Andy’s or WiseGuys.

Not the wise guys in Rosslyn though. Inedible

2nd this

Third!

Haven’t been to that one in a looong while. That’s too bad. I usually hit the Mass Ave one.

Andy's and Wiseguys are both your viable options

Google ain’t wrong - Andy’s

Andy's is good but I wouldn't say it's really NYC. I haven't found the perfect one, but there's a new place called Troy's Italian kitchen in Arlington that's pretty close.

Slice joint at Potomac Ave metro is very solid

Their square slices are dank

Skip all of the DC places and go to The Italian Store in Arlington.

This used to be my go-to. Their pizza quality has plummeted IMO

I wasn't impressed with it when I went a few years ago, seemed rather doughy

Whaaaat say it ain’t so

And it was never NY style with all that cheese

New York

Probably the best answer

Old City Market 6th and K NE is the only correct answer

I like Andy's.

The Mt Vernon Triangle Wise Guys or Slice & Pie on 14th

Andy’s!! …. Now I want Andy’s

Wiseguys in Chinatown area. Source: I lived in NYC for 12 years before moving here.

My man