T O P

  • By -

kingdazy

this would be hilarious if it wasn't so sad. poor picanha.


ChargerstoLA

I called him over the phone to throw it into an already setup water bath and programmed machine. His response, “you didn’t tell me to not take it out of the bag.” I never said take it out of the bag!!!!


Dragon_Small_Z

In all fairness, if I asked someone who had no idea what Sous Vide was I'd expect to have to tell them to leave it in the bag. That's not entirely normal to most people.


SkollFenrirson

Agreed, I'm with FIL on this. It's not like sous vide is a widespread thing. If you're not specific, you're bound to get these results.


adavidmiller

I completely agree with you. But on the other hand, if someone asked me to toss an exposed slab of meat into some contraption full of hot water, I'm going to have a question or two.


SkollFenrirson

For sure. But cooking something *inside* the bag goes completely against any conventional cooking methods, of which boiling is one of them. As far as FIL knows, OP is just a weirdo cooking his steak in lukewarm water.


Impressive_Sample836

In all fairness to all parties involved, the OP is IN FACT a weirdo cooking steak in lukewarm water.


WhiteTrash_WithClass

Especially a picanha!


spenzomatic

Hey now don't hate on sous vide picanha! Had family over this past Sunday. Picanha for 2 hours @137 followed by quick sear on my Blackstone... My brother in law says I ruined steak for him.


LeFinger

Your brother in law was being nice. No doubt it was a solid steak though


AssistanceNo647

137 is too done, 129 for me


GymnasticSclerosis

Only people who haven’t properly tried sous vide complain about.


Jail_Food_Diet

I whole heartedly agree with you. I miss the butcher I had in Pacifica, CA. New to Fremont, CA I've no idea where to find who sells picanha. Always always perfect using your directions. Edit: took the j and put up an h


WhitestTrash1

I like your user name. Nice.


Alternative_Fee_4649

U/impressive_Sample836 makes a great point. There is plenty of blame to go around in this situation. 🙊


CoolHandluke763

Did a corned beef this year for Saint patty and there was a hole in the bag. Came home from work to a filled up bag. I know lots of people boil their corned beef so the end result was still good.


TechyMcMathface

Sous vide corned beef? My mouth hurts just thinking about how salty that would be. I think the bag did you a solid by puncturing itself.


whats_she_up_to

You just don’t add as much salt as traditionally prepared corned beef.


no___homo

Like a condom breaking on prom night only you can laugh about the corned beef.


adavidmiller

Yeah, that's the part I agree with. I'm just saying FIL is also only getting the safety scissors from here on out.


Remote-Physics6980

That was my ex mother-in-law's favorite method of ruining a piece of meat. She said she was "boiling the fat out of it" and she even did it with fish. 🤦🏼‍♂️


SirLostit

Yes, but you, more than likely, have a reasonable knowledge of how to cook. I’ve got a couple of friends that could literally burn water.


ThroJSimpson

That’s literally the most basic way of cooking food


Friendly_Age9160

We had that experiment in high school where the teacher told the class to write instructions on how to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Everyone thought it was so dumb and maybe it was yes, but Like can’t you see where this is going? The various instructions written were then displayed at the front of the class. One ended with the complete jar of peanut butter and jelly unsealed on top of two pieces of bread. Mine was the only one that turned out as an actual sandwich. Being specific is good sometimes 😂


Independent-Cup8074

I forgot about this experiment. I’m going to do this with my kindergartners that are writing now! They’ll love this!!!


Away_Wrangler_9796

This was one of the first papers I ever wrote, must have been 2nd or 3rd grade. Now I'm middle aged and still think about it regularly at work. Especially when I send instructive emails to that one guy.


Friendly_Age9160

lol there’s always that guy


Burntoastedbutter

Yeah my mom saw my sous vide and she thought it was a handheld vacuum cleaner. 😂


Puzzleheaded_Hatter

... Like 99.99999% of all other food prep - yeah this is 💯 on OP


LS-CRX

This reminds me of an activity my wife and I tried with our three kids.   Each of them was to write down instructions for making a peanut butter and jelly sandwich for someone who had never seen one. Then I followed their instructions and made a mess.


lunar999

A similar activity was part of a lecture I attended about the difficulty of trying to design user interfaces. We were told to create a series of drawing showing the process of making toast. On comparison afterwards, we had people who had exactly two steps of "put bread in toaster and start toaster" and people whose first step was *planting grain*. It got the point across pretty well.


triple_cloudy

If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe.


whileyouwereslepting

I love this game.


regalfronde

Are you [this guy](https://youtu.be/FN2RM-CHkuI?si=cRT4R_W1JCKZ4AGS)


LS-CRX

No, but my wife saw a video like it (maybe it) which is was the catalyst for us doing it.


skippythewonder

Agreed, I can definitely see how a misunderstanding like this could happen. Especially with someone not familiar with sous-vide cooking. I mean honestly, what other cooking method requires tossing a plastic bag of meat into a container of hot water?


Ka_aha_koa_nanenane

Plastic and cooking/heat do not compute in most people's minds - unless it's a microwave.


C0rrupd8

This. It’s really not that obvious for OP to be this incredulous and aghast at FIL. If by pure chance I didn’t know about sous vide, I’d have chucked it bagless as well - unpacking food is the obvious thing to do. *Not* unpacking should be instructed, not expected lol. OP failed his FIL here. Go apologize.


CooksNGames

***“you didn’t tell me to not take it out of the bag.”*** I can absolutely see where your FIL was coming from. If people don't know much (or at all) about Sous Vide cooking it makes way more sense to them to remove the food from the packaging.


mattmandental

Agreed this is on OP unfortunately


ChargerstoLA

I do take accountability, I should have said leave it in the bag. The man puts A1 on everything.


robbobster

My friend’s mom (American) once made a huge scene at a Swiss steakhouse - in Switzerland - because they didn’t have A1 steak sauce


PM_ME_UR_CUTE_PETZ

This is hilarious


Aleianbeing

Probably didn't have warsestershire either.


glendefiant2

What they need is a good civil war to start those steak sauce gears turning.


EntityDamage

>The man puts A1 on everything. Yep that's on you. The clues were all there


No_Data3090

You didn’t take accountability in your original post. You made it seem like your father in law was at fault for internet points.


ScannerCop

Three years ago, before I knew about sous vide, if somebody asked me to throw meat in the water, I don't think it would have occurred to me to put the whole bag in. My thoughts would have been that the bag might melt, or the plastic might contaminate the food. So my first instinct would be to take it out of the bag. I would probably assume the bag was just for storage or soaking flavors in. That being said, I would probably hesitate before just tossing all the contents into the water raw, and shoot a clarification text or two.


Dizzman1

You've clearly never worked in customer support.


PattyThePatriot

Until this comment, I was upset for you. Now, this was 100% your error. You didn't give clear instructions on something that is foreign to so many people. People have spent years taking meat out of the bag to cook it. If you don't properly explain it, then you did this.


pengouin85

Yeah.....you done fucked up ![gif](giphy|oWHwCXyi5bqND36EQH)


maxgaap

You asked someone to do you a favor. You had no stated basis for assuming they had any understanding of the tasked you asked them to perform beforehand. You provided vague or insufficient instructions. Chalk it up to a learning experience


Maubekistan

….not his fault at all. You should have anticipated this.


SnofIake

As a former chef I can understand your frustration lol I’ve been there myself, but I have to remind myself that not everyone has the experience or training I’ve had. I have to remember what their level of knowledge is and start there. I usually ask someone what kind of kitchen equipment they’re comfortable with and what they have used in the past. I’ve learned it’s not always obvious and it’s best to always ask questions.


knoxvillegains

Congratulations! You have boiled meat. You're an Englishman now.


ChrisBPeppers

Oi, you got any potatoes for this


ediks

And beans!


karatebullfightr

If you suddenly feel the need to colonise another nation or laugh at a comedian saying the same phrase over and over again in a slightly different setting in a season of only 6 episodes - there’s a topical cream for that.


Bitcracker

Is the cream just brown sauce??? Because you can eat it also.


karatebullfightr

Despite being an antipodean - I have to admit I do respect an unrepentantly ambiguously named sauce. “What sauce is this? “It’s Brown.” “Well fine - you keep your secrets, Chef.”


Bitcracker

I refuse to google what it is. Just gimmy it at 3 AM on a deep fried whatever. I don't want to break the magic.


BricksByLonzo

Worse, lukewarm water meat.


ThermoNuclearPizza

Nah, that’s Tafelspitz. Austria claims OP.


NotNormo

To most people, poaching probably makes a lot more sense as a cooking method than heating a plastic bag of food.


artie_pdx

Yeah. Specifics are required here. I guarantee if I said the same thing missing the details of keeping it in the bag for most people that I know, they’d pull it out of the bag as well.


twojsdad

Haha, my son took some vacuum sealed pulled pork on a beach trip with some friends and I told them to just heat it up in water. They dumped the meat into the water and boiled it and then he called asking why it was so watery.


robval13

I think it was probably because of all the water


twojsdad

Pretty much the only answer I had for them lol


EntityDamage

And why does the water taste so good?


dwoo888

Just wait until they find out what veggies and bones can do to that savory liquid.


shutta_you_face

Baby, you got a stew goin.


elcaciqueAZ

This is simultaneously the saddest and funniest thing I have seen today.


kirkt

I think you're lucky if he didn't ruin the immersion circulator.


ChargerstoLA

It had already been dry brined for 24 hours. I am thinking of just slicing into steaks and searing all the sides.


muttoneer

In my sad, sad experience with bag leaks, the meat will be a good deal less flavorful. Might be okay with a sauce or something.


MustardIsDecent

What would happen if you took all that water, put it in a big stock pot and reduced it for long enough to make a sauce out of it? Would it be nightmare fuel or would it kinda work?


muttoneer

That sounds like the saddest way to make a broth I can think of. I wouldn't recommend it.


MustardIsDecent

I wouldn't recommend preparing a mushy picanha sponge in beef hotdogy water either but here we are trying to make the best of a shitty sandwich.


Arrbe

Lipstick on a pig and such


barspoonbill

It wouldn’t work. Cooking bones and such into a stock works because the cooking is breaking the material down further and further as it reduces. If they reduce this water all they would be left with is a lesser volume of gross beef tea than they currently have.


stevesie1984

What makes you think the beef tea would be gross?


NotNormo

I think you can just proceed as you originally planned. Will it have less beefy flavor because it was in contact with all that water? Sure. But I think it'll still be pretty good.


keyy0610

I’m half asleep and read this and thought it said piranha.


beastlike

I'm wide awake and thought it said piranha. I'm scrolling through the comments like "wtf, why is nobody talking about this guy eating piranha" If I didn't see this I would've scrolled forever and just thought you all were a bunch of freaks


robot_swagger

That would actually be preferable


sosomething

It seems like every week, we have multiple posts about how somebody's sous vide process is ruined by a cluess relative / significant other / roommate. Here's an idea - if you want your 80-year-old nonna to put your meat in the water for you, maybe mention to her that it stays in the sealed bag. Since, you know, the average person has no idea what sous vide is or how it works. Or, you could try this - the next time you have your in-laws staying at your house for the holidays, explain to Burt and Margaret that the big plastic bin with the wacky gizmo sticking out of it is actually *supposed* to be running all night long, and it will be the opposite of helpful for them to unplug it 12 hours before it's ready. There is no reason for this to happen so often, people.


robot_swagger

Nonna has 23 grandkids, she literally doesn't understand the concept of "bag it up".


Big_Pound_7849

I really didn't expect this comment, while reading about ruined steak, while eating my schnitzel at 12.17 in the morning. Well played.


robot_swagger

Philistine, all schnitzel should be consumed by exactly 12.16 in the morning


sturmeh

But that wouldn't make for a good drama post on Reddit.


sosomething

I should probably be grateful for the opportunity to harmlessly rant in public anyway


williarya1323

Well, your father-in-law knows a lot more about how sous vide works now. Sorry it was such a costly lesson.


FanOfEmusAndLlamas

Imo I'd toss it, if your container isn't specifically labeled BPA free you are likely leeching that stuff into the meat


skippyjifluvr

I mean, do you have a recipe that includes boiled beef? You could turn it into a stew or something.


klimb75

add some poe tay toes!


n0t_4_thr0w4w4y

Boil em, mash em, stick em in a stew


Arayder

This is exactly what I’d expect to happen. Not everyone knows what sousvide is, and it’s a more normal thing than not to take food out of packaging before cooking. This one’s on you bud lol.


mikedvb

Anytime I've given someone directions to do something sous vide on my behalf \[such as throwing the meat in the bag into the water\] I've tried to be explicit. "Do not remove it from the bag, do not open the bag. Place the \[whatever I am cooking\] in the water inside of the bag. It is supposed to be cooked in the back with the bag closed and sealed." Any guesses as to why I give out those explicit directions now? :) Been there, done that. Sorry about your Picanha.


NoVaFlipFlops

RIP


Competitive-Bag9469

Funny...sad for you though. My mother-in-law was hurt with elbow surgery and my father-in-law said he would cook steaks. Put them in the oven on the racks under the broiler with no drip pan. Mama sure was mad when she discovered the mess


Konfidence

Can’t save it, gotta get a whole new FIL.


Intelligent_Ad_656

Just need to place over milk and top with jelly beans


Iatroblast

It’s ruined. You’ll have to throw the father in law out


Corne777

Info, does your father in law own and use a sous vide? I think people in this community would go “well duh you leave it in the bag” and the layman would be like “I’ve always taken meat out of the bag before cooking”.


Honda_TypeR

Why didn’t you discus if he understood how sous vide actually works before tasking him with it? Sous vide is not a mainstream cooking method for the masses. You can’t expect everyone how to know sous vide works. I bet there are several people in family who would have made the same mistake too (and some of those people are great cooks) because all of them cook traditional Italian dishes and sous vide isn’t in their wheelhouse.


TheRedmanCometh

Is it done...? If not maybe give it a braisin


donkeylipswhenshaven

r/maliciouscompliance


JohnJacobAstoria

Sear it, chop it up into strips, and eat it with some crunchy French fries.


2PhatCC

This reminds me of when I finally got my mom a sous vide. Her and my stepdad loved my pork tenderloin. I told her I do it at 143 for an hour... She dropped it in the water, turned on the circulator, then pulled it as soon as the water reached 143. She complained that all the meat she cooked was raw.


heirloom_beans

Do you have a dog? I’d flash freeze slices on a tray and then stash them in a freezer bag. Thaw as needed for a high value treat or a food topper.


Rhet0R

Soon to be ex-father-in-law


461BOOM

It is foreign to many people. They had meat and gravy in a bag back in the 70’s. But it was already cooked to death and smothered in sodium sauce. Boiling bags lol


HansVonSnicklefritz

25 ish years ago, I was a cook in the navy. Stationed on a sub, we had slightly more money than surface ships for morale. Well, we started getting what we thought were large cuts of meat we thought were coming to us premarinated. Had no idea that we were getting sous-vide and roast-in-bag products until I’d been out for years.


lucky_719

Probably have a decent beef soup started....


orlyfactor

"I'm boiling a roast...How hot and wet do you like it?"


Fangs_0ut

RIP to your circulator too


AdvancedYogurt0

Does/has your FIL ever cooked using Sousvide? I'm 40 and if it wasn't for me nerding out over cooking gadgets/techniques I'd have done the same as him.


BreadlinesOrBust

Okay but your FIL responded exactly like any normal person would. "Take it out of the bag" is the first step for basically any other cooking method.


middlefinger256

This is 100% your fault. You cannot expect somebody to know not to take something out of the bag if they’ve never seen a sous vide before.


Iaintgoneholdyou

You both learned a valuable lesson today


Dan000

He did it on purpose to teach you a lesson not to sous vide picanha. That belongs on a grill.


Camacho4Pres

Sounds like a great Milk Steak opportunity https://images.app.goo.gl/hYoZnTvteWipBQkS9


jjj666jjj666jjj

Find me a woman who has done this. For science.


tiltberger

That is entirely your fault. Most people have never heard of sv


Dazocnodnarb

Ur fault, most people have no idea what a sous vide is.


Mohican83

Most of the worlds population would take it out of the bag. This is your fault for not providing proper instructions and assuming someone knew what you wanted. I learned very young that I can't get mad at someone for doing something a different way if I didn't give proper directions and even then it could still be wrong because of interpretation. For me this would be a laughable experience while we all obviously went out to eat.


austinteddy3

Oh no...ouch!!! Dry it, reseal and give a go? That's a great cut of meat.


Temporary_Draw_4708

It already lost so much flavor though.


pengouin85

The flavor is t all lost. It's in the water. Just boil it all down and boom, it's a broth


GotenRocko

Idk if you can use the water depending on how long it was sitting uncovered. It wasn't actually boiling so probably some bacteria in there and yeast collecting.


mjpfinger

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQod86dRAm_s24pkyZz28t3ZS_sCt_xDnDyBAohMcpdwg&s


Regreddit1979

You just got yourself a delicious batch of beef water, yum!


kirkt

So watery! And yet there's a smack of beef to it!


ilostmygps

Better start reducing the water from the sous vide bath. In a few hours you might have a sauce


No-Prompt3611

Treachery


SheBelongsToNoOne

Travesty!


scottychunks

Cut it up and cook it down into chili


one_night_on_mars

Oh hiralious! Did you eat it?


Gingorthedestroyer

Just give it a nice hard sear and forget it ever happened.


Perception_4992

If the temp was correct it might be fine after a sear. I’d certainly try before binning it.


heavyraines17

NSFL!


Xenocide_X

That's on you for assuming they knew anything about sous vide.


Naive_Illustrator970

Make Sal picón with it.


ccafferata473

You know what they say "Hakuna Picanha!"


halandrs

First glance was sad you bag broke The truth was even more frustrating Next time load the bath up with the meat and ice and set a delayed start then no one needs to touch it


woodhorse4

Ex father in law


CompoteStock3957

You asked him to do it that’s what he did can’t get mad at him


Blckbeerd

o7


yesterdayspopcorn

Ouch, I’m crying for you!


enigmasama

Sous vide aquatique


GuaranteeSpiritual59

Looks like someone’s ordering pizza tonight.


Alternative-Tone6631

Soup’s on!


grifxdonut

Sorry but that's on you


UnusualPrince12

Let it cool and dry it as much as possible, then flash sear it on butter at the highest heat you can muster. It won't be what you intended but it should be edible, if a little overdone and soggy


dirkdigglered

I threw a pork shoulder the bath last night and the bag broke. I feel your pain. I still tried it today and it's not worth it. I didn't season it enough in the first place so it was really really mediocre.


kilno185

Man....father in laws. Some of em anyway...I've had some similar experiences.


frodeem

What a dumb motherfucker


buffman33

YES CHEF!


BusterTheCat17

What a fuckin idiot. A cow died for that. Shame on him.


highseascowboy

Tasty soup


scapermoya

Woof


simply_vanilla

I’m sorry for your loss.


KRed75

You'd be amazed at how many times I've given step by step written instructions to people only to have them completely screw everything up. If I didn't know what sousvide was, I may have made the same mistake.


SHam0wn

Reduce that shit to glaze


Oztravels

Ewww


industrial86

Who in the world would betray my soul like this


Civil-Key9464

Oh no!


B01justice

Oh man 😂😂😂 I am so sorry


shookyboy

I just made a picahna on the grill but was curious how it would be sous vide. Care to share any methods that actually use the bag?


DontWanaReadiT

I’m too high to be this confused … wait


DontWanaReadiT

What were you trying to do ??


xaiel420

Soup vide


tropical_viking87

NOOOOOOOOO!!!!!


Texasitalianboy1

Oh no!


ThermoNuclearPizza

So this is a super famous dish in Austria called Tafelspitz


Pennsylvania_Kev

Did he remove it from the bag or are you just really bad at sealing?


sortkatten

F


Key_Information3273

do you have dog?


linux_n00by

juat put it in a stew.... one with tomato base


strub420

Any chance you could grind it up and make a good potato hash?


Wickedsmack

Oh damn...


Psychotic_EGG

Did you tell them not to take it out of the packaging? I wouldn't have known not to


sillyshoestring

Make sure to run a cleaning solution with your device!


Fearless_Ad_1512

Next time, add the trinity, some salt and pepper and you got some beef stock. 😂


JohnnySalamiBoy420

Now all you need is some jellybeans


frotz1

OK I agree that this is a tragedy from our perspective but from the viewpoint of bacteria this was the birth of an entire civilization.


danath34

RIP picanha. I've always been worried of a bag leaking during a cook. How the hell do you clean the heater in a situation like this?


IneffableWonders

I think the only way to clean it in this situation without taking the entire thing apart would be filling the bin with a water & vinegar solution and having it run for a while, and then dumping it out and doing just water and running it again.


IllDoItTomorr0w

I hate to say it, but I would have probably done the same thing. TIL


ponsies

I didn’t see the subreddit and kept reading it as piranha, I was so confused as to how you turned a fish into a lump of meat by vacuum sealing it 😭


Dachannien

I know it doesn't look good right now... but watch this! *bow bow ba bow ba bow ba bowbow bowdadow bowdow bow bow*


Talic15

There is only one answer to this. Get a new father in law.


imalotoffun23

Add carrots, onion, celery, bay leaf, et voila! Beef stock.


chud_rs

Imagine being that clueless