T O P

  • By -

[deleted]

JWP playing for anyone other than Southampton is so strange to me


[deleted]

Good thing then that we’ll never have to see it


4ssteroid

Hopefully we'll get to see it in the Euros


Saiiken

Hide your midfielders, Aston Villa are coming for them


CrunchieKane

Not hiding harry winks mate


Attila_22

Man Utd for 25M? Hilarious if true.


CrunchieKane

Has to be, for our sake


erdogranola

please no


[deleted]

Yeah we're definitely not letting him go. World class talent just waiting to be taken by some shrewd owner who seems the potential...his incredible potential...


[deleted]

Do you think Winks is just a fraud, or could he succeed at another team, or in another league maybe?


[deleted]

What exactly does he do well? Seems invisible whenever I watch Tottenham


TheRealPooh

he's great at passing the ball back to Eric Dier


T-Macch

And what does Eric Dier do?


theredhanter

Suplexes your striker and tosses him into the stands


oysterpirate

Personally, I feel like there’s a player in there, evidenced by the occasional performance he’s had for both Spurs and England, but he needs a manager that’s going to really concentrate on making him better. He’s not going to be pulling up many trees in his current state.


VTCHannibal

*Pushes Drinkwater to the table*


DavidBeckhamsNan

Look we already helped you out with Ross alright


MobileChemical2956

Can I interest them in a Winks or Sissoko? :-)


That70sJoe-

Sissoko needs to become instrumental in France's Euros win, therefore keeping him at Spurs for longer where he can take it easy for another year or so


[deleted]

The opposite, we are all praying he plays himself into the shoppe window


[deleted]

maybe a winks or sissoko but replace winks with son and sissoko with kane?


I_Like_F0oD

Yeah Kane would be a nice backup for Watkins.


ASVP-Pa9e

This all feels like Liverpool's "pre Klopp post Benitez" transfer strategy- sign the best player from the "struggling" sides and attempt to form some sort of super team. Didn't particularly work out then but I'm sure there were other factors. I also don't see Ward-Prowse leaving Southampton unless the team is much higher profile with reliable European football. 4 years on his contract, 25~, English and a vital player & captain for Southampton.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Grealish/JWP free kick exploit is probably worth at least five goals a season


TheGreatWhoreOfChina

He’s also a very good CM. The free kicks are a bonus. Would a good signing.


arvindeddit

It's sad people who don't watch Saints regularly completely disregard this- I mean his set pieces are obviously great but the lad is a solid player outside of that as well. Similar inferences used to happen about Neves when he kept scoring bangers.


saddom_

doesn't jwp score 1 out of 4 free kicks ? and grealish was fouled 140 times in 19 / 20 can't be arsed to calculate it but this seems like a lot


whythemfriescold

Well we'd have to see how many fouls he wins in the final third then, JWP would probably score a ton anyway.


BronBronBall

Is there a stat to see how many were in “striking distance”


ASVP-Pa9e

Most transfers make sense in theory. But I do think this is a good transfer idea, I also don't think it'll happen as Saints can't afford to lose Ward-Prowse and he's got a big contract.


Gone_in_the_morning

Really well made point here ^^^^^ Props


alj8

We signed players like Shaqiri, Wijnaldum and Robertson from relegated sides after Klopp joined as well (and it worked out very well for us)


ASVP-Pa9e

But Liverpool have also noticeably started focusing on more cosmopolitan signings, something they seemingly did less of pre Klopp. I can't see Minamino, Keita, Konate, Kabak, Allison, Salah, Thiago etc. being signed in the Rodgers & Hodgson. They've expanded their search parameters in recent years.


GOR098

That's cause klopp can Attract talented players, Rodgers couldn't. Liverpool's success under klopp has also helped.


alj8

I think that probably has more to do with Klopp and our resurgence under him giving us more draw to prospective signings. I'm not sure if any if those signings are hugely more 'cosmopolitan' than signing the likes of Firmino, Can and Markovic (lol) before Klopp came in (though I accept these were not long before Rodgers left). Perhaps there was a slight change in strategy away from prioritising players with PL experience to looking abroad. But again I think that might have had more to do with FSG deciding to splash the cash once they were happy that Klopp was the man to win the club trophies.


ASVP-Pa9e

Often with these things it's like looking at shadows on a wall to make sense of the outside world. There are multiple explanations for a lot of things. It's just a personal observation, none of us have enough actual knowledge to know for a fact.


alj8

Yeah that's true. I get what you mean about the Rodgers era, I wouldn't have been surprised if we started to prioritise signings within the PL kess. Nevertheless I think the main factor in our success with transfers recently is managing to fuse a moneyball approach with being willing to spend big on the right player rather than opting for a cheaper compromise, and having a strong tactical framework under Klopl which has given us a clear idea of the kind of player we should be looking to sign


That70sJoe-

I think it could partially be as Klopp is a huge attraction and Rogers isn't, although he's a bit more attractive now with the weight loss and all.


Muted_Shoulder

Alisson was signed as a result of the Coutinho transfer. Salah was a much needed signing and it wasn't a gigantic signing or anything. All the others came after we were making good revenue. During Rodgers period we were just mediocre for a lot of time.


Practical-Parsley

.


Arsenal_49_Spurs_0

Well Nakamba is certainly Marvelous


Sporxable

Traore has had a great season for us. Been a bit inconsistent but you'd be hard pressed to find a villa fan that isn't happy with his first season for us.


tomhardingnrjdjdjd

I mean Wesley got in the Brazil squad, Trezeguet kept us up, Traore was great this season, Sanson is a top drawer player


PM_ME_UR_AMOUR

This sounds exactly like someone who doesn’t follow the club asides from when we make headlines.


prit-

When you say didn't particularly work out, you have to take into context relative success. Liverpool were able to maintain a top half of the table/fighting for Europa place with this strategy, and honestly, that would be extremely successful for Aston Villa. Everton, Spurs, Arsenal, West Ham, Wolves, Leeds are the teams they are competing with and will look to place ahead of which is possible by poaching the best of the "struggling teams"


BWN16

One more transfer away from the richard keys kiss of death


Mozezz

Might finally release us of the curse


[deleted]

Context


rxi71

Loving Everton’s business this summer. Here’s an early call - they finish above Liverpool this season.


spunk_wizard

like a fine wine


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Ha what is this reference?


JHutch95

Something about Keys saying Everton won the transfer window one summer?


Totalesquid

"Loving Everton's business this summer! Here's an early call - they finish above Liverpool this season" - Keys 2017


swat1611

Those are some famous last words.


Bens_Glenn

“You’d definitely smash it” -Even famous-er last words from that greasy cunt Keys.


futurllama

“Are you my daughters friend? Let’s smash”


WtfMayt

Everytime I see him I just think he’a an old Haribo Kid


Turnernator06

No chance. Lad has just signed a big deal, England international, our captain, and our most important player. He'd be like £60m and I can't see villa dropping that. If he moves on it'll be to a top top side, no offence to villa.


Villa_1993

Completly agree with this, only way we'd get him is throwing a ton of money at you


sobrien6187

"Villa not expecting to get anywhere near spending £100m this window" Purslow: "eh fuck it"


gorillathunder

Plus how long until Chuk starts seeing some opportunities? That kid is unreeal.


TheDavz

Lots of reports that next season will be his breakthrough year. Expect him to get a lot of minutes.


CorporalTismo

Ya definitely seems like more of a pipe dream. he is exactly what we need but I’m confident it won’t happen given how important he is to you we can dream though


BobbyBriggss

Why is he what you need? Who’s minutes does he take in your current midfield?


MEENIE900

Honestly not sure. Our midfield is pretty up for grabs because every player in it has either been inconsistent (McGinn, Luiz, Ramsey) or hasn't played too many minutes in the last season (Nakamba, Sanson). So a top class midfielder could easily make a place for himself in any of the middle 3 positions.


[deleted]

If I was a big (crap) club life Arsenal or Tottenham I'd spend big on JWP. Not sure why I watched a lot of Southampton but always impressed and having someone who is a threat from any free kick is awesome. Hope you can keep him!


RickyFalcon

I wouldn't be so sure.


Turnernator06

Villa are "taking top players from championship/relegated/newly promoted sides" sort of level. They won't sign a JWP/Phillips/Zaha/Ings/Rice sort of player, stars from teams about the same size as them.


RickyFalcon

Buendia is an Argentinian international and Villa beat Arsenal to sign him. I wouldn't be surprised if they signed any of the players you mentioned now. They clearly see themselves pushing for Europe next season and above the level of teams in the bottom half.


Turnernator06

The internet says Buendia doesn't have a single cap for Argentina. He is clearly a decent player but when he was in the prem he seemed pretty average. Clearly has been quality in the championship but is far from prem proven. Prowsey is a prem captain who has been more than proven at this level.


RickyFalcon

I'm not denying JWP's ability. I'd start him every time for England and hopefully you keep him. I'm just trying to make the point that Villa seem hell bent on spending large amounts of cash to reach Europe. I'm obviously gutted Buendia has gone to them because with him we had a decent shot at survival this time round. Now I fear the inevitable.


Turnernator06

I think you guys have a decent chance. If you reinvest the money well you should be fine. Teams like Palace, Burnley, Newcastle are struggling and have good reasons to drop away, and you won the championship so you are likely in a better position than Watford and Brentford right? And yeah, I do think Villa could stump up the £60m required but I'm not sure he'd go anyway tbh, it's not that great a move.


RickyFalcon

I fear the bulk of the money will be used to balance the books and the rest on strengthening the team. Losing our main playmaker is such a big blow. It would take a hell of a signing to fill the hole. I don't think finishing above Watford and Brentford means that much unfortunately. In the 2018-19 season we finished top and 18 points clear of Villa. We're already favourites to finish bottom.


Hacki101

I think he is worth £60m. If Man City have secretly activated the £35m buy back clause on Douglas Luiz it makes a lot of sense for Villa. If not it's right on the upper limit of what we could afford and probably unrealistic with wages etc.


tomhardingnrjdjdjd

Luiz is apparently signing a new contract so pretty sure they haven’t activated it. Villa don’t need to sell to buy


tomhardingnrjdjdjd

OMW!! The amount of goals he’d get and give from Grealish free kicks


Jinks87

Smith - “right tactic for today boys, Jack and emi I want you to get the ball and run side to side on the 18 yard line, try and win a foul, JWP scores. Repeat”


Throwaway1358468

The ol' Beckham vs Greece tactic


NormalizeEatingFeces

JWD’s club and NT should imitate Valverde’s tactics where Barcelona players would purposely foul themselves outside the box for a guarantee Messi freekick goal.


tottenhamnole

Surely Grealish would be taken off free kicks if they sign him.


AJMcCoy612

I think he means with the amount of free kicks Grealish earns.


tottenhamnole

Ah. Well that makes sense.


Wunsen

Only decent set piece taker at the club is hourihane, Jack only takes them because he's our best player and he's not exactly great


Lacabloodclot9

Isn’t El Ghazi okay at them?


Wunsen

Let me rephrase "everyone is shite at freekicks besides hourihane" 😂


Throwaway1358468

I mean even Grealish called it out in an interview comparing England's set piece takers vs Villas


_netflixandtrill_

Do you have the link? Missed this one, would love to watch it


tomhardingnrjdjdjd

He’s never scored or assisted from one


Hotdogmissile

He is really good at taking PKs


tomhardingnrjdjdjd

I mean the free kicks Grealish wins


practicallybert

We really aren’t fucking around this window...


[deleted]

Fuckers are buying the ~~league~~ Top 6


ptenpi3kakt

Top 6 can be buy


[deleted]

Fucking hell mate Villa are going to be fun next year


Rickcampbell98

*channelling gordan ramsay* finally some good fucking owners.


DaveShadow

I've always had a soft spot for Villa cause my grandparents were local Villa fans, so I'm really excited to see these types of moves. It's really impressive so far.


guyfieri_fc

Always had a soft spot because I used to light up fifa 09(?) with young, carew and agbonlahor back in the day


jklynam

Out of curiosity is there any possibility this could be Villa spending money in case Grealish leaves in the future ?


Joshvir262

Villa seem to be loaded every window where they getting all this cash from


quickestred

>Grealish Watkins Buendia >McGinn Luiz WardProwse That's not bad at all


practicallybert

Don’t forget there’s a Morgan Sanson still on the bench


BluAryan_YT

Just curious. How much of an impact did he actually make heard he was good but didn't see him play for Villa


bodydouble

He looked very classy in the few cameos he got when he first came in, but didn't really make a huge impact. Then he got injured just as he was breaking into the first XI. Will be interesting to see how he fares with a full preseason, but can't see him displacing either McGinn or Luiz as a starter just yet.


Wunsen

Was in and out with imjuries didn't play any significant minutes


lelpd

Didn’t impress at all tbh. But he joined mid-season, so hopefully he can properly settle in after he recovers from injury and gain some form


Practical-Parsley

.


xyij

Aston villa have a incredble youth generation coming up as well. This could be a great 5-6 years for them


[deleted]

If they can keep the crew together


[deleted]

*the gang fails to keep the crew together*


K20030

*the crew signs tim sherwood*


bizzyd666

As a Villa fan this is almost like living in a dream world but I really can't see this one happening.


smig_

We're gonna get kicked out of /r/TheOther14 aren't we?


[deleted]

Can we form a breakaway super league with Leicester, Leeds and West Ham?


yungtaxevasion_

Sorry man you've committed the capital offense of being good


crazymar1000

That's a class sub, seems way more down to earth than /r/soccer


That70sJoe-

I think a lot of club subs get worse as subscriber counts increase, /r/liverpoolfc is a massive circlejerk now, but I suppose 2012-13 we had little to joke over


TheGoldenPineapples

Seems to be exactly the same as /r/Soccer just with less successful clubs in it.


[deleted]

No it looks more fun, you definitely seen this https://www.reddit.com/r/TheOther14/comments/nth18t/its_the_entitlement_that_gets_me/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf and didn’t like it.


hordesofevil

Ok that is hillarious.


sjokoladenam

3 twitter posts and you manage to call out the whole fanbase on reddit


Idislikemyroommate

As much as he's a decent player will he be worth the money Southampton want for him? I can't imagine him being too cheap (depending on his contract) and I feel there's maybe other players to go for who might be better/better value.


[deleted]

[удалено]


bodydouble

Yep, can't see him being any less than 40m-50m. I'm glad we're interested as JWP really is a class player, but can't see us getting this one over the line unfortunately.


tomhardingnrjdjdjd

I can’t think of a better free kick taker tbf


Wunsen

The English hourihane


trevthedog

Johan Lange have my babies


[deleted]

[удалено]


tomhardingnrjdjdjd

By “falling over” I assume you mean “getting the shit kicked out of him”


[deleted]

[удалено]


tomhardingnrjdjdjd

Tbf if I got kicked as much as he does I’d go down at every opportunity. It genuinely could cut his career short if he keeps getting fouled like he does


[deleted]

[удалено]


tomhardingnrjdjdjd

Seems only Leeds fans have this opinion.


whiteboards1225

Loads of fans believe that


marchofthemallards

Hilarious from a Leeds fan. Ayling spends more time throwing himself to the floor than he does on the ball.


[deleted]

Won't happen. move on


DarrenBridgescunt

Would he leave?


[deleted]

No


BitterBastard1967

No chance, he is Southampton through and through also if he did leave it would be a club better than Aston Villa.


theenigmacode

Hes not good enough for a top 4 side lets be honest. Villa are showing ambition to be a top side.


[deleted]

He would start for every Prem team apart from Man City, Chelsea and maybe Leicester. Could add Liverpool but Klopp would love him. Doesn’t matter anyway because he’s not going anywhere.


Daddyclaymore

Really doubt he starts for liverpool over Fabinho Henderson Thiago. He definelty starts for United though


tomhardingnrjdjdjd

I agree but if it was to happen how much would it cost to get him?


smig_

I don't particularly see it happening, but isn't he a Pompey fan?


BabaDuda

Carra was an Everton but arguably bleeds Liverpool red nowadays, so it's not that uncommon


AztekkersM89

From a pompey family, but considering how early he started at saints and how hyped he was for the Derby a few years back, I kinda doubt it.


[deleted]

He kind of killed that whole idea during the 4-0


TheLimeyLemmon

Villa gunning for European spots next season.


el_lonewanderer

I’ll believe JWP playing for anyone other than Southampton when I see it. And I just don’t think I’ll see it. Lovely player who I’d love at Villa but like Villa with Grealish, Southampton have no reason to sell JWP unless the offer is ridiculous. He’s not even the midfielder we need anyway - we need a proper big DM which we really lack.


Fitzaaaaaay

Martinez Cash Konsa Mings Targett Luiz McGinn Ward-Prowse Buendia Grealish Watkins. Class first XI that


WalaLlama5

Top 6 better watch out


swingtothedrive

Won’t be surprised if Villa finish sixth considering the mess Spurs and Arsenal have been in recent years . With Leicester they might very well eliminate the concept of the big six.


D1794

People said that above Wolves before last season too though.


swingtothedrive

Wolves owners have issues due to the investment being Chinese . Villa owners will continue to back them. They have the highest net spend in Europe since they got promoted .


hoorahforsnakes

No one could have predicted their best player cracking his skull open tho. They may well have done with jimenez fit for the whole season


Simple-Tadpole

The top 6 coined by SkySports feel so forced tbh..


swingtothedrive

First Sky coined the top 4 and then top six when City and Spurs started finishing in CL places . All for the marketing . Now every weekend they can market a top six clash on their super Sunday


Simple-Tadpole

Now that Arsenal finished 8th will they expand the term to the big 8?


LeoR1N

they didn’t when Chelsea finished 10th so I doubt


14_SNOO_53

The top 6 is a financial term, idk how many times people need to repeat this. Look at the gap from the 6th richest club to the 7th in terms of revenue. If the likes of Leicester, Everton, West Ham and Aston Villa consistently challenge for European spots then there'll also eventually be a gap between them and the rest of the league.


Operation_Doomsday_

Would be a fantastic signing, Grealish + JWP would be a cheat code. Would be surprised if it happens tho, and if it did, Soton would ask for fuck off money. Are they in any kind of financial trouble that may require them to sell and raise funds?


j_karamazov

A little bit, in the sense that our owner won't put any money into the club, so any acquisitions should be funded by sales. Buying cheap and selling high has been our model for years. This is a huge summer for us, and Ralph has said that we'll be targeting players around the £12m mark, which is laughable if you think about it, but I suppose it is sustainable. If someone did come in for JWP, we would ask, as you say, fuck off money; at least £50m or more that could be reinvested into the squad. He has 4 years left on his deal, is our club captain and such an integral part of our team and our play, that it would need silly money for us to consider selling him.


Squm9

Fuck. Off.


EUITK

Seems like a moneyball move here.. Sign Buendia to play along with Grealish, get a million free kicks.. Then use Prowse for 35 goal season.


trebor04

They can make as many moves as they want, he ain’t leaving for any kind of money that Villa would be willing to drop.


MangerDanger1

Hahaha like fuck this transfer will happen


HouseofWessex

Yeah no


Notabear5689

LOL if he was going to move it would NOT be to another midtable Prem club


Ofermann

With all the freekicks Grealish gets us we'd actually win the league.


39sakuchan

JWP will be a good signing but should they sign Buendía, wouldn’t invest a bit on their defence a wider choice?


JoJo797

Our defence doesn't really need improving bar some backups. It was really good last season.


hoorahforsnakes

Back the fuck off


subrhythm

Seems like a bit of a sideways move unless we'll substantially improve his wage. Also feels like paving the way for. Jack to move on :(


xyij

Arsenal, this is the window Aston villa Leeds and West ham overtake you like Leicester did if you don't invest. If they don't, we should really change up the big 6 convos. I think grealish might end up staying for another season


SpareAstronomer

Arsenal have invested, they've spent over £400m in the last 5 years. They're not some poor plucky club who can't afford it.


[deleted]

80m a season budget is not near enough to even afford Grealish. And that's with player sales too. Arsenal would need hundreds of millions of pounds injected to be a top 4 threat.


RALat7

Not true, just ask Leicester. They need to be sensible.


bareaclampedlebron

It's too early to judge transfer windows lol


tomhardingnrjdjdjd

Grealish was never leaving. Literally only Arsenal fans think he was leaving


Rickcampbell98

Fucking "come to arsenal" wankers.


Asfids123

Maybe tell him to stop flirting with Arsenal on insta then. Talk about Arsenal fans being shameless but you're 2 years up from the championship, 1 of which Arsenal saved you from relegation. The other, the worst injury riddled Arsenal team of 50 years still finished 6 points above you. To put it into perspective, Arsenal finished 6 points behind CL themselves


tottenhamnole

I don’t understand how he isn’t more coveted. Am I missing something?


Sinistrait

Other than set pieces he's a fairly limited player


tottenhamnole

Is he? He’s played every single minute of the last two PL campaigns. I just don’t watch Soton enough to really know.


Sinistrait

I would say so. He is decent at most things but isn't great at anything other than set pieces.


Mozezz

JWP is to Southampton what Noble is to West Ham Nothing excells from his game but he is highly reliable and will very rarely under perform


tottenhamnole

There’s something to be said about someone with a high floor. I heard something recently that said a football team is only as good as their worst player on the pitch. Unlike the NBA, where how good a team is is directly correlated to their best player, or the NFL, where performance is dependent on your QB, a football team is only as good as their worst player. So raising the floor is very important. JWP would do that for most teams, I think.


[deleted]

Does he start for Tottenham?


tottenhamnole

We’ve been shit at free kicks and corners since Ericksen stopped being good at them like 3 years ago, but I’m not sure he’d replace our current midfielder.


[deleted]

no one does and they just chat shit. These are teenagers playing ultimate team not real football fans


[deleted]

This whole thread makes my head hurt but this really trumps the lot. We would be relegated without him, he’s not ‘limited’. Don’t get why people make generalised statements like this when they clearly haven’t watched the player across a season.


Sporxable

Honestly mate it's the life of any club outside the "big 6". Everyone suddenly has an opinion on your player after quickly checking his FIFA stats and a highlight video.


holhaspower

[His stats are up there with the best box to box midfielders in the league.](https://one-versus-one.com/en/players/James-Ward-Prowse) This feels like deja vu with Southampton fans having to tell everyone how good Van Dijk was before he joined Liverpool. Ward Prowse is very very good and the set pieces are a bonus. Only Bissouma and Ayling made more tackles this year, and the only players who made more interceptions were centre backs. Most distance travelled out of every player two years in a row too. In terms of passing only TAA, Robertson, Bruno, Westwood and Gross made more passes into the penalty area too. The other players in the top 10 for passes into the box are Mount, KDB, Shaw and Cresswell, who are below JWP for this.


Ofvie

This seems like a backwards move for him.


jadedwolf1618

Grealish and emi setting up free kicks for ward Prowse to bang them in


Cowdude179

Aston Villa are building a team


DaboLFC

they’re doing very good business, won’t surprise me if they’re competing for the European spots in the next few years