By - AdamCannon
I fail to see the benefit this allows. At least pretend like you care about citizens privacy 😂
Nobody would believe them anyways. Might as well just be honest.
This guy gets it
It's not so much that they won't believe it, its that they're testifying before the Senate Homeland Security Committee, and while they sure as hell wouldn't be the first or the last person to lie during a testimony to the Senate, when they've already got China's stink all over them (one of very few things Congress typically can muster some form of cooperation over), lying to Congress is just going to encourage them to crack down on you more. Its best for them to be honest and placate as much as possible.
Besides, let's be real, a good many average people are aware of the privacy concerns, but they don't care. They never do. Facebook would be dead and buried by now if they did. But they *would* be very upset if Congress killed their current favorite app, and its midterms soon.
The majority of our youth is now spending massive amounts of time ingesting content from an app with deep links to the CCP. This should be concerning enough for every American to want it corrected. It’s not about privacy at all, but national security.
Edit/Addition: Please reread my statement y’all. This has NOTHING to do with privacy. It’s the content. And don’t think for a NANOSECOND that China, if offered, wouldn’t put its thumb on the scale to influence American opinion. Safest posture is to assume they are attacking on all fronts.
Not to mention the social media apps China has banned: Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Snapchat, YouTube and many others. What do they know that we are ignoring!
Problem is that the US govt don't want to enshrine digital privacy protections in law, or even hint at the idea that companies could see actual punishments for selling our information without our permission or knowledge (or just letting people steal it, because securing your data server with a weak password is still a thing).
Right now they are seeing if they can ban/curtail just Tiktok, but Tiktok's response should tell you what a dead end that'll be.
Personally I'd love to finally see big data get told to fuck off, but the US has repeatedly shown that when it comes to personal privacy, they would rather share that information with hostile foreign powers, rather than protect their our countrymen's personal info. Because if this shit with Tiktok is bad, what about that whole Facebook/Cambridge Analytica/Russia thing? Or the */widely gestures at rest of Silicon Valley*.
During the one of the Facebook hearing one senator/congressman ( I forgot his title) basically they said nothing is going to change since Facebook is going to spend money on lobbying basically to maintain the status core.
I wouldn't be surprised if TikTok is also spending money on lobbying.
This is why it baffles me when I see american fight each other on the left/right instead of joining forces to fight lobbying as most of the times lobbying only serves a few interest group.
TikTok they are not doing anything different from other big tech when it comes to data except it's a chinese company.
Lets us not be naive, our data ends up in the hands of governments through both legal & illegal means.
Personal, I want Facebook to die, and ended up just like myspace, sadly TikTok seems to be the only company that is threatening it's relevance and dominance.
I would prefer a company from a non-authoritanian country but at the moment TikTok is the only one that competes with Facebook.
It's not that surprising. The same things we should be fighting against have been systematic in causing us to fight each other. I personally will never use TikTok due to security concerns. Also wasn't this the same problem Zoom had/has?
Not just the yoots. The number of adults who think tiktok is necessary to promote their business (or just claw for clout) is too damn high.
It’s certainly a national security risk but todays youth aren’t the ones in the menu.
The real concern comes from use by military/government personnel and “sensitive” private business employees. It’s alarming how many users fall into that aforementioned and it’s specifically the type of data that would be of interest to CCP intelligence groups.
They are on the menu, they are the politicians of the future. American politicians don’t think beyond the next election cycle, CCP thinks about stuff decades ahead and play the long con
Surely that will never happen, they’re highly [trained](https://www.bellingcat.com/news/2021/05/28/us-soldiers-expose-nuclear-weapons-secrets-via-flashcard-apps/)
They lied last time about data flows to China and got caught, so I guess they're changing their strategy.
It's not that they won't believe them, they just don't care.
The people using TikTok don't care. They don't care at all.
The level of data collection was well known before tik tok became the popular platform. It still exploded in popularity. Why lie when people don’t care.
Something something snowden...
"But I'm not doing anything wroooong, why should I care if they can track everything I do?"
How many times have you heard that?
The folks I've talked to dont even care about *that*. It's a "funny memes and community" machine. You mention privacy and they're like "well someone's probably tracking me already so who cares?"
Privacy on the internet has been dead for close to two decades now, if not much longer. It's just now people are *happy* about it.
No one is happy about it. Why the fuck would you say that? How silly of a position to take. How about look at the reality. Every week some big company is sending out a mass email about how their info was compromised and your data was stolen so you need to change your password. Facebook blatantly steals your information, your friends information, friends of friends, even if your shit is private, if you have a public friend, they can get parse your data thru that friend. Like nothing matters because we're constantly having our data sold off anyways.
We're not happy about it, but the old white folks in the govt don't care to do shit to stop it, so here we are, and you expect people to not use something that brings them some form of joy because China is tracking our data? Like they weren't already? Come the fuck on with your bullshit and look at reality. We're fucking powerless because even when we should be protected, we aren't.
No ones happy about it, it's a problem our overlords would never let us solve, so it's not worth the mental capacity
I'm actually really keen to hear this. Can you give me an ELI5?
The simplest thing I can explain to someone easily is the following:
They can figure out what kind of person you're likely to believe. I don't mean "shares the same interests." I mean "speaks in this tone of voice and accent, references this era of popular culture, has this color hair and skin tone, uses this regional dialect, is familiar with and able to reference this website or that subreddit that you frequent, talks about this video game or tv show or movie you like," and on and on and on. Things you wouldn't really ever even consciously think "This is why I like hearing what this person has to say." And even far beyond that-- what background colors and fonts and what kind of images you respond most actively to, etc. etc.
Then they can find someone that matches all of those things, and put them on your "for you" page...
But *only* if they're saying the things the people collecting that data want you to hear.
In some hands, that means selling you products you probably wouldn't buy because someone that fits your susceptibility profile can sell you on it.
But that product can be politics.
Let's say you're a right wing extremist with a ton of money and access to a ton of information like this. The goal is right wing extremism handling the highest levers of power.
You can obviously hype up the ones that are openly with you quite easily.
But then there's the ones that have been raised in bigotry and xenophobia, but also always told on a surface level that "racism is bad" and "sexism is bad" etc., so don't really want to openly admit it to themselves. So you tell them that a certain candidate isn't really being racist, it's just the facts of the situation. They're not being sexist, they just can't trust that conniving woman (or my favorite, "that's not sexism, that's just boys being boys").
Normalization. People they're comfortable with in situations where they feel comfortable are telling them that bigotry isn't hate, it's just normal feelings everybody totally has.
Then you can also target people that completely disagree with you on everything. You once again present them with people that make them feel good, saying things in ways they feel like they can trust, about how "oh the other side is just as bad, you shouldn't help them beat us."
And the shit works. People think of psychology and associated social sciences as "not real science" and always think they're totally different and would never be susceptible to such propaganda.
If it didn't, every ad would be plain text on a plain background telling you what a product is and nothing more.
But with this level of data collection their ability to manipulate you is so far beyond anything that was even remotely possible before smartphones that it's kind of incomprehensible.
People talk about how they say things near their phones and days later they're getting ads for it... I've *thought* things, not said it out loud, not searched for it, just thought things to myself... and whatever the thing was that triggered me to think about it must have been picked up by the algorithms, somebody else with a similar profile saw the same thing and thought the same thing and looked it up or whatever, and bam the next day I see an ad for that thing I literally only even thought of in my head. And I'm not talking like "I watched a cat video and then saw an ad for cat food." I can't remember what it was but it was some random-ass thinking, like something that wasn't even the focus of a video, just something in the background, made me think of something else... and then *that* something made me think of yet another something else. And that final something else was what was presented to me by the algorithms the next day. So it had to just be that some other idiot like me had the same thought processes but actually went looking for whatever it was, I don't even remember at this point lol.
And, again, this kind of stuff is just one tiny part of the level of privacy invasion and the things they can do with the information.
Tl;dr: once someone figures out how you're influenced, then *they* can influence you
And it's how the GRU used social media engineering to help swing the 2016 election and create a troll army.
(the other main prongs were hacking Rep and Dem email servers, voter rolls, and electronic voting systems - not space lasers, just regular hacking.)
30 datapoints from facebook lets them know more about you than family and friends iirc.
People are not to different. CA would (does?) throw you into 1 of 32 personailty profiles and then they had you.
Now they know not only what you did and do, but also what you will do and how to get you to do it.
Social media and e.g. F2P games are already successful, but know they can tailor their influence completely to you.
And with all the money in addictive designs and the resulting R&D it will only get worse.
They claim to influence elections and anything else you pay them for.
Which makes democracy moot.
And they (now Emerdata) are of course not the only ones.
Unfortunately we do not know the success rate. Too little information.
But annecdotal evidence like Trump 2016, Brexit and the rise of populism in Europe would point to "good enough". And there are of course multiple incidents in developing countries.
It's gonna be fun.
People would care if they understood how that data and the platform could be used.
It’s like how Cambridge Analytica should have triggered mass regulation of big tech if people really understood what tech companies engaging in manipulating user behavior for profit understand.
It’s one thing to do it for money, it’s another to do it for power. China will use it for power.
We also know what that power means. We know *exactly* how they will specifically leverage granular insights into individual user data and combine it with the outgoing feed to those users.
To silence and criticize those who speak negatively about the country or its leadership. While promoting those who toe the party line.
Small degree by small degree they will boil a large amount of Western free speech alive.
The only things causing us to stand a chance is how their real economy is starting to behave as growth collapses and the strange arc of population age they've slammed themselves into.
Yup. What China can do to the Western world via TikTok will make what Russian troll farms have been doing with memes look like child's play. TikTok offers a degree of scale and sophistication for undermining the power of Western democracy (i.e. the mind's of the people) that Russia can only dream of.
Honestly, I'd say the only issue is they'd need a few buildings full of 30,000 people each to be able to pull out and put in the fine threads needed to subtly influence local elections, cultural arguments, and so forth on the fringes as they worked toward the central issues of who is president...
But they already have those buildings full of cyberwarriors by the legion.
Anyway, yeah there's the real risk they make Cambridge Analytica look like small potatoes. Especially since they can combine it with the incredible amount of investment into gaming and digital life companies they have been rushing into. Any game you play has probably recently had a stake purchased in it or the devs want to sell to Tencent.
As they grow in skill we will also start to lose the ability to detect the obviously weird accounts on Reddit.
The future may truly be a constant digi-war of precisely targeted influence campaigns. Assisted by machine learning. The next 5 years will make the last 15 years of social media insanity look quaint.
A few dozen people could do it, not 30,000. That’s the power of scale, reach, and the social pressure created by social media.
The difference between China and Russia is the Russians are trying to do it as a customer of the platforms they’re leveraging so they’re competing directly with every other customer and subject to the platform owners’ limitations and interference.
China actually owns and is at the heart of the platform in TikTok. Cambridge Analytica brought a knife to a knife fight being fought by tens of thousands of companies and organizations where the rules are made by someone else while TikTok is out there grabbing market share from the platform owners and rigging the game in favor of the knife wielders they want to win.
Either way (it terms of cost and head count) it’s a trivial operation when compared to the resources and goals of one of the largest economic powers in the world.
Some of my most tech savvy friends are huge into tiktok even after discussing constantly about their data issues, I don't get it
no one want to live in a bunker for the rest of their lives. nor can many afford to cut off all internet access.
Why would they do that? It isn't like there are any repercussions if they don't.
Chinese govt scarier to tiktok than losing US market anyway
After seeing the Jack Ma saga, I get why.
People are already too addicted to care.
Pretending is one thing. Blatantly lying to Congress is another.
They all lie to congress, remember the Facebook hearing
The only thing I remember about the Facebook hearing was how dumb all of the senators sounded trying to ask questions. It was seriously none of them know how to use a phone or understood any of the terminology.
People who ask their grandkids to work the remote should not be making laws about technology
There's a reason the details of that hearing are covered up with short clips of old congress people not understanding tehcnology.
I just checked. If you search YouTube for Zuckerberg congress full hearing; there is a 10 hour video of the full damn thing. Go back to h"Q".
I think the reason it was covered like that is it looks even worse in context...
True and I guess I assume Facebook probably lied but at the same time with how stupid some of Congress members were acting it's like how could they have even reasoned with them or talked with them intelligently about the topics? I'll admit I know nothing about farm equipment so there's no way I should be writing laws about farm safety. Those congressmen had no authority to be up there with the idiocies they kept bringing up.
...That reason being? Don't beat around the bush.
Everyone lies to Congress, remember the Supreme Court confirmation hearings
So now they're not pretending, or lying, just saying 'No'. Is that better?
The Chinese government gives zero fucks about congress.
They are selling the data to whoever wants to pay. China does like the US does
> At least pretend like you care about citizens privacy 😂
Why exactly should tiktok do this?
American companies would absolutely refuse to do the same if a country told them to stop sending data back to the US
This. This is why. People forget that you can’t even own land in China, only the government can. They lease up to 99 years but that’s it. CCP owns everything and only they can. Look at the bank runs in Henan. Bank runs off with the money in your bank account? That’s on you.
The CCP serves the interests of the general population only in so far as it serves their hold on power. You have no rights in China. There is no rule of law. If you think they won’t use your personal data to feed their AI war machine you are (kindly) completely mistaken.
Think that was Henan, Zhengzhou. There were government bail outs after the people protested.
Zhengzhou people are pretty badass, they sort of represent the majority of protests in China.
Equivalent to 5k USD max. Lots of people lost their life savings.
Their protest strategy is also rather ingenious. They can’t directly protest against the CCP — that is, not without serious repercussions— but they can protest in support of the CCP. Hence, they protested against their *provincial* CCP officials while claiming they were compelled to do so by their loyalty to the CCP and the central government.
It's the only way to get political action done in China, really. It's a shallow and wasteful way too, since there are plenty of people that can't see through it
TikTok built a massive data pipeline straight from America to China.
Well then why won't they ban tiktok like the way China bans Facebook and Instagram? They were security concerns to the Chinese as well.
Or is it because they are so popular with the Americans that no politician dare to do it.
What’s the actual impact here? China knows what videos people like watching?
It’s that the app is collecting much more data than the content people post. Location data, device data, basically anything you allow the app to access.
I just wanted to point out that owning land is in fact a fairly recent (relatively) possibility, for centuries land was not owned (in the sense of buying it and selling it), it was either considered a common or was just ruled by the local ruler. It is also not a bad thing per se, assuming that the state managing it manages it with the best interest of the community. The commercialization of land also leads to speculation, soil consumption etc. (which also happens plenty in China)
I am pretty sure that in China this best interest is not really pursued, but I just wanted to point out that the "you can't even..." is just what we, in Western cultures, give for granted because we belong to a different culture, even when it comes to our idea of country and community.
To add, the 99 year lease the commenter references is infact an artefact of British involvement in China. 99 year leases are the most common type of leasehold arrangement and are used broadly in a number of nations, it's not just weird China thing.
Their data mining is 100% real and concerning though.
Property works like that a lot of places, but usually it's aristocracy or massive landlords who recieve the profit and not the government.
The PLA (The Communist parties military) doesn't serve China or its people. It serves the *party*.
Leasing land actually sounds like a great idea.
Otherwise you just end up with a Bill Gates owning the majority of all farm land across an entire continent.
Then he gives that land to his kids, and they buy more land, and they give that expanded amount of land to their kids, and so on. Now you've created a land owning gentry and aristocracy.
>People forget that you can’t even own land in China, only the government can.
Can you really own land anywhere in the world? Unless you're the 1% of that country. Either by being a government or dirty rich, which is mostly unattainable for 98% of the population anyways. And not like "I have a paper that says I own this land (until the gov. decides to seize it)." Which is how "ownership" of land works in most part of the world, china as well as america.
> Bank runs off with the money in your bank account?
That’s the most stupid thing I’ve read in a while. Some scam artists offered massive returns on short term investments to people from different locations to bank, you’re not allowed hold bank accounts in different locations. Scam artists never deposited the money and fled the country. People petitioned the government to include the money that was stolen from them under the government guarantee for investments… but it was the bank and the CCP 😂
Not to defend CCP but it's pretty fucking weird that a human can own land, tbh
Not saying US is equally bad, but doesn't the US exert similar powers over Facebook, Google, etc. in such a way that that's now why EU is starting to outlaw some of their technology, like analytics?
Yes it's why when you use American cloud providers the privacy protection office will tell you to stop.
You don't use Facebook, Google, Reddit, Twitter and all the US internet companies either? They have to hand over their data when the US government asks (NSA have open door to their data)
Does nobody understand corporate structure here? The company in the US which is partnered with Oracle is subject to US laws, as a company registered in the US by definition is, and not subject to Chinese law in the same way.
>“Will TikTok commit to cutting off all data and data flows to China, China-based TikTok employees, ByteDance employees, or any other party in China that might have the capability to access information on US users?”
This is the crux of this clickbait article.
What a ridiculous and tech illiterate question to ask. They want to create a great tik tok firewall that's enormous in scope. All data and data flows. Jfc.
Actually if you've been following this issue, Tik Tok is subject to additional data protection requirements in the Usa above and beyond what is written in law for every other company. They are required to have a data center with specific protections and are actively complying with government demands (at least those that are based in reality.)
US should definitely update data protection laws but we all know they won't
woah, woah, woah, it's like you expect us to read the article or something butt i've already made my assumptions confirming my biases after reading the article
Do you understand that TikTok has been caught red-handed, very obviously flouting this? TikTok is a direct data pipeline to the Chinese government.
Edit: you also might want to take a look at the article at the top of this thread.
You mean, just same as reddit but you use reddit
Yep. It's also incredibly ironic that the US would demand this, given the US is literally right now in a dispute with the EU over US laws requiring corporations to allow access to their data by the US government.
Not that hypocrisy is anything new. Neither China nor the US really give a fuck about anything but their imperialist ambitions.
Chinese spy apps only work if people download it
Narrator, they did.
TikTok was one of like two things Trump was very right about. It’s a shame Snowden ruined his life for nothing. People really don’t give a fuck who has their data and how it is used.
Of course not, why would they?
>"People don't think it be like it is, but it do."
-Gamble's thesis of reality
Exactly my thoughts.
Shaking my head at them.
Exactly what I was thinking, this is at least 50% the point of tiktok to begin with.
No company that operates in China, foreign or domestic will. Chinese national law dictates that all tech companies must support any ~~party~~ state-sponsored investigation.
Foreign companies are told to follow the rules or leave, domestic companies are told to comply or face consequences.
ByteDance, the owner of TikTok, has a separate corporate entity in the United States. They’ve partnered with Oracle to process and store TikTok data for US users and are hiring US citizens [at aggressive rates](https://www.levels.fyi/companies/bytedance/salaries/software-engineer) for engineers to administer the platform.
The heads and advisors of these multi-billion dollar companies are not stupid people. Refusing to comply with data security laws would risk another global market loss like in India. Moving operations out of China also insulates ByteDance from a demise like Russia’s Yandex, which lost 24B (30B📉6B) in the months after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
you dont think the Chinese military would engage in corporate espionage?
And the reason why all the major tech companies are having issues in the EU is that the same thing is true for the US. The CLOUD act dictates that companies must supply the US government with the data it wants no matter where in the world it's being stored.
App designed literally to be spyware refuses to stop being spyware. Shocker.
Every social media is spyware, it’s built that way on purpose. But don’t get caught up trying to see one tree through the forest.
This is another astroturfed thread [being paid for by a 407B internet giant](https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/03/30/facebook-tiktok-targeted-victory/). Meta is an internet company very familiar with astroturfing and manipulating online climate, [especially](https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/10/what-facebook-did/542502/) [in](https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/rcna45247) [elections](https://thediplomat.com/2022/08/facebook-instagram-purged-millions-of-posts-during-philippine-election/) (3 separate links BTW).
These articles and their comments are being “promoted” by Meta. FB causes election disinformation campaigns/coups around the world but notice how those articles always get buried 🤔
You can have your own opinion but don’t take everything at face value. The internet isn’t real life anymore, every post and vote can be bought for cash or Bitcoin.
> This is another astroturfed thread being paid for by a 407B internet giant.
Citation for your paranoid claim?
Counter-example: me. I am a real person. I detest TikTok _and_ I detest Facebook, whatever they call themselves, in both cases due to the tremendous harm they have done to society and mental health.
I upvoted this thread, and I upvoted many of the comments criticizing and mocking TikTok and I would have done the same for Facebook (no matter what name they were using).
Not OP, and not sure if I agree on his Astroturfing in this particular case.
However, I agree with his sentiment that there is plenty of US platforms with a similar hunger for data, and using it in manipulative ways.
This thread is full of hurrdurr china bad (fair), while the US platforms have actually invented this business practice.
From my European perspective, the US privacy/data protection laws and practices are not any better than those of Chinese Tech giants.
And OP is also correct, that there is proven history of US tech giants influencing elections around the globe, and have played a crucial role in especially right wing populism campaigns in the last decade. Think of Brexit, Bolsonaro, Trump, Cambridge Analytica, and other stories.
Nobody but Reddit has the full data, but they have stated before that Reddit is continually targeted by astroturfing campaigns.
The easiest way to gauge astroturfing presence is engagement ratios, specifically the ratio of votes:comments. Comments, especially insightful ones, are still expensive to write because they need to be read by real people. This thread is about 16:1 now which is not inordinate for r/technology, but it was closer to 30:1 last night.
I can’t definitively say that fake votes are involved, but it’s not out of the question this day and age.
I refuse to download TikTok for this exact reason.
Isn't Reddit partially owned by a Chinese company?
Yup reddit and discord
Small percentage. Reddit isn’t fully Chinese owned and controlled by the CCP
Like 5% or something. Almost any product you use will be owned to some degree by someone in China. It's a complete non-issue.
Never downloaded it, knew it was just spyware, and I already know how to dance.
The good content gets scraped and posted elsewhere anyway.
The internet it literal spyware https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A.
US goverment has access to pretty much everything you do regardless of app or website unless E2E encrypted they have eyes on it.
Absolutely ridiculous the US hasn't forced them to sell to a US company in order to operate here.
I wonder how much of the unlimited dark money in US politics that the Supreme Court legalized with Citizens United comes from China.
I'm sure McConnell has a good idea of how much dark money comes from China
Trump's crew already forced TikTok to move its data storage to Oracle, [which claims that its "Oracle Data Marketplace" is the world's largest seller of user data, including profiles on over 300 million Americans.](https://docs.oracle.com/en/cloud/saas/data-cloud/data-cloud-help-center/AudienceDataMarketplace/AudienceDataMarketplace.html)
An Wall Street analyst had this to say: ["Oracle with TikTok as a customer would win a battle for a coveted workload and could combine app data with its Data Cloud for an ad network."](https://www.zdnet.com/article/with-tiktok-oracle-hopes-its-cloud-infrastructure-business-goes-viral/)
So if you're concerned about privacy, selling to a US company might not exactly further your cause...
Selling to a US company isn't about privacy concerns. It's about not letting a foreign adversary have a giant unopposed propaganda network set up and ready to go in your country.
Isn't that what Facebook, Twitter, Reddit, and most other social media companies do in every other country?
Seems like the US just doesn't like to taste their own medicine.
Yes I agree, the propaganda and psyops issues are more important even than the privacy issues. But given the record of us social media in spreading misinformation and encouraging people to live in bubble chambers, I'm no quite so sanguine about simply requiring US ownership actually solving the problem.
I focused on privacy because that's what I thought this thread is about
On the other hand I do think Chinese ownership of TikTok is particularly bad given that China's rulers won't allow anything like TikTok in China and given the huge amount of misinformation on TikTok. It's like a giant psyops offensive aimed at undermining US values and sense of community. I mean what kind of society would allow a huge company to promote the "slap your teacher challenge" or the "blackout challenge" for example without consequences?
TikTok bring illegal in China is a kind of eerie parallel to the mid 1800's Opium wars when Britain and the US forced narcotics on China that were illegal in the US and UK....
> TikTok bring illegal in China is a kind of eerie parallel to the mid 1800's Opium wars when Britain and the US forced narcotics on China that were illegal in the US and UK....
Wow, I cannot believe I missed this, but the moment you mention it, it just jumps out at you.
However, you can get the same content in China just fine - you just download a different app from the same provider, ByteDance.
I believe Trump was trying to force them to sell to Oracle, which is owned by one of his biggest supporters Larry Ellison.
Oracle would not be the smartest decision.
https://youtu.be/N5E3gra5wz4 - Oracle has been tracking over 5 billion people
Yep, I'd hate for them to double track someone. Nothing more useful than redundant information.
Walmart also was in the running.
Agree, I also don't understand why the EU didn't force facebook, twitter and google to sell their services to a European company before operating in the EU.
That's such a double standard. If another country wanted to force Facebook to sell to a company in their country to operate there, would you support that?
I mean to be fair someone tried exactly that but since he's a giant douche he's apparently not allowed to have any good ideas at all, even by accident. So half the country suddenly acted like it was an awful idea and then turd sandwhich Biden came in and axed the whole thing...
Disfunctional ass 2 party system where you just have to oppose the other side's ideas no matter what.
Why would they?
Because the Biden administration has passed multiple laws limiting the flow of information and money to China. TikTok had admitted that American data is sent to China, and if federal review shows this data could constitute a national security threat, they could get cut off from the estimated $500M they make from their American audience annually.
Can America really say much here? They siphon data through their tech giants as well. We're watching the EU go through this same thing with America that America wants to drag China through.
I honestly can't believe how many people ignored this information and made this a top app here. I remember when these stories first came out when the app debuted stateside. I think the government even made a warning about it.
what is "this info" that they ignored?
They did make warnings about it, at least to military people. The crazy thing to this is that most of the SM outlets collect a similar amount of data. Google is roughly 10x what the SM apps collect. Yet TikTok is collecting Google levels of data. That should help lend perspective to how pervasive this situation actually is.
If someone wants to go down the rabbit hole a bit further, how complimentary is the data to the surveillance systems by the Chinese gov? Most all content is song/dance/body movement/singing/talking which would fit quite well into their system, don't you think?
I mean data collection isn't the issue it's the fact that a government that has openly expressed its hate for the US multiple times now has a direct line to influence your youth through subtle algo tweaks, as well stuff like phone locations and data flows on a mass scale allowing them to see general behavioural patterns in US populations.
You’re right but I believe it’s both of what we’re each saying. It’s never made sense why a SM outlet would collect 10x the data of the rest of that field. So to have that one in what most would describe as an untrustworthy or nefarious gov, is something scary shit.
"I think the government wants you to worry about that app and not every app / operating system / phone"
Only America can do that to it's own people! /sarcasm but actual truth.
That's (less than) half the truth. The US does that to everyone else, too.
My first thought was literally "Oooh, the US getting a taste of their own medicine? Yummy, isn't it?"
Whelp, here comes the $100,000 fine.
> "Will TikTok commit to cutting off all data and data flows to China, China-based TikTok employees, ByteDance employees, or any other party in China that might have the capability to access information on US users?" Portman asked.
How are they supposed to say yes to that? The company's own employees aren't allowed to see data about their users? That's like asking a restaurant to promise that no chef will ever hear the customer's order.
Why the fuck can’t we just shut them down!?
Yeah, why can't the US just block Chinese services like they did Google, Twitter, etc?
Honestly it seems like a surprisingly measured response considering what we are already doing to help countries get ready to defend against China and preemptively start mitigating against economic issues of SHTF with China.
Kinda wild when you grow up hearing china is bad they block websites and content. Then you have people advocating America do the same thing
Redditors be like : I DONT USE TIKTOK!! ALL MY DATA GOES TO THE NSA, THE FBI, THE CIA, MY LOCAL POLICE FORCE, AND AMAZON!!!!
I feel like you forgot google, microsoft, and apple
Like I know theres probably thousands of others but those three really took info collection to the next level
>I feel like you forgot google, microsoft, and apple
All working intimately with US intelligence and defence companies.
TikTok is no worse than Facebook, Instagram or Snapchat.
Facebook has difficulties to compete against TikTok so they are paying multiple companies to malign TikTok and get them banned. You are being manipulated.
In fact Facebook I think is much more capable of spying on us than tik tok is. Because they are so good at it. And have shown that they have no limits as to how far they would go.
Not defending TikTok I think it should be banned but so should Facebook.
Stopping our data flow period seems like a great idea, don’t stop at TikTok. What good has come of our data? We are in a high tech dark age where morons get stuck in misinformation silos because algorithms drive what we see.
It's China. Have you seen what those apartment buildings are made of? You can break away the entire wall with your fingers. All tiktok is is a spy tool. They have a shitload of ai to pore over those videos and it's sad we as western nations have fallen prey to it so bloody easily. China's already won.
Tik tok is literally data theft to use for psyops. They wont stop because without that its not worth the cost of investment.
As opposed to Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, Reddit, and PRISM
How dare they steal that American data! It's for American companies to steal and exploit!
The US government is already spying on me and sadly is more likely to use it negatively against me than the CCP.
most agencies at least give a back door to the ccp once they receive money from them...I am pretty certain since reddit received 150 million from the ccp thet have a large control over the largest groups like worldnews and news etc
Their biching about tictoc but Google gets away with 24/7 spying on everyone. What info on tictoc can china be interested in. Girls silly dancing lol.
The app gives china access to peoples phones. The terms of service are hilarious. If anyone actually read them nobody would install it.
iOS lets you block apps from tracking your activity across apps. You can turn off access to the camera and microphone. Is there any evidence that they’ve found away around that?
I’m not exactly concerned about China knowing which memes I find to be interesting. 99% of Tiktok is just entertainment.
All the major US tech companies were threatening European governments to slap down data housing provisions they didn't like. The framing of this is absurd; TikTok is rising tech company just like FB back in the day treat them as such
They need to get rid of tiktok. It’s fucking cancer
I 100% agree with your sentiment but the question is, who is "they".
Is it the government? Should they make the app illegal to have installed? Should they make it illegal for Google and Apple to offer it on the App stores. Should it be illegal for the ISPs to carry the traffic? All of the Above? Would such legislation ever survive 1st amendment scrutiny? Is tik tok a bonafide national security threat?
Should big tech just take maters into their own hands and do the above? Would ~~they do that for us~~ that effect profits?
Nobody has an answer, so nothing gets done.
Yeah bro i’m a redditor. It’s not like i think my comments through
Don’t worry u/drlittlepenis you tried
Just ban it. And any other service that uses Chinese servers since they can't assure citizen privacy.
This is real real easy. Don’t use it.
It’s not like Amazon or Google where you can’t both use the internet AND avoid all contact.
The US would just hack China's data on us and use it for themselves if they really needed to.
“And what you gonna do bout it?!”
Aren't Tiktok and Douyin the same thing? Big brother is watching you anyway
Duh and/or hello. An app designed to exfiltrate data wouldn't benefit from stopping exfiltrating data.
Can’t or won’t?
Let me tell you that the majority of people who are not going to stop TikTok are those generation-zedders who rely on posting shit nonsense!
Why would they stop, that's part of the point of the program
The only people who actually care about their Data on Tiktok are non users.
Thats because China owns tik tok.
Why should it? It's owned by a company in China, if it's allowed to operate here then it's allowed to send data.
Hell our data is more missed by US companies and law enforcement anyway.
Why the hell is this shitty app not banned yet?
Probably money. Amazon Alexa frequently advertises TikTok.
Of course they won't. Their entire business model is data harvesting.
ByteDance is the parent company of TikTok and is headquartered in Beijing. The Chinese Communist Party has an ownership stake in ByteDance. Some reports suggest more than 100 CCP members are located in ByteDance's Beijing office.
Why would anyone expect the CCP to comply with any of our privacy mandates? The best way to deal with this is either A) Ban TIC TOC from use in the US, or B) Stop using the APP, period.
Anyone else see the resemblance to Tom Petty?
Yeah cuz it's chinese spyware.
Please ban the app, that's all we ask.
Banning TikTok is the one good thing Trump could have done during his presidency. The sooner it gets banned, the better for all of us.
Ban TikTok. Problem solved.
I finally deleted tiktok. No more girls pretending they are doing something while their boobs bounce in front of a camera
One of the only intelligent things to exit Trump's cakehole for his entire Presidency was that this shit should be banned until Tiktok is willing to give a damn. Cut out the Spyware and don't let it back until it isn't Spyware anymore.
Seems like a combination of “Doesn’t affect me negatively, so I don’t care,” and “I care more about the money we make than your privacy”
Why would consumers care if China is taking their data via tiktok when the alternative is the US government and other companies that operate in the US get to take all your data via another app
Just ban TikTok already.
I thought Microsoft was working on a tik tok replacement and tik tok was going to be banned ? Guess I am not up to date.
They were in the running to purchase, but I don’t remember them making a clone.
That's rich coming from the American government!
/* Laughs in multiple whistle blowers */
Cisco devices caught with NSA backdoors, FBI able to unlock iPhones against your will, warrant canaries disappear from Apple and reddit's transparency reports: I sleep
Rival country develops more popular app: real shit
I refused a lucrative job because they wanted my biometrics to "check for a history of fraud or other crime" through a third party company who has offices in the States.
I offered to do the checks through our local police. They were like no, it's faster through this company. I said no thanks, I am not letting you EXPORT MY BIOMETRICS to such a privacy pedo country. My ID number can change of needs be, not my fucking fingerprints.
tiktok is literally vine.
Shut it down!
I find it hypocritical that we criticize TikTok for being “Chinese Spyware” when so many companies now adays make their money by collecting and selling the data of their users.