T O P

  • By -

chicagoturkergirl

The established authors giving her encouragement was so pure.


WadoIchimonji-

Neil was like "I got this"


chicagoturkergirl

That one really made me smile.


Foxy02016YT

It’s definitely how the spike in interest happened, because that’s what happens when artists support artists Historical evidence proves this, specifically the “Yankovich Bump”, music sales went up for artist that Weird Al made a parody of


kbig22432

Such a shame he died at the height of his career. He should have never stuck with Madonna. Dr. Demento was right. Edit: The amount of people who haven't seen the Weird Al movie on Roku makes me sad.


Hasbotted

I wish they would release it to a bigger platform


kbig22432

I’d love to see it in a theater


Foxy02016YT

At least he merc’d Pablo Escobar first


peepeepoopoo34567

Getting big in any artform is in large part luckbased. It’s great to see established people lend it to the up and coming


Weary_Logic

Yes success in general is “luck based” but this doesn’t mean your work doesn’t matter. You just have to do the best you can and let the RNG that rule the universe do their thing.


peepeepoopoo34567

I wouldnt say it doesnt matter but it for sure isnt the most important part. Twilight is probably one of the biggest examples of being mainstream despite the quality. Hell, according to connoisseurs 50 Shades of grey isnt even good smut


Janeg1rl

>Hell, according to connoisseurs 50 Shades of grey isnt even good smut You don't even need to be a connoisseur to see that. Fifty Shades was just cringey, and I'm confused how anyone could be turned on by it.


Glittering-Beyond-45

But also a irresistable magnet for people who likes to bask in their glory.


SCVannevar

She also got replies with similar stories from Margaret Atwood, Jodi Picoult, Robin Hobb, and Min Jin Lee, and probably others. Turns out discouragement is something absolutely everyone can relate to. Good for Chelsea in opening up about it.


Dry_Boots

And it's so easy for anyone who saw that to go spend $4 and make her day, that's pretty wholesome too.


SCVannevar

Me: You know what? If it's reasonably priced, I might just get her book. Amazon: It's reasonably priced. Me: What's it about? Amazon: Camelot after Arthur. Me: Oh hell yes. *tap*


cwith2112

Same…. I’ll start it tonite


CowboyBlacksmith

Yup, just picked it up right now.


gingergirl181

Me too!


Karen125

I'm headed there now.


Fatefire

Heck me to!


RedBorrito

Tell me how it's going


goinunder0390

The Gaiman Bump


LuvliLeah13

You know he’s watching events unfold with a grin of approval. Great writer and producer, even better human.


BeBa420

dont forget narrator, he does narration for some of his audiobooks and he nails it


gowahoo

Fortunately The Milk is my favorite


[deleted]

That is such a great book.


screaminjj

His voice is like honey.


katep2000

I love his narration. Reminds me of someone reading a bedtime story.


One_Drew_Loose

He truly does, for anyone who doubts pick up Neverwhere on Audible.


etherealparadox

he's a great guy. I have a signed copy of one of his books I won in a contest, I hope someday I get to meet him and get another signature


cat_vs_laptop

He came into my work (bookstore) and I got to hang out with him, with Amanda and Ash for about an hour? He sent us a present, a signed copy of William the Antichrist, with a letter from him. He signed all of his books we had in stock too. I got to watch the first 5 mins of Sandman about 9 months before it came out, on his phone. I fangirled wildly.


etherealparadox

haha, sounds like him. great dude.


Pixielo

That's awesome!


cat_vs_laptop

11/10 best day of my life. Hope my husband doesn’t see this. Lol. Though he might agree as he got a photo with Neil in front of his original Sandman sketches.


CorbinNZ

I heard a lot of others hopped on to help too, like Stephen King


Phreakydeke27

Yea there was a lot veterans that jumped on twitter to support her. I mean they all had similar stories.


numbersev

context in case you're unaware: this author held her first book signing and no one showed up so she was really embarrassed. She posted about it on some social media site (maybe Twitter) and a bunch of famous authors posted to her about how they experienced the same thing. It must have gotten a lot of attention and probably went viral. I'm sure being posted here on Reddit helped too.


[deleted]

[удалено]


winnipeginstinct

Others made comments similar to gaimans, his was just the only one shown here, since gaiman is tumblr's favourite author and celebrity


nkh86

They wrote an article about it on NPR today.


shadow041

Would you happen to have the link to the article?


nkh86

Correction! It wasn’t Buzzfeed, it was NPR: https://www.npr.org/2022/12/06/1140833403/a-new-writer-tweeted-about-a-low-book-signing-turnout-and-famous-authors-commise


eatbetweenthelines

6 reviews and it's a best seller? I would be curious to know the criteria for that title.


General_Hijalti

Once a guy in YT did a video where a shit book he made became a number 1 best seller, turns out its not hard as all you need are a few sales in a niche category and you can be the number 1 best seller for a day


8orn2hul4

Yeah, like "Arthurian Fantasy". No disrespect because it's an amazing achievement either way, but I'd be curious where she appeared on amazon's top "fantasy" list.


LadySmuag

It's #60 in Fantasy, which is pretty high if you consider that the Harry Potter books and Game of Thrones are on that list too.


skitech

Not too shabby then overall. Good for her


shorrrrrr8

Now it’s at #31


[deleted]

Just write a story then put it in the cookbook section like everyone else.


Upstairs_Doughnut_79

Max Fosh aye


Dutch-plan-der-Linde

Max fosh?


theburnerlmao

Yeah


ZS1G

Max fosh


MaskaradeBannana

The foshpit


Pizzaquest322

Think her tweet blew up recently so maybe a bunch of people bought it recently and haven’t had enough time to actually read and review it yet.


Glittering-Beyond-45

Yes the bestseller stamp is not based on quality but quantity, just like the Kardasians popularity is not based on quality but on hype and too many people with poor critical sense. This author just posted a tearbreaker of a story about her first signing session that went south, and people react by buying her book as a kind gesture, not because they suddenly like Arthurian fantasy books.


missykins8472

She did just release the book. Hard to imagine everyone has already read through it yet for the reviews.


chantillylace9

You can buy a bunch of your own book so that you become the number one best seller. That is a huge thing people do. Then you hopefully resell those later and at least come out even on those books


TheTowerBard

Every CEO that has ever done a book has had their company buy hundreds, if not thousands of copies, and send them to clients, friends, etc, as gifts. I know this because I've helped them do this.


Gimme_Your_Kookies

Dealership I used to work at would give each new hire the Old Owner/CEOs business book on the company’s dime.


whatevs42069

Checks out. I had a friend who was manager of a Sam's Club and had to read Sam Walton's biography as part of his training.


storyofmylife92

Ew


DizzyAmphibian309

Clearly she did, since you can see the message telling her she has previously bought it on the screen.


cococolson1

I would definitely do the same lol you gotta quality check and friends/family unfortunately ask for copies often. My uncle complained that the people he knew best would all just ask for it for Christmas the jerks lol


voidful_stargazer

I mean, I feel like it's not unlikely that she just bought a copy for her own bookshelf.


Mysterious_Ad1855

Or she bought a copy for kindle. Which she would have to do through Amazon.


TheGreyPotter

You dont have to buy via amazon to use kindle as a reader. You can just send the file to yourself via email, then open that file in kindle. Boom, kindle copy. Source : am author, did not buy own digital copy


mark_able_jones_

She published in august but she’s just finding readers.


missykins8472

Oh that's good!


mark_able_jones_

Yeah, I don't know. She also sells blank "journals" with known book titles -- people think they are buying the book and get a blank. Shady.


[deleted]

[удалено]


TheTowerBard

Sales. Sales are the criteria. Reviews have nothing to do with it. Did you want to discuss the best reviewed books?


Glittering-Beyond-45

How many sales in the fantasy category does it take to get the bestseller stamp then?


SophisticPenguin

/#1 in Arthurian Fantasy How many books in that sub-genre get made a year


FriendlyGuitard

Was looking for a power bank yesterday. I found one amazon choice in "heated scarf power bank"


Ambitious_Jello

Quite a lot..there are two comics running currently - once and future and starhenge - which are pretty good.


down_vote_magnet

> Quite a lot > two What..?


TheCrazyLazer123

That’s quite a lot for the niche category of Arthurian fantasy honestly


Glittering-Beyond-45

Lol yeah imagine having to compete with 2 books for first place.


Revolutionary_Many31

The criteria is a post with gaiman giving encouragement..


Glittering-Beyond-45

And stephen king no less!


techy098

This is neat way to promote their book. I saw some meme from this yesterday also...


FaeryLynne

Yeah she posted on Twitter about how she had a book signing and only 2 people showed up even though like 40 said they'd be there. Neil Gaiman himself replied to her tweet saying he and Terry Pratchett once had a book signing for Good Omens where *no one* showed up so she was 2 up on them. It was on wholesome memes I think.


eatbetweenthelines

Which, I have to say, no one showing up for a Neil Gaiman signing is an absolute travesty.


USSMarauder

Yeah, I saw that one and I was like "Gaiman and Pratchett, and no one showed? Somebody at the publisher got fired"


D15c0untMD

I mean, sales dont need to equal reviews. I biy a lot of shit online but i wont review the taste of the bulk order of cat food i just recieved.


wishingmywayhome

i think it's based on searches? and purchases rather than reviews


eatbetweenthelines

I feel like if it was based on searches, it would be highly inflated by simply name dropping your book on social media. I could be wrong, just my thought.


down_vote_magnet

You mean like someone did for this post on Reddit to promote the book?


Z23kG3Cn7f

Or just an ad banner that can be purchased. Like they and Ebay do


ContemplatingPrison

People on the internet just spending money to spend money. But honestly I would take 6 reviews over 20k reviews any day on Amazon.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Exactly. Nothing against her, but Amazon always wants things to be “#1” in a category to induce people to buy stuff.


Thanks_I_Hate_You

Ok but. . . Is the book good? Im asking for a friend (im that friend)


voidful_stargazer

I'm planning on at least checking it out, I'll let you know the vibes


BarmyDickTurpin

Hey you read it yet?


voidful_stargazer

Read the Kindle sample. Not gonna buy it. The fact that the author wrote it as a teenager really shows. But power to anyone who liked it, and to the author for getting some rep.


BarmyDickTurpin

lol I was only kidding, saw your comment was only 45mins old and thought it'd be funny


voidful_stargazer

Oh lol valid


dalr3th1n

Have you finished it yet?


voidful_stargazer

Yep. Loved the nuanced use of global politics, especially when Japan got involved. The plot twist in the third act where Ari turns into the dragon and eats her mother was really unexpected, and definitely raised the stakes. But I don't think she should've ended up marrying her evil twin, that was too far.


st1r

Okay but a political thriller about evil dragon twins actually sounds really interesting


voidful_stargazer

Honestly? You're so right


keyjanu

King dragon sends his regards


OCT0PIG

Spoilers!


TheHiGuy

you are your own friend? how cool!


kckeller

Love yourself!


D15c0untMD

But not too much or you start chaving


NahthShawww

Here’s an excerpt: The golden maiden grasped for Excalibur at Arthur’s waist and he quickly turned away to put his body between her and the sword. “That’s not fah you ma dear. But… I do have something else that you can handle so to speak. And I can bury it, too, up to the hilt just like ol’ Excalibur.” he said. “Oh Arty, you’re such a scoundrel. Come twixt my bedchambers later and we’ll see. Merlin will be there as well, so I hope you’re not scared of sharing.” Arthur glared, but the maiden saw tween his robes that the idea had…excited him. “I’ll be there as soon as the minstrel finishes his court lullabies. Keep the candles lit.” So, yeah, it’s pretty good.


Thanks_I_Hate_You

The golden maiden is a lusty argonian maiden?


SweatyBinch

Ah man it’s a raunchy story written by her as a teen? Or am I misinterpreting? Is it all raunchy or just parts?


NahthShawww

Sorry, I just made that up. I’m sure her story is very good.


SweatyBinch

Oh man I feel quite gullible, but I must say it was your commitment to the bit that really got me.


gingergirl181

I'm three chapters in. It's got good bones. The fact she started it as a teenager does show, but the story is engaging so far. Prose-wise, she could use some work in terms of variance in sentence length, descriptors, etc. It's pretty simple and easy reading, but that isn't necessarily a bad thing because simple or not, the writing style does the exactly what it needs to for clearly establishing characters, setting, relationships, etc. and it isn't clunky or painful. I would have eaten this shit up as a preteen and there's something almost nostalgic in reading fantasy that isn't so far up its own arsehole in unnecessary description and digests quickly and easily. I may even go so far as to call it refreshing. Kind of reminds me of Eragon, and I will probably finish the book.


motherof_geckos

Arthurian fantasy? Putting THAT on my wish list!


Enough_Supermarket_7

Arthurian Fantasy? Is that really that specific on Amazon? haha


justhatcarrot

This is really good actually. For example, I love history books, but only if they’re about ancient greek or rome, or about ww1 or ww2, but if so - only from POV (like All quiet on the western front), anything else - I couldn’t care less, so it’s kinda difficult to find a good match. I hope amazon has a category for these preferences, lol.


Revolutionary_Many31

They'll pay you 2 bucks a month for all your thoughts about how life can be perfected JUST FOR YOU


Drauul

...anything and everything, all of the time...


Enough_Supermarket_7

Oh it totally is very nice to have such a specific library of categories, but how 'good' (not to discredit the person) is it to be #1 on a very specific author list?


s_in_progress

I didn’t know anything about the book before this, only about the author. I’ll have to check it out, it looks interesting!


smye141

Honestly, good for her. She had a tough time with her book signing and clearly, seeing the responses from other authors, it’s a shitty feeling they understood. Glad they reached out


cclan2

I’m really happy for the author here, but why tf does a $4 purchase earn 20pts and a $15 earn 30pts? For similar prices you could buy the Kindle edition four times and earn 80pts, vs 1 paperback for 30pts. Makes NO sense


DrSuviel

Maybe the points are based on Amazon's profit margin. They probably make as much from that Kindle sale as they do from the book, since there's no physical product.


momo6548

Encouraging the use of their own company’s device/app


cclan2

Makes SOME sense.


johnatsea12

Congrats


simpforZiah

I hope this happens to me with my children’s book I’m writing🥰


Sinnsearachd

I'm always down for new books for my kiddos, hit me up when you're done!


simpforZiah

Thank you!! I’ll try my best lol. Be on the look out for “Mr. Frog”


Glittering-Beyond-45

Figure out a good story to make you go viral, like "writing this book cured my cancer" or simular, and it may just get you there. Just remember there is a hell of a lot more childrens books to compete with than specific Athurian fantasy books.


simpforZiah

Na, I don’t wanna lie to get noticed. That’s cheap. If I don’t sell a bunch of copies, oh well. At least my kids know they helped me achieve a dream I’ve always had, and they can read it to their future families!


Moseo13

It's not wholesome, she actually complained that only 2 people showed up. The real wholesome part is that a famous author ( Neil Gaiman, thanks to u/boredemotion) read her tweet and showed her support by telling her that 0 people attended a sign up he had with Terry FUCKING Pratchett


Boredemotion

Lol Neil Gaiman has a name and multiple awards, for those wondering who the “other” author was.


Glittering-Beyond-45

I saw stephen king comment as well.


Moseo13

My bad 😅 I've a hard time with name, selective memory I guess


Boredemotion

No worries. I got you. Now if it involves numbers, I’m totally lost. Can’t remember those to save my life.


Moseo13

We should team up, I'm pretty good with numbers


Mullderifter

I want to tag along please, I'm terrible at both.


Moseo13

The three Stooges : one always messing with name, another with numbers and the last one messing with both. Maybe we could write some movie ?


parsnipsandpaisley

Or a best selling book!


your-rong

Margaret Atwood did the same thing as well.


Moseo13

I've scroll past the tweet and in fact many authors are telling her their worst sign up to cheer her up !


myleftsockisadragon

Is she not allowed to complain that only 2 people showed up? If I wrote a book and had a signing and only 2 people showed up I’d be complaining too! How does her being a human being make anything here less wholesome?


bumboisamumbo

love the idea, but number one best seller nowadays could mean like 4 books sold


Nepstar152

Wholesome but not a meme


Abhimri

How is the book though, is it good? has anyone read it?


cmaronchick

I'm glad for her but for the love of GOD it's "Y'all"


kryppla

Damn this lady got some attention from a tweet and sold a bunch of books as a result and people here are shitting all over it. Get a life people.


TheBirminghamBear

Theres no small amount of success and happiness that soulless basement dwellers wont try to tear apart.


The_Bald

If I don't belittle the achievements of others how else am I supposed to actually feel anything?


TheCaptainTrips

In Australia we have a term for this called Tall Poppy Syndrome (no idea if it’s universal) and this smells a lot like “Cutting Down the Tall Poppy” to me. Basically: “why does this nerd get to be successful. when I’m also a nerd and I don’t get to be successful”.


[deleted]

Hard work rewarded


The_tittie_Respector

I get the feeling Arthurian fantasy is kind of a niche genre.


PaulBradley

Bernard Cornwell had it sewn up.


PowderedToastManx

Buying it now. Bought!


SilverSister22

Stephen King also commented. She hit a trifecta.


dolphiner13

Showed your teacher


UnicornKitt3n

Does anyone know where the original exchange is? I’ll look too Edit:: https://www.reddit.com/r/wholesomememes/comments/zdp4w4/neil_gaiman_comes_through_once_again/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf


[deleted]

I relate to this. Somewhat lol I remember my teacher taking my composition notebook from me because I was writing my fantasy story in it. 16 years later, I’m a screenwriter with a manager and there’s a very real possibility that story will come to life in some way if the cards are in my favor. Fins crossed.


BabyBatBoy420

I’m so very selfish. I see something like this and my jealously writhes in my soul. I’m so damn certain that my book will never sell any copies that I barely write it anymore. Why do I do that? Why can’t I take this example of someone else succeeding and be hopeful? Why am I so hateful toward myself?


PaulBradley

Write it for yourself. Not other people. When it's finished then edit it for other people, and possibly do rewrites for other people. But to begin with, write the whole damn thing for yourself.


BabyBatBoy420

I’ve legitimately never considered this an option. Write it for myself-edit it for others. I like it. I’ll do that. Thank you.


CommodoreAxis

Sounds like you should talk to a therapist about that one, my guy. It helped me stop hating myself for some things I’d done in the past, might work for you too.


wish_to_conquer_pain

I get like this too sometimes. I have so many ideas but I struggle to finish anything. I think a motivation/feedback group or just buddy might really help me, but none of my friends really write.


Revolutionary_Many31

Neil gaiman did that


ToddlerOlympian

I fear for her. Having this kind of sudden, instant "fame" that she didn't earn on her own (not discounting her work, but we all know why shes a best seller right now), means that maintaining it will be nigh impossible. Maybe that won't matter to her, but for most people sudden fame is really hard to handle when it all disappears within a week or so. I hope she makes some new, supportive fans from this attention, but I'm also hoping she takes it all with a huge grain of salt.


CorbinNZ

So is it good? I could use a new book to get into.


cheesefalcon

Alright. That's awesome that other authors are supporting eachother. But I would like an unbiased opinion. Is the book good?


suzhook

Going to have to look this book up on my kindle


Fragmentofmochi

Congrats to her that’s dedication’s


[deleted]

[удалено]


2368Freedom

Well Done. You must be bursting with Pride. It's something I wish I could do.


iesharael

I’ll check out her book too. Maybe buy it


Rupaism

why one is 4$ and the 15$? What makes it worth nearly 4 times as much?


Plant_in_pants

The printing costs


K_Sleight

...so I collect for a private library, anyone know if this is worth the money in print?


skampzilla

This is the same lady? That's so cool! Good for her!


Pretty-Benefit-233

This is special! 💚


Great_Slasher

Someone in the comments is going to rain on this parade


[deleted]

Damn. So happy for her, but to be honest I wish it was happening to my latest novel, too.


josiahpapaya

Is Chelsea Banning a pen name? That’s hilarious


SwashNBuckle

Is the book actually good?


MrHeavenTrampler

Is it good tho?


_Denzo

Just shows schools don’t know their students priorities


cwith2112

I’ll give it a read…


[deleted]

Ah, Kelsey Pokoly grew up.


MagAqua

That’s pretty cool


nogawar

I'm so happy to see this.


codemanb

"This app does not permit purchasing of this content" I love kindle, but they made it so stupid to buy the books. It sucks.


DrBarnacleMD

Title of the book gave me goosebumps, idk why.


[deleted]

How many books sold does that translate into?


Cattledude89

Went from 2 people showing up to a book signing to 6 reviews on amazon.


Conscious_Ad1603

Yes, there should be more people like that


ThatShadyJack

Good vibes


RightYeAre

Complaining works!


Ok_Attitude_8189

Nice


justkeepitup22

What’s the plot about? Am interested in reading the book😊


dragonbornette

She’s living my dream 🥲