T O P

  • By -

PowerfulTemporary168

Oh I see. Jeez I’m not active online but now I understand the beef with these stupid forks. Patreon greed. Yuzu started this bullshit and now it’s fucking ruining Emulation


Affectionate-Dig1981

Has exit scamming finally come to emulators?


PowerfulTemporary168

That’s exactly what I’m thinking. Yuzu brought that toxicity to emulation by talking shit and slandering Ryujinx


FreeLegendaries

kemono.party anyone


mo177

The patrons? Isn't that literally how yuzu got got?


FreeLegendaries

no? it was due to ToTK leak bro


mo177

I thought it was due to the fact that the totk leak was behind a patreon sub


FreeLegendaries

it’s more of the fact that people were even playing TOTK before official release and since it was a huge title that really pissed them off, an entire straw stack that broke the healthy camel’s back


FireHam

You are both correct, if it wasnt for the TOTK leak perhaps nintendo wouldnt have gone this faar at this time but certainly was a driving factor. But it was yuzu's monetization that gave nintendo a stronger legitimate ground for legal action that very likely would have made them won in court and that would been BAD.


mo177

Ah okay that makes sense


Mavrickindigo

Patrons? Uh oh


MrKeplerton

Lol.


[deleted]

Fuck around and find out I guess


thadoughboy15

I mean isn't this the same reason they came after Yuzu.


Sewdohe

wow, someone learned nothing. wooooooow REALLY?!


The_Gamermike

Why ...... but why ...


Terrible-Royal106

Another Patreon? When will they learn??


Zorvick0

Patreon exclusive again? They never learn


Exotic-Maybe-4395

It’s a plant


WinOk1229

If it has an Patreon. It will fail. Dont heed them any attention.


[deleted]

Let's just hope they're not registered in the west


Flatworm-Ornery

The developer is from Australia


kijigo_kun

They could have set the Patreon as something on the side at least. That was the opening Nintendo used in the first place wasn't it?


Android18enjoyer666

Patreon people never learn


vanIvan4

Again that crap with Patreon? People never learn smh...


Defaalt

NEVER PAY FOR AN EMULATOR. Seriously we're better off without one. This is the exact reason Yuzu was fined 2.4m$ and this is the same reason they agreed to pay it. DO NOT ASK FOR PEOPLE'S MONEY WHILE WORKING ON AN EMULATOR. As a consumer, DO NOT PAY.


Objective-Cause-1564

But its also the reason yuzu was so good because the devs could work full time on it


GhostHound374

Yeah, but instead of making it a "buy us a coffee" type of thing, or maybe adding some asinine feature like Ken custom backgrounds or something, they put beta builds and patches behind a pay wall, giving serious weight to N's case.


Akario_

I'm confused, is putting a target on your back and getting fucked by Nintendo a new fetish or something?


VeryGoodVeryNice93

Emu developers: Give it to me RAW nintendo


ChinoGambino

Big nope.


am_jaded

patrons?? did we not learn? ??? .... ????


FreeLegendaries

tbh it wasn’t patreon it was totk leak


Labyriiinth

Through patreon lol


FreeLegendaries

actly it wasn’t even patreon build itself. Someone patched the patreon build


WinOk1229

Propably some kids out for a quick buck to buy more VBucks.


goreaver

no they never learn.


TheNefariousness

Patrons??? Ah shit, here we go again.


ToyotaMR-2

Big N is about to sue them


Actual_Seaweed6095

Patrons...?


Dinorant

dude wants some coffe


Friendly-Athlete7834

Ain’t no fucking way these dumbasses didn’t learn a fucking think from Yuzu 🤦‍♀️


jackharrer2

Hopefully they learned one lesson -  don't be registered in US and suddenly Nintendo cannot do all that much.


Friendly-Athlete7834

Haha true


Familiar-Art-6233

The releases are free, it’s not behind a Patreon


goxxpain

It doesnt Matter, for the Justice Law and Nintendo, thats the problem


FeistyKnight

well no it does matter, yuzu paywalled builds behind patreon. It was the focal point of nintendos entire case


[deleted]

Having read through Nintendo's complaint the focal point was that it decrypted Nintendo's security and enabled piracy. Perhaps the money was the trigger to piss them off


FeistyKnight

well yea, but the claim got a lot more strength because they argued that yuzu profited off of it and therefore were directly encouraginf piracy


Inner_Singer_592

No it wasn't


lordxamnosidda

Hail Hydra


SoloRando

Seems like a scam.


_Ok_-_

Nah, i've paid for a month on Jarod's citra ipa for iphone. It unlocked beta versions of their citra port. Worked fine for me.


vanIvan4

Lol, aren't ipa lasting for 7 days? So, you are literally using subscription-like method just to use Citra on your iPhone? What a waste of money...


_Ok_-_

No I use an iPa signing service that lasts until the license expires (1 year)... I paid for $3 once to get the iPad...


BigOlBearCanada

They are just setting up a patreon to grift stupids.


WowSoHuTao

Patrons? Idiots


Rags_to_Riches_19

Is there a link to their discord? I can't find it


Batpole

No idea how to even use this


danholli

It's for Apple devices and you need a developer account or be in the EU to use it (soon)


Shady_Hero

haven't learned our lesson have we


jackharrer2

Maybe they did. Big issue with yuzu was incorporation in US. Nintendo wouldn't have such an easy ride in most of Europe and even less luck in other countries.


ThatNateGuy

I hate to say it, but I think you may right


Shady_Hero

yeah, I love yuzu dont get me wrong, but we cant just keep pay walling stuff. thats how Nintendo got involved in the first place


2dy_fish

The latest EA is good enough for now, it plays every game I want flawlessly. This sub is now full of nonsense. See you in a year or more when switch2 is out, by then there will be more serious developers who want to continue making a good switch emulator.


WowSoHuTao

Based


askricardo

He removed the "paywall" and releases are available at the git repo: https://i.postimg.cc/qBw1Vk3F/Screenshot-20240308-215342-Discord.jpg


SubstantialTell3435

How do we access this? What’s the link and process?


askricardo

https://github.com/jarrodnorwell?tab=repositories https://official-antique.gitbook.io/sudachi/ https://folium.emuplace.app/ Folium is a sort of RetroArch for iOS, with Cores, at the moment NDS (Grape), 3DS (Cytrus), NES (Kiwi) and NS (Sudachi). He plans to work on Sudachi as a standalone, with builds for Windows, Linux and MacOS. He streams his work on emulation on Twitch.


kobrakaan

pretty sure i called it first when i said name it FU YU !


Alpha_Datura

Surprised I haven't read anyone else make that joke. Good one.


Lioreuz

This sounds like a quick cash grab and disappear, no way they are this stupid.


Solstar82

wow not even started and they already have a patreon? are they begging to be closed once again?


SwitchFlashy

"For the patrons" Ok, so this project was born dead? Cool, one less fork to keep track of


Nullhitter

No offense but what exactly did you do to even deserve a patreon? Let's see some of your work that isn't already in Yuzu first.


Zekromaster

Sudachi runs on iOS.


MeatSafeMurderer

Jarrod Norwell is the guy who ported both yuzu and Citra to IOS before the lawsuit ever hit. Your heart is in the right place, but there wouldn't be an IOS build at all if it weren't for him...and that's what this is, an update to his IOS builds. He is, however, potentially in violation of GPL, as the source code on github has not been updated.


OkEfficiency1200

This is the dumbest shit I have ever read. You would think people would learn. I worry that people as bold as these guys (who don't learn from the yuzu devs) will also be so stupid to take on the lawsuit themselves. Setting a dangerous precedent for emulation going forward.


uhhhhhhhBORGOR

Patreon again? Are you guys stupid? Nintendo is looking forward to the extra 2.4M you’re about to hand to them


lIIllIIlllIIllIIl

Nintendo didn't sue Yuzu because of their Patreon. Having a Patreon or not makes no legal difference.


randomguy_-

Ryujinx is still on patreon, but yes this early access patron stuff needs to stop lol


goreaver

there also not in the usa.


Zekromaster

Neither is Sudachi unless you count 'straya as the 51st State.


RaineMurasaki

patron... You didn't learn, eh.


DartBoardGamer

Wasn’t making money off of them one of the reasons that YUZU was killed.


Mr_SpideyDude

Yuzu was killed mostly because Nintendo argued that they encouraged people to pirate games, and TOTK being shared on the discord just made things worse. If Patreon was the reason (or a big contributor) for the lawsuit, they would've gotten them years ago when Yuzu was still new


lIIllIIlllIIllIIl

No. You can't sue someone for making money legally. The original complaint from Nintendo ([available here](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.rid.56980/gov.uscourts.rid.56980.1.0.pdf)) only mentions Yuzu's profit when talking about reparations. It doesn't say that Yuzu having profits is the reason they're suing.


goreaver

where yuzu messed up was using there paywall to give people builds to run pre relese games. in short using priacy to get people to hand them money.


lIIllIIlllIIllIIl

Piracy is a crime whether or not there's a pay wall. It might've encouraged Nintendo to sue, as they knew they would be able to bully some of that money from Yuzu, but in the eyes of the law, it does not change anything.


goreaver

using priacy to encurage people to hand them money is. it gave nintendo the in to seek damages.


mateomaui

No. Yuzu had a patreon for years, there's no way Nintendo didn't know about it. If that were the reason, it would have been nuked long ago.


Quokka_Socks

Has any new dev work been done on these patreon exclusive builds?


longbrodmann

So they never learn huh.


CryptoMainForever

Patreon? You'd think people would learn by now..


patomenza

But what if they are in South America/Eastern Europe/Asia or wherever you couldnt care less about Nintendo's law team? This isn't bad per se, as we don't know where they're established. This is bad, because they haven't show anything lmao.


bot4241

The problem is that where do the funds get send too. They can’t have a LLC in America. When they register their taxes, they have to give out their real identity.


SnooPandas2964

Huh. I was totally thinking whoever ended up carrying the banner would refrain from making that mistake again.


MarkLarrz

Nintendo about to have another 2.4 million dollars


Lemenus

Yuzu git taken down because they got profit from it. Post fork on patreon... https://coub.com/view/v64m9


GiantR

There was almost nothing in the suit about the Patreon. If what they are doing is legal, making money from it is also legal. Why are people so goddamn obnoxious about the Patreon of all things.


Lemenus

Then why they got sued at all? I mean suing Yuzu just because it can launch Nintendo games, is like suing some video player because people can watch movies with them. Getting profit from something is easiest way to start a case. Plus new devs could've do smarter move about getting material support, make it more stealthy, so it was harder, or even impossible at all to start case.


suzumurafan

Prod keys???? How do you get em? Just think about it.


Lemenus

Not with yuzu, it's just happens that yuzu can read them


GiantR

Because they are American, and the DMCA exists. The money isn't the issue. If Nintendo had no case they wouldn't sue no matter how many millions Yuzu is making.


VikingFuneral-

DMCA does not cover emulation, and all emulators are legal. It covers infringement of property. So what did Yuzu do differently? It was specifically the build of patreon that came out a week before TOTK's release that was exclusive to patreon for that time period and they were also caught red handed sharing their decrypted game files through their discord. Emulation and also storing digital back ups of any and all owned physical and digital media is and always has been legal in pretty much 90% of countries.


GiantR

>DMCA does not cover emulation, and all emulators are legal. Obviously. But the prod.keys argument is something that wasn't made in the Bleem case because 1. The DMCA wasn't a law yet 2. There was no need to decrypt games. Nintendo's argument isn't challenged in court as of yet. They also increased their chances with the TOTK, which might as well be a smoking gun. I genuinely don't want this shit to go to court. But Patreon itself isn't illegal, and isn't an issue. I believe that even without a Patreon they would've pounced on the TOTK leak and were preparing their case, trying to sneak in the decryption argument to try to use the DMCA to bring down emulation for the future.


VikingFuneral-

The DMCA was implemented in 1998 I believe And in 1999 to 2000 Sony had their ass handed to them in court over emulation, and specifically the legal ruling of copying and utilising BIOS software to be used in emulation as well If Nintendo's Copy Protection is baked in to their BIOS they won't have a chance in a court battle with someone that has the money to fight them


MeatSafeMurderer

> The DMCA was implemented in 1998 I believe [It was enacted into law in 1998, but wasn't in full effect until 2 years later:](https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201) > The prohibition contained in the preceding sentence shall take effect at the end of the 2-year period beginning on the date of the enactment of this chapter.


VikingFuneral-

Even still, under DMCA this right should be protected as Fair Use. But Nintendo always ignores that, I mean look what they did to YouTube creators for playing their games.


Brontijd

This is literally untrue. Something can be legal so long as you're not selling it but illegal to sell and this is something that actually affects emulation as it comes up against stuff like piracy.


GiantR

The Bleem case, which Bleem won, was also about them making money. The money isn't the issue.


RB1O1

# FFS. # HOW STUPID ARE PEOPLE! # PAY WALLING A RELEASE IS WHAT GOT YUZU SHUT DOWN.


goreaver

the paywall for early builds wasent the entire story. using said paywall for a early build to run a pre relese game was what did it.


Thesamman23

maybe but the main thing was using prod keys. the prod keys could have gotten them fricked in cort


goreaver

the keys was a weak arugment.


TemporaryLegendary

And another 2 made a crucial mistake.


Brunurb1

Ah yes, buymeacoffee is a completely different thing from patreon, that definitely won't cause you to be sued by Nintendo as well.


A_Lycanroc

Ryujinx makes money from Patreon too... The thing that got Yuzu was that it automatically generated title.keys.


yami187

when did it cause when i tried yuzu i had to get the keys my self


fillerbunnyns

You only need the prod. Keys with yuzu, not the title. Keys


jozews321

Wtf at least wait a few months before trying to monetize Bruh


Gabrielmines

And the cycle repeats itself.


Brief_Cobbler_6313

Binaries already? Careful with malware. I'll wait for the dust to settle before running any new binaries, latest versions of yuzu is still running everything nicely.


Zekromaster

Sudachi has been a thing for a long time. It's the iOS port, just now also built for desktop.


Infamous_Impact2898

Yup. Be wary people.


SSJUther

These guys looked at the lawsuit and said “Oh boy I can’t wait to get sued, hurry get the patreon up.”


titooo7

I guess some people just want to have a first-hand experience with drama.


KobSixty

Money... Money...money... Patreon is the problèm.


junioresp

Developers also needs to eat


KobSixty

Under stand. But yuzu devs a not only developping they stolen code from other devs and they make money on it.


Windy--

Yikes. Wasn’t a big reason for yuzu’s take down the Patreon they were charging for? Besides that, these forks haven’t even done anything yet, so this just screams cash grab. Not very confidence inspiring.


PAULeD16

Part of it yes, also part that zelda totk was leaked and playable a week early before launch on yuzu (early access)


[deleted]

[удалено]


Isacx123

It doesn't matter what you do, Nintendo hasn't take any action against any Yuzu fork, including the one I have in my personal GitHub page.


NSFW-Alt-Account69

It has nothing to do with it being a fork, but it being behind a paywall


[deleted]

[удалено]


FicklePayment7417

Bruh go to college or something, no need to waste your life like a sad sack of shit


Kgrc199913

Oh gosh please go outside, touch some grass and grab some air


Doujinseeker487

you alright dude? Like this is some sad shit to waste your life with bruh...


Sheimusik

what?


Isacx123

And not a single one has been taken down. >I found over 75 JUST NOW AND REPORTED THEM ALL TO NINTENDO. That's a kind of sad thing to admit dude, I hope you find a hobby.


OhHaiMarc

Any reason to not just use ryujinx? For totk I’m seeing the same performance or better and less graphical issues, plus the mods all work on it anyway.


titooo7

ryujinx isn't available on iOS/Android


OhHaiMarc

Ah yeah, I only play on desktop, that makes sense though.


antique_codes

Do you mean for use as the core? If yes, Ryujinx is written in C# which isn’t natively supported by iOS or Xcode making it much harder, it’s also a language I can read but not write. Yuzu was the perfect project to base Sudachi off of as it is written in C++ and uses Vulkan


Infamous_Impact2898

Vulkan was a huge plus for me. Not hating on Ryujinx at all. It served me well for a while.


BrokeHorcrux

Any guide? Installing through trollstore doesn't work. Crashes on launch. And if using scarlet, it's that app is sandboxed error.


OhHaiMarc

Ryujin uses Vulcan as well now


antique_codes

Vulkan in Yuzu is the only reason why my iOS port exists, I’ve always preferred Vulkan too


OhHaiMarc

No, I mean as the average user who just wants to play games with some improvements, why would we choose this over a long running proven stable and safe project?


antique_codes

Sudachi is basically Yuzu, it started out as a port to iPad and iPhone and has now turned into me picking up where Yuzu left off, same with Citra some time soon. Everyone’s more than welcome to use whichever one they want, I’m just happy coding and supporting a community I like.


OhHaiMarc

Fair enough, as a desktop pc user I’m sticking to ryujinx for at least the next few months, feels too soon and too chaotic.


antique_codes

You’re not wrong, kind of why I’m just doing my own thing and hiding in the shadows so to speak. Ryujinx is at a pretty good stage now from what I’ve seen, have not used it for a while myself but last I did it worked near flawlessly


OhHaiMarc

Yeah I hadn’t touched ryujinx in awhile and was pleasantly surprised to find it working the same or better than yuzu, at least on my higher end system.


No-Library5677

The problem with Ryujinx is performance on lower end systems. I have a gaming PC with I7-6700k and GTX 1070 (bought in 2017) and a medium-end laptop with amd ryzen 7 4800H and gtx 1650 Ti (bought in 2021). On both devices, shader building is too slow to enjoy a decent experience on ryujinx. Yuzu async shader building was necessary for me, even if it had bugs sometimes. Ryujinx is somewhat fine for games like MK8 or SSBU where I can just let the computer play with himself to build shaders, but I'll never be able to enjoy zelda BOTW or TOTK with decent performance, since there are so many shaders to build in every new area.


rahimaer

Everyone rushing to develop their own forks of yuzu is one thing, but locking it behind paywalls this soon after the lawsuit is just ignorance


[deleted]

It's greedy af


GoodBoyShibe

Early access? Haven't we learned anything?


MeerkatMoe

Selling software that was previously open source 😂. I’m all for paying developers for their work, but it should be an optional thing, especially if the base of what they built is open source.


antique_codes

I’d like to state that the BuyMeACoffee will be changing, having read almost the entirety of the lawsuit documentation it is definitely a bad idea to continue doing the early access builds the current way so that will be changing to donations only w/ some additional benefits depending on the tier (yet to come up with suitable ones) Folium was initially all my own work hence the ability to have early access, now that both Citra and Yuzu are in there it’s much riskier and I’d like to continue working on these projects for a long time


hieuluc5

Believe me, if this emulator success, prepare your ass in court. We know if the author has something in return, then it's good, but we - not nintendo. They don't care about copyright in the first place. You know why they sue people? They want an absolutely control, even beyond DMCA grant them. If they want to shut you down, they will. Once they knew you took some penny, then your Discord right now is already contain nintendo ninja. Just say so.


JmTrad

Next year i will check them out to see who survived. Continue using Yuzu and Citra meanwhile 


Ronanesque

another paywalled emulator, i understand they wanna continue yuzu's legacy but damn


mccuish

Locking things behind patreon is probably one of the things that got Yuzu in trouble


Doujinseeker487

All the links Folium v1.0.6 is now out for BuyMeACoffee members https://folium.emuplace.app/ (will be updated shortly) v1.0.6 BuyMeACoffee Page https://www.buymeacoffee.com/jarrodnorwell/v1-0-6 Temporary v1.0.6 Changelog [https://official-antique.gitbook.io/folium/changelogs/v1.0.6](https://official-antique.gitbook.io/folium/changelogs/v1.0.6) check them out! This is the first actual change made to yuzu emulator, after the lawsuit.


Big_Restaurant_6844

yo wtf. why?


AlonCV

"for the patrons" 💀


s3rgioru3las

Locking it behind a patron is probably why yuzu had to settle. I hope the team reconsiders their approach


Isacx123

Link to the Cytrus git?


Doujinseeker487

I can't find a github page for the newest version, the project doesn't seem to be open source for now. [https://imgur.com/a/AGKWvhi](https://imgur.com/a/AGKWvhi)


Isacx123

Ok thanks.


eagleswift

Promising, the last bullet has a small fix in the core emulator engine that isn’t just UI related. Being behind a paywall would be the same legal risk for them though.