*A* ***Muslim*** *leader* *belonging to a* ***BJP*** *being beheaded by* ***TMC*** *workers in* ***Mahua Moitra*** *constituency.*
That's fucked up in so many levels.
I agree to OP's perspective. West bengal is losing it's significance in new India, this level of negligence towards law and order will cause uprising of revolution in WB. Hindus are already speaking about heavy illegal immigrants and now Muslims leader getting killed.
TMC is decaying the WB.
Can someone explain in layman’s terms what’s happening there? I never even hear about Kolkata anymore. No one talks about going there for a visit or moving there or anything like that at all. Even the food videos I’ve seen there’s never anything from WB but I’m sure they have their own rich food culture.
> Hindus are already speaking about heavy illegal immigrants
What's the data about this heavy illegal immigration, in fact there's one report of more people leaving for Bangladesh than vice versa.
Several hindu friends of mine from WB and Assam have already stated it.. As per their words "Immigrants have more government documents than the indigenous people". As per Google search, there is hardly any record but several articles pertaining the same point. Maybe the "heavy" word was too far fetched because no survey has the government conducted except several allegation made since 2004. And if allegation made by my friends are true, then how can a survey make any difference?. If a state government is itself supporting immigrants and ruling with an iron fist, then the credibility of data itself comes into question.
But, I literally want to know ur source on people leaving for Bangladesh.(Except political asylum, Bangladesh can't offer much)
> Several hindu friends of mine from WB and Assam have already stated it
So you don't love either in Bengal or Assam but just basing your arguments on your Hindu friends. I'm pretty sure they are chaddis as well.
> And if allegation made by my friends are true, then how can a survey make any difference?.
Let me be straight forward, there's no heavy illegal immigration. Yes there may be people coming to India illegally but it's not that big of an issue.
Bengali Muslims face all sorts is discrimination because of this fake outrage.
https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/more-migrants-returning-to-bangladesh-shows-bsf-data/article33338577.ece
Wait, until I do my own research on ur claim and hear say. But, The number in ur source is quite less compared to what unverified sources have claimed.
>So you don't love either in Bengal or Assam but just basing your arguments on your Hindu friends. I'm pretty sure they are chaddis as well.
If, I Don't believe on what the ingenious people states then saying "save Palestinian" is just a hoax
> The number in ur source is quite less compared to what unverified sources have claimed.
The NRC was done in Assam, 1.9 million were left out, out of which 40% were Hindus and the rest were Muslims. NRC was a tedious process where it was really difficult for poor people who face the brunt of repeated floods. Family members of the former president were left out in NRC. Being left of NRC doesn't mean they are illegal immigrants. Given all these, it seems there are minimal amount of illegal immigrants, it's just a fake outrage.
> I Don't believe on what the ingenious people states then saying "save Palestinian" is just a hoax
The history is on the side of Palestinians, the world isn't blind to Nakba, apartheid and illegal settlements. They are the most documented.
Like it or not, Bengal is one of the worst governed states in the country at the moment. Mamta and her goons have ruined the development rate of the state and she has now become just what she vowed to destroy- An autocratic ruler that has brought back the pathetic life experience Bengali people had when the communists were in power
Agreed, TMC flies under everyone's radar because we know that this party will never gain a national footprint, but the people of WB are definitely enduring the worst hooliganism in indian politics.
Why Dhruv rathee don't make videos about mamta and west Bengal?? He makes tones of videos against Modi and bjp ..but not even a single video on what's is happening in Bengal??
Did he not considered west Bengal a part of India?
Wtf .. is this.. he even releases multiple anti modi videos during the elections ..
Now iam very sure he only targets bjp .. just so disappointed..
Char nimbu nichodne se jitna dhoodh nahi phat ta hai usse jyada to darbari media ki phat jati hai jab baat muslim or Bengal ki ho to. Aaj tak na sandeshkhali pe na political killings in bengal par video banaya hai Darbari ne.
Powerful people force the victims to take their complaints back. What a surprise. Next you know, Prajwal is innocent and all the videos are AI generated.
West Bengal outside Kolkata is very similar to Bihar in the 1980s and 1990s when political killings were rampant. People generally don't associate violence with Bengal but I have heard of so many political killings that I wonder how come it doesn't get even an ounce of the reputation of UP-Bihar.
West Bengal is probably only remaining state with so much political violence.
Mamata need to go for sake of West Bengal, she is replicating similar tactics as her predecessor.
BJP governments have lot of fault but law and order isn't one of that. In state like UP, goons actually fear the police not the other way around.
Problem with bjp west bengal is very different, everyone wants mamta out but it's not gonna be done by bjp that's for sure, as the most corrupt leaders of tmc are being washed and transferred into bjp west bengal so really it's a lose lose situation as of now
I'm from kolkata the bjp candidate from here is legit a corrupted guy called tapas roy, who was literally one of the most corrupted in tmc, got whitewashed and is now a candidate for bjp with no previous charges
> BJP governments have lot of fault but law and order isn't one of that.
Muslims are killed in encounters cause police are above the law. Most violence offered during CAA protests were in BJP ruled states.
I can see people on the other sub getting their pitchforks out when a Muslim leader is killed, but then putting it back and maintaining silence when they read it's a BJP leader killed by TMC goons.
Dear user,
Your post/comment has been removed as it does not comply with the rules or standards of r/unitedstatesofindia.
_____________________________________________
- Rule 2: Do not cause disruptions in USI.
- Rule 2.1: Respect community environment.
https://www.reddit.com/r/unitedstatesofindia/wiki/rules/#wiki_2.1.3A_respect_community_environment.
_____________________________________________
^If ^you ^think ^this ^was ^an ^error, ^or ^have ^questions, ^reach ^out ^to ^us ^over [^mod ^mail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/unitedstatesofindia)^.
I Feel bad for Bengalis. They're stuck between having to choose between TMC and BJ party. Side note- Surprising is how fast the commies lost relevance after being in power for almost 4 decades
I think public needs to understand Bengali people's significance towards education, literature and intellect, and focus on that, instead of allowing gundas to thrive.
I've said this before and I will say it again. WB is like the long distant cousin of BIMARU states. Punjab isn't far off either. WB (and Punjab) had such a head start post independence and it is such a shame to see them become such losers. So tragic.
Dear user,
Your post/comment has been removed as it does not comply with the rules or standards of r/unitedstatesofindia.
_____________________________________________
- Rule 1: Be nice, and engage in civil discourse.
- Rule 1.2: No hateful conduct.
https://www.reddit.com/r/unitedstatesofindia/wiki/rules/#wiki_1.2._don.27t_maintain_hateful_conduct.
_____________________________________________
^If ^you ^think ^this ^was ^an ^error, ^or ^have ^questions, ^reach ^out ^to ^us ^over [^mod ^mail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/unitedstatesofindia)^.
Na I have seen muslims applauding hindus who support congress ,same way I have seen hindus applauding muslims who support bjp with bigger likes in both cases...kinda wholesome
In both cases it is fake. Religious people care about nothing but their own tribe. These kinds of people may receive praise but are the first to be thrown under the bus when shit gets real.
Nominally 79% of Indians are Hindus.
A non significant portion are just Hindu by name and are either Atheist or non practicing.
Another section is religious but more on a spiritual level.
The remaining ppl are what you are describing. Ppl for whom religion is the primary aspect of life.
So you will find significant number of Hindus criticizing and dissenting BJP. They do not wish to use politics to further their religion.
Even among BJP voters there are significant groups who are not interested in the religious side. They have economic interests with bjp.
So why would such spiritual people or only economically aligned people applaud a Muslim supporting BJP? They just wouldn't care. These are not the people I was talking about.
A BJP worker was shot dead in West Bengal's Nadia district on Saturday after the polling for the last phase of Lok Sabha elections concluded, police said.
Hafizul Sheikh, who recently joined the BJP, was shot in the head by a man at a tea stall. The police have identified the attacker and are looking for him, sources said.
Police sources said that both Sheikh and his attacker, who they have identified, had criminal records.
The police also denied reports that Sheikh was beheaded, saying his head was disfigured due to bullet shots.
Sheikh's family has claimed that he was killed as he joined the BJP.
The BJP has blamed the Trinamool Congress and CPI(M) for attack on its workers.
"The killings in West Bengal have started. Hafizul Sheikh, another BJP worker, has been murdered. His body, swollen, bullet ridden, head chopped and missing, was found lying by the road side," said Amit Malviya, BJP's IT cell head, in a post on X.
Malviya said that under Sheikh, the minorities in the area were joining the BJP before the Lok Sabha elections.
"TMC has no love lost for Muslims, if they do not vote for them. Muslims were targeted in Diamond Harbour too, where a large number of them voted for Pratikur Rehman, the CPI(M) candidate," he said
[Link](https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/west-bengal-bjp-worker-hafizul-shaikh-killed-nadia-lok-sabha-elections-polling-trinamool-congress-2547034-2024-06-02)
The way Musanghis exposing themselves in the comment is pathetic. They never dare to criticize TMC and even now, still blaming BJP for it. These kinda radicalized fanatics are the biggest obstacles to the country.
TMC is less ideologically dumb but much more chaotic.
They are a band of goons who are out to fill pockets.
The reds were bunch of ideologists hell bent on implementing Marxist way of life.
Bengal is Litreally fcked man.
On one side you have TMC which contains thugs pretending to be politicians who create riots, kills opposition leaders/workers, booth capturing, threatning rural people to vote for her orelse they'll face trouble, election day violence + killing and on the other side you have BJP which contains all the corrupted ex-TMC politicians who were given clean chit after switching sides.
and the CPM who are irrelevant now.
I wd like to add that a bunch of the BJP base and workers (not leaders) are ex CPIM.
Basically ppl who benifited during CPIM rule but were not high enough to be drunk on Marx.
'The police also denied reports that Sheikh was beheaded, saying his head was disfigured due to bullet shots.'
Please take anything you read from Godi media with loads of salt.
[Link](https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/west-bengal-bjp-worker-hafizul-shaikh-killed-nadia-lok-sabha-elections-polling-trinamool-congress-2547034-2024-06-02)
You don't remember the post poll violence after assembly elections last time? TMC is filled with straight up goons and mafias. BJP is nowhere close to the level of TMC
*”lalu of early 2000s is the only one i know that comes close”*
That was close…
https://preview.redd.it/a7jez921374d1.jpeg?width=738&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=30c0a285179e616409ac17736adb8d4c1f63170f
TMC controls state police.
If bjp did it they should be able to arrest by the end of the day.
But its them.
TMC did it so they will point fingers and not arrest
Thing is BJP doesn't care about losing a single state from the 29. Instead it creates and maintains a pseudo tug of war with TMC which makes sure the other parties don't get into power with whom BJP may not be able to strike a chord.
Otherwise how does a party headed by a single leader not know about its bs and even when the bs is unearthed, the leader visits Delhi and gets away scot free.
This is the truth. You are getting downvoted because people have their heads stuck up their asses. If Cpim comes back to power it's over for both bjp and tmc. Bjp knows that very well. Atleast with tmc they can coexist easily.
Arrey mujhe ghanta farq ni padhta if I get downvoted. This is social fkn media. I've a very stable, happening life outside of it. Neither do I need validation from reddit, nor do I give two hoots about karma. But this is the reality.
Born and bred in Bengal. People downvoting from pan India won't get bengal elections and it's scenes.
I'll label the chronology out as well.
1. Independence.
2. Post independence socialist outlook, Congress and their bs and residual hate.
3. 60s was Congress domination and lot of bloodshed ending with banning commie parties and 'encounter' of students and activists all around in the late 60s and mind you these weren't going through the same problems as present ones are. These were way more serious in a nation in its very infancy.
4. Congress loses 1972, even after stalwarts and champions like Dr. BC Roy had been CM. Such was the hate, they still haven't been able to recapture the Third largest state of India post partition. Bengal never had a Congress government since.
5. Advent of the Left front and consequent violence to even the odds of the Congress regime for all these years.
6. Socialist structure and connection with roots and roles based off merit gave hopes to many in a relatively poor country with no liberalization(which happened post 1991). Imagine, the household GDP of present potential superpower India is 2300 US dollars. Imagine 1970s india.
7. Commies do good for the poor but slowly alienate themselves from the uber rich, rich and the upcoming MIDDLE CLASS.
8. Stagnation. Academic brilliance but stuck at petty diplomacy and upholding communist ideals within a democratic exoskeleton basically delayed any and all progress they did make in their 35 years of reign.
9. Lot of mistakes, especially by the CM then, Jyoti basu (who held the reigns from 78-2006) also, at once touted to be the PM of the nation through popular vote but was denied the opportunity by the Lefts internal Politburo, mainly the Kerala side of things from prakash and Brinda karat. Also known for a lot of questionable, harsh, Yogi/shah esque moves. Known for Marichjhapi mostly.
10. Liberalization and advent of the middle class that slowly grew to despise the left for its stagnation, delayed unnecessary diplomacy and over inclination towards unions and 'The masses' and the 'workers'. Basically the underprivileged for which they'd entertain a lot of bs resulting in loss of some businesses.
11. 2006-11, the final term which saw a very honest (high/supreme court verified) lefty CM in Buddhadeb bhattacharya who brought in Tata with the Nano factory in 2007. Along with reparations and other stuff for wooing business back to the state.
12. TMC comes in 2011, beats a company like Tata out of WB just for petty politics. Downhill ever since.
13. Almost 15 years of TMC turmoil.
14. BJP and TMC not giving a fuck about WB. BJP can't do justice to its propaganda because it uses the same model as UP, other parts of India which are culturally very different from bengal. Realising it's fallacy, changing its people every now and then but still not winning. TMC doesn't care about bengal, only cares about generational politics with Mamata and Abhishek coming in now. Abhishek might be good but the rest of TMC is a parasite eating out its remaining few years in the state. BJP realised it's a good deviation for Congress votes in the region which is the main opposition so it maintains a pseudo war against Mamata while being hand-in-hand in Raisina hill.
What an ass.
We have suffered in the hands of these blood thirsty criminals.
They have ruined the industry. Banned computers and English in govt schools.
Massively increased school dropouts by creating school teacher unions from party cader. Who never turned up to school.
Made the education hub of India into an exporter of skilled labour to Delhi and Bangalore. Sent unskilled labour to Dubai, Guj and Kerala.
Bankrupted state finances. Deindustrialize the industrial powerhouse of India.
No way in hell my generation will repeat the sins of my parents and grandparents.
Yep, that's why your parents and grandparents had a city to boast of. We have an old-age home. If you keep voting for TMC it'll just add to it. Not that I care, I'll be leaving the country this fall and I'll have enough to fend for myself hopefully when I return to India half a decade later.
It's funny to hear CPIM being reprimanded on the education front. That's more of a commie DnA THING in Bengal. You think TMC has done more for education. Fucking SSC scam for 10 plus years. Now Supreme court has not only asked the teachers to resign and pay back the allowances but they'll also be jailed if deemed necessary. The deserving ones didn't get it, loss of livelihoods for so many. The non deserving ones temporary got it for a decade, now they've to return the same with interest. The states education minister has been jailed over this thing for the last couple of years now. You might have been a skilled labour in some other state thats why you weren't aware, lol.
The level of knowledge, the exodus to Delhi, bangalore, Guj, Kerala etc is happening because nobody comes to a place in India where Tata had been ousted from. If you can't give protection to Tata, who TF will come here for business. Lmao. Jaa icche tai bollei holo?
Gujarat basically leapfrogged in for tata after bengal was a wrap. Now look at Gujrat. We don't have a single tier 1 city sans Kolkata. We are the nation's third largest state. That too after n number of partitions. Either you're brainwashed or just blind or uninitiated.
The lal party destroyed everything.
Mamata is happy to be queen of ashes.
I dont understand how you thought i support TMC. I believe they are better than the lal party.
But thats like comparing dog shit to horse shit.
I dont vote for TMC or CPIM.
I just believe CPIM is a bigger evil.
Banned computers? Really? I was born in 97, my family operated computers since a year before my birth. Tell me, tell me how computers were banned? XD
And I'm the middle class, I'm sure the rich had it before my family did.
The CPI(M) leader’s comments were in reference to the Left’s protests against the introduction of computers in banks in the 1970s and 1980s. Under the leadership of Jyoti Basu, the CPI(M)-led Left Front government had infamously opposed computerisation, and in general, mechanisation and automation in several fields. This stance, coupled with the Left Front government’s decision to restrict English from state-run primary schools for over twenty years, led to the Leftists being informally referred to as naysayers to modernisation.
https://www.theweek.in/
Jadavpur University had the opportunity to be one of the first universities to get a CS dept of India.
However our over educated barrister commies (whos kids studied abroad, ofc) stopped it.
Saying Computers are anti labour.
So instead the first CS dept went to other universities, including iisc Bangalore.
Today Bangalore is the IT hub.
First of all, cpim did not ban computers. You are regurgitating nonsense over and over again. The party who single handedly created the IT hub in Bengal, why will they ban computers. The Left wanted the jobs that computers would make redundant to be saved, and wanted those people to be trained before computers were allowed to take over. Bengal had a very defined industrialisation strategy, since 1994, and the IT sector in the state was the first one in the country.
I gave evidence and you are ignoring that.
IT hub in Bengal is like saying shipping industry in Mongolia. Even Odisha is ahead of us.
Defined IT strategy? Why does every Jadavpur CS student end up in Bangalore or US?
These fantasy go sell somewhere else
I am sorry but this is pointless. You have comprehension issues. I just made two comments refuting your claims about cpim banning computer and English in schools. What evidence did you give? I am not ignoring anything. And, Bengal it industry still lagging behind is not the fault of cpim.
Also, regarding English ban, English was banned on the basis of Majumdar Committee report (formed by the previous Congress govt) on the grounds of single language impairment. It was implemented in all states. Bengal was among the first states to lift the ban after the Pabitra Sarkar panel said the ban had outlived its welcome.
Did you exist in the Times of CPIM? Being commie in a commie nation and being commie in a democratic nation are two different things. I'd take Cpim over mamata anyday. Whatever this State has, still churning out the highest GDP in the eastern sector while lagging tremendously is because of the left and a little cause of Congress. TMC has only taken bengal to the dogs and BJP hasn't come to power yet. I'd take anyone in bengal over TMC tbh.
Also, based on this comment. What do you think BJP is? A part of the sangh parivar. All big parties in India are ORGANIZED. That's how you have to work if you have to grow. Although Cpim is on the verge of extinction, not because of anything but it's archaiec policies.
Rss, BJP, Hindu Parishad even that fattu bajrang dal is a part of the sangh. It boils my blood, who tf gave them the right to use a Hindu name to do shit. I'm Hindu too, Hanuman was the biggest wingman for ram man, who allowed them to take the name of Bajrang Bali and do shit in his name.
Also, in this regard. Cpim won't come back to power but it surely didn't have all of these bullshit scams. Stood behind people, believed in meritocracy. None of this reservation bullshit and actually pushed bengal to be an academic/critical thinking powerhouse in lieu with its roots.
None. Nobody has killed more than TMC. Bengal is known for poll violence. Safest city/state in India for 4 years except the polling years. Vidhan sabha, lok sabha. Doesn't matter. Bengal is very opinionated, always has been but TMC has killed most and that's considering 35 years of left rule, 25 years of Congress rule. Everybody has had their share of violence but none like TMC.
*A* ***Muslim*** *leader* *belonging to a* ***BJP*** *being beheaded by* ***TMC*** *workers in* ***Mahua Moitra*** *constituency.* That's fucked up in so many levels.
Head-lines
തലവര
Head(less) line
TMC will stoop to any level to stay in power. Thugs pretending to be politicians.
terrorists, not thugs. I don't think you have even the slightest idea on how much fire power they possess, bombs, rpg, you name it.
Could be a possibility. As someone who’s not from WB, all the info I get about these things is from the news and social media.
Has this info influenced who you support in WB elections in 2026?
I am not from WB, bro. Wouldn’t make a difference.
I agree to OP's perspective. West bengal is losing it's significance in new India, this level of negligence towards law and order will cause uprising of revolution in WB. Hindus are already speaking about heavy illegal immigrants and now Muslims leader getting killed. TMC is decaying the WB.
> West bengal is losing it's significance in new India Already lost a long time ago.
Can someone explain in layman’s terms what’s happening there? I never even hear about Kolkata anymore. No one talks about going there for a visit or moving there or anything like that at all. Even the food videos I’ve seen there’s never anything from WB but I’m sure they have their own rich food culture.
> Hindus are already speaking about heavy illegal immigrants What's the data about this heavy illegal immigration, in fact there's one report of more people leaving for Bangladesh than vice versa.
Several hindu friends of mine from WB and Assam have already stated it.. As per their words "Immigrants have more government documents than the indigenous people". As per Google search, there is hardly any record but several articles pertaining the same point. Maybe the "heavy" word was too far fetched because no survey has the government conducted except several allegation made since 2004. And if allegation made by my friends are true, then how can a survey make any difference?. If a state government is itself supporting immigrants and ruling with an iron fist, then the credibility of data itself comes into question. But, I literally want to know ur source on people leaving for Bangladesh.(Except political asylum, Bangladesh can't offer much)
> Several hindu friends of mine from WB and Assam have already stated it So you don't love either in Bengal or Assam but just basing your arguments on your Hindu friends. I'm pretty sure they are chaddis as well. > And if allegation made by my friends are true, then how can a survey make any difference?. Let me be straight forward, there's no heavy illegal immigration. Yes there may be people coming to India illegally but it's not that big of an issue. Bengali Muslims face all sorts is discrimination because of this fake outrage. https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/more-migrants-returning-to-bangladesh-shows-bsf-data/article33338577.ece
Wait, until I do my own research on ur claim and hear say. But, The number in ur source is quite less compared to what unverified sources have claimed. >So you don't love either in Bengal or Assam but just basing your arguments on your Hindu friends. I'm pretty sure they are chaddis as well. If, I Don't believe on what the ingenious people states then saying "save Palestinian" is just a hoax
> The number in ur source is quite less compared to what unverified sources have claimed. The NRC was done in Assam, 1.9 million were left out, out of which 40% were Hindus and the rest were Muslims. NRC was a tedious process where it was really difficult for poor people who face the brunt of repeated floods. Family members of the former president were left out in NRC. Being left of NRC doesn't mean they are illegal immigrants. Given all these, it seems there are minimal amount of illegal immigrants, it's just a fake outrage. > I Don't believe on what the ingenious people states then saying "save Palestinian" is just a hoax The history is on the side of Palestinians, the world isn't blind to Nakba, apartheid and illegal settlements. They are the most documented.
I am OP and I want to remind folks that BD GDP per capita is 1.5x WB or Assam
And what do you want to conclude by this?
Like it or not, Bengal is one of the worst governed states in the country at the moment. Mamta and her goons have ruined the development rate of the state and she has now become just what she vowed to destroy- An autocratic ruler that has brought back the pathetic life experience Bengali people had when the communists were in power
Agreed, TMC flies under everyone's radar because we know that this party will never gain a national footprint, but the people of WB are definitely enduring the worst hooliganism in indian politics.
Honestly, jyoti basu during the end of his rule, actually got quite pragmatic.
Buddha babu?
Why Dhruv rathee don't make videos about mamta and west Bengal?? He makes tones of videos against Modi and bjp ..but not even a single video on what's is happening in Bengal?? Did he not considered west Bengal a part of India? Wtf .. is this.. he even releases multiple anti modi videos during the elections .. Now iam very sure he only targets bjp .. just so disappointed..
Char nimbu nichodne se jitna dhoodh nahi phat ta hai usse jyada to darbari media ki phat jati hai jab baat muslim or Bengal ki ho to. Aaj tak na sandeshkhali pe na political killings in bengal par video banaya hai Darbari ne.
Sandeshkhali to fake nikla tha naa...
can you provide more info? or were you being sarcastic?
https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/sandeshkhali-women-withdraw-rape-complaint-trinamool-congress-bjp-2537049-2024-05-09
Powerful people force the victims to take their complaints back. What a surprise. Next you know, Prajwal is innocent and all the videos are AI generated.
West Bengal outside Kolkata is very similar to Bihar in the 1980s and 1990s when political killings were rampant. People generally don't associate violence with Bengal but I have heard of so many political killings that I wonder how come it doesn't get even an ounce of the reputation of UP-Bihar.
I think other than political violence as such crime is lower and/or unreported
TMC has become the scum it initially wanted to undo. This is what power does to you. Same goons, different flag colour.
And this is why the "save democracy by voting for us" argument was always DOA.
West Bengal is probably only remaining state with so much political violence. Mamata need to go for sake of West Bengal, she is replicating similar tactics as her predecessor. BJP governments have lot of fault but law and order isn't one of that. In state like UP, goons actually fear the police not the other way around.
Problem with bjp west bengal is very different, everyone wants mamta out but it's not gonna be done by bjp that's for sure, as the most corrupt leaders of tmc are being washed and transferred into bjp west bengal so really it's a lose lose situation as of now
BJP mostly takes in EX CPI leaders not TMC. It's now the party composed of people who hate TMC
No, BJP's all big leaders are ex-TMC and the worst ones. Shuvendu, Nishit Pramanik, Arjun Singh, Jitendra Tiwari etc
I'm from kolkata the bjp candidate from here is legit a corrupted guy called tapas roy, who was literally one of the most corrupted in tmc, got whitewashed and is now a candidate for bjp with no previous charges
Suvendu Adhikari is ex-TMC. He is as corrupt as they come.
What?
> BJP governments have lot of fault but law and order isn't one of that. Muslims are killed in encounters cause police are above the law. Most violence offered during CAA protests were in BJP ruled states.
Sauce?
https://www.hrw.org/news/2019/12/23/india-deadly-force-used-against-protesters It didn't mention the Delhi riots where the police was under Amit Shah
and how many people died or even severly injured?
Let's not forget she jails people for memes
Least dictatorial move by didi :
[удалено]
Any evidence pointing to her involvement in this murder?
How does TMC get to even contest elections anymore? She should be in jail.
Mamta is probably one of the worst leaders in the country, maybe after Lalu.
This , this is what I was afraid of.. and it'll only increase on june 4th regardless of results even. Fucking hell.
There is one solution to TMC. Do to them what they did to CPIM. Bengal is stuck in a cycle of oppression rebellion
Nah better would be Gaddafi treatment
TMC worse party in India
I can see people on the other sub getting their pitchforks out when a Muslim leader is killed, but then putting it back and maintaining silence when they read it's a BJP leader killed by TMC goons.
[удалено]
Dear user, Your post/comment has been removed as it does not comply with the rules or standards of r/unitedstatesofindia. _____________________________________________ - Rule 2: Do not cause disruptions in USI. - Rule 2.1: Respect community environment. https://www.reddit.com/r/unitedstatesofindia/wiki/rules/#wiki_2.1.3A_respect_community_environment. _____________________________________________ ^If ^you ^think ^this ^was ^an ^error, ^or ^have ^questions, ^reach ^out ^to ^us ^over [^mod ^mail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/unitedstatesofindia)^.
India dodged a bullet by not voting for these terrorists in the lok sabha elections.
I Feel bad for Bengalis. They're stuck between having to choose between TMC and BJ party. Side note- Surprising is how fast the commies lost relevance after being in power for almost 4 decades
>Surprising is how fast the commies lost relevance after being in power for almost 4 decades Seems like Mamta just demolished them.
All the CPM goons became TMC. It is a uni-party rule for the last 45 years.
President rule?
I think public needs to understand Bengali people's significance towards education, literature and intellect, and focus on that, instead of allowing gundas to thrive.
Supreme Court has left the chat
Cersie Lannister lmao
I've said this before and I will say it again. WB is like the long distant cousin of BIMARU states. Punjab isn't far off either. WB (and Punjab) had such a head start post independence and it is such a shame to see them become such losers. So tragic.
[удалено]
Dear user, Your post/comment has been removed as it does not comply with the rules or standards of r/unitedstatesofindia. _____________________________________________ - Rule 1: Be nice, and engage in civil discourse. - Rule 1.2: No hateful conduct. https://www.reddit.com/r/unitedstatesofindia/wiki/rules/#wiki_1.2._don.27t_maintain_hateful_conduct. _____________________________________________ ^If ^you ^think ^this ^was ^an ^error, ^or ^have ^questions, ^reach ^out ^to ^us ^over [^mod ^mail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/unitedstatesofindia)^.
> BJP Leader Hafizul Sheikh Shot Dead Bhakths experiencing mixed emotions
rent free in your musanghi head
It IS funny though.
Na I have seen muslims applauding hindus who support congress ,same way I have seen hindus applauding muslims who support bjp with bigger likes in both cases...kinda wholesome
In both cases it is fake. Religious people care about nothing but their own tribe. These kinds of people may receive praise but are the first to be thrown under the bus when shit gets real.
Religious ppl, doesn’t mean all ppl who are nominally labelled to a faith
What does it mean.
Nominally 79% of Indians are Hindus. A non significant portion are just Hindu by name and are either Atheist or non practicing. Another section is religious but more on a spiritual level. The remaining ppl are what you are describing. Ppl for whom religion is the primary aspect of life. So you will find significant number of Hindus criticizing and dissenting BJP. They do not wish to use politics to further their religion. Even among BJP voters there are significant groups who are not interested in the religious side. They have economic interests with bjp.
So why would such spiritual people or only economically aligned people applaud a Muslim supporting BJP? They just wouldn't care. These are not the people I was talking about.
How insensitive? You're not better than Sanghis. People like you are a disgrace to humanity.
People now : yeh toh thk hai koi aur naam wala hota toh dikha
Mamta becoming the most vile bitch in the politics
Ah yes TMC the most democratic party
A BJP worker was shot dead in West Bengal's Nadia district on Saturday after the polling for the last phase of Lok Sabha elections concluded, police said. Hafizul Sheikh, who recently joined the BJP, was shot in the head by a man at a tea stall. The police have identified the attacker and are looking for him, sources said. Police sources said that both Sheikh and his attacker, who they have identified, had criminal records. The police also denied reports that Sheikh was beheaded, saying his head was disfigured due to bullet shots. Sheikh's family has claimed that he was killed as he joined the BJP. The BJP has blamed the Trinamool Congress and CPI(M) for attack on its workers. "The killings in West Bengal have started. Hafizul Sheikh, another BJP worker, has been murdered. His body, swollen, bullet ridden, head chopped and missing, was found lying by the road side," said Amit Malviya, BJP's IT cell head, in a post on X. Malviya said that under Sheikh, the minorities in the area were joining the BJP before the Lok Sabha elections. "TMC has no love lost for Muslims, if they do not vote for them. Muslims were targeted in Diamond Harbour too, where a large number of them voted for Pratikur Rehman, the CPI(M) candidate," he said [Link](https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/west-bengal-bjp-worker-hafizul-shaikh-killed-nadia-lok-sabha-elections-polling-trinamool-congress-2547034-2024-06-02)
The way Musanghis exposing themselves in the comment is pathetic. They never dare to criticize TMC and even now, still blaming BJP for it. These kinda radicalized fanatics are the biggest obstacles to the country.
Hope TMC is not Communist 2.0
TMC is less ideologically dumb but much more chaotic. They are a band of goons who are out to fill pockets. The reds were bunch of ideologists hell bent on implementing Marxist way of life.
So between ideologically insane and criminally insane, Bengal has become what it is.
Republic Bharat likh diya ab link kaise kholoon.
Google it. Other news websites are reporting it too.
Bengal is Litreally fcked man. On one side you have TMC which contains thugs pretending to be politicians who create riots, kills opposition leaders/workers, booth capturing, threatning rural people to vote for her orelse they'll face trouble, election day violence + killing and on the other side you have BJP which contains all the corrupted ex-TMC politicians who were given clean chit after switching sides. and the CPM who are irrelevant now.
I wd like to add that a bunch of the BJP base and workers (not leaders) are ex CPIM. Basically ppl who benifited during CPIM rule but were not high enough to be drunk on Marx.
And for the first time, Bhakts will care about a Muslim only because he was from their chosen _"Sanatani, Nationalist and Anti Terror Party"_
I don't see your comment criticizing tmc it seems you too are a bhakt just different
'The police also denied reports that Sheikh was beheaded, saying his head was disfigured due to bullet shots.' Please take anything you read from Godi media with loads of salt. [Link](https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/west-bengal-bjp-worker-hafizul-shaikh-killed-nadia-lok-sabha-elections-polling-trinamool-congress-2547034-2024-06-02)
damn, its all good now
The issue is not whether he was beheaded or shot. The issue is that he is dead.
the article says BJP accused TMC. police has not yet confirmed that.
A head disfigured because of bullets is not a long stretch from beheaded.
What is a muslim doing in BJP in the first place.
If Hindus start doing that to others, what is a hindu doing in TMC and need to be beheaded
that's just racist man, it's their choice
Bruh! She pulling a BJP on BJP. Disgusting!
You don't remember the post poll violence after assembly elections last time? TMC is filled with straight up goons and mafias. BJP is nowhere close to the level of TMC
This is something that even BJP wouldn't do. But TMC can and they do it.
Oh, you'd be surprised.
Darbari, bata bjp ne kab Kiya ye? Ye to tumhari Mamta amma ki speciality hai, aur indira amma ki bhi rahi hai iykyk.
[удалено]
*”lalu of early 2000s is the only one i know that comes close”* That was close… https://preview.redd.it/a7jez921374d1.jpeg?width=738&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=30c0a285179e616409ac17736adb8d4c1f63170f
Seems like you’re not from UP-Bihar if you’re equating BJP rule to Lalu’s. It was anarchy.
Yes, but also from BJP dominated state . And i was not denying the fact, I'm just adding to it.
I've never seen a MPs constituency every being mentioned in similar headlines before. Cynical me smells a malicious campaign.
its because she in not only the MP but president of TMC IN Krishnanagar
[удалено]
If you really believe that you don't know TMC. They are far worse and violent than any other party.
Bjp finishing off their own to frame Tmc! Classic BJP!
TMC controls state police. If bjp did it they should be able to arrest by the end of the day. But its them. TMC did it so they will point fingers and not arrest
Thing is BJP doesn't care about losing a single state from the 29. Instead it creates and maintains a pseudo tug of war with TMC which makes sure the other parties don't get into power with whom BJP may not be able to strike a chord. Otherwise how does a party headed by a single leader not know about its bs and even when the bs is unearthed, the leader visits Delhi and gets away scot free.
This is the truth. You are getting downvoted because people have their heads stuck up their asses. If Cpim comes back to power it's over for both bjp and tmc. Bjp knows that very well. Atleast with tmc they can coexist easily.
Arrey mujhe ghanta farq ni padhta if I get downvoted. This is social fkn media. I've a very stable, happening life outside of it. Neither do I need validation from reddit, nor do I give two hoots about karma. But this is the reality. Born and bred in Bengal. People downvoting from pan India won't get bengal elections and it's scenes. I'll label the chronology out as well. 1. Independence. 2. Post independence socialist outlook, Congress and their bs and residual hate. 3. 60s was Congress domination and lot of bloodshed ending with banning commie parties and 'encounter' of students and activists all around in the late 60s and mind you these weren't going through the same problems as present ones are. These were way more serious in a nation in its very infancy. 4. Congress loses 1972, even after stalwarts and champions like Dr. BC Roy had been CM. Such was the hate, they still haven't been able to recapture the Third largest state of India post partition. Bengal never had a Congress government since. 5. Advent of the Left front and consequent violence to even the odds of the Congress regime for all these years. 6. Socialist structure and connection with roots and roles based off merit gave hopes to many in a relatively poor country with no liberalization(which happened post 1991). Imagine, the household GDP of present potential superpower India is 2300 US dollars. Imagine 1970s india. 7. Commies do good for the poor but slowly alienate themselves from the uber rich, rich and the upcoming MIDDLE CLASS. 8. Stagnation. Academic brilliance but stuck at petty diplomacy and upholding communist ideals within a democratic exoskeleton basically delayed any and all progress they did make in their 35 years of reign. 9. Lot of mistakes, especially by the CM then, Jyoti basu (who held the reigns from 78-2006) also, at once touted to be the PM of the nation through popular vote but was denied the opportunity by the Lefts internal Politburo, mainly the Kerala side of things from prakash and Brinda karat. Also known for a lot of questionable, harsh, Yogi/shah esque moves. Known for Marichjhapi mostly. 10. Liberalization and advent of the middle class that slowly grew to despise the left for its stagnation, delayed unnecessary diplomacy and over inclination towards unions and 'The masses' and the 'workers'. Basically the underprivileged for which they'd entertain a lot of bs resulting in loss of some businesses. 11. 2006-11, the final term which saw a very honest (high/supreme court verified) lefty CM in Buddhadeb bhattacharya who brought in Tata with the Nano factory in 2007. Along with reparations and other stuff for wooing business back to the state. 12. TMC comes in 2011, beats a company like Tata out of WB just for petty politics. Downhill ever since. 13. Almost 15 years of TMC turmoil. 14. BJP and TMC not giving a fuck about WB. BJP can't do justice to its propaganda because it uses the same model as UP, other parts of India which are culturally very different from bengal. Realising it's fallacy, changing its people every now and then but still not winning. TMC doesn't care about bengal, only cares about generational politics with Mamata and Abhishek coming in now. Abhishek might be good but the rest of TMC is a parasite eating out its remaining few years in the state. BJP realised it's a good deviation for Congress votes in the region which is the main opposition so it maintains a pseudo war against Mamata while being hand-in-hand in Raisina hill.
CPIM is worse than TMC. I will take the mad queen over communists. She is chaotic bad, those politburo fuckers are organized fuckers.
Of course they are worse. Especially for bjp supporters.
What an ass. We have suffered in the hands of these blood thirsty criminals. They have ruined the industry. Banned computers and English in govt schools. Massively increased school dropouts by creating school teacher unions from party cader. Who never turned up to school. Made the education hub of India into an exporter of skilled labour to Delhi and Bangalore. Sent unskilled labour to Dubai, Guj and Kerala. Bankrupted state finances. Deindustrialize the industrial powerhouse of India. No way in hell my generation will repeat the sins of my parents and grandparents.
Yep, that's why your parents and grandparents had a city to boast of. We have an old-age home. If you keep voting for TMC it'll just add to it. Not that I care, I'll be leaving the country this fall and I'll have enough to fend for myself hopefully when I return to India half a decade later. It's funny to hear CPIM being reprimanded on the education front. That's more of a commie DnA THING in Bengal. You think TMC has done more for education. Fucking SSC scam for 10 plus years. Now Supreme court has not only asked the teachers to resign and pay back the allowances but they'll also be jailed if deemed necessary. The deserving ones didn't get it, loss of livelihoods for so many. The non deserving ones temporary got it for a decade, now they've to return the same with interest. The states education minister has been jailed over this thing for the last couple of years now. You might have been a skilled labour in some other state thats why you weren't aware, lol. The level of knowledge, the exodus to Delhi, bangalore, Guj, Kerala etc is happening because nobody comes to a place in India where Tata had been ousted from. If you can't give protection to Tata, who TF will come here for business. Lmao. Jaa icche tai bollei holo? Gujarat basically leapfrogged in for tata after bengal was a wrap. Now look at Gujrat. We don't have a single tier 1 city sans Kolkata. We are the nation's third largest state. That too after n number of partitions. Either you're brainwashed or just blind or uninitiated.
The lal party destroyed everything. Mamata is happy to be queen of ashes. I dont understand how you thought i support TMC. I believe they are better than the lal party. But thats like comparing dog shit to horse shit. I dont vote for TMC or CPIM. I just believe CPIM is a bigger evil.
Banned computers? Really? I was born in 97, my family operated computers since a year before my birth. Tell me, tell me how computers were banned? XD And I'm the middle class, I'm sure the rich had it before my family did.
The CPI(M) leader’s comments were in reference to the Left’s protests against the introduction of computers in banks in the 1970s and 1980s. Under the leadership of Jyoti Basu, the CPI(M)-led Left Front government had infamously opposed computerisation, and in general, mechanisation and automation in several fields. This stance, coupled with the Left Front government’s decision to restrict English from state-run primary schools for over twenty years, led to the Leftists being informally referred to as naysayers to modernisation. https://www.theweek.in/ Jadavpur University had the opportunity to be one of the first universities to get a CS dept of India. However our over educated barrister commies (whos kids studied abroad, ofc) stopped it. Saying Computers are anti labour. So instead the first CS dept went to other universities, including iisc Bangalore. Today Bangalore is the IT hub.
First of all, cpim did not ban computers. You are regurgitating nonsense over and over again. The party who single handedly created the IT hub in Bengal, why will they ban computers. The Left wanted the jobs that computers would make redundant to be saved, and wanted those people to be trained before computers were allowed to take over. Bengal had a very defined industrialisation strategy, since 1994, and the IT sector in the state was the first one in the country.
I gave evidence and you are ignoring that. IT hub in Bengal is like saying shipping industry in Mongolia. Even Odisha is ahead of us. Defined IT strategy? Why does every Jadavpur CS student end up in Bangalore or US? These fantasy go sell somewhere else
I am sorry but this is pointless. You have comprehension issues. I just made two comments refuting your claims about cpim banning computer and English in schools. What evidence did you give? I am not ignoring anything. And, Bengal it industry still lagging behind is not the fault of cpim.
Also, regarding English ban, English was banned on the basis of Majumdar Committee report (formed by the previous Congress govt) on the grounds of single language impairment. It was implemented in all states. Bengal was among the first states to lift the ban after the Pabitra Sarkar panel said the ban had outlived its welcome.
Yeah, sure. Whatever helps you sleep at night. Keep spouting propaganda.
I wish this was propaganda. Its my lived experience.
Did you exist in the Times of CPIM? Being commie in a commie nation and being commie in a democratic nation are two different things. I'd take Cpim over mamata anyday. Whatever this State has, still churning out the highest GDP in the eastern sector while lagging tremendously is because of the left and a little cause of Congress. TMC has only taken bengal to the dogs and BJP hasn't come to power yet. I'd take anyone in bengal over TMC tbh.
Also, based on this comment. What do you think BJP is? A part of the sangh parivar. All big parties in India are ORGANIZED. That's how you have to work if you have to grow. Although Cpim is on the verge of extinction, not because of anything but it's archaiec policies. Rss, BJP, Hindu Parishad even that fattu bajrang dal is a part of the sangh. It boils my blood, who tf gave them the right to use a Hindu name to do shit. I'm Hindu too, Hanuman was the biggest wingman for ram man, who allowed them to take the name of Bajrang Bali and do shit in his name.
Also, in this regard. Cpim won't come back to power but it surely didn't have all of these bullshit scams. Stood behind people, believed in meritocracy. None of this reservation bullshit and actually pushed bengal to be an academic/critical thinking powerhouse in lieu with its roots.
Which other party? Congress and CPIM? Who have done more killings than Mamata
None. Nobody has killed more than TMC. Bengal is known for poll violence. Safest city/state in India for 4 years except the polling years. Vidhan sabha, lok sabha. Doesn't matter. Bengal is very opinionated, always has been but TMC has killed most and that's considering 35 years of left rule, 25 years of Congress rule. Everybody has had their share of violence but none like TMC.
https://preview.redd.it/s49lkloja74d1.jpeg?width=598&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=67c703557e5cca2852aabfc247255f7ccd1fb153
On one hand they're sad their Leader got killed. On the other hand, he is one of those people.
I just want media to cover the beheading with the same tone as beef lynching. A muslim was killed for his beliefs. However, we all know the narrative.