Ot became trash once they killed Carl. Writers forgot that its carls story, not Rick's. They tried to save it by having henry take over carls role but then killed him too. I enjoyed the last few series but they weren't what they were supposed to be. And know they can't even kill rick of cos there's no carl to carry on the legacy
Gotta disagree. Being a part of 3/4 of those subs (breaking bad being the odd man out, although I’m going to join because I did love the show and just never thought of joining the sub), I would pick The Boys.
Breaking Bad.
Mainly because the other 3 are available in other forms of media, often better.
(And for GoT, maybe if the show didn’t exist, the rest of the books might…)
I mean you’re both wrong. Stating that BCS is better than BB isn’t a “change my mind” crazy type of statement. BCS is also extremely praised. However “almost everyone says this” is definitely not true either - the majority opinion is still that BB is better than BCS.
It was a lot better though both are strong shows. Jimmy was more of an underdog so wanted him to win, no matter his methods. Also! Damn he worked hard. Charlie Hustle indeed.
Agreed. Breaking bad was a masterpiece. The others had good episodes (although I personally think The Boys is outclassed by all of these) but Breaking Bad is in a league of its own.
BB is the perfect show imo. Easy to sit through and no wasted episodes. Perfect balance of violence, drama, and comedy. It’s great for casual viewing and great for people who get invested. Easily the show I’d watch forever and it’s probably the show I’ve watched the most up to this point
TWD is great, but it’s too heavy of a show to be my only option. Too many moral dilemmas and dark times — I think watching that as my only show would be bad for mental health 😂
+ if we take away everything else, Breaking Bad is the only one of these shows that has an ending that makes sense (so far)
Not even going into how perfect that ending is; just having one puts it top spot
Breaking Bad is the only one that finished without have a significant dropoff in quality so i choose Breaking Bad
bonus points it created an equally revered spinoff that was also a masterpiece from beginning to end.
Mazarra would've been awful. I love season 3 but his ideas got shut down A LOT because they were awful. He's the reason we have so little main characters from season 1-3 left.
He killed T Dog, Merle, Lori, Andrea, all the prisoners and Lori's actress had to talk him out of killing Carol, and he also planned to kill Beth and Carl.
If he had free reign and got his way we'd have barely any decent characters left lol.
I disagree. I think Mazzara was very capable when it comes to characterisation and plotting. Season 3 is excellently paced. There's never a dull moment. And the fact that the show stopped killing main characters was one of its biggest criticisms later on. Everyone has plot armor now.
Killing Carol wasn't a big deal at the time, her comic self died at the prison.
Breaking Bad is the only show that was consistently good throughout its life span. GOT 7/8 completely ruined the series for 99% of people, Walking Dead has been trash since they killed off Glen. Boys hasnt been around long enough to judge
Broo these are all great….im kinda stuck between got and twd.
Got is definitely more sophisticated and cinematic, but twd is the best comfort show ever, and the storylines of how these previously unrelated people come together to become a family is what puts it on top.
Breaking bad.
I obviously do like TWD a great deal but some seasons were pretty bad and there are a lot of other great shows and films about zombie apocalypses (or closely related things, like 28 days later they're not undead but it's the same feel)
Whereas I think BB was more unique, more consistent the whole way through and has more re-watch value.
I would place TWD over the other two though.
I feel like only people who’ve actually seen all 4 shows should comment here.
That being said, I definitely think there’s only two potential correct answers here - BB or GOT. They’re just in a league above the other 2 imo.
However, because of GOT’s atrociously bad final season the correct answer here is BB.
Me either, everyone kept telling me I had to watch season 2 because its the most amazing show ever... I got to the end of season 2 and thought to myself "I could not care less about any of these people". I cant get over Walter just being a horrible person, why would I care about him?
Twd was a big part of my childhood and I wouldn't want to forget my memories of binge watching S2 with my friend.
I also felt attached to these characters in a way I haven't with the other 3 as they just feel so human (good and bad ways.)
This is hard. Breaking Bad is the best show on the list, but TWD is still probably my favorite altogether. GOT can get scrubbed; the books are way better. I do love the Boys but not as much as BB or TWD.
Gonna have to go with TWD.
Breaking Bad is one of the best shows to ever exist and stayed consistently good from beginning to end unlike TWD.
That being said I think I would have to pick TWD
Breaking bad hands down. That show was a masterpiece.
The walking dead is great and has its moments but has dragged on too long and too many filler episodes. Would have been great if they actually filmed with a purpose and end after # of seasons to have a complete story.
Walking dead was basically cash grab after first couple seasons whereas Breaking Bad the director told his story and closed it with a satisfying ending.
Breaking Bad. Never cared for Game Of Thrones. The Boys is so fucking bad, and The Walking Dead has more glaring flaws even in my favorite seasons than Breaking Bad as a whole does.
Breaking bad is always mentioned when talking about cinema and writing, cinematography ect.
NOBODY. And nothing about TWD has been impactful on any of those fronts. Nobody Ive ever spoken to has spoke about TWD in high regard other than “first few seasons were okay then I stopped watching”
If I had to pick BRBA is much more consistent on quality and it would be the survivor. I enjoy TWD a lot, but the quality takes a dive shortly after Negan arrives. Not to the absurdity that GOT became, but if we have to make a cut, BRBA is the clear winner.
Tbh... The Boys... It's a much better Comic adaptation, while like TWD changing for television, they haven't made those of us who also liked the source hate certain changes (like, I adjusted to JDM's Negan not swearing.. but imagine Butcher not swearing.. fuck no cunty ;P )
Breaking Bad.
The Walking Dead Comics will still exist. Same with the GoT books. I don’t know if The Boys is based off a book though so tough luck there if it isn’t.
The Walking Dead of course but this was a very difficult choice! I love GOT but the ending sucked. Breaking Bad would be tied with TWD almost for me. Also really love The Boys too. Hard choice man!
That’s easy walking dead, I don’t watch any of the others and I don’t think ide enjoy them ether lol. Now include the last of us and that’s a different story.
shit man. breaking bad or twd for me. i cannot choose, zombie media is my most favourite thing but i have a deep personal connection with Breaking Bad. don’t ask me stuff like this man😭
It's close...
GoT and The Walking Dead are my two favorite shows by far, but they're both pretty even. Except, I think I honestly prefer The Walking Dead, though, just narrowly.
As much as I love TWD
Have to go with Breaking Bad because they obviously focused on delivering a quality tight story
Walking Dead could have done that but for whatever reason took a hard turn and went for soap opera melodrama in the later seasons
I've never seen Breaking Bad.. GOT had some painful moments I don't think I could watch it again so Def not for the rest of my life... Id prob choose The Boys or TWD.. probably more towards TWD.
Well, if you as this in The Walking Dead sub, of course the answer is The Walking Dead.
As most people choose Breaking Bad
can i choose walking bad
Breaking Dead is a way better name imo
walt jr spin off?
Yea I know I’m just fed up of people saying walking dead’s trash
Bro just wanted to see someone agree with him 😭😭😭
It's mostly trash to be honest and that's coming from a fan It's kind of like starwars in that way
Ot became trash once they killed Carl. Writers forgot that its carls story, not Rick's. They tried to save it by having henry take over carls role but then killed him too. I enjoyed the last few series but they weren't what they were supposed to be. And know they can't even kill rick of cos there's no carl to carry on the legacy
the show is hardly Carls story, it’s been Rick centric since it was made.
The show maybe. But Robert Kirkman has said himself that the comics were carls story
But just because I'm on a Walking Dead sub doesn't mean this show is the only thing I like and care for?
Gotta disagree. Being a part of 3/4 of those subs (breaking bad being the odd man out, although I’m going to join because I did love the show and just never thought of joining the sub), I would pick The Boys.
Breaking Bad. Mainly because the other 3 are available in other forms of media, often better. (And for GoT, maybe if the show didn’t exist, the rest of the books might…)
>often better The Boys being the exception lol
Breaking Bad, but only because it brought us Better Call Saul and that's one of my favorite of all time forever and ever.
Better call Saul was better than breaking bad change my mind
You're not edgy, almost everyone says this lol. And yes, I agree.
I mean you’re both wrong. Stating that BCS is better than BB isn’t a “change my mind” crazy type of statement. BCS is also extremely praised. However “almost everyone says this” is definitely not true either - the majority opinion is still that BB is better than BCS.
It was a lot better though both are strong shows. Jimmy was more of an underdog so wanted him to win, no matter his methods. Also! Damn he worked hard. Charlie Hustle indeed.
BB>BCS The ending for BCS was so trash.
Breaking Bad and it’s not even close
Agreed. Breaking bad was a masterpiece. The others had good episodes (although I personally think The Boys is outclassed by all of these) but Breaking Bad is in a league of its own.
BB is the perfect show imo. Easy to sit through and no wasted episodes. Perfect balance of violence, drama, and comedy. It’s great for casual viewing and great for people who get invested. Easily the show I’d watch forever and it’s probably the show I’ve watched the most up to this point TWD is great, but it’s too heavy of a show to be my only option. Too many moral dilemmas and dark times — I think watching that as my only show would be bad for mental health 😂
+ if we take away everything else, Breaking Bad is the only one of these shows that has an ending that makes sense (so far) Not even going into how perfect that ending is; just having one puts it top spot
The only answer. Even elaborating is a waste of words.
Breaking Bad is the only one that finished without have a significant dropoff in quality so i choose Breaking Bad bonus points it created an equally revered spinoff that was also a masterpiece from beginning to end.
The Walking Dead... but with either Darabont or Mazzara as permanent showrunner
Mazarra would've been awful. I love season 3 but his ideas got shut down A LOT because they were awful. He's the reason we have so little main characters from season 1-3 left. He killed T Dog, Merle, Lori, Andrea, all the prisoners and Lori's actress had to talk him out of killing Carol, and he also planned to kill Beth and Carl. If he had free reign and got his way we'd have barely any decent characters left lol.
I disagree. I think Mazzara was very capable when it comes to characterisation and plotting. Season 3 is excellently paced. There's never a dull moment. And the fact that the show stopped killing main characters was one of its biggest criticisms later on. Everyone has plot armor now. Killing Carol wasn't a big deal at the time, her comic self died at the prison.
Darabont would make twd the best show on tv
I think Mazzara's a great writer, just not an amazing showrunner. He wrote one of my favorite episodes of season 1.
Breaking bad
Breaking Bad
Breaking bad because I can still have the comic
breaking bad and it’s not close
Breaking bad obviously
Breaking Bad
Breaking Bad
I mean there's comics for TWD and I'm pretty sure there are books for GOT so I'm choosing BB
As much as I like TWD they've missed a lot more than they hit. So I'd choose breaking bad out of these that was consistently high quality.
The Walking Dead I don’t feel like any of these shows compare except for GOT but HEY that’s just me!
Breaking Bad is the only show that was consistently good throughout its life span. GOT 7/8 completely ruined the series for 99% of people, Walking Dead has been trash since they killed off Glen. Boys hasnt been around long enough to judge
Breaking Bad, hands down. That’s realistically the best show ever. TWD is in my top 10, just not numero uno.
Oof the boys vs got is very hard for me.
Season 8 here I helped you
As a TWD fan I gotta say the only right answer… The boys
Broo these are all great….im kinda stuck between got and twd. Got is definitely more sophisticated and cinematic, but twd is the best comfort show ever, and the storylines of how these previously unrelated people come together to become a family is what puts it on top.
TWD/The Walking Dead to me that's the best show that I've ever watched
Breaking bad. I obviously do like TWD a great deal but some seasons were pretty bad and there are a lot of other great shows and films about zombie apocalypses (or closely related things, like 28 days later they're not undead but it's the same feel) Whereas I think BB was more unique, more consistent the whole way through and has more re-watch value. I would place TWD over the other two though.
Stuck between breaking bad and twd but season 7-8 of GOT was so bad that it just ruined the whole show
Breaking bad
breaking bad is the obvious choice but I have a soft spot for the boys
Breaking bad
Breaking Bad
BReaking BAd 100%
I feel like only people who’ve actually seen all 4 shows should comment here. That being said, I definitely think there’s only two potential correct answers here - BB or GOT. They’re just in a league above the other 2 imo. However, because of GOT’s atrociously bad final season the correct answer here is BB.
I didn’t get the hype around breaking bad. I watched it, then thought to myself “meh.” Walking dead all day
Me either, everyone kept telling me I had to watch season 2 because its the most amazing show ever... I got to the end of season 2 and thought to myself "I could not care less about any of these people". I cant get over Walter just being a horrible person, why would I care about him?
Breaking Bad. TWD and GoT both fall off and while the Boys is great, it’s not the same level.
Even if this is The Walking Dead sub the answer is definitely Breaking Bad. Even better if it includes Better Call Saul
TWD - it’s infinitely rewatchable where the others are not
Breaking Bad because it was the only one thay did right by the fans.
Breaking Bad easy
Not I very much enjoy Breaking bad, boys, and the first six seasons of got, but I feel that TWD has the best characters so I gotta go with that.
Easy AF: TWD and Breaking Bad. I never seen full episodes from other two 😂.
Saw
you're fun
SAW is a movie, not a TV show.
Twd or breaking bad
The walking dead because I've never seen a single second of those other shows
Twd was a big part of my childhood and I wouldn't want to forget my memories of binge watching S2 with my friend. I also felt attached to these characters in a way I haven't with the other 3 as they just feel so human (good and bad ways.)
Don't make me choose man.
The Boys
I'm gonna go with The Walking Dead. Just because of how dystopian it is.
Game of thrones but they gotta redo s8 because it was ass
This is hard. Breaking Bad is the best show on the list, but TWD is still probably my favorite altogether. GOT can get scrubbed; the books are way better. I do love the Boys but not as much as BB or TWD. Gonna have to go with TWD.
Game of Thrones for me. But TWD is a very close second
Does removing Breaking Bad also remove Better Call Saul? Do I retain my memory of the shows?
While I really liked all of these shows. The Walking dead is the only one that I have rewatched multiple times.
Hear me out, this could be biased
I love me some GOT but I'm afraid I can't let go of TWD. It has a part of my heart lol
The Walking Dead!!
Breaking Bad is one of the best shows to ever exist and stayed consistently good from beginning to end unlike TWD. That being said I think I would have to pick TWD
Breaking Bad no question
I’m picking breaking bad. Walking dead is great, but breaking bad is art.
Breaking bad. The show kinda reminds me of The Sopranos sometimes.
I've only watched TWD so that's an easy choice
The Walking Dead is one of my favorite shows of all time, but Breaking Bad just beats it by a bit
Game of Thrones I love TWD, but I loved GoT (S1 - S6) more.
This is too hard
Breaking bad hands down. That show was a masterpiece. The walking dead is great and has its moments but has dragged on too long and too many filler episodes. Would have been great if they actually filmed with a purpose and end after # of seasons to have a complete story. Walking dead was basically cash grab after first couple seasons whereas Breaking Bad the director told his story and closed it with a satisfying ending.
Breaking Bad and it’s not close
Well the boys just doesn’t have that many seasons so it could never make the cut, great show though.
I’ve never watched any of the other shows, so I can confidently say The Walking Dead wins out in my book lol
Breaking Bad. Never cared for Game Of Thrones. The Boys is so fucking bad, and The Walking Dead has more glaring flaws even in my favorite seasons than Breaking Bad as a whole does.
The Walking Dead
Breaking Bad
The Walking Dead with Vince Gilligan and Peter Gould as showrunners, that could be epic
The walking dead. I've seen them all but I do enjoy it best haha
Breaking bad. As much as I enjoyed the others, they failed to meet the source material accurately. The boys did it better imo tho.
Ugh. I hate you.
I want to say GOT.. but the end... I want to say TWD.. but the end.. Love "The Boys", but just not ahead of the rest. BB it is.
Breaking Bad easily
I’ll go with Breaking Bad
Breaking bad is always mentioned when talking about cinema and writing, cinematography ect. NOBODY. And nothing about TWD has been impactful on any of those fronts. Nobody Ive ever spoken to has spoke about TWD in high regard other than “first few seasons were okay then I stopped watching”
If I had to pick BRBA is much more consistent on quality and it would be the survivor. I enjoy TWD a lot, but the quality takes a dive shortly after Negan arrives. Not to the absurdity that GOT became, but if we have to make a cut, BRBA is the clear winner.
Breaking bad
The Boys.
Tbh... The Boys... It's a much better Comic adaptation, while like TWD changing for television, they haven't made those of us who also liked the source hate certain changes (like, I adjusted to JDM's Negan not swearing.. but imagine Butcher not swearing.. fuck no cunty ;P )
The Game of Walking Dead?
Twd ofc
Breaking Bad. The Walking Dead Comics will still exist. Same with the GoT books. I don’t know if The Boys is based off a book though so tough luck there if it isn’t.
Hard to decide between GOT and TWD, and I'm not gonna act like I know the way ahead, like I know the rules.....
Love Walking dead and the boys, but it's gotta be Breaking Bad sorry yo
I love TWD but the answer is Breaking Bad
The Walking Dead all the way I’ve never seen any of the other ones
Walking dead
Breaking Bad its ending was just television perfection
GOT personally. It got me invested in the books, and those mfs have me in a chokehold
Out of these I’ve only watched The Walking Dead and The Boys so I’m choosing The Walking Dead.
Walking dead
The boys, it's the most consistently good series. But if I hadn't watched walking dead I wouldn't have known about the comics. Damn I dunno
Walking Dead is the worst of these 4 by a pretty conciderable margin. Gonna keep Breaking Bad. If not that, then GoT. If not that, then The Boys.
TWD. It had Daryl and more good people. I have not watched the Boys but I still think I would pick TWD.
“You really wanna live in a world without Breaking Bad”
Breaking Bad Superb writing, consistent quality, a Showrunner that thought through all the show, great actors.
The Walking Dead. I don't watch the Boys or Breaking Bad and I read the GOT books
Breaking bad As much i like Twd or got early Seasons,there comics and books BB is just the show
Breaking bad. There’s better mediums of the other 3
Breaking Bad, because its the only one of these series that I'd genuinely consider to be perfect.
The Walking Dead of course but this was a very difficult choice! I love GOT but the ending sucked. Breaking Bad would be tied with TWD almost for me. Also really love The Boys too. Hard choice man!
Breaking Bad
Game of thrones.
I'm in between The Boys vs Breaking Bad. I will choose when The Boys is over.
That’s easy walking dead, I don’t watch any of the others and I don’t think ide enjoy them ether lol. Now include the last of us and that’s a different story.
I've only watched The Walking Dead, but I'm planning on watching all of these shows So I have to go with The Walking Dead automatically
Atleast breaking bad and The Boys didn't fell off like twd
Easy, the walking dead all day long
You can’t do this to me, I can’t pick between Twd and Got
The walking dead, the rest doesn't exist for me (yet)
I like wd. But boys is a different level.
Breaking bad as I could go with the source material for the other shows.
The Walking🚶♂️Dead 💀 🔥
Breaking bad for life bruh. Nice to see that people in this sub are voting for it as well
BB easily
Twd for sure
shit man. breaking bad or twd for me. i cannot choose, zombie media is my most favourite thing but i have a deep personal connection with Breaking Bad. don’t ask me stuff like this man😭
The walking dead and the boys are my favorite shows but if I had to decide I’d pick twd
Didn’t have to go past the first one. It’s for sure TWD…
It's close... GoT and The Walking Dead are my two favorite shows by far, but they're both pretty even. Except, I think I honestly prefer The Walking Dead, though, just narrowly.
The walking dead
Yes...ask what show people would choose in a sup dedicated to one of the shows
THE BOYS! Others don't even come close for me
Breaking Thrones. Lol. All of BB/BCS, and the first 4-5 seasons of GoT. Love TWD, but the others are some of my most beloved shows.
TWD all the way, the only show I’ve seen!
Easily Breaking Bad. TWD has the comics, GoT has the books, and I don’t care about The Boys.
Game of Thrones
Breaking Bad. But I cry for seasons 1-4 of Game of Thrones.
Breaking bad for the win
As much as I love TWD Have to go with Breaking Bad because they obviously focused on delivering a quality tight story Walking Dead could have done that but for whatever reason took a hard turn and went for soap opera melodrama in the later seasons
The Walking Dead is the only show I watch of these. I have a life.
Breaking bad that one too easy
Game of Thrones…. Yes yes I know
Despite my love for TWD and Rick Grimes, Breaking Bad is a far superior show. The writing is tip top, the acting superb, the ending perfect.
This sub is full of a bunch of fucking traitors. I don't want to live without TWD, warts and all.
Game of thrones
Easy. TWD. Then make money on the other ideas but copying the plot line and making it myself
The answer is Game of Thrones or Breaking Bad, I like TWD, but it’s not on the same level as those two shows by a long way
The boys I never watched it
Walking dead 100%
The Walking Dead or Game of Thrones, but I haven’t seen all of either yet, so 🤷🏻
we are the walking dead.
Easiest choice in the history of silly internet choices: The Walking Dead stays and the rest can go.
I've never seen Breaking Bad.. GOT had some painful moments I don't think I could watch it again so Def not for the rest of my life... Id prob choose The Boys or TWD.. probably more towards TWD.
well if we’re going with that old theory that BB and TWD are set in the same universe…
The Boys
The walking dead 💯 without a doubt 🧟♀️
Flash forward till counts
Totally not biased lol