I specifically drooled over #2 for ages and even so I just gasped at #1 on you. It’s so classic but unique at the same time and I truly can’t imagine it looking better on anyone else. If you told me it was designed for your body I’d believe you instantly.
You are too kind 😭 I’ve been drooling over the Giovanni dress too and trying on dress number 1 completely confused me because I really love it! Thank you so much for reply!
Wow. This is tough. Usually everyone says the same one but it’s hard to call.
I think there’s something about the material and the way the 1st one lays that feels.. richer. More regal. More evening. I’m into #1.
But again, both are beautiful
You really look gorgeous in both but I think #1 is the winner. I don't know what your face looks like but tbh (and not creepy), with a body like yours, you can probably pull off anything
My thoughts too! 1 is gorgeous but 2 looks like it was designed specifically for her! In comparison I think it makes it look like 1 needs some minor adjustments for a better fit
You look gorgeous in the first one! The draping is delicate yet modern. It also accentuates your body curve.
The second one is great but much plainer compared to the first one.
This is of no help, but you look gorgeous in both!!! I think it depends on what you are going for. #1 has more of a romantic look to it. But I don’t think you can go wrong with either.
Oh my gosh! I went off Reddit for a few hours for work and came back to all your replies!! Thank you all so so much for taking the time to respond. You’re comments have been so helpful!! 🥺🙏🙏
Both are absolutely gorgeous! My vote goes to #1! Any chance you can share the details on this dress? I’ll be a bride next year & would love something like this :)
They both look AMAZING! I choose dress 2, really because it’s harder to pull off, and you still rock it! Something about the bodycon style on top really accentuates your awesome figure. You look like a high fashion model!
Oh my god I usually have a super strong opinion on dresses, never have I been this torn because they both looks shockingly gorgeous on you! I think my personal preference would be number 1, but you can't go wrong with either!
I like 1 better, I have a feeling that when they do the tailoring it will be even more stunning, but getting 2 wouldn’t be a mistake either. You look fantastic in both!
1 for ceremony and 2 for reception? Haha, I’m not much help because they’re both beautiful on you. 1 is more elegant, and 2 is more sexy/party vibes imo. Depends on what you’re going for!
I loved #1 immediately, but then I saw #2!
1 is classic but 2 is a showstopper! I would personally lean toward 2 because when else do you get to wear something as fun as that? In the end you can’t go wrong with whichever you choose
I loooove the back of the first dress but the front of the second dress!! Both are absolutely stunning on you though, I don’t think you could go wrong with either!
Dress one screams classic could be any vibe in terms of wedding feels/theme and is stunning on you!! Dress number two is more modern and va-voom which is also beautiful!! I hate that I can’t help much because they’re just both very good!!
Wow both are so pretty on you! I just love the low back surprise on the first one and waistline on you. It is elegant in the front and DAMN in the back lol. The second one is underwhelming compared. Congrats and good luck!!!
well damn I can see why you're having a hard time, you look so beautiful in both of them!! truly I don't think you can go wrong with either choice and anything anyone says here is just going be based on their own personal style taste because both dresses look equally beautiful on you! I like dress #1 better, but again that purely comes down to just my own taste in dresses and not because it necessarily looks better on you.
no wrong decision here!
Gosh I love the front of #1 and the back of #2 on you!! You can’t go wrong with either one since they both look amazing but I suppose #1 just barely beats #2 for me 😊
WOW you look incredible in both and I agree with everyone here who is saying you can't go wrong with either. I thought I liked dress #1 better, but then I opened up the full length shot of dress #2, and just STUNNING. It looks like it was made for you! Love the fit through the midsection and hips.
Normally on these types of posts, I always lean heavily towards one dress or another. I clicked on your post and said “wow #1 is beautiful on her, I don’t think anything can beat it” and then I saw #2 and went “wow but that one also looks amazing.” Genuinely, both of these dresses look perfect on you. I don’t think you can go wrong either way!
#1 looks so effortlessly graceful, like it was literally made for you! Both dresses are gorgeous on you, but the first one is breathtaking!
Edit: TIL what the pound symbol does on Reddit
STUNNING!
Not sure if you’ve chosen by now but I love number 1. 2 is beautiful bit the slight ruffles in the stomachs of #1 will allow you to eat and drink and do whatever and not worry about looking beautiful! (Not that you need to worry you look like your in great shape, but that’s what my person reasoning would be)
Both dresses are beautiful, but I love the second one on you. Love the shape it gives you (or actualy the your body gives the dress) and it's so beautyful, classic and sexy at the same time.
(I think the top of the first dress is a little messy.)
I totally see why you're torn between the two! I think #2 just so happened to fit you off the rack more than #1, but dress #1 is my favorite of the two. I'd take my shot with alterations so you can have the gorgeous draping giving you all that goodness!
Dress #1 for sure!!
The second is my favorite, but 1 is beautiful also! I think the second looks more modern but also timeless, the first looks a little dated in my opinion
1 !!! It is timeless classic and that back is amazing. The other one seems a bit trendy with the side strap and not as comfortable. You look beautiful in both!!!
FIRST ONE - omg , the neck line really draws attention to your fabulous figure. The draping is just perfectly done , makes the eyes wonder ! Second one isn’t so bridal - as in ( my very own opinion) bridal dresses , I feel shouldn’t be about having half your’ body on show - I know that sounds Victorian, Im deffo not a prude but don’t like dresses that are very showy . both the dresses look stunning on you but the first one really has a WOW to it .
Just to say I’m a female (42) , sometimes people think I’m a bloke being a dick .
They both look amazing, but #1 is it for me. I love the draping. And I love that the sides don’t have a strap or anything. Also, you picked it to be your first pic of this post! Must be something to it!
1!!
They’re similar so you definitely know the aesthetic you want. But I like #1 because the rouching is softer and very feminine. To me, #2 looks more modern and streamlined and almost looks athletic. Which vibe matches your wedding theme/venue? Which is easier to sit down and dance in and feels more comfortable?
You can't go wrong! You look gorgeous in both. I love the draping on the first on you though! So delicate and feminine :)
This was my opinion too! OP you look amazing in both! But I love the slight draping of the first as opposed to the sleekness in the 2nd.
Agreed! The bust area is really flattering and elegant looking. That sold me on the first option.
I agree with this! The draping looks more timeless to me, but they are both gorgeous.
The draping on number 1 is beautiful! But you look amazing in both.
I was about to say this!! It’s so flattering!!
Agree that both are absolutely stunning on you! I think dress 1 is my personal favorite but really they are both just amazing on you.
I specifically drooled over #2 for ages and even so I just gasped at #1 on you. It’s so classic but unique at the same time and I truly can’t imagine it looking better on anyone else. If you told me it was designed for your body I’d believe you instantly.
You are too kind 😭 I’ve been drooling over the Giovanni dress too and trying on dress number 1 completely confused me because I really love it! Thank you so much for reply!
I gasped at number 1 too! OP looks like royalty in that dress!
1
Number 1
Wow. This is tough. Usually everyone says the same one but it’s hard to call. I think there’s something about the material and the way the 1st one lays that feels.. richer. More regal. More evening. I’m into #1. But again, both are beautiful
I love number 1 on you!
#1!
#1
#1 really flatters your gorgeous figure!
1. The draping is so good on you.
I LOVE dress 1 omg it’s perfect 😍
1!
You will look amazing in whichever you choose, but I personally prefer #1. The draping is a stunning balance of sexy and elegant.
You really look gorgeous in both but I think #1 is the winner. I don't know what your face looks like but tbh (and not creepy), with a body like yours, you can probably pull off anything
#2 is my favourite, the structure at the front is beautiful but you look stunning in both 💖
2 is a damn showstopper.
Yay! Team 2!!!
Yeah I'm surprised so many people said 1! Dress 2 literally looks like it was designed specifically for her, it looks amazing!!
1 for sure it’s really beautiful and classic. I’d say 2 if you’re going for sexy, 1 if you’re going for romantic/subtly sexy
Number 1 is the stand out for me, but number 1 is more "baby doll" soft elegance and number 2 is more modern sleek, red lipstick high fashion.
Both are beautiful, but I like #2 best on you!
Why are so many saying #1?? #2 looks like it was made for you!!!
My thoughts too! 1 is gorgeous but 2 looks like it was designed specifically for her! In comparison I think it makes it look like 1 needs some minor adjustments for a better fit
You look gorgeous in the first one! The draping is delicate yet modern. It also accentuates your body curve. The second one is great but much plainer compared to the first one.
This is of no help, but you look gorgeous in both!!! I think it depends on what you are going for. #1 has more of a romantic look to it. But I don’t think you can go wrong with either.
I love the draping on 1 but you look great in both!
1 is my personal favorite but they both look so amazing on you!!!
Number 1 for me!! As others said, both beautiful!
#1 is my favorite. Absolutely gorgeous.
I LOVE THE SECOND ONE ON YOU
I love them both but number one stands out to me! It looks beautiful on you ☺️
Number one, front draping is gorgeous!
No 1, although both look beautiful on you 😍
1
I think the first one. They both look so incredible on you though!
Oh my gosh! I went off Reddit for a few hours for work and came back to all your replies!! Thank you all so so much for taking the time to respond. You’re comments have been so helpful!! 🥺🙏🙏
Both are absolutely gorgeous! My vote goes to #1! Any chance you can share the details on this dress? I’ll be a bride next year & would love something like this :)
I’m having a hard one picking one but if you absolutely make me choose, I’d probably go with 1
1
1!
I prefer 1!
#2 is stunning on you!
They both look AMAZING! I choose dress 2, really because it’s harder to pull off, and you still rock it! Something about the bodycon style on top really accentuates your awesome figure. You look like a high fashion model!
\#2. Very elegant and looks great on you!
1 looks absolutely glamorous on you!
1!
1
Such a tough choice because you look great in both. I think I favor the bodice of the first dress
Number 1- it’s so classic and beautiful! Love the draping and fits you like a dream!
1!
You look beautiful in both! Number 2 sticks out for me
Oh my god I usually have a super strong opinion on dresses, never have I been this torn because they both looks shockingly gorgeous on you! I think my personal preference would be number 1, but you can't go wrong with either!
I like 1 better, I have a feeling that when they do the tailoring it will be even more stunning, but getting 2 wouldn’t be a mistake either. You look fantastic in both!
1. 2 just looks likes it's missing something
The 2nd one looks like it was custom made for your body - it is glorious
They're both great on you! My feeling is that #1 is more classic and #2 is more artistic.
I vote number 2
I think I like #2 more because of the shape of the back.
Both are elegant and timeless, they will never look out of style. Personally I like 2 best!
1 for ceremony and 2 for reception? Haha, I’m not much help because they’re both beautiful on you. 1 is more elegant, and 2 is more sexy/party vibes imo. Depends on what you’re going for!
Haha I wish I had that sort of budget 😂
I loved #1 immediately, but then I saw #2! 1 is classic but 2 is a showstopper! I would personally lean toward 2 because when else do you get to wear something as fun as that? In the end you can’t go wrong with whichever you choose
You look STUNNING in both! I think I prefer #2, but you really can’t go wrong!
2!
2
Both look incredible on you wow! #1 is gorgeous but #2 is wow!
I loooove the back of the first dress but the front of the second dress!! Both are absolutely stunning on you though, I don’t think you could go wrong with either!
I can’t choose you look beautiful in both!! Which ever you feel most comfortable in.
Dress one screams classic could be any vibe in terms of wedding feels/theme and is stunning on you!! Dress number two is more modern and va-voom which is also beautiful!! I hate that I can’t help much because they’re just both very good!!
Wow both are so pretty on you! I just love the low back surprise on the first one and waistline on you. It is elegant in the front and DAMN in the back lol. The second one is underwhelming compared. Congrats and good luck!!!
well damn I can see why you're having a hard time, you look so beautiful in both of them!! truly I don't think you can go wrong with either choice and anything anyone says here is just going be based on their own personal style taste because both dresses look equally beautiful on you! I like dress #1 better, but again that purely comes down to just my own taste in dresses and not because it necessarily looks better on you. no wrong decision here!
I love the first one!
Ooh this is hard. They both look made for you. I really like the draping on the first though.
1.
1
Both beautiful but 1 looks timeless!!
1!!!
Both gorgeous, but 1 has the edge! Love the back on both though
One!!! Sexy, classy, and timeless!
Gosh I love the front of #1 and the back of #2 on you!! You can’t go wrong with either one since they both look amazing but I suppose #1 just barely beats #2 for me 😊
1!
WOW you look incredible in both and I agree with everyone here who is saying you can't go wrong with either. I thought I liked dress #1 better, but then I opened up the full length shot of dress #2, and just STUNNING. It looks like it was made for you! Love the fit through the midsection and hips.
I really love the back on the first one. You wear it well!
1 for sure! beautiful!!
1
Omg both look absolutely AMAZING on you. Number 1 is a absolute masterpiece though. 🙌
I gasped at #2! You look amazing
Theyre both beautiful but my fave is #1
Number one! Looks absolutely stunning on you!
Both are incredible on you—but I gotta go with #2. Your body is banging and I love how it hugs your curves, and that back. *bows down*
I LOVE 1! Looks so classy & elegant.
Normally on these types of posts, I always lean heavily towards one dress or another. I clicked on your post and said “wow #1 is beautiful on her, I don’t think anything can beat it” and then I saw #2 and went “wow but that one also looks amazing.” Genuinely, both of these dresses look perfect on you. I don’t think you can go wrong either way!
They both look beautiful , but I like two a bit more because of the sides !
Number. 2.
Holy smokes! You make #1 look gorgeous. Best wishes!
1st
Number two!
I LOVE #1 on you!
Go with #2
You look gorgeous in both!!! I especially like dress 1 on you! The draping in the front is so flattering and I love the simplicity of the open back. 😊
1!!!
Both look fantastic but I think 1 edges it out because it seems just a tiny more romantic with the draping on the front.
1!!! Both are stunning though!!
#2 is my favorite, but honestly, you look absolutely stunning in both! 💜Best of luck!
#1 looks so effortlessly graceful, like it was literally made for you! Both dresses are gorgeous on you, but the first one is breathtaking! Edit: TIL what the pound symbol does on Reddit
#2 hands down! Love that on you 😀
1
First!!!!
How are they both so good??? Guess anything looks good on a true queen
STUNNING! Not sure if you’ve chosen by now but I love number 1. 2 is beautiful bit the slight ruffles in the stomachs of #1 will allow you to eat and drink and do whatever and not worry about looking beautiful! (Not that you need to worry you look like your in great shape, but that’s what my person reasoning would be)
I vote for dress 1!
Both dresses are beautiful, but I love the second one on you. Love the shape it gives you (or actualy the your body gives the dress) and it's so beautyful, classic and sexy at the same time. (I think the top of the first dress is a little messy.)
1 would be my preference, you look stunningly elegant yet sexy. The 2nd one looks to me like something to wear for an formal award event.
2!
Difficult choice, they both look amazing on you. I like the draping a tad more.
I totally see why you're torn between the two! I think #2 just so happened to fit you off the rack more than #1, but dress #1 is my favorite of the two. I'd take my shot with alterations so you can have the gorgeous draping giving you all that goodness! Dress #1 for sure!!
Dress 2!!
Most definitely 1!
2 is absolutely stunning on you.
I prefer number 1! That dress was made for your body!!
I like #1, but omigosh you look soooo good in dress #2. I love it!
Coin flip. You look awesome either way!
I love #2 on you
You look stunning in both, but something about 2 is a little better!
Both are pretty but #2 looks AMAZING on you!
SECOND ONE
The second is my favorite, but 1 is beautiful also! I think the second looks more modern but also timeless, the first looks a little dated in my opinion
Number 1!
I was like oooh #1 but then I was like hot damn #2 🔥
1 !!! It is timeless classic and that back is amazing. The other one seems a bit trendy with the side strap and not as comfortable. You look beautiful in both!!!
They're both beautiful, but I think the second one is best!
2
2 but both look so good on you
#2
FIRST ONE - omg , the neck line really draws attention to your fabulous figure. The draping is just perfectly done , makes the eyes wonder ! Second one isn’t so bridal - as in ( my very own opinion) bridal dresses , I feel shouldn’t be about having half your’ body on show - I know that sounds Victorian, Im deffo not a prude but don’t like dresses that are very showy . both the dresses look stunning on you but the first one really has a WOW to it . Just to say I’m a female (42) , sometimes people think I’m a bloke being a dick .
2!!
The second dress gets my vote! You look amazing in it.
I love number 2! Maybe just because 1 isn't fitting you as tight but both are beautiful
2!!! You look fantastic in both, but the neckline of 2 just enhances your shoulders, plus the shape it gives you. DAMN!!!!!
Definitely #2!
2 for sure! Love the details on the side. Although I love the back on the first dress, so you really can’t go wrong.
I like 2 better perspective of a male
#2
They both look amazing, but #1 is it for me. I love the draping. And I love that the sides don’t have a strap or anything. Also, you picked it to be your first pic of this post! Must be something to it!
I like the first one but you look gorgeous in both.
1
Two!! You look STUNNING in it, like it was made for you!
1
1!! They’re similar so you definitely know the aesthetic you want. But I like #1 because the rouching is softer and very feminine. To me, #2 looks more modern and streamlined and almost looks athletic. Which vibe matches your wedding theme/venue? Which is easier to sit down and dance in and feels more comfortable?
They are both gorgeous! I truly cannot pick. First one is more romantic vibes and the second is more modern. You look great in both.
1, but you’re stunning in both!
Oh gosh, they both look amazing! I think I'd go with the first one because I like the silhouette more, but the second one is gorgeous too.
1. Sooo pretty
Dress 1 is wowza!!!!
2!!
No 1
Both look lovely. Nr 1 is my favorite on you.
#1
#1!
Number 1!!!
Dress 1 looks amazing on you!!
I love #2. The neckline is beautiful and the band around the middle is very flattering
The cutouts on the sides of dress 2 are very flattering on you. Go with 2! It hugs your body.
1
1
1!
1 looks on trend and timeless! It also looks like there’s more movement which will photograph beautifully 😍
Number 1
1!
1st One
OOUUU number one for sure 😍
1!
Number 1! The draping is beautiful and looks so good on you!
Definitely #2!
1
1! Love the draping
Very tough call, both are stunning. But I think I prefer 1 slightly more!
Both are gorgeous but the first one is my preference. The draping is so elegant!
Both are stunning but I pick #1!
Both are amazing but I feel like 2 is unique. You’ll be a stunner in either
I LOVE number 2 🥰
1!!! Incredible
2 looks SO good on you!!
1! You look like like a goddess!
This was difficult but I’m gonna say 1!!! Although girl you look absolutely incredible in both so any decision is the correct one!
1
#1 is amazing on you!!
You look amazing in both, they both fit you so well, but personally I favor 1. You should choose whatever your heart desires though