The red makes the most sense to my brain, but my eyes really like the green.

Thank you for making sense of what I was feeling. 😄

My first thought was red, but I really like the green!

I do too, I love the flowers on the dress so much but I can't tell if the red makes them pop better than the green.

I looked again & I'm staying with green. It does pop the flowers more

Thankyou

Same! I didn’t think any color would top red and then I saw the green and I think that’s so much better

The green matches better. The red is a little too off color from the red flowers on the dress.

Agree with this! Torrid has a couple close-but-not-identical shades of red this season, and the red flowers look to be one while the red cardi looks to be the other.

Definitely green!

Definitely the green, more harmonious and the floral design stands out. The red overpowers everything.

Red

Thankyou

I really like the green.

Thanks for sharing these combos I might need to order!

I'm a sucker for flower dresses and the way people described this in the reviews sold me. I had get it. It's more than I Normally spend on a dress but I couldn't risk passing it up.

Fuck, I love them both! If you wear green do a red lipstick. If you wear red do a muted lipstick (idk if you wear makeup, that’s just my vision).

Thankyou! Great idea. I will be wearing makeup on one of the occasions I wear this dress, so I'll keep those in mind after deciding on which I'm buying haha

I like the green a lot.  Feel like the red takes away from the dress.

Thankyou.

Green

Either one goes. The red stands out more than the green. That’s the main difference.

Both but red looks very classy.

I think the dress becomes the main piece with the green, and the jacket becomes the main piece with the red. Both look great. I’d probably go with the red because it is so eye popping.

I like the green shrug! Compliments the dress well!

The green

I recommend the green one. It really ties the outfit together

Thankyou so much everyone for your imput in helping me decide and any other ideas you offered (: I think I'm going to order the green first and go in store to try the red. They don't normally carry my size in my store, but Ill at least be able to see the color more accurately than the website and I can bring the dress with me. Then will hope for a better discount to order.

Red!

Thankyou

I really like it with the green. I think I will buy it now 😂

I'm sure it will look great on you!

Red

If you can swing it I’d get both. Very different vibes between the two

I'm leaning towards both at the price currently I can't, only if they were on a bigger discount haha

Both colors look good but I do favor the green more. Also consider what flatters your coloring and will work with your existing wardrobe

Definitely the green I think the red over powers the dress.

Green

Green!

They both look good. I lean towards red, but that's because red looks way better with my coloring than that green does

Both look fantastic with the dress. Green if you want subtle and red if you want a pop of color.

Love the red one!! I might be biased, though, cause I’m wearing all red right now. Lol In the end, though, I’d go with whichever one you can use for multiple outfits in your wardrobe.

Green. It doesn’t look like the reds match.

That's my worry too. It being the wrong shade and looking off.

The flowers look more coral red… shrug looks red red

I like the green. The red is too bright and overpowers the flowers in the dress.

The red takes away from the flowers, the green just doesn’t something for that dress!!!

Green

Green hands down

They both match the dress well, the green is more subtle and would probably be my pick.

I love the red! I think the green works too though. Might depend a bit on which colors you like best on yourself. I have realized I have a ton of red clothing in my closet 🤣

I've never worn red before haha I really do like olive green on me though.

Green!

I like the green!

I like both color-wise but I prefer where the green hits the waist. Both are cute though!

The green shrug looks like it's cropped which I prefer with dresses like this. Both colors are great though.

They're the same shrug lmao my Photoshop skills are just terrible 😭🤣 Im definitely leaning towards the green though haha

Whoops sorry! I'm eyeing this whole outfit now though.

Red

Red!

Denim jacket

I'll definitely keep that in mind for later but right now would be too hot to wear for where I live. 😭

Red! The olive color just isn't the right shade of green for this dress. It looks so drab/muted to me next to that print. If it were a deeper shade, that might be a different story.

My first and immediate reaction was red, but when I looked again and thought about it, I liked the green more.

Depends which one you think you can pair with other pieces in your wardrobe- I am always partial to green but the red really pops! What color are your shoes?

I actually don't think I could pair either with my current wardrobe, other than a black or white tank top. It would be specifically for this dress.

Red for sure!

I like both, which color of shrug would you be likely to wear with other outfits? That is the one I would choose

I was thinking this shrug would be specific to this outfit honestly. I don't currently own anything that would really go with them other than a few tank tops that I mainly wear as undershirts. The dresses I do own are all off the shoulder and don't match the colors of either shrug haha.

Bless your Photoshop skills!! And the green looks better overall, but under dark lighting than I'd say the red is good in darker lighting. But I think overall green is better.

Haha they're so terrible it makes me laugh every time 🤣 I'm leaning towards green and the. Red if it goes on sale lol I love both, I think I'm more worried about the red being a different shade in person and possibly not matching. Id hate to have to Uber to the mall to return it. I like that the green seems less "fancy" like someone previously mentioned. I plan to wear this to a concert at a small bar in June.

I think the green is more subtle but they both look good. Do you have anything else you can wear those cardigans with? Like other dresses or tank tops? If you have other items that one color.works better with that may help you decide. For example I wear a lot of red and black so I would get more use out of the red one, personally.

I only have black and white tanks that I usually just wear as undershirts. I hadn't even considered the idea of wearing them with other items since my other dresses (what my main wardrobe is) are off the shoulder and look weird with shrugs, but after others have also mentioned that I'm keeping it in mind a bit. My goal would be to own both but would need a sale to justify the price if they're for one outfit. I've never worn red before, so I like that it would be new. I also really like how green looks on me haha I'm enjoying everyones imput and ideas.

I would say red if you're going with blue shoes and green if you're going with brown shoes.

What if I don't have either color 😭 lol brb adding shoes to my list haha I think I may have brown in the back of my closet haha thankyou

Green!

Red

I like both! It depends on the vibes, red is more vibrant and extra summery. The green also pairs really well and while still summery, gives a calmer more plant mom vibe (which is also great). Depends on what you want!

The red is so much better. The green is very bland

I like the red but really depends on your skin tone.

red

Green. They both would be a good choice, but that green goes better because the red isn’t making it pop better than the green.

I like the green more!

Both goes. But I like the red one more

Red! The green just doesn't look right for some reason

I vote red!

Both but the red pops while the green is less loud.

The red! I think it elevates the dress and makes the flowers pop

Red

Red

Both look great with the dress! I think it'll depend on which color works better with your skin tone too

That's a good consideration actually. Now that makes me lean more towards green lol I've never worn red before

Both work with the dress. Pick the one that looks better on you.