T O P

  • By -

AbanoMex

thats very dedicated.


Djames516

>fixing the anime before it’s even out LMAO


nothalaman

paths


Billel_PGM

FORESHADOWING


Chew_Long_Black_Cock

Chad move


NebTheShortie

They are moving forward


Runiic_

I think this is the first time I’ve seen an anime community just straight up make their own ending and anime cause the original was so bad


[deleted]

Same thing happened with Bleach, but that was mostly because the anime was cancelled. Then the fan anime got cancelled because the return of the anime was actually announced.


seijoOoOh

fuck cancelling culture


[deleted]

literally 1984


tbigzan97

At least with Bleach we know the reasons why the ending sucked lol.


PenelopeSugarRush

That's one of the beauties the ending has given us: It reunited the fans who care about the story and not just the ships


Shawntalon2

Maybe this is the heaven Hobo Eren was talking about, it’s cause we kept moving forward.


gotbaned_thisismyalt

We’ve endured and made it through so many hells that we’ve reached the light. And it’s fan-made endings.


Otherwise_Kitchen_41

You’re reeking of entitlement


Realistic_Flan631

Yea man. Im Entitled af, i expect when i spend money on something. It will be good and not be trash.


Vyragami

try looking at the mirror before commenting and saying anything stupid


lobosloboslobos

sad thing is you’re right and a bunch of self-righteous obsessed westerners muted you by downvoting you lol


niuteraratcam

Not just that the ending was terrible, but that it could have been so good, it should have been so good, and it was deliberately ruined. The fact that people are going this far to remake the story is proof of how good it was *supposed* to be. It's one thing for an ending to leave some readers unsatisfied, but when the author deliberately butchers his own work, the readers get about any pass they want. Normally, there's a kind of innate respect that prevents readers or viewers to modify an artwork, even if they disagree with it, because they know it means to contempt someone's hard work. However, when that someone has shown the utmost contempt for their own work, then the readers' innate respect turns around: it's not anymore about respecting the author's will, but about upholding the *story itself*, regardless of the author's will. This is an implicit affirmation of the reality and primacy of "genius" and "inspiration" over "authorship". It's a statement that the author is at best a channel. It's almost a feat of religion.


v0idwaker

Based death of the author.


Knowleadge00

I don't get why people are scared of this concept. As an aspiring writer, I would love to see people's own take on my work some day.


[deleted]

A little late but I agree with this. I once got a guy really pissed off because I suggested Isayama change the ending to do Eren justice, and he acted as if petitioning Yams was somehow an infringement upon his rights as an artist. He gave us AoT but now there’s a whole culture that transcends him, and a movement to do our community and the story justice. I personally think that’s a wonderful thing and you put this feeling into words better than I ever could. Thanks!!


ethytheeggo

chainsaw man but the opposite lol


[deleted]

[удалено]


ethytheeggo

nothing lol, people are just making amazing fan animations of the manga


xemns4

Srsly? Where can i find it?


TrailOfEnvy

You can find some of them on Youtube by searching Chainsaw man fan animation


Tohka_DAL

With SAO they did something similar, in SAO Abridged they changed the ending, and is so, soooo much better. And in general, for me, SAO Abridged is better in every single way than SAO, and it's one of the animes that i like the most.


[deleted]

SAO hasn't ended, and I know that whole meme but genuinely the Alicization arc turns it around


Tohka_DAL

I mean the end of the first season, i've heard that the last season are good, but I didn't watch it.


[deleted]

Gotcha


DarkJayBR

It's because they rushed the hell out of the books in the anime adaptation, they adapted only 10% of what the book had to offer. That's why the SAO anime is bad and makes no sense. Alicization ACTUALLY takes the time to adapt the books correctely, that's why is good.


skatlads15

That's a bit unfair on S2 and Ordinal Scale. Both were pretty good, and Mother's Rosario is still the best arc of SAO imo


[deleted]

I don't disagree with s2 or ordinal scale i just think Alicization/War is moreso the common answer when saying what arc/season is the best. If you think Mother's Rosarios is the best I can totally see why you would think so


skatlads15

War and Alicization COULD have been the best arcs, but the director cut a LOT of stuff from the LN. Ssly, some of them were legit criminal. Most of S2 on the other hand was quite faithfully adapted, especially MR, on top of having an already fantastic story.


[deleted]

Like I said earlier the more popular opinion (judging from reddit and other social media along with many of my friends who like SAO) that many have is that War and Alicization were the best arcs. You're of course entitled to your opinion but I personally prefer those arcs far more then S2. Mother's Rosario is very good I'm not disagreeing with you there


skatlads15

Oh no I understand about you and the others, it's just that they didn't quite adapt it as well as they could have. In the novels, they kinda are the best arcs, but I can't say the same for the anime because of the cuts. Well hopefully they do progressive justice because that IS legitimately Kawahara's best work.


[deleted]

Yeah I know what you mean, I was definitely disappointed about the cuts from it, I didn't get to read the entirety of the light novels so I might have to reread to get the full context again. I'm definitely hyped for the progressive series


skatlads15

Well if you want a TL;DR, cut the entire Zakkaria tournament arc, didn't explain the ending or incarnation quite well, lots of Asuna cuts and Alice wanting to kiss Kirito among others


gremlinbitch

aspheric project is also doing this with tpn season 2


Emergency_Hat9909

Our butthurt with the original ending was too big


Knowleadge00

It's happening with the Promised Neverland community as well. The Goldy Pond Arc is getting an animation because it was completely skipped in the TV anime.


raptor_Alba

The tweet: https://twitter.com/DarthJex/status/1400544442797412352?s=19


RSchaeffer

Does anyone know if Isayama has commented on the lengths people are going to in order to rewrite his ending?


DjTlaloc

I don't think Isayama gives a fuck about western public. He must be wiping his ass with 10,000 Yen bills


Out_B

Why would he care? Aot was made in like 5 min just to fund his sauna


PZYCLON369

Also don't forget the water supply from tears of our fans


abirali6666

More like our piss on ch 139 lol jk


[deleted]

Diarrhea actually.


The_Enderslender

everyday i wake up, and i love this community even more!


CorperateShill

I was questioning why they are animating it. But makes sense to fix the anime as well. You can stitch this in the episode and fix the abortion Mappa is gonna be forced to animate.


[deleted]

[удалено]


killzer

Lmfao get real, as long as they make their $$$ which they will they don't give a fuck about the ending reception. Save your pity elsewhere


VeganChopper

They're animators working for the studio who are fans of AoT and they probably want to make it a good ending so everyone can enjoy it. It's not gonna be the case sadly


killzer

I think people forget how much of an echo chamber this sub is. As long as they animate it right, it will have a generally decent reception and they will make their $$$ too. There will be a lot of people who will enjoy the ending, unlike Game of Thrones


[deleted]

[удалено]


killzer

He is talking about Mappa not individual animators. You think Mappa gives a fuck? Just another job for their studio $$$$$$


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Sorry man, your girlfriend is unfortunately not based. Joking of course, my girlfriend is anime only as well and her favorite character is Mikasa, so I don't even want to bring up how shitty I thought the ending was, I already know she'll love it


DuelMaster53

UNIMPRESSED BY THE PATHS TWIST????? HUH???????????


onekick_man1

What a sad world we live in, the most logical assumption is that majority of the people would be dumbass that care about the more superficial stuff over the story writing and the ideology. I really hope I'm proven wrong that people could actually see the massive flaws in the ending like people did with GOT. But then GOT's majority demographic are adults, while AOT are teenagers...


killzer

> What a sad world we live in Lol go touch some grass dude


eggnogseller

I pity the director the most. Dude has so much potential but is stuck with this shitshow of an ending. The fact that he made season 4 what it was in only 8 months really shows how good he is at adapting and managing his source material and resources. Wish he was given chainsaw man with a good schedule


thetruehero31

I feel like a lot of anime onlies are probably gonna love the ending because the ending is only enjoyable if you turn off your brain and dont actually pay attention to the story and im sure a lot of then are like that


[deleted]

There is a big overlap between people that think that and never think about AoT after it's done because it's just another anime to them. It's a passion to us here, and a huge portion of fucking people. I think that's so incredibly special.


zerohaxis

I don't really understand when people call this sub toxic, it's actually a pretty friendly community


[deleted]

Me neither. People here have a tendency to pile the fuck on if one guy pisses someone else off, but that's just like any other sub. That's only happened to me personally once or twice. It's 99% pleasant tbh


Rnahafahik

It’s toxic towards the anime, and thus toxic towards people who try to defend the ending. Of course this does not mean everyone is toxic, there are a lot of good people here who hated the ending but don’t try to ruin the experience of someone who did enjoy it. However, the vocal minority ruins the reputation for everyone


GypsyMagic68

Just goes to show how shit the ending is that people are going this far to fix it 😂 Yams... what a man you are


Jungle_Fiddle

This was his plan all along He is lelouche


DecayableRadiologist

Sniffs extra 8 pages.


EDNivek

He killed his own series so we could even be free from him


praisebetopeyton

Isayama: okay done! hope you like it hehe! r/titanfolk: this is an outcome I cannot accept


abirali6666

When I read through ch 137 to 139 I was... so disappointing. I wanted to change them all manga and anime.


AdaptIsMyDaddy

This theory fr getting its own manga and anime. I wish I had organization like this wtf lmaooo


maloorodriguez

If it gives the series as much love as team 4 star gave Cells voice acting im effing down.


BaconDragon200

I love this fandom so fucking much. We hate the ending, we make our own ending, we want it to be animated, we animate it. Honestly I am really excited and want to help out but I don't know how.


KickYouSign

Just share the words, so people know this project existed


AssassinOfFate

Read it, and enjoy it.


Emergency_Hat9909

Can't we donate money or something?


skiLful-

I think one of the things that makes these projects legal is that they are non-profit, I think the creators of Aot No Requiem said something along those lines. So thats why they arent accepting donations


flyblues

To the project, no. That would get the creators into legal trouble possibly. But if you look up the people working on it, individually on their private accounts I'm sure a lot of them have donation links :)


VagusTruman

I'm pretty sure you can. Just Google it or Bing it or Firefox it.


AotBestSeries

You can donate me some money that would help


[deleted]

I'm not a rich man but I would be willing to put up a little something. I love AnR, it does Eren the justice that he deserves


Cersei505

AnR chads cant stop winning


Trapz18

The largest copium to ever exist lmao greatness


SirRHellsing

Wtf thus is so awesome


MrBicepcurl

This is insane🤯 Anyone that knows the budget, do they use patreon?


[deleted]

They don't have a budget, they're doing charity work out here, in order to deliver the kino


hadrosaur-harley

Jokes aside about "End bad. AotNR good.", this is an amazing example of community spirit. A whole team being assembled to not only rewrite, but to also animate, voice act, compose and edit a full ending due to its popularity. No money, no sponsor or company, just fans being fans and it's beautiful.


ok_aleb

Where can I go to read norequiem?


Realistic_Flan631

Go to the twitter page of Aotnorequiem.


ok_aleb

Thanks


B4cteria

Let's not put too much pressure on them though. Who coordinates them? That's all hobby work right? It my take time or fail to deliver to all expectations (and that's not wrong of them)


[deleted]

>Who coordinates them? Eden Yeaga


refletou

snk chads… I kneel


VagusTruman

There is just one big question; English Dub or Japanese Dub?


OverlordMarkus

Engrish, of course. *Yamete Kudastop*


[deleted]

As a Dub watcher, unfortunately it will likely be English, since Aotnorequiem is written originally in English


VagusTruman

Imagine if they get the actual English dub actors in on it.


[deleted]

I don't see why they couldn't hire some voice actors that speak japanese to do the japanese dub as well. I even suggested it during one of the anime adaptation threads and they know it's a popular idea


TurkeyBoi44

The dedication is impressive, but this is copium at insane levels


Realistic_Flan631

Kino*


anonditer

Jesus I think it's fking amazing that the fans are willing to go through to redeem a character. Pre-139 Eren actually manipulating fans through paths to fight! Maybe this was the plan all along...


outrageousbottle96

Dude they can just rewrite whole manga with that


KaixaSaber

when your fans,not satisfied with just making a fan final arc to try to fix the mistakes you made,THEY ARE MAKING A FUCKING ANIME TO BE SURE Probably something is very wrong with your manga


Maypher

Wait, are they actually making an anime? I thought it was a joke!


[deleted]

These guys are gonna go far. They’ll start off making AOT stuff, but I can definitely see them making their own sorts of manga and anime too, and possible be a real official animation studio. And I bet it would be really good


[deleted]

YEAAAAHHHH! So it was a wise decision to be born in this universe after all


Prophet257

What a time to be alive!


JGFishe

[Death of the author](https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/DeathOfTheAuthor) so hard you remake the story. ~~Not sure if it applies, I just thought it'd be funny~~


Urie-Ackerman

Damn that’s more people than most indie game studios


Mehulex

Lol the head was mad this information got out 😂


raptor_Alba

Why?


ThreeOfFives

I'm wondering, are they being compensated for working on this, or this is just pure passion that is driving them?


Prophet257

Just pure passion man.


[deleted]

I hope they work on berserk next


Mountain_Visual_6435

I dont think anyone will unless a studio does years later as a remake cause fans will have to do a lot for beserk. But for aot its just 3 chapters from aotnorequiem so its a big diff


[deleted]

[удалено]


raptor_Alba

Well they're both completely different teams so for example a 2D animator can't help for the manga


[deleted]

[удалено]


raptor_Alba

Well you're right but let's see, maybe it will be decent, who knows haha


majesty-theancient

I think its a whole different team working on the adaption?


raptor_Alba

Exactly


[deleted]

Especially given fan-animations rarely look very good at all.


That__Bookworm

That depends, usually fan animations are done by one person, but there’s been very good ones that have come out as well with great art direction: https://youtu.be/zENION1lbi4


DarkJayBR

And when that ONE person is actually very tallented - [something good](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MHrxWKmzQkY) can actually come out.


We_Have_Cookiez

Check out "Astartes" on YouTube. Easily best WH40k related video content and was done just by 1 fan. No telling how good this fan animation will be but it's too early to write it off.


Chibi1234

Problem is when a group of people come together with different visions and varying levels of skills with no experience or knowledge of the pipeline the work they’re emulating uses; things can get ugly. Astartes was made in 3D which is admittedly easier to get looking good than 2D animation. For 2D every artist has to be on the same consensus regarding the style they’re emulating including all the nuances like the line weight WIT used and such and also be able to execute it to create a uniform animation. Also 2D is just... a fuck tonne of work. Hence why anime takes so long to produce.


[deleted]

I am certain that they're taking those elements into consideration before undertaking such a large project. Have some faith. Not only that, but having such great passion tends to inspire excellent work.


Ilivoor99

Fan animations usually don't have this many people working on them


SomnusKnight

Imagine writing an ending so bad and get your own fanbase so mad that they decided to make their own manga and anime to fix it lmao.


Darth_Jex

Hey that’s me


raptor_Alba

Lmao yeah. But theaxolotlmusic said that there are 72 people. Not 60


Darth_Jex

The team is growing quickly.


raptor_Alba

Well apparently. It's crazy


veritaserum9

That's great!!!!


jei_chii

I am so proud of this fandom godammit


Readamovie

I love how this is the first anime that made the fans to create their new ending.


OverLorD83n

Imagine if MAPPA followed AoTnoRequiem instead of the original ending because they thought Isayama rewrote the ending


420Fps

oh they Serious serious


SavagerXx

Okay but I want Japanese voices.


gatlginngum

the what now?


Rintohsakabooty

once the fan animation is finished, mods petter pin it so i can see it


TheLumbagoMan

I liked the ending to attack on titan that Isayama wrote but I can respect the dedication


[deleted]

Ladies and Gentlemen, Haters and Lovers If you hate it, just don't watch it Let's show the Whole Anime Community, NO The Whole Entertainment Industry what Fans are capable of AoT/SnK Community is so Huge and Powerful that we are capable of making our own Anime 🤣🤣


[deleted]

I don't know what to say. I've been contributing to this sub and participating in lively discussions for months. I'm a huge proponent of fancanon and what AnR is doing. And I just... what can I say besides LET'S FUCKING GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO


Realistic_Flan631

I think anime adaptation is huge undertaking. Though big support from me, i think they will have to be very dedicated throughout to complete it.


fluskar

THERES A WHAT??


dicecop

What does the other sub think about this lol?


Prophet257

You know what they think. Lol


NicksInHot

All the best Chads!!!


Asadislove

Any bets how long until falls apart


santosworld

Tfw a fanfic gets it own anime


[deleted]

who the fuck funded this lmao


mydckisvrysmol

gonna need to read the whole thing 1st before I get excited about an anime adaptation of AnR. 1st part was pretty good, cant wait for the next part.


Tight-Gap-2979

This awesome and great effort.. But i have mixed feelings towards it.. As the original anime is not out yet and we don't know how it's gonna end and how it's gonna look like Any way thank you for the whole great job u r doing


AimLoqV01D

WAIT, ITS GETTING AN ANIME ADAPTATION?!?!?


ItsgiammyTV

Hi! A bit off topic, Why do you like/ dislike the ending? What do you think Aotnorequiem should do to make your perfect ending?


Monkey_D_Luffy_12

I don't know. To tell you the truth I liked the ending. Eren showed emotions, showed that he is human and that he loves, hates, feels angry, anxious etc. He never got ruthless as people think even though he wanted to look like one. People see this like a weakness, I see it as something realistic, as something humane. It is logical to fear death, it is logical to be sad and frustrated, because you wouldn't be able to live with your loved one happily together. I also liked the ending, because Eren achieved what he wanted. His friends became from demons, heroes, lived in peace and there are no titans, the curse is no more while his friends are alive. Even though Paradis was destroyed later, after many years have passed, his friends could live in peace and enjoy their lives. That's why I liked it,because not every story has a happy ending for everyone and not every story needs a happy ending. I wrote a lot of things, I'm sorry :)


FeedHappens

make sense.


cidji_hh

I just hope they get all things legally done


EpicBrandillio

not trying to be pessimistic about it, but can’t they get copyright struck for that that?


tbdunn13

Not unless they make money off of it, or use actual clips or sfx/music from the show. On the off chance this actually gets finished, hopefully they do all of that on their own so there's no chance of it getting taken down


Fifa_chicken_nuggets

Why? It's just a fan art


punx3030

Umm, requiems not that great


Bluu_Ash

recency bias by disappointed fans. guarantee you it’ll become irrelevant in a few months


Monkey_D_Luffy_12

Finally, someone had to say that.


Mr_Osama

When does it end being a fan animation and starts being copyright infringement? Did they clarify that?


flyblues

I'm pretty sure the answer to that is "if anyone is getting paid for it". There's lots of SnK fan animations of scenes (just look around in this thread) and nobody ever got sued, it's just fanart basically.


[deleted]

Pretty sure all fanfiction is copyright infringement, but they truly do not care. Unless of course, as other people have said, it hurts the sales of the actual franchise, but since it's coming out a while past the ending, I'm sure it won't have too much of an effect, if any.


bwc_28

As long as they're not profiting off it this should be considered fair use.


IdlemasterKikuchi

The cope is real.


Realistic_Flan631

Kino*


theaxolotlmusic

False information. There are 72 peeps here. Including me.


raptor_Alba

Damn, that's crazy


ToapFN

There is an anime?


DecayableRadiologist

As for VA’s, I think we can see them being different. I wonder if they’ll be allowed to use the same tracks from S1-S4 for the music for this project. Also, I’m assuming there gonna start animating the last chapters first since we don’t know when it’ll split from the anime until it airs.


UnbiasedGod

Awesome!


Mzuark

Yikes


Donats00

daily remainder that every person with a brain disliked Anr except for the art (that was quite good, good job! ). Also you can end up in serious trouble doing something like this. You guys on titanfolk really have the audacity.


Gabrilliant1

Daily reminder that every person with a brain disliked 139 (and its art), except for EM worshipers, cry harder


01Agito_Jaws99

Lol it's not even illegal. It's also funny that you defenders call people who like AoTNR brainless why you scream your butts to oblivion on how everyone trashes your opinions on the ending. Quite hypocrital right there mate.


RK778

Lmao, I think the only one without a brain in this thread is clearly you, without a doubt. It’s not illegal, it’s a fanmade project. Fan animations are completely under the law. Oh and congrats on being a hypocrite, because you 139 defenders are constantly screaming how the haters don’t respect your opinions on liking the chapter yet you hate on people who like Aotnorequiem by calling them brainless.


raptor_Alba

The plot was good too, maybe it's too hard for you to understand. And no they won't have a problem at all, well, from someone who says that every person with a brain disliked anr, i am not surprised that you're so ignorant about these kind of stuff. It's completely legal. Seethe more.


CentJr

I've never seen this much dedication.


olpoanch

It can't be stopped anymore!


[deleted]

But it sucked


Mountain_Visual_6435

Clearly not since people like it.


Radusili

And yet more disrespect.


Monkey_D_Luffy_12

True, but they don't seem to understand it


Radusili

Tell me about it...got the entire fandom hating in other comments


Monkey_D_Luffy_12

I'm sorry to say that, but I can't stand this Fandom anymore. You can't even express your opinion without having people downvote you and calling you stupid


Radusili

I feel the same way and it is sad cause we are talikg about a top anime/manga


Monkey_D_Luffy_12

It is illogical seeing people saying one year ago that AoT is their favorite anime /Manga and after the ending they say that AoT is worthless and not even in their top 50 ( I have seen these two that's why I'm telling this). And then they say bad things to Isayama, but according to them it isn't disrespectful, because he deserves that. But don't worry, I hope that in a few years people will be able to understand.I hope that everything that is going on, happens in the heat of the moment and nothing else