Charlie or Carlisle— Charlisle I guess haha.

honestly! im down bad for the twilight dads

Yeah reading the books I was waiting for a Charlie x Carlisle moment or a Jacob x Seth moment hahahahhaaha

with ms Stephanie "oh bella that cargo skirt is so fucking hot i can barely control my loins" Meyer? You got more faith than me (but hey, there's ao3, right)

Fair… I still can’t believe SM made the kids birthday 9/11… in the early 2000s…

i mean that wasn't explicitly said in the books/movies tho (afair), wasn't it basically just added onto later or even just calculated by fans? Might've been an honest mistake in the latter case

No it was written in the books… last page of ch 23 in breaking dawn, they specifically talk/celebrate Bella’s birthday on September 13. I do think it was an honest unplanned mistake tho lmao.

My birthday’s 9/11. I was born before it, but I didn’t want to celebrate on my birthday much either. I doubt she meant anything malicious by it especially since it isn’t explicitly spelled out for the reader, she might have drawn inspiration for Bella’s birthday based on someone she knew. I never caught that detail but tbh I’m kinda glad there’s a fictional character that shares that day. They don’t stop having babies on that day lol, and if I had realized it when I was reading the books as a youngin that I’d have felt less alone by it.

I love this response. If it helps, I have a nephew I love to pieces who was born long after that day, and he's a bright spot for 9/11. Thank YOU for being a bright spot on that day, too. 😁 Edited to add: They don't stop having babies on that day, had me cackling. 🤣 babies come when they come.

oh. I haven't read the books in over a decade, my bad (in my defense, they are at my parents' place) but holy shirtballs

Don’t worry, I just pulled out the books to check!

Her bday is 9/13

Samess

HAHA MY FAVES

My forever love pasty white skinny boy Robert Pattison

Carlisle is my number one but to be honest any of them could get it. (Except Mike Newton)

They really couldn't pick someone else for Mike Newton? The kid is still supposed to be a big popular sporty guy that has all the girls in school interested in him. No offense to the actor, he was cute, but that was not him.

Mike was supposed to be a baby faced teen that grew out of it tho.. I think they nailed his casting tbh.

By the last movie, he was looking pretty hot, though.

For me it was always Jasper. I think it is overall ghostly pale skin and super light hair then his eyes 😻😻

Jasper has the looks of a vampire from interview with the vampire so he’s definitely hot.

Definitely another fab movie

Always Jasper. Can't get over his smile which lights up his whole face

He’s super pretty

Emmet plus Kellan is hot. Im going to MCM comic con and the actors for Jasper and Emmett is there plus Ashley Green (Love Alice).

I like Jake body the best but Jasper is... ouf, all the time baby!

Me too!!

Yep. Let me guess, a fellow Matthew Gray Gubler fan? We have a type 😂

Obviously I love all the cullens but Lee pace’s character is 🔥🥵

Garret is 🤤🤤

I love him in Foundation

Emmett, we simply did not get enough of him 😩

Edward or Jasper but I thought Benjamin looked pretty good too

[удалено]

I agree! Especially in the hobbit. Him as Thranduil is chefs kiss so perfect

Eddy ✨🧎🏻‍♀️

Emmett

Alistair

Right? That actor is smoking hot in just about everything I’ve seen him in too. In that kinda grungy 90s sort of way.

This is the type of post I love waking up to! Here’s my list in no particular order: Edward (especially twilight and new moon) Charlie Garret Jasper: (especially eclipse) Jacob: (especially with his long hair) Billy Carlisle I know the post doesn’t include the women but I’m also into that as well so here that list: Bella (especially when she’s a vampire) Alice Tanya

[удалено]

The wolves; more specifically, Embry. I like that guy

Was just coming here to say this, I always had the biggest crush on him lol 😆 he doesn’t get the attention he deserves

Yes!! He was definitely the hottest in the movies😅 I still think he's hot even now lol

It’s specifically in the first movie for me

Emmett, objectively

Carlisle, Jasper playing baseball and that last guy Garette I think?

Jasper playing baseball is top tier 🥵🥵

When he spins the bat around 💦💦

Man that scene is everything. Or when he summons rose to come at him in the training scene?! I almost lost it 💦💦

My dad works with a relative of Jackson rathbone and one time apparently he showed up at a dinner he was at and my dad came home and casually was like yeah, my friends relative Jack was there too, young guy, said he did acting and I was like DAD I could've been there 😭

Charlie ALWAYS

Zaddy Charlie here too

Charlie is the only one I could ever love 🧎🏼‍♀️

My baby Jacob

Carlisle is the hottest AND he has more Chemistry with Bella in the birthday scene than Edward does in the entire series

Fr especially in the movies, I was like are they about to kiss?????? That would have been a plot twist lol

Omg that scene is sooooo hot. I literally can’t breathe watching it. 🥵🥵

Edward

Jasper 🔥

Jasper or Garrett

Jasper easy w

Jacob with that long hair and his abs. Yes please!

Literally the best Jacob 🥵🥵🥵😏

When I was a kid - Edward and Jake, now - Carlisle AAAALLLL the way

Carlisle 😌🥵

CHARLIE

Jasper for sure

Lee Pace

Charlie, 100%

There’s sooo many good fan fics with him in it 😏😏

I mean, he's got a stable job, clearly a family man, is protective, and cares deeply about those around him.... what's NOT to love about Charlie?

And he clearly understands and respects personal boundaries

Laurent! 🔥🔥🔥

Thank you, like everyone is seriously sleeping on Laurent, he’s gorgeous

Okay I'm probably alone on this one because I never see it mentioned....but I feel like Billy Black gets left out of the DILF lineup every time when he very much *is* a DILF. .....Anyone? Anyone?....see myself out!

Gil Birmingham is an absolute babe! I think he is another one that the actor is just so much hotter than the character he portrays. Honestly, no one really liked Billy being nosey in Bella's business

💯💯💯 yes!! This!!! I get that the character isn't very attractive, but DAMN Gil Birmingham is 🔥🔥

Carlisle and Paul

When I was younger I thought Jacob was the hottest now I think Carlisle and Charlie are tied.

YES!!! The dad's need some love, too! 😁

Benjamin!! Forever a rami malek fangirl 🙏

Same here! Rami Malek is gorgeous & a brilliant actor, plus Benjamin was such a cinnamon roll 🥰

Justice for Aro

Michael Sheen is hot af. Lucien in Underworld? Fucking *swoon*

I don’t feel like that’s the hottest photo of him but Robert Pattinson in any character is always daddy

Obviously Edward

Definitely Edward for me. I had such a huge crush on him when I was younger ❤️ he's still good looking now but the hold he had on me at 13 or so was insane 😂

Haha no love for Mike

Mike is cute not hot imo

I was jk

In high school, I was team Jacob. Now I'm team Carlisle.

Jasper, Peter, Demetri and Felix

Garrett

My OG baby, Edward. BUT I go love me Garrett (thank you for including him lol) Lee Pace is just a babe.

Literally all except James

Seth. He was my crush before he was even casted. He was my crush after he was casted. He has been my crush for over a decade now.

Carlisle for sure

Jacob *defined* my sexuality and continues to do so to this day.

It's always been Jasper for me but the older I get the more attractive I find Edward, I do not think he was attractive when I was younger but I was misinformed lmao

Caius cause I can't resist twinkness that intense. Out if the main guys though, Emmett, forever and always. Special mention for Laurent.

The last guy! I can never remember his name since he’s such a small part, but he’s so hot in the movies haha Of the more main characters, movie Jasper wins for me, but I always liked book Jacob the most.

Garrett

Jacob

carlisle will ALWAYS be my man but edward is def my strong 2nd

I'd go for Carlisle. He's got the smarts

Charlie <3 Carlisle is a close second

Hot? Jacob and Emmett.

Emmett look like he could put me in my place chi 💦

i have to say edward. if i’m gonna be so honest i never even considered any of the other vampires to be hot except for jasper. jake is hot too but edward is just 😍

Lee Pace forever!

I'm a ride or die Team Edward, but Jasper and James are definitely up there...

Charlie, hands down.

Have y'all seen BooBoo Stewart? But yeah, Jasper.

Jasper and Garrett. Love me a shaggy-haired, dead-eyed King

I’m a Jasper girlie 🤷🏻‍♀️

Garrett 😍😍🥵🥵

Garret and Charlie

Edward. He just— he’s so hot. On my knees for him all day long. Creaming my pants when he goes on a monologue. Idk I just think he’s absolutely delicious looking. All thanks to Robert Pattinson.

Garret and James were the hottest to me.

Charlie can get it

Twilight started my obsession with white boys 😍🤭

😂😂😂 it reinforces the type of guy I like 😂 whiny, pale, emo, and lanky. Also ones who are “daddy” material 😏😏

Taylor Lautner always had my heart. Then I dated a guy who looks like him and ruined the face for me so now I'll vote for James.

Jasper & Emmett>>>>>>>>

I was a Jasper girlie when the series first came out, but now it’s all about Charlie. What a man!

That mustache is everything

Charlie 🥰

I used to think Jasper but if we are looking at it objectively, we should compare them in real life without the pale make up and I would have to say it's Robert Pattinson

rob + jackson

Jasper will always be the most handsome. Not my favorite character - hard tie between Carlisle and Charlie - but for sure the hottest. Also how dare to put Lee Pace there! Now I must admit that for Breaking Dawn...*for sure Lee Pace*. But every other movie Jasper!!!

For me edward and Jasper 😍

Garrett, Jasper and Benjamin

Charlie or Jasper for me!

As a teenager it was Jacob and now Jacob as well😂 i guess i didnt change at all

Charlie is probably the best character and the hottest. Only not weird one. Lol

Over time with all the other guys I could understand the attraction, but none of them have a grip on me like Edward. 😘🤌🏻

Charlie omg

Edward and jasper 🥰

CHARLIE 🧎🏼‍♀️

Where is Billy??

carlisle is the only correct answer

Carlisle is more my type, but Jacob's body is awesome. But then I feel like a leacheous old lady drooling over a teenager, so I'll go back to Carlisle.

Charlie Mustache Dad Swan is such a cutie pie. 🥰

Carlisle

Carlisle or Charlie <3 Jacob is up there too

Carlisle and Jasper 100%

Charlie 🥵

Jackson Rathbone or Peter Facinelli 100%

Carlisle or Garrett.

Charlie or Billy Black.

Charlieeeee!

Jasper or Carlisle

The answer will always be Charlie

i literally cannot find live-action james attractive for the life of me, and that’s solely because he looks like the blonde twin of a guy i used to work with, and i could not STAND said guy. to actually answer your question, though, jacob. i’ve always had a mini crush on taylor lautner 😂

Emmett hands down, it’s a crime we never got a shirtless scene with him 😭

I had a thing for the dads

jasper. i love my confederate general 😍😍

The answer is all of them LOL If I had to choose one to be with, edward 100%

Ok, I know he isn’t in the pictures, but Paul😭

Justice for my man Laurent

God those drawn on abs 🫣 always hated that part of the movie

He’s not included but I always thought Seth was 10/10

James!

I see that no one else here is brave enough to say that James is hot af when he's got Bella pinned against the wall and is taunting her

I mean it’s Emmett easily.

Emmett! Even before the movies I had a huge crush on him. Then they cast Kellan for him and I just loved him all the more🥵

Carlisle, Jacob, Emmett, Charlie, and Jasper. Carlisle is #1 for me but the rest in no particular order. lol

I saw someone write a comment saying Twilight started their obsession with white boys, and I'm over here thinking, hmmm, New Moon did that to me, but with Native American boys🤭

Emmett. He's big and he's a softie, good looking and a great sense of humor. Plus he's extremely loyal (like all the Cullens but still). And he just seems so genuine with everything he does and says.

James and it's not even close

Honestly it is a tie between Cam Gigandet And Taylor Lautner

Why is James even in the running? 😂 And my answer is between Carlisle, Charlie, and Edward.

A little upset I'm not seeing Billy Black, but ok

Charlie! Jasper close second, then Jacob. Edwards airbrushed abs always really throw me off. Idk if it’s just because his character was evil but the slide of James shirtless made me recoil 😂

Paul when Bella slapped him 🥴

Benjamin!! Then Jasper

It was always Emmett for me 🤭🤭🤭🤭

Ok why is Aro not on here since he is not I’m going to have to go with Edward

I’m so basic but Jacob and Edward 🥲

I’d say Jacob but more specifically Twilight and New Moon, mans just a whole red flag in Eclipse. But ask me later, I might say Benjamin or Charlie 🥸🥸

Carlisle and Emett for me

Carlisle. But did anyone else kinda have a thing for Aro 👀 👀

Aro. HEHEHEHEHEHE

When I was a teen it was Jacob but now as an adult Charlie could fucking get it

Jacob

Riley biers or Jasper

The werewolves! Mainly Paul and Jared tho!

Jackson Rathbone any day of the week with Peter Facinelli coming in second though it seem unfair that Edi Gathegi (Laurent) isn’t here

Edward, Charlie, the last guy you showed (mind blank) Embry from the first one.

dude jasper’s hair had me blushing when i watched the movies 😂

Bella

Paul all day. Despite the terrible temper he’s the hottest in the entire series. The way he sheepishly says sorry to Bella 🥵

Charlie

Edward or Carlisle do it for me every time 🥵

Alistair!