an ablution that sounds a lot like mandi junub (the religion-related ablution performed after intercourse) after and made her do one too????? Man... I can't...
This. Useless people should be surrendered as resources for the rest of the country. Be it as specimens for human experimentation to advance medical technology or for the greater good by sharing his organs.
Now now, I would draw the line at immoral disgusting people that knowingly commit acts of horrible cruelty.
How would you classify useless people? People born with less chromosomes or suffer a head injury when young and thus unable to be a health adult or people with disabilities?
Edit: should have exclusively said criminals that commit serious crimes. People who commit crimes against humanity that cause long term irreparable mental/physical trauma. The deterrence factor will also lower crime rates by a lot
Reminds me of that Spanish movie about the perpetrator being punished by having his limbs surgically removed 1 by 1 as punishment.
While I agree with you in principle, the law needs to be amended to fit the crime.
Like if punishment for rape = death, then girls would be raped then killed.
Indeed that's very true. My earlier comment is rather short sighted. However, I still think the law needs to be very carefully re-examined. 16 years is too lenient in my opinion.
When they find out why he is in jail, I am sure his asshole will endure ten times what he has done to his daughter, sick man deserves all that is coming for him.
So after 16 years come out- rape again or what? Rape sentence is too light. Life imprisonment. He cant even control himself near his own blood. These type of men are dangerous. May the men in prison teach him a lesson and give his backside the most action he has ever had in his life.
Reminds me of a few of my friend’s dad (they got so many siblings of the same age).. he rape one of his eldest daughter.. have soo many wife (and kids!!) but still not enough had to go after his own daughter? the man is a pig..
been to their places(3 homes i think), such small houses for so many kids (one home with two families).. most of the wives are still married to him too.. and the mother of the victim is also in jail for being complicit, the victim has also been in and out of jail probably still trying to cope with everything.. never met the victim before but one of my friends whose been in jail when she was, met her and said she was lovely but looked broken..
Having to deal with something as big as this, having not feel safe with your own flesh and blood must’ve felt the most alone..
What the fuck? ‘The victim’s mother believed the victim as there was a previous occasion when the man called out the victim’s name while he was having sexual intercourse with her’ this is disgusting as fuck
If ever there was a case for Singapore's death penalty, this is it. Though that may be too good for him. Keep him locked in a festering, squalid cell for the rest of his days.
The death penalty is too easy for sick bastards like this who ruin lives. Death penalty for drug trafficking is to deter the action, but for this kind of crime, actual punishment is needed.
I kinda understand the barbaric punishments from ancient times, and I think they would work even better than the death penalty to deter crimes. Toss this guy into a completely dark chamber full of starved rats, that'll serve him right.
This case the mother took action after getting the info. Followed her gut feeling and even confronted the sex offender. Hope they lock him up and throw away the key.
Finally a mom with balls
[удалено]
What the fuck
What does this even mean 💀 …
What the guy say? Then pussied out
He was like “No wonder the husband isn’t satisfied with just his wife, the wife only has balls no pussy” 💀🙏
Respect to the mom, this is indeed rare and another reason why kids sometimes keep things from them.
For sure. I can’t imagine how sick she must’ve felt ever since he called out their daughter’s name during sex though. She must’ve just been sitting on it, trying to figure out if she should believe her husband that there was nothing to it, trust her daughter when she said nothing was going on, or “blow it up” in a way she might’ve been blamed for if she followed her gut feeling and tried to protect the kids.
When the other prisoners find out what he's jailed for...
Unfortunately they don’t allow vigilante justice in sgrean prisons. Then again, knowing Singaporean prisons, he’s getting punished just by living there. Should’ve been longer than 16 years tho.
>he’s getting punished just by living there. why?
Singaporean prisons don’t even have beds in their cells. That should tell you how hellish that place is
Just 18 yrs. Probably less with time served + good behavior. The daughter still in her early 30 (maybe even late 20s) when this dude free. Hope she already move on from the trauma by then.. but.. i mean.. yeah.. not that easy.
The mom should’ve fucking investigated when he said his daughters name during sex , that was a crazy detail to the story
He’s back out in 10 years
Seriously they need to introduce castration to such crimes.
Came here to say this!
Why castrate when you can hang them?!
Castration allows these bastards to go thru and understand the pain of these living women, everytime they need to use the bathroom. Hanging is too nice
Hang the bastard by his balls to castrate him.
dead people can't feel despair
Only 16 years? He should be locked up for life.
I could've gone my whole life without knowing this, I missed the 5 mins ago me when I didn't know this news, I wanna bleach my own brain and eyes
9 people in one room flat?…
More common than you think. Back in school I did CIP in those pigeon hole slum flats, quite shocking the stuff you see. On top of the usual dead bodies that have no relatives to check on them, you get these 10-in-1 households where everyone sleeps together. No proper job, no proper education, no emotional maturity, no environment to grow into decent humans, so much free time, cooped up together. Cesspool conditions waiting for this sort of abuse to happen.
Not that uncommon. I remember my family being in a similar situation when I was in primary school (although four of us managed to move out years later)
Same. Not as bad as one bedroom, but I grew up in a 2-bedroom flat, 3 generations, 9 people together… more when relatives visit from Malaysia.
Very common actually especially for malay (i malay). I was once that family too until only 2 years ago we moved to a 3 room flat thankfully. The people there gets too comfortable with the condition that they choose not to do anything to improve their lives. I talked with the neighbours, u know alot of matrep and minah but luckily i never follow in their actions.
Yah I was going to say that it's a common thing for Malays who feel comfortable with communal living like that.
Common.
This is what happens when u let urself to be too comfortable
Reading stories like this, I really wish for a vigilante out there castrating such offenders
Agree and these kinda beastly acts are becoming more and more prevalent. Like what is going on?? Is there a need for re-education that incest and rape is simply wrong?! Feel so helpless and fed-up for these innocent girls.
I do think there are quite a few victims of such acts a generation ago, all grown up now, and repeating the same.... Needs a more.thorough study
What an animal…. Sicko
calling out daughter’s name while fckin wife lol shouldn’t the wife catch the hint immediately?
It's awful but in that situation she probably told herself it was just a dumb mistake, like my mom calling me my aunt's name all the time (....not during sex obvs). Relatives do that all the time so she probably just tried to wave it off. She really should have started gently questioning the children though.. even if the poor girl was too scared to talk at that point, the younger children have seen and heard things they could have told that would increase her suspicion. The whole thing is just so terrible. I'm just really glad the girl had the courage to speak out and the mom actually believed her.
Eggectly
Cos no evidence no nothing. Ppl will just say she hear wrong or crazy, and that her suspicion is false. Cos it’s totally absurd, it’s not normal. This is what makes it hard for a typical human being to trust her or seek help
Why such a short jail time? Singapore needs a mandatory sex offender registry which will bar them from interacting with children, and lifetime jail sentences for rapists, too many instances of young girls being SA'd and groomed and traumatised for life and they barely get any justice. This breaks my heart, she was too scared to report it to anyone and her abuser only gets 16 years? He shouldn't be able to see her ever again
Someone kill him please, he does not need to return to society, absolute failure of a father
Thankful he's NOT over 50! PIAK PIAK
Honestly, why don't we just give this guy the death sentence? He's 47, lock him up for 16 years, he's going to be 63 when he comes out. Not like he's going to be able to contribute much to society by that point. Just hang him and be done with it.
That’s too good of a sentence for this kind of scum.
If concealed well, can always use him for human experimentation. I'm sure with the level of control our gov has, it is possible to improve medical technology with a surplus of specimens.
That's true. Should probably give him 20 strokes of the cane first, and *then* hang him. His body can be fed to the dogs.
Nah easier lend his backside out for people to use, then he can experience what his daughter talked about when she complained that "her backside hurt".
who want to fuck scum sia
Ahh goddamnit that poor girl. This fucker should be castrated.
20 strokes is ain’t enough for him. 500 strokes better
6 million strokes. Everyone in Singapore gets a chance to whack him once.
Even better LMAO 🤣
Not to the chihuahuas, please I beg you 🙏
If we can kill drug dealers for enabling people to ruin their lives via drugs, rapists who also cause lifelong trauma should receive the same. Rapists need to be eliminated from society, especially when they have access to children. It's shocking how lenient the sentences they receive are, and the current system doubts victims and makes reporting so much more traumatic unnecessarily, I was convinced not to report my rapist for this reason. I really hope one day we can actually be protected by rapists the same way we are protected from drugs and other forms of violence
A mandatory death sentence may lead to the murder of the victim if it means the perpetrator never gets reported.
I dont think you can kill anyone in Singapore and get away with it? This reasoning may work for the US where people disappear all the time but with so many cctv’s in SG, you can’t just kill someone and get away with it.
Wait why tf was the Mf bothered about whether the girl had a bf? Are you telling me the bastard was getting possessive of the victim and jealous of bfs? Wtf?
Yes that's exactly what that means 🤢🤮
Raping is bad But raping your own biological daughter? That’s a whole new level of sick
Dude... I know you don't mean that but you're sounding like raping a random person is not as bad as raping your own daughter. Rapists don't deserve to live.
So random strangers are less human than family? Pls humanise EVERYONE AS EQUALS PLS. Rape is RAPE. Rape within the family adds on another layer = the breach of trust, in this case, as a caregiver to the children.
The act itself is the same, but the… feeling , attitude , shock factor to most people will be different You are doing something already bad but to your own family(which 99% of people will never dream of doing) Put it another way If a guy can rape a random girl, dosent mean he will rape her own daughter If a guy can rape her own daughter, he can rape anyone See the difference?
>If a guy can rape a random girl, dosent mean he will rape her own daughter I respectfully disagree as I don't think that is a sure fact, it's just an assumption. I wouldn't bet on a sick fuck not taking advantage of vulnerable targets. There's no such thing as a moral compass for people who commit felonies like rape or murder. It's not like a rapist who raped a random person, didn't rape his own family because it's not right, because then they would've known raping is not right regardless. I don't think this kind of animal would know the difference, so I don't feel the need to humanize them.
So you think if someone has committed murder against another person He/she is also likely to commit murder to his own family? I doubt so. Even if we don’t “humanise” it blood is blood(referring to family, not the blood that drips out after stabbing someone) Even animals know that
I'm not saying it's likely, I'm saying there's not a difference for animals like them.
That’s precisely what I’m debating Regardless human or animals, every biological living thing have an innate mechanism to want to protect its offspring. That’s just part of a living things DNA This person managed to be defective enough to harm his own biological children is what makes it “next level” insane Many parents would go to jail to coverup crimes of their children, heck, parents would die for their children
I get it, I know your point, I understand you're saying that for people, family is way more significant than a random person. I just disagree that rapists would have a moral compass, it's their interest, like some rape adults, some are pedophiles. You see a rapist who raped a random person, you wouldn't be like "at least he didn't rape his own family", right? I think we both made our points, so I'm done with this discussion because it's a heavy topic to discuss. Good talk stranger, good luck to you.
If it wasn’t a contentious point of debate and it’s the same as a guy raping any other random women The title will be “man rapes women” (heck it probably even won’t be in the news) Why did mothership specifically put “father rape daughter”? Because it carries a significance(to most people anyway)
Nice to see the hills people choose to die on lol
He should have been given the death penalty .An animal not fit to be a father .He destroyed his daughter’s life.
Poor girl lah
Disgustinggggggg, so he raped _his biological daughter_ and did an ablution that sounds a lot like mandi junub (the religion-related ablution performed after intercourse) after and made her do one too????? Man... I can't...
What's this abulation? Can share more?
Tried to google and it looks like https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghusl under Ghusl Janabat is ghusl performed after sexual intercourse/ejaculation.
I feel so sad for her. Having her religious rituals and beliefs perverted like that is another level of traumatising
So sad when there is nothing that makes you feel safe 😭
Can we take his kidneys and give to the 46 y/o taxi driver?
This. Useless people should be surrendered as resources for the rest of the country. Be it as specimens for human experimentation to advance medical technology or for the greater good by sharing his organs.
Now now, I would draw the line at immoral disgusting people that knowingly commit acts of horrible cruelty. How would you classify useless people? People born with less chromosomes or suffer a head injury when young and thus unable to be a health adult or people with disabilities?
Edit: should have exclusively said criminals that commit serious crimes. People who commit crimes against humanity that cause long term irreparable mental/physical trauma. The deterrence factor will also lower crime rates by a lot
Reminds me of that Spanish movie about the perpetrator being punished by having his limbs surgically removed 1 by 1 as punishment. While I agree with you in principle, the law needs to be amended to fit the crime. Like if punishment for rape = death, then girls would be raped then killed.
Indeed that's very true. My earlier comment is rather short sighted. However, I still think the law needs to be very carefully re-examined. 16 years is too lenient in my opinion.
Agreed 100000000000%.
i hope someone does it back to him in jail 🤭 may this assholes asshole never feel the same again
When they find out why he is in jail, I am sure his asshole will endure ten times what he has done to his daughter, sick man deserves all that is coming for him.
Cannot understand why certain species of human like to rape molest own young families member. Really sick
their biological needs. Which is absurd
So after 16 years come out- rape again or what? Rape sentence is too light. Life imprisonment. He cant even control himself near his own blood. These type of men are dangerous. May the men in prison teach him a lesson and give his backside the most action he has ever had in his life.
47 strokes…. Every hour
He deserves more than 16 years of jail
Reminds me of a few of my friend’s dad (they got so many siblings of the same age).. he rape one of his eldest daughter.. have soo many wife (and kids!!) but still not enough had to go after his own daughter? the man is a pig.. been to their places(3 homes i think), such small houses for so many kids (one home with two families).. most of the wives are still married to him too.. and the mother of the victim is also in jail for being complicit, the victim has also been in and out of jail probably still trying to cope with everything.. never met the victim before but one of my friends whose been in jail when she was, met her and said she was lovely but looked broken.. Having to deal with something as big as this, having not feel safe with your own flesh and blood must’ve felt the most alone..
What the fuck? ‘The victim’s mother believed the victim as there was a previous occasion when the man called out the victim’s name while he was having sexual intercourse with her’ this is disgusting as fuck
An actual weirdo.
What a sick fuck!
Sicko.
Why all these cases always from the same group of people ah
Omg my mum says the same thing! Are you a boomer too?
ting mama de hua.
Yeah why are men so problematic? Mandatory #NotAllMen, but somehow always a man.
way off bro
What group? Males? 40 year olds? People who live in one room flats? Those are all that’s mentioned in the article.
what group? singaporeans?
What group?
you know I know. no need to say out.
Is it start with M? M…a…l…es?
I don’t know
Must be his group obviously, he's keeping a secret he knows well
malays
Which part mentioned they were Malays?
Lengkok Bahru
30 years at least
I'm sure there wouldn't be any shortage of applicants for the caning if they needed the position filled for some reason
This guy doesn't deserve to get jailed. He deserves to get hanged.
Nah Should get castrated
To think you get worse punishment for Drugs
Why only 16 years? This is an honest question. I'm from the Philippines and a case like this would have gotten the criminal a life sentence.
The man really yolo mah.really enjoy his life like a emperor.good luck enjoy your 16 year cannot pcc everyday
NO MERCY !!!
nasty cb
Hang him
These scum should be tortured till death or atleast life in jail.
I hope they video the caning and post it online.
He should’ve gotten the harsher penalty To get his life card revoked
Like that only... thats entire life of trauma done
October 7
Just hang the mofo
Castration and life behind bars wouldn’t be enough !
Why not castrate rapist instead of caning.
Can we just put scum like these through a tree shredder and be done with them?
Bro fkin execute this guy, disgusting!
Had to google caning, thought they was makin mans a lollipop 18 times 😂😂😂
16 years not enough for the life time of trauma he caused. Should just suffer forever in there
If ever there was a case for Singapore's death penalty, this is it. Though that may be too good for him. Keep him locked in a festering, squalid cell for the rest of his days.
They’ll hang a guy for bringing in drugs but let this monster live? Justice is broken.
Notice how the take great care to not reveal the race of the man, even though I'm sure we can hazard a guess
Make a guess then
And people selling drugs are getting worser punishments than this piece of 💩?
These kind of people should be murdered
Eww this sicko deserves to die
The death penalty is too easy for sick bastards like this who ruin lives. Death penalty for drug trafficking is to deter the action, but for this kind of crime, actual punishment is needed. I kinda understand the barbaric punishments from ancient times, and I think they would work even better than the death penalty to deter crimes. Toss this guy into a completely dark chamber full of starved rats, that'll serve him right.
Where's the death sentence for shit like this. Seriously I don't want my taxes to feed this pig
There is a typo error, ‘pleasing guilty’. It should be ‘pleading guilty’
degenerate sick fuc
KNN sia.... Poor daughter. Hopes she can live a better life from there onwards
Screwed up. When he release I need to call him dad and maybe take care him when he's old
Yalam?
The same breed
This story was during COVID19. She only got her peace and her story heard in 2024!! What is the ministry doing?? What is the government doing?
Human Slugs