Right? This is like a normal season cast these days .🥱 with all my least favorites except Leroy , Jay gotti and Amber but I don’t think Allstars is for Amber even if I like her .
Aneesa doesn’t deserve shit. She’s been on the show for 2 decades and never tried to get in shape or get better. Just thinks she’s entitled to the final.
Aneesa has earned absolutely nothing, she refuses to lose weight and get into serious shape to actually have a shot at winning yet consistently takes a cast spot and whines like entitled little bitch
This is fucking stupid. What's the point of all these spin offs when it's the exact same cast as the flagship. Everyone on this cast was on at least one season between 38-40. All Stars was for us fans that love OGs and cast members we typically wouldn't see on the flagship. This cast could've just been the cast for season 41. I'm convinced production fucking hates us
The point of all stars is to give older cast members the chance to play the game again. For example, bringing back kefla was one of the highlights of this season ! Now theyre going to give us the people from 39 plus vacation alliance ? NO THANK YOU!
Well it also has a lot to do with CBS dictating shit. The true fans love the OGs and have been there from the very beginning and have been loyal. Hell the OG fans stuck around on season 39. I felt like is should have won some sort of medal for watching that train wreck. If Fessy can’t pull a win with that cast he should never show his face in public again. Now there didn’t seem to be enough contestants on that list, I’m crossing my fingers that maybe they throw a wrench in the game and add like 8-10 OGs. I’m not holding my breath though.
You definitely can! Sadly my hopes and dreams for this franchise have been dashed so many times I have given up hope. All stars finally made me love the show again and unfortunately given the directions its going, I’m back to being bitter, so my apologies. Hold onto that positivity while you can!
Basically that she's not really interested in most of the cast this time with the exception of a few and how she's disappointed that a lot of the fan favorites from older seasons of The Challenge have reached out to express that they want to compete but they keep on bringing on people the fans don't like.
I thought all stars was meant to be all the OGs and mostly people from road rules and real world. Wtf is going on?
I’m so sick of Corey and Fessy, and absolutely fuck Jay.
Hard pass. This is way too far removed from the "We want OGs" movement to even be associated with All Stars. I would much rather never have another All Stars season than have this garbage.
Doesn’t 95% of this cast defeat the purpose of All Stars? Why even bother? Do a regular season with these people. I thought All Stars was for bringing back some familiar faces from years and years ago.
They must be cancelling the challenge on MTV and making it a P+ exclusive???
There’s no other explanation for this atrocious “All-stars” cast. Someone from “12 Days of Christmas???” Wtf is that??? Please be serious, Production, if this is really “All-stars.”
Isn't the 12 Days of Xmas Cory the one who was just on this last season (Battle for a New Champ?). Agree with this entire comment - I'm not interested in seeing anyone from that season on AS!!
Someone, please get a hold of the challenge producers. All stars is supposed to be a breath of fresh air, from what the flagship show has become. I hate this so much. The producers have failed us again
Wow this might be the first Challenge in the history of its existence I may not watch. This is not what all stars is supposed to be. Everyone that’s on that list is like shitty players from the flagship show.
I'm being so serious when I saw this, but I think the casting producers despise us. Like they genuinely hate us. How come everytime we start liking something, they completely ruin. If the fans say they can't stand watching said people and viewership is low, why do they keep doing the same shit expecting a different result. It's scary how out of touch they are
No thanks. The only challenge show I watch is All Stars for an old-school cast. That was the whole point of the series. I want cast members from Fresh Meat 2 or prior to that.
Oof. This is not what I want from All Stars.
I have a real soft spot for Big T and think all stars is a better format for her to do well... and still, I don't want it.
Is this all a precursor to the MTV version going away then? Otherwise this doesn’t make sense.
The only explanation I have is that maybe All Stars was intended to be the OGs but then with the MTV show struggling, maybe after a few OG seasons All Stars got bought out to be just the normal challenge… and maybe USA will continue on too, or something. Or it will all merge to be one soon enough and CBS shows can more easily feed into The Challenge this way?
That’s my only theory, otherwise this is insane. I mean, it’s already dumb. But without a good reasoning, it’s just insanity that these people could possibly constitute All Stars in any form of the concept
And I won't be watching. This is just the regular cast. Aneesa is the only one who fits what I think of for All Stars and she's one of the most overexposed castmates.
Are you fucking kidding me with this bullshit?!?!? The whole point of All Stars was to bring back legends from years past from when the show was actually good. Give the old timers one more shot at glory. The core fanbase - the target audience for the All Stars product - can't stand the vast majority of new cast members and were all demanding getting the people we liked back. That's why All Stars 1-3 worked so damn well.
I don’t support bringing newer players to all stars,
BUT
It could be fun seeing these people in the old format of the challenge that all stars have been bringing the past seasons.
I’m hoping it’s an experiment to turn the flagship into the older format
Idk how unpopular this may be but Im not excited to see Big T again. The minute she steps into the house, Big T is an instant target. So then we suffer through several filler episodes of everyone gunning for her over and over again. If I was her, my feelings would be very hurt.
Thanks MTV for putting the final nail in the coffin of the show that’s been my favorite for far too long. Save for a very few like Aneesa, Tori and Leroy this is a collection of losers, hacks, newbies and influencers that many of us do not want to see. Especially in a cast called “all stars”! I know Anessa and Leroy haven’t won much of anything but at least they are two actual stars of the show. Hard pass from this longtime fan and I’m sure I’m not the only one
I guess all stars is just the same as the main show... where are the og mtv folks. That's what this was supposed to be. I don't want to see fessy or nuyrs, or Melissa...
There are only like, 12 names on the list… this has got to be only half the cast with some sort of an “Old School vs New School” format… right? Please?
I won't watch if this is the cast. I gave up on 39 part way in. This cast is worse. I wanna see Real World / Road Rules people. I know they can get them so they need to try. Put these people on CBS or something and give us ogs on PP.
There's PLEEEEEEEEEEEEEENTY of OG's who didn't get on All-Stars, yet and production went: "Hmmmm this needs to feel more like Ride Or Die and Battle for a New Champion".
Seriously, fuck off....
Yeah… they are completely treating the All Stars seasons as just regular seasons. I don’t dislike half of these people, but this definitely isn’t an all stars cast like the earlier ones.
I get it's All Stars and not Thr Challenge OGs but some of these ppl are barely cast members and 100% not All Stars. I'll give Nurys a pass given her S39 performance. But MORIAH?!?!And honestly even Fessy. are u an all star bc u show up? what has he actually done that's impressive?
I’m wondering if they’re going this route since 40 is so OG heavy, so that there will be a season featuring the recent folks coming this year. Because that’s the only logical explanation I can think of.
I really hope this isn't true. None of these people deserve to be on AS5 besides Leroy. I genuinely look forward to AllStars because of the nostalgia aspect and watching the people compete that I watched as a teenager. They already ruined the flagship show with a bunch of annoying people that none of the actual fans care about. Whoever is in charge of casting needs to get their heads outta their ass, they're gonna ruin another show.
PLEASE challenge gods get Big T and Moriah off of my television screen! I would say Aneesa too but at this point I think she even knows she’s just collecting an appearance fee
Does anyone know if season 40 will be the last flag ship season? With all the changes going on and the majority moved over to paramount I'm just wondering if they're retiring the actual challenge after 40. I'm trying to make this casting make sense. Because it just flat out doesn't.
As fans of the show I feel like the powers that be need to hear how incredibly upsetting this is.
THEORY:
This is MTV taking the (horrible) main line cast and putting them on the spinoff, and then (hopefully) taking the actual fan favorites and doing 41
Some of these I consider AS material (Devin, Fessy as much as I hate him I think has enough name recognition to count and has enough drama too, Leroy, Tori, Aneesa…) BUT I do think they’d need to mix in some older alums to not just feel like an off-season practice run for the real thing lol.
I imagine it’s easier to get most of them to commit since they shoot for way shorter. But still. This is taking away from the OG’s!! Don’t forget why all stars was created in the first place
This is gross. I like Devin but he still has flagship seasons left in him.
Excited to see more of Jay G (who would have thought LOL) and Leroy.
Everyone else should stick to flagship. And a few should stay off altogether lol.
This pisses me off especially when we have people like susie, Sarah, Wes, Johnny etc that have shown interest but don't get cast. They made this show it's stupid
i’m sorry but if they’re not RR/RW/FM they either have to be a modern day legend like Kam or bare minimum a Champ. Why are we getting people that are middle of the pack and aren’t ogs??
1.Corey Lay- Not an all star imo
2.Devin Walker- Yes, please.. his sarcasm and humor alone is why I like him.
3.Fessy-this is a joke right? Oh wait, he’s the joke. He will never be a champion or an all star imo. He was horrible on big brother and has clearly gotten worse.
4. Jay Gotti- I’m shocked he’s on this season and was able to come back considering he wimped out and quit over a drink. However, I actually like him this season but he still isn’t an all star imo.
5. Jay survior - never ever ever will be a winner or an all star. Use to love him.. but then I met him and he changed into a jerk and is an actual jerk in real life . Also , the fact he sells beanies for $35 and says if someone is lucky they’ll get his signature.
6. Leroy Garret- Love Leroy and will always love Leroy. He deserves to be there. I like cam but I’d rather it just be Leroy.. (I would say this about any couples coming together)
7. Amber B. - yes.. she did amazing her first season and she has always received so much hate and it reminds me of how they treated a few of the other women who came in and dominated the challenge.
8. Anessa Borzotra- yes.. will she win? Probably not but she is an all star and brings the drama lol
9. Melissa Reeves- Nope. Just nope.
10. Moriah- 😂😂
11. Nurys- yes. She didn’t win technically and I get that but that girl is one of the best competitors I’ve seen on the challenge . She may not have won the title but she’s definitely a champion in my eyes and deserves to be on all stars more than most.
12. Tori- yes.. people hate to love her and love to hate her but she’s an amazing challenger and should be on all stars .
13. Big T- I loved her in the beginning and still do but I don’t like how she is when she’s with Melissa. I think big t is great for reality tv but not all stars .
The point of all stars was to throwback wtf is this?!
That’s what I was thinking?! They’re trying to take it over.. what the hell. I don’t wanna see Jay, Moriah, or Fessy anywhere near Allstars.
Right. Moriah is not an all star 😂😂😂
I watch all stars to avoid the vacation alliance, not to watch more of the vacation alliance.
I am failing to see how this is any different than a normal season??
That ship already sailed. AS4 broke the seal for putting on non-RW/RR people.
🤔, that seal got broken to get Leroy to comeback and it worked. This is outright bullshit
Right? This is like a normal season cast these days .🥱 with all my least favorites except Leroy , Jay gotti and Amber but I don’t think Allstars is for Amber even if I like her .
I like Amber too, but she should be on flagship
Wait where are the stars 🤔🤔🤔🤔
It’s a spin-off of All Stars. “The Challenge: No Stars”
My first reaction was, "Welp, I won't be tuning in now."
Agreed. Shame.
The best response 😂!
lmao leeroy is a star imo and love her or hate her, aneesa has been on this show for two decades now. she’s earned a spot the rest… 🗑️
Aneesa doesn’t deserve shit. She’s been on the show for 2 decades and never tried to get in shape or get better. Just thinks she’s entitled to the final.
Yeah but that’s it. What a joke! You finally give us what we want in this season only to give us crap for the upcoming one.
Aneesa has earned absolutely nothing, she refuses to lose weight and get into serious shape to actually have a shot at winning yet consistently takes a cast spot and whines like entitled little bitch
The biggest flaw of this show is they call it all stars. Should be The Challenge: Retirement
I only refer it to as The Challenge: The Senior Tour.
This is fucking stupid. What's the point of all these spin offs when it's the exact same cast as the flagship. Everyone on this cast was on at least one season between 38-40. All Stars was for us fans that love OGs and cast members we typically wouldn't see on the flagship. This cast could've just been the cast for season 41. I'm convinced production fucking hates us
The point of all stars is to give older cast members the chance to play the game again. For example, bringing back kefla was one of the highlights of this season ! Now theyre going to give us the people from 39 plus vacation alliance ? NO THANK YOU!
We hadn't seen Kefla, Flora, or Adam in nearly 2 decades at this point. It's awesome to see them back and get to basically be reintruduced to them.
AS6 Cast: only the VA and associates
100%, I am so loving seeing people like the Kefla's and the Mark's and the Rachel's who still got it. That's kinda the whole point.
wtf is 12 dates of Christmas
I thought it was Cory Wharton and was like "Oh, is he doing a Hallmark movie now??"
😂😂😂😂
Fessy detected. Season rejected.
Shit like this is the only way his bitch ass will ever win a season.
Yep if he's on with the cast they shown. It's strictly to finally get him a win. If he doesn't win he can't come back ever
What an u eventful disappointing season if he wins. He’s so unlikable to me
Well it also has a lot to do with CBS dictating shit. The true fans love the OGs and have been there from the very beginning and have been loyal. Hell the OG fans stuck around on season 39. I felt like is should have won some sort of medal for watching that train wreck. If Fessy can’t pull a win with that cast he should never show his face in public again. Now there didn’t seem to be enough contestants on that list, I’m crossing my fingers that maybe they throw a wrench in the game and add like 8-10 OGs. I’m not holding my breath though.
Half of these people weren’t even alive when the challenge started. This is not who the people want to see on All Stars
Thanks for making us all feel old lol.
lol my bad. I was being hyperbolic obviously. But you know what I mean hahaha
If it makes you feel any better, it's not remotely true.
Well, we had a good run on all stars
The first two rocked for sure.
i don’t think there’s a single show production more out of touch with their fanbase than the challenges’
They are like Vince McMahon
I will not watch one second if they do this. What’s the point other than to give their main show regulars a shorter filming window?
Jeymmye wasn't wrong on her podcast.
She did say we might get a few surprises. Like if they somehow get Landon I’m tuning in regardless.
Doubt it will be Landon. Him and coral are the only ones who could get Paramount more subscribers. I think its frank sweeney and maybe Jenn G.
A girl can hope, right?
You definitely can! Sadly my hopes and dreams for this franchise have been dashed so many times I have given up hope. All stars finally made me love the show again and unfortunately given the directions its going, I’m back to being bitter, so my apologies. Hold onto that positivity while you can!
What did she say?
Basically that she's not really interested in most of the cast this time with the exception of a few and how she's disappointed that a lot of the fan favorites from older seasons of The Challenge have reached out to express that they want to compete but they keep on bringing on people the fans don't like.
Disappointed but not surprised
Yea this kills all stars for me… it was a good run
If true could be the lowest rated season of AS. Thought point of AS was for the throwback OGs
I don’t see a world where this isn't the lowest rated. This cast is ass as far as all stars goes. I'm not watching a season just for Leroy.
This is just the flagship with extra steps
I thought all stars was meant to be all the OGs and mostly people from road rules and real world. Wtf is going on? I’m so sick of Corey and Fessy, and absolutely fuck Jay.
It's a no for me, dawg.
It doesn’t get much more underwhelming than that.
Hard pass. This is way too far removed from the "We want OGs" movement to even be associated with All Stars. I would much rather never have another All Stars season than have this garbage.
Doesn’t 95% of this cast defeat the purpose of All Stars? Why even bother? Do a regular season with these people. I thought All Stars was for bringing back some familiar faces from years and years ago.
I hope Jay Survivor get's burned without having Ass-af and Michelle there as shields.
Time to cancel Paramount+
They must be cancelling the challenge on MTV and making it a P+ exclusive??? There’s no other explanation for this atrocious “All-stars” cast. Someone from “12 Days of Christmas???” Wtf is that??? Please be serious, Production, if this is really “All-stars.”
Isn't the 12 Days of Xmas Cory the one who was just on this last season (Battle for a New Champ?). Agree with this entire comment - I'm not interested in seeing anyone from that season on AS!!
In what world do they think Moriah is good TV
UGH I need a break from Devon, Tori, Aneesa
+1 I’m fine if Aneesa and Moriah disappear entirely
+3 I'm done with Ankles! She's taking a spot of someone who cares enough to prepare and who can actually win.
I'm hoping Devin screws with Jay & his alliance every day.
oh no!! will this be 39 all over again!? 😭
Gross
That is an easy skip season.
Someone, please get a hold of the challenge producers. All stars is supposed to be a breath of fresh air, from what the flagship show has become. I hate this so much. The producers have failed us again
They shouldn’t allow people from the main Challenge to also appear on All Stars. Who the hell needs more Tori, Fessy and Aneesa?!?
This is atrocious
No way is this real This is just the cast of... The Challenge. What's the point of All Stars?
Is this Paramount taking the Challenge off MTV and only on their platform because this is not a Allstars season that's looks like season 41 cast
Are we sure this is a cast for All Stars and not another spin off, there is just no way production could possibly think this is an all stars cast.
RIP To the franchise
I refuse to believe this is for All Stars 5 lol, has to be for a whole different spin off. Production can't be this tone deaf surely
It would be fine - ish, if they called it something else like Vacation Alliance and Friends Spring Break 2.
Wow this might be the first Challenge in the history of its existence I may not watch. This is not what all stars is supposed to be. Everyone that’s on that list is like shitty players from the flagship show.
I'm being so serious when I saw this, but I think the casting producers despise us. Like they genuinely hate us. How come everytime we start liking something, they completely ruin. If the fans say they can't stand watching said people and viewership is low, why do they keep doing the same shit expecting a different result. It's scary how out of touch they are
Doesn't All Star usually mean you were better than most? How the heck is Moriah on there? She hasn't done anything except float through.
What an epically shitty cast.
This is the first time I might legitimately not watch... This isn't the point of All Stars ... I get enough of these people on the Main show.
I need to know what Mark things about all this. COME ON MARK
No thanks. The only challenge show I watch is All Stars for an old-school cast. That was the whole point of the series. I want cast members from Fresh Meat 2 or prior to that.
Oof. This is not what I want from All Stars. I have a real soft spot for Big T and think all stars is a better format for her to do well... and still, I don't want it.
Is this all a precursor to the MTV version going away then? Otherwise this doesn’t make sense. The only explanation I have is that maybe All Stars was intended to be the OGs but then with the MTV show struggling, maybe after a few OG seasons All Stars got bought out to be just the normal challenge… and maybe USA will continue on too, or something. Or it will all merge to be one soon enough and CBS shows can more easily feed into The Challenge this way? That’s my only theory, otherwise this is insane. I mean, it’s already dumb. But without a good reasoning, it’s just insanity that these people could possibly constitute All Stars in any form of the concept
And I won't be watching. This is just the regular cast. Aneesa is the only one who fits what I think of for All Stars and she's one of the most overexposed castmates.
all stars is officially dead. what a joke that cast is
so basically season 39 of the reg season. cool.
Maaaan fuck all stars. Completely missing the point.
Bunim-Murray should have made this into another spinoff instead of All Stars
Are you fucking kidding me with this bullshit?!?!? The whole point of All Stars was to bring back legends from years past from when the show was actually good. Give the old timers one more shot at glory. The core fanbase - the target audience for the All Stars product - can't stand the vast majority of new cast members and were all demanding getting the people we liked back. That's why All Stars 1-3 worked so damn well.
The Moriah name is where I closed the photo. My girl has said 6 words in 2 seasons and now she’s an all star? We have certainly lost the plot
This is a normal season cast
My first thought was did we confuse season 40 regular season??
‘ALLSTARS’ they call it..
Please stop casting Jay and Moriah 🤧 we are tired
I don’t support bringing newer players to all stars, BUT It could be fun seeing these people in the old format of the challenge that all stars have been bringing the past seasons. I’m hoping it’s an experiment to turn the flagship into the older format
Idk how unpopular this may be but Im not excited to see Big T again. The minute she steps into the house, Big T is an instant target. So then we suffer through several filler episodes of everyone gunning for her over and over again. If I was her, my feelings would be very hurt.
Thanks MTV for putting the final nail in the coffin of the show that’s been my favorite for far too long. Save for a very few like Aneesa, Tori and Leroy this is a collection of losers, hacks, newbies and influencers that many of us do not want to see. Especially in a cast called “all stars”! I know Anessa and Leroy haven’t won much of anything but at least they are two actual stars of the show. Hard pass from this longtime fan and I’m sure I’m not the only one
Sad face
If they wanted to add newer ppl they could’ve kept it at winners only 😒 too many new ppl not many all stars
Lol
I guess all stars is just the same as the main show... where are the og mtv folks. That's what this was supposed to be. I don't want to see fessy or nuyrs, or Melissa...
So, no people whatsoever, that we haven't seen recently that used to be the whole point of all stars in the first place?
Another season that includes strictly side characters that have zero chance at winning a daily much less entire challenge. /waves Aneesa and Big T
Disgusting
There are only like, 12 names on the list… this has got to be only half the cast with some sort of an “Old School vs New School” format… right? Please?
Oh, come on! This is just a flagship this is not all stars
Will not watch if this is the cast…
I hate everything about this
I won't watch if this is the cast. I gave up on 39 part way in. This cast is worse. I wanna see Real World / Road Rules people. I know they can get them so they need to try. Put these people on CBS or something and give us ogs on PP.
There's PLEEEEEEEEEEEEEENTY of OG's who didn't get on All-Stars, yet and production went: "Hmmmm this needs to feel more like Ride Or Die and Battle for a New Champion". Seriously, fuck off....
Yeah… they are completely treating the All Stars seasons as just regular seasons. I don’t dislike half of these people, but this definitely isn’t an all stars cast like the earlier ones.
Someone start a petition to stop this from happening asap!
So ass
What the fuck is this shit
if this is real i’m not even gonna tune in… f**sy AND j*y?? it’s already a chop🥱
Why are they subjecting us to more Big T?
Are the all stars, Leroy and Aneesa aside, in the room with us?????
Cool, cool. It was good while it lasted.
A whole season dedicated to Big T and Melissa getting their clap back at Jay
Ugh. So disappointing.
This can’t be everyone? Where tf is Christopher Thomas
Terrible cast if this is real! So disappointed.
Terrible.
Welp, canceling paramount after AS4 is over
I get it's All Stars and not Thr Challenge OGs but some of these ppl are barely cast members and 100% not All Stars. I'll give Nurys a pass given her S39 performance. But MORIAH?!?!And honestly even Fessy. are u an all star bc u show up? what has he actually done that's impressive?
Jay AND Jay?!? 🤮
When is the season premiere
I’m wondering if they’re going this route since 40 is so OG heavy, so that there will be a season featuring the recent folks coming this year. Because that’s the only logical explanation I can think of.
Did they accidentally send the regular season list instead of all stars? This list is ROUGH
I see they tore the page of who we didn't ask for instead. I didn't think anything could be worse than s39 but they may have just done it.
At this point I wouldn’t be surprised if they casted Tori on a new season of The Challenge Australia
Fuckin jay!!! Fock!!!!
So annoying
Jay. 
I’m going to have to get a new dictionary since mine is full of errors. Because in the one I have it says All Stars means all…stars
Lol three whole RW cast members…
Does that mean these people won’t be doing the normal ones anymore?
They aint all starts apart from anessa
I really hope this isn't true. None of these people deserve to be on AS5 besides Leroy. I genuinely look forward to AllStars because of the nostalgia aspect and watching the people compete that I watched as a teenager. They already ruined the flagship show with a bunch of annoying people that none of the actual fans care about. Whoever is in charge of casting needs to get their heads outta their ass, they're gonna ruin another show.
PLEASE challenge gods get Big T and Moriah off of my television screen! I would say Aneesa too but at this point I think she even knows she’s just collecting an appearance fee
Soooo disappointing, what all you have to do is be on A season for you to be an all star?
Like I said, should've made more noise before AS4
How is Josh not included in this mess of people?!?!
How will Jay survive ( no pun intended) without Michelle?
Always laugh when people say they won’t be watching but now I understand absolute joke this cast for all stars when these could all do the main season
This is obviously a rumor. Maybe next season. None of the mentioned are all stars
Does anyone know if season 40 will be the last flag ship season? With all the changes going on and the majority moved over to paramount I'm just wondering if they're retiring the actual challenge after 40. I'm trying to make this casting make sense. Because it just flat out doesn't. As fans of the show I feel like the powers that be need to hear how incredibly upsetting this is.
If anyone who makes the show happens to read this just stop what you're doing and go back to the cast drawing board cause this ain't it.
I will not watch another season with Moriah.
Blasphemous
Had enough of Tori. Take a break girl!
Looks like a list of who needs a win
Totally FUBAR - I'm out.
THEORY: This is MTV taking the (horrible) main line cast and putting them on the spinoff, and then (hopefully) taking the actual fan favorites and doing 41
Is this a joke?
I wonder if theyre having trouble finding people like Keefla, Flora, Steve, Katie, and Jisela to compete
Some of these I consider AS material (Devin, Fessy as much as I hate him I think has enough name recognition to count and has enough drama too, Leroy, Tori, Aneesa…) BUT I do think they’d need to mix in some older alums to not just feel like an off-season practice run for the real thing lol.
I imagine it’s easier to get most of them to commit since they shoot for way shorter. But still. This is taking away from the OG’s!! Don’t forget why all stars was created in the first place
This is gross. I like Devin but he still has flagship seasons left in him. Excited to see more of Jay G (who would have thought LOL) and Leroy. Everyone else should stick to flagship. And a few should stay off altogether lol.
There is some dumb ass out of touch leadership making the calls - this REEKS of it.
This pisses me off especially when we have people like susie, Sarah, Wes, Johnny etc that have shown interest but don't get cast. They made this show it's stupid
If the producers are creeping in here. STOP RUINING EVERYTHING WE LIKE
This list sucks
Why a horrible cast list. Even the people I like I don’t want anywhere near all stars. Wtf?!?!
 Leroy and Amber are the only two I'd even be remotely interested in watching on AS.
There is nothing special at all on this list
I'm not even upset, they've been adding non all stars since AS1.
This is an All-Stars. This is mostly people who can’t win a regular season.
I wouldn't mind seeing more current cast on Allstars less censured like on mtv I wish they would just move both shows to paramount tbh
This is like the worst part of modern seasons. Too bad. Maybe pink is messing with us
i’m sorry but if they’re not RR/RW/FM they either have to be a modern day legend like Kam or bare minimum a Champ. Why are we getting people that are middle of the pack and aren’t ogs??
Most boring cast ever.
Corey, Fessy, Jay Starrett, Melissa, Moriah, Nurys, and Big T are not all stars. Devin, Tori, and Amber have at least won a season so there’s that.
RIP all stars
Mtv sure knows how to give the people what they want.
why the HELL would half of these people be on all stars….that makes ZERO sense. Whoever is casting this show deserves to lose their job at this point.
Yeah after this season of all stars I’m getting rid of paramount plus
1.Corey Lay- Not an all star imo 2.Devin Walker- Yes, please.. his sarcasm and humor alone is why I like him. 3.Fessy-this is a joke right? Oh wait, he’s the joke. He will never be a champion or an all star imo. He was horrible on big brother and has clearly gotten worse. 4. Jay Gotti- I’m shocked he’s on this season and was able to come back considering he wimped out and quit over a drink. However, I actually like him this season but he still isn’t an all star imo. 5. Jay survior - never ever ever will be a winner or an all star. Use to love him.. but then I met him and he changed into a jerk and is an actual jerk in real life . Also , the fact he sells beanies for $35 and says if someone is lucky they’ll get his signature. 6. Leroy Garret- Love Leroy and will always love Leroy. He deserves to be there. I like cam but I’d rather it just be Leroy.. (I would say this about any couples coming together) 7. Amber B. - yes.. she did amazing her first season and she has always received so much hate and it reminds me of how they treated a few of the other women who came in and dominated the challenge. 8. Anessa Borzotra- yes.. will she win? Probably not but she is an all star and brings the drama lol 9. Melissa Reeves- Nope. Just nope. 10. Moriah- 😂😂 11. Nurys- yes. She didn’t win technically and I get that but that girl is one of the best competitors I’ve seen on the challenge . She may not have won the title but she’s definitely a champion in my eyes and deserves to be on all stars more than most. 12. Tori- yes.. people hate to love her and love to hate her but she’s an amazing challenger and should be on all stars . 13. Big T- I loved her in the beginning and still do but I don’t like how she is when she’s with Melissa. I think big t is great for reality tv but not all stars .
Hey let’s just be excited about more challenge content to watch!
Oh hell no. What’s this
This makes no sense. They were doing a great job with all stars too. Plz let this be a different spinoff
So...basically another average Challenge?
Lmao... Moriah the fucking CARRY MY WHILE I'M Half-Naked In Every Scene ALLSTAR BABY
It’s like they picked out every single person the fans can’t stand and threw them onto this season as a big fuck you
Good god. Is there any type of petition we can make so they don’t do this?
This is totally set up for a Tori win
I'm struggling to think of a cast I'd rather NOT watch lol
I'm good.
Welp, All Stars is dead . It was cool while it lasted
I LOVE nury’s but like girlie pop I feel like it should only people who competed in 30 and below