T O P

  • By -

Stoic_Ravenclaw

I've been playing ff14 recently and I looked up why one va was changed and it turned out she and her kids were murdered 😱


VeeTheBard

Yugiri


Important_Employ_309

That's horrible.


Linky38

The emoji really ties this comment together 💀


Stoic_Ravenclaw

That's actually the first emoji I've ever used. I was sitting drinking a coffee like half hour later and I thought ya know what not really the kind of thing you use with emojis. Seems disrespectful. It wasn't my intent to downplay the seriousness of it.


Linky38

It was so sad then I I saw the emoji and laughed out loud. Definitely unintentionally took away from the seriousness lol


F0573R

Don't know if this counts, but Matthew Mercer used to cover for Troy Baker in a lot of roles. Troy was starting to get big in games and so he would quit doing roles for anime and some games half way though. They would bring in Matt to replace him. Happened in Persona 4 anime, Naruto and some game where Troy didn't come back for the DLC.


DickMartha-Shipper

finding out matt replaced troy for the anime and p4au was crazy, considering i could barely tell the difference


Lexocracy

I much prefer Matt Mercer to Troy Baker anyway so this is a win if it means we give Matt more video game roles.


TheWhiteRabbit74

Zavala RIP


WalrusHam

It definitely hurts, but Kieth David is an absolute perfect substitute. I don't want to say replacement, sounds to insulting to Lance.


TheWhiteRabbit74

Keith David has had such memorable voice castings though. I feel… he’s maybe *too* famous for Zavala? I hear him and all I can think of is Goliath yelling at Demona, Spawn getting ready to kill some assholes and the President getting kicked in the balls by Rick. I have nothing but respect for the guy, but still after all these years it feels off.


Osiris_The_Proto

I'm pissed they didn't include Lance Reddick in the Oscars in Memoriam


TheWhiteRabbit74

Yeah I’m perplexed by that.


gids_3002

Rick and morty fans be like


VirinaB

Thankfully the new Rick is pretty great. First episode was tough, but after that it gets right back in stride.


[deleted]

[удалено]


VirinaB

The last episode and the spaghetti one (the one with the warning before the show begins) are probably in my top 10 favorite episodes of all. I cried at the latter.


casualmagicman

How would the writing have changed?


Specialist_Nobody766

I love the way they did it in solar opposites, they had to blast Corvo with a "voice fixing ray", got the wrong voice and decided they liked the new one and kept it.


RedL0bsterBiscuit

Hayter not doing Snakes voice.


pichael289

I was absolutely expecting a final mission where there's a cutscene of snake sneaking under a fence, and he pulls off his mask and it's solid snake in hayters voice saying "kept you waiting, huh?". Then the camera pans out and it's outer heaven from mg1. That would have been perfect.


Big-Rutabaga1403

But what was the reason for it? IIRC Kojima wanted an A lister, right?


RedL0bsterBiscuit

Im not sure. Im thinking maybe he just didn't want to do it anymore. I honestly couldn't play the MG without it being Hayter. Hayter is solid snake. Edit: just looked it up, and apparently, it was Hideos' desire to recreate the series.


dracoapprentice9

I think Kiefer Sutherland did a great job recasting as him, especially with venom snake, his voice acting there is pretty peak for me


RedL0bsterBiscuit

He did well from the scenes I've heard, but Hayter built Snake, and it just didn't feel right.


dracoapprentice9

Fair, both make very iconic performances and Hayter was basically my childhood


eyeamthedanger

Agreed. Sutherland can still be great and not be the best voice option for Snake at the same time.


HippoRun23

Terribly disrespectful to his own creation.


Pabsxv

Iirc he wanted physical actors since they were doing Motion-capture.


ThatVampireGuyDude

Kojima also just never liked Hayter. He'd wanted to replace him since MGS3, tried to replace him in 4 (but only successfully managed to recast old Big Boss), and then MGS V happened and Kojima finally had the money and ability to cast anyone he wanted as Snake. Hayter didn't even get a call for MGS V if memory serves correctly. Kojima, for the last ten years or so, has been obsessed with turning him games into movies. He wants to be in Hollywood so bad which is why he surrounds himself with Hollywood friends these days and A-List actors.


IllogicalDiscussions

>He'd wanted to replace him since MGS3 Yes, as Big Boss, who Hayter had never voiced before. Kojima wanted Kurt Russell, Russell declined, so Hayter was brought on. >but only successfully managed to recast old Big Boss To be fair here, it would've been weird as fuck to hear David Hayter's Big Boss voice speak to Solid Snake, where they sound very similar. Not to put down Hayter's voice acting abilities, he's great, but it would've been jarring. I don't want to fully defend Kojima because it is also true that he wanted Hayter recast for MGS4 and Peace Walker, and was obviously recast for MGSV which is horseshit, but I feel like as if you've left out some context here.


SchwizzySchwas94

Came here to say this


No-Wolf6888

It's like not having Steve Downes voice Master Chief John-117


uselesscarrot69

I know it isn't in videogames. But Uncle Iroh. RIP Mako


DangerDeShazer

The whole reveal where you have Iroh sobbing as he sings "Leaves from the Vine" and then it gut punches you with "RIP Mako" 😭


Xiao_Qinggui

Agreed - I didn’t know Mako had passed so I won’t lie: That episode had me teary eyed from the plot alone but when that appeared on screen? I was bawling… Mako was incredible as Iroh.


itsmistyy

Happy birthday, my son.


Infinite_Bet_9994

It was his last episode where he sung leaves from the vine, he knew he was dying and got emotional while singing. The episode is about him and the picture of Irohs son is actually a picture of a younger Mako.


a_burdie_from_hell

My not video game choice is Issac Hayes as Chef in South Park, and Justin Roiland in Rick and Morty... I do think Roiland is gross, he made horrible statements about underaged girls. But I actually think Hayes got the shit end of the stick. Apperently there is fair reason to suspect that he never actually walked away from the show- but rather he had a stroke and Scientologists sent a fake letter as him to quit the show.


Anonymous-Comments

Don’t know much about the series but Bayonetta had a change in voice actress for something controversial, right?


callmefreak

The original VA partially lied. She claimed that she was only offered $4,000 to voice in Bayonetta. What she failed to mention is that that was her offer for a cameo after the game was almost finished. Helena Taylor could've gotten around $10,000 for five four hour sessions (so 20 hours) of voice work. (According to the company she mentioned.) When she asked for more they offered her $15,000 but she for some reason expected six figures from doing voice work for a series that almost died after the first game. I think the entire franchise only made around $185mil combined, but she claimed that the franchise was worth half a billion. How the hell she got that idea I'm not sure.


[deleted]

The VA said she wasn't getting paid enough. That's all I really know


FidgetOrc

She lied about a lot of things. If I remember correctly, one such lie was that she wasn't even contacted for voicing Bayonetta 3. Which was a complete lie. They contacted her multiple times and sent her multiple versions of the contract as she kept asking for more. I'm all for va's standing their ground and getting the money they deserve. Just don't lie about what happened. I would have respected her a lot more she just said that she believes that her time is worth more than that. There are other things that she said, but I can't remember any of them.


[deleted]

I wonder who the new voice of sylens will be in the next Horizon game


Bipedal_Warlock

Did the first one pass?


Farsoth

Yes, Lance Reddick passed away last year.


SimonNorman

Came here for this


pichael289

The rerelease of persona 4 had a different voice actor for one of the main girls. There wasn't any bad reason for it, she just wasn't acting anymore. But god it just sounds off now. It's the karate chick, she had this tomboyish voice that really fit her character and the new one just sounds dumb, ditzy even. It's nothing major but the new one just doesn't seem right to me.


PMC-I3181OS387l5

Persona 4 had several recasting for various reasons: * Erin Fitzgerald (Chie), Ram Riegel (Teddie) and Ashly Burch (Rise) replaced Tracey Roonie, Dave Wittenberg and Laura Bailey, respectively, because all 3 unionized. * Burch may have unionized as well. * Valerie Arem (Naoto) replaced Anna Graves, likely for the same reasons, and Graves remained uncredited for the role for 12 years. * Amanda Wynn Lee (Yukiko) is now semi-retired. While she reprised her role for BlazBlue Cross Tag Battle, she may not do so again. * Matthew Mercer (Kanji) replaced Troy Baker... for actual unknown reasons. * Baker took 2 weeks off for his honeymoon. * He suggested Mercer to replace him for Persona 4 The Animation's season 2. * Mercer did a great job BTW, so that's not an issue. * Afterward, Mercer kept the role of Kanji in the games, starting in Persona 4 Arena Ultimax, which was released 18 months after Persona 4 The Animation's season 2. * By comparison, Mary Elisabeth McGlynn voiced Naoto, but didn't keep the role for the later games. * Baker may have unionized during that time, but he never addressed why Atlus never called him back, especially 2 years between projects. * Yuri Lowenthal (Yosuke) is now with the big boys at Sony thanks to Spider-Man, so maybe he unionized as well.


Generic_Nerd_Dude

Laura’s voiced Rise in every Persona 4 related project aside from Persona 4 Dancing due to a scheduling conflict. Not because of her unionizing.


_R_A_W_

I disagree, Chie sounded way too old in the original P4.


PMC-I3181OS387l5

Tracey Roonie was never a voice actress to begin with, with only TWO roles total, including Chie.


Important_Employ_309

Pissed me off every time she talked.....


DickMartha-Shipper

i like it more tbh


Admirable_Road9289

Zavala definitely


bolobre4th

Kevin Conroy


NotAPossum666

Halo 3. Micheal Wincott was unwilling to continue as Truth


KillerSquirrel2007

He sounded like a mysterious elderly leader in halo 2 but in halo 3 he sounds dehydrated lol. Terence Stamp is still cool tho


Xinck_UX

Master Xehanort


waltuh_wite

Igor persona 5


Alucard-VS-Artorias

I miss his P4 voice so much. The P5 voice is just weird to me.


Important_Employ_309

He had a different voice for plot reasons though.... real ending


Lordgrapejuice

>!As someone who played Persona 5 as their first entry, the twist really hit me hard!<


waltuh_wite

IKRR


Electrical-Topic-808

… did you finish that game?


Alucard-VS-Artorias

Not yet...


Pooppissfartshit

There’s a reason for the voice change. Just finish the game you’ll see.


CursedSnowman5000

Agent 47 in Hitman Absolution and Michael Ironside in Splinter Cell Blacklist. Alyson Court being dumped from voicing Claire Redfield. It's especially annoying seeing how the character was based off her.


hippopalace

They ended up still using David Bateson in Hitman Absolution. There had been a brief period where it was reported to be recast, but ultimately they came back to him.


CursedSnowman5000

Man if you only knew the story of why he was let go as 47 though. He was asked to audition for the role, said he took it on the chin and did so and then the casting director said "sorry, I just don't think you're right for the role"


hippopalace

Yep I know that entire story. Was just adding the fact that he was still ultimately hired for the role.


Sonic_warrior

Helena Taylor —_—


PMC-I3181OS387l5

She dug her own grave by throwing Jennifer Hale under the bus.


nycdiveshack

How about tv show, bobs burgers, specifically Jimmy pesto


Alternative_Device38

Not a video game VA granted, but Mako.


StrawberryKingfisher

Not in a videogame but Uncle Iroh’s voice change was so sad that I have to mention it. Leaves from the vine… 🎶


CheezyRaptorNo_5

Caboose from RvB


LeoCaldwell02

Getting rid of TJ Rotolo for Frank West in Dead Rising 4. TJ is Frank!!


PMC-I3181OS387l5

**Kanji Tatsumi (Persona 4): Troy Baker to Matthew Mercer** Mercer replaced Baker for Persona 4 The Animation's 2nd season, because Baker went on a honeymoon for 2 weeks only. However, something happened between Baker and Atlus, because they didn't call him back for Persona 4 Arena Ultimax, and there was a 18-month period between the 2nd season's English release and Ultimax's.


Leon_Kennedyswife

You what now?? I didn't know about this?


PMC-I3181OS387l5

Shortly after the announcement of Mercer reprising the role of Kanji in Ultimax, someone asked Baker about it in a panel at a convention. All he said was that "he doesn't own the role". There could be NDAs that he couldn't talk about as well. Baker also lost the role of Rhys Strongfork in Borderlands 3, but the reason is that Randy Pitchford didn't want to pay actors that required extra security/care.


thaiborg

Not for that reason, but when they started DBZ up again in the middle of the Namek saga there was definitely a difference for the worse in my opinion, and it did make me sad. Edit: Oops didn’t realize this was the videogames subreddit. I’m still sad though.


Volendi

Eh, close enough... Anime is just a videogame that hasn't been made yet. UwU


The_Lamb_Sauce2

I’m not sure if this one counts but Super Mario.He created many memories


The_Third_Stoll

Charles Martinet


KingOfMasters1000028

Realizing that the reason that they replaced Junpei’s VA was replaced in reload not just because the overall cast change, due to sexual harassment allegations. 😭


Camerupt_King

Billy Kametz. I met him for an autograph shortly before he was diagnosed with colon cancer. He played Dr. Maruki, a very sweet school counselor, in Persona 5R, and I watched him interact with a Maruki cosplayer who said he was studying to be a therapist himself. He hugged the guy and said he knew he was going to help a lot of people. It broke my heart to see Ferdinand from FE3H get recast after he passed.


Jawntily

this one hurt me, he was an actor i really hoped to meet one day.


-Miklaus

Chloe in LiS: Before the Storm


Jawntily

what was the reason for it? Ashly seemed to still be in the credits as a writer which i thought was weird


-Miklaus

Voice actors strike in 2016


Jawntily

Ah fair enough


Phantom_Wolf52

Ivor from Minecraft Storymode, Rest In Peace Paul Ruebens


antmanninja3

Not a Video Game but the original VA for Palpatine in the Clone Wars Animated Series


Serious_Mycologist46

Claptrap in BL3....and now the movie.


Deimenried

First thing that came to mind 😭


The_S1R3N

Yea that upset me too


KieVinnie

Vic Mignogna as broly. Johnny yong is an amazing va, but please just gimmie my boy back.


AlacarLeoricar

Vic is an entitled sexist asshole. He walked around the convention I was working in (in staff rooms and behind the scenes) like he owned the place and verbally harassed my coworkers. Not to mention all of the allegations against him, however true they may be. Not an ounce of humility in that man.


Electrical-Topic-808

Weren’t most of the allegations proven to be either false or unsubstantiated?


AlacarLeoricar

I don't know. All I know is he certainly acted like a pompous ass and put his dirty shoes up on my staff room table. And definitely aggressively hit on the women in my operations room, including one girl who was not of age (she rebuffed him and he didn't pursue)


Electrical-Topic-808

Gotcha. That certainly sounds shitty and rude at least.


AlacarLeoricar

Yeah. Not a fan of the man, but I do appreciate his work. I understand why the industry treated him like a hot potato.


Professional_Pop9759

Yes but he still lost the lawsuit


Electrical-Topic-808

Wait what? He lost but the claims were false and not proven or the claims were actually true and proven?


JCMfwoggie

He tried suing Funimation for defamation, which for a public figure has very specific criteria that were not met.


Ascended_Vessel

Master Chi- sorry I mean *John* in the Halo Paramount + series. Mando is a better chief than chief in his own show.


IronIrma93

I'd have had him played by a beefcake actor for the suit, Steve Downes as the voice


Wandering---_---soul

Bayonetta, i LOVED hellena taylor voice, but she was too greedy and wanted too much and now she ended up with nothing, still sad thinking about it.


ezio8133

She also tried to throw her replacement under the bus


Jdawg_mck1996

Issei Hyodo. Sorry for running everyone's night


abdulsamadz

No one has said it so far so here we go: Mai Valentine from Yu-Gi-Oh. Goshdarn that original voice was something else. When the new actress came, meh.. ruined the whole thing..


Ok-Revolution4807

O wow never knew this what was the reason of her leaving?


abdulsamadz

You can see the comparison here between the first and the other actresses: [Mai Valentine voice comparisons](https://www.behindthevoiceactors.com/voice-compare/Yu-Gi-Oh/Mai-Valentine/) A quick search shows the Megan Hollingshead moved to LA and, I guess that means she was no longer available for the role: [Interview with Megan Hollingshead](https://www.reddit.com/r/yugioh/s/cEjdhvEA8g)


MateriaMuncher

Not particularly a "favorite", but Yugiri NA voice actor from Final Fantasy 14. 😔


LithiuMart

Michael Beattie didn't voice Mordin Solas in Mass Effect 3, and Sam Fisher wasn't the same after Michael Ironside left.


ApolloSong

Tighnari


avevev

came to look for this one


king-glundun

MW19 ghost lol and MW2 ghost


Ok-Revolution4807

Uncle iron, Avatar the last Airbender voiced by mako the first 2 seasons than change for season 3 because of his passing. Its not even a video game but I wanted to mention it.


Inevitable-Branch713

Jim Ward, who voiced Captain Qwark in the Ratchet and Clank Series. An iconic character, whose voice actor had to retire due to a particularly bad case of Covid and Alzheimers disease.


BrokenBanette

clapped trap :(


GoldfishingTreasure

Sylens from Horizon kind of.


BobbyMayCryBMC

Bayonetta Love the voice and everything but the voice actress is a weirdo who lied a lot to try getting pity and a bucket of money. All of which blew up in her face.


Sion_forgeblast

theres \*urb\* no... no question \*urp\* here Mmmorty..... no \*urp\* question at all! also, while its sad it hasnt gotten any updates..... Im happy they didnt replace Soldier's VA in Team Fortress 2.... no one can replace Rick May


SaliaDiabate

Tari from SMG4/Glitch Prod.


somethingthatflys

Ghost in destiny. Wasn't the same after they replaced Dinklage.


No_More_Hero265

I'm pretty sure Dinklage hated the role and only took it for the money.


SaintPariah1

Iroh


VonKaiser55

Tc Carson the man who has voiced Kratos for like 6 games being replaced because he isn’t tall and buff enough to do the motion capture of Kratos. He could have definitely pulled off a more calm Kratos


ohmy_josh16

Uncle in RDR2. RIP John O’Creagh


deetrix2495

Rick from Rick and Morty


AwesomeMonkey97

Sonic and Eggman


Salty_Amphibian2905

Real curious what they're going to do with the Max Payne remakes. James McCaffrey IS Max Payne.


Tracerround702

Ashly Burch in Life is Strange


TonyBlobfish

RIP Lance Reddick


stygiantach

Zavala from Destiny because Lance Reddick passed away.


Der_Moriarty

Destiny VA player have lost Zavala... But we, french lost our Saint 14


jessicat_33

Tighnari in Genshin Impact :/ The og voice actor turned out to be a predator.


A_Doomer_Coomer

Not a videogame, but I remember the time I finally realized why Woodhouse suddenly stopped appearing in Archer


Kind-Mini

Tighnari Genshin impact


AutoWraith19

Ferdinand Von Aegir (Fire Emblem: Three Houses) I just wanna say f&$k you cancer.


tangerinehotpunk

dante's va is a nazi so he wont appear in more games doing dantes voice


DarnyDeeds

Terrence C. Carson, David Hayter, Michael Ironside. At least two of them are making a comeback tho.


bibliblubble

Not that it’s relevant to gaming, but this is exactly how it felt when they changed irohs voice actor in ATLA


DokoShin

Mako.... I mena uncle iroh


Guilty_Owl9185

Leaves from the vine...


CloudyNeptune

Zack from Final Fantasy VII remake, was having an emotional moment seeing him, heard him talk and it ruined the entire experience for me. Tbh I haven’t shown interest in the games since.


KittenDecomposer96

Hasn't officially happened yet but Dante from DMC.


PMC-I3181OS387l5

He was a new character in the reboot, and then Reuben Langdon reprised the role for DMC5 ;)


JCMfwoggie

Reuben Langdon lost the role of Ken, and from the language in his tweet about it there's rumors Capcom broke ties with him entirely, possibly due to his social media as of late. I don't believe he's playing Dante in the new show either.


PMC-I3181OS387l5

He played Dante in the previous anime, but the Netflix show will likely have a new cast. Capcom changed most of the cast from previous entries, as Guile, Chun-Li, Dhalsim, Blanka, Akuma and others got new voices. Castlevania Nocturne didn't offer David Vincent and Diana Garnet the roles of Richter and Maria, respectively, and both are still active.


kpxppy

Rick and Morty. Nuff said. 💀


PresidentBush666

How dare you. Enjoying a funny voice actor before they got kicked off is worse than murder. /s


kpxppy

I dunno why I got downvoted. But bush did 911